题名

兒童事故傷害嚴重性與嚴重度之評估工具

并列篇名

Evaluation of Assessment Methods in Childhood Accidental Injuries

DOI

10.7023/TJFM.200509.0159

作者

羅品善(Ping-Shan Lo);游文瑜(Wen-Yu Yu);周稚傑(Chih-Chieh Chou)

关键词

Pediatric Trauma Score PTS ; Pediatric Glasgow Coma Score PGCS

期刊名称

台灣家庭醫學雜誌

卷期/出版年月

15卷3期(2005 / 09 / 01)

页次

159 - 171

内容语文

繁體中文

中文摘要

事故傷害一直是危害國內兒童健康的嚴重問題,即使是官方公佈的死亡資料,仍無法真正了解兒童事故傷害問題的嚴重程度與影響層面。過去對於兒童事故傷害測量指標是否能適當反應出受傷嚴重度的真實性,一直值得討論。本文將過去衛生單位之統計或評估時常用的兒童事故傷害測量方法分為-發生的嚴重性及傷害的程度兩部分加以評估。過去對於兒童事故傷害測量的受傷程度評估,除了兒童外傷指數(Pediatric Trauma Score-PTS)與兒童昏迷指數(Pediatric Glasgow Coma Score-PGCS)是以兒童為評量對象發展出的評估工具,所評量出的結果之正確性比較高之外,其他的測量方法都是以成人的標準來評量兒童的受傷程度;儘管PTS及PGCS兩個指數是針對兒童所發展出的評量工具,但是這兩個指數並無法正確評估中毒、窒息與溺水等事故傷害之受傷的嚴重性。未來期待能藉由建立完整的「事故傷害監測系統」,收集到最完整、詳盡的資料,經由這些資料的分析過程中,發展出適用於國人兒童以及各種事故傷害的評量工具,明確且完整的表達出事故傷害之嚴重度,喚起國人的重視及瞭解事故傷害對兒童所造成的不良影響。

英文摘要

Accidental injuries have always been a serious children's health issue. The real impact caused by accidental injuries is not fully represented in the death rates reported by governmental agencies. The suitability of childhood accidental injury assessment indices used in the past, and their dissimilation ability to reflect the severity of injury and accuracy of data warrant further discussion. This article evaluates frequently used childhood injury assessment methods that employ two dimensions-severity and extent of injury. The accuracy of these assessment methods is controversial, especially regarding the extent of injury at the time of the accident. Except for the Pediatric Trauma Score (PTS) and the Pediatric Glasgow Coma Score (PCGS), instruments designed specifically for children, all other assessment methods evaluate the extent of injury using standards and norms based upon adults. However, even though PTS and PGCS are children-specific, they do not accurately evaluate the severity of injury in certain types of accidents such as intoxication, asphyxia and drowning. It is hoped that by developing a comprehensive ”accidental injury monitoring system,” new tools will be developed to collect more complete and accurate childhood injury severity data. In addition, this extensive data may raise public awareness about the negative impact of accidental injuries in childhood.

主题分类 醫藥衛生 > 社會醫學
参考文献
  1. Baker SP,O`Neill B(1992).The Injury Fact book.New York Oxford:Oxford University Press.
  2. Baker SP,O`Neill B,Haddon W,Long WB(1974).The injury severity score: a method for describing patients with multiple injuries and evaluating emergency care.J Trauma,14,187-196.
  3. Beattie TE,Currie CE,Williams JM(1998).Measures of injury severity in childhood: a critical overview.Inj Prev,4,228-231.
  4. Boyd CR,Tolson MA,Copes WS(1987).Evaluating trauma care: the TRISS method.J Trauma,27,370-378.
  5. Breaux CJ,Smith G,Georgeson KE(1990).The first two years` experience with major trauma at a pediatric trauma center.J Trauma,30,37-43.
  6. Cooper DJ,McDermott FT,Cordner SM,Tremayne AB(1998).Quality assessment of the management of road traffic fatalities at a level I trauma center compared with other hospitals in Victoria, Australia. Consultative Committee on Road Traffic Fatalities in Victoria.J Trauma,45,772-779.
  7. Cornwell EE,Belzberg H,Hennigan K(2000).Emergency medical services (EMS) vs non-EMS transport of critically injured patients: a prospective evaluation.Arch Surg,135,315-319.
  8. Currie CE,Williams JM,Wright P(1996).Incidence and distribution of injury among schoolchildren aged 11-15.Inj Prev,2,21-25.
  9. Dierking BH,Ramenofsky ML(1988).The pediatric trauma score: an effective method of field triage.JEMS,13,70-72.
  10. Eichelberger MR,Champion HR,Sacco WJ(1993).Pediatric coefficients for TRISS analysis.J Trauma,34,319-322.
  11. Engum SA,Mitchell MX,Sehcrer LR(2000).Prehospital triage in the injured pediatric patient.J Pediatric Surgery,35,82-87.
  12. Friedrich MJ(1999).Report documents causes of child death JAMA,24,1903-1905.
  13. Girasek DC(2001).Public beliefs about the preventability of unintentional injury deaths.Accid Anal Prey,33,455-465.
  14. Guyer B,Gallagher S(1985).An approach to the epidemiology of childhood injuries.Pediatr Clin North Am,32,5-15.
  15. Kaufmann CR,Maier RV,Rivara FP,Carrico CJ(1990).Evaluation of the Pediatric Trauma Score.JAMA,263,69-72.
  16. Kendrick D,Marsh P,Fielding K(1999).Preventing injuries in children: cluster randomised controlled trial in primary care.BMJ,318,980-983.
  17. Li L,Ozanne-Smith J(2000).Injury hospitalisation rates in Victoria, 1987-97: trends, age and gender patterns.Aust N Z J Public Health,24,158-165.
  18. Lu TH,Lee MC,Chou MC(1998).Trends in injury mortality among adolescents in Taiwan, 1965-94.Inj Prey,4,111-115.
  19. Marsh P,Kendrick D(1999).Using a diary to record near misses and minor injuries-which method of administration is best?.Inj Prey,5,305-309.
  20. Morrison A,Stone DH(1999).Unintentional childhood injury mortality in Europe 1984-93: a report from the EURORISC working group.Inj Prev,5,171-176.
  21. Osler TM,Vane DW,Tepas JJ,Rogers PB,Shackford SR,Badger GJ(2001).Do pediatric trauma centers have better survival rates than adult trauma centers? An examination of the National Pediatric Trauma Registry.J Trauma,50,96-101.
  22. Peterson L,Harbeck C,Moreno A(1993).Measures of childhood injury: self reported v maternal reported events with temporally proximal versus delayed reporting.J Pediatr Psychol,18,133-147.
  23. Potoka DA,Schall LC,Gardner MJ,Stafford PW,Peitzman AB,Ford HR(2000).Impact of pediatric trauma centers on mortality in a statewide system.J Trauma,49,237-245.
  24. Ramenofsky ML,Ramenofsky MB,Jurkovich GJ,Threadgill D,Dierking BH,Powell RW(1988).The predictive validity of the Pediatric Trauma Score.J Trauma,28,1038-1042.
  25. Russell R,Halcomb E,Caldwell E(2004).Differences in mortality predictions between Injury Severity Score triplets: a significant flaw.J Trauma,56,1321-1324.
  26. Staffle J(2001).Outpatient management of bum patients.J Bum Care & Rehabilitation,25,10-13.
  27. Suruda A,Vernon DD,Reading J(1995).Pre-hospital emergency medical services: a population based study of pediatric utilization.Inj Prey,5,294-297.
  28. Tepas JJ,Mollitt DL,Talbert JL,Bryant M(1987).The pediatric trauma score as a predictor of injury severity in the injuried child.J Pediatr Surg,22,14-18.
  29. Tobiasen J,Hiebert JM,Edlich RF(1982).Prediction of burn mortality.Surgery, Gynecology & Obstetrics,154,711-714.
  30. Vernon DD,Furnival RA,Hansen KW(1999).Effect of a pediatric trauma response team on emergency department treatment time and mortality of pediatric trauma victims.Pediatrics,103,20-24.
  31. Wallace KL,Pegg SP(1999).Self-inflicted burn injuries: an 11-year retrospective study.J Burn Care & Rehabilitation,20,191-194.
  32. Wolf SE,Rose JK,Desal MH(1997).Mortality determinants in massive pediatric bums.An analysis of 103 children with ≥80% TBSA bums (≥70% full-thickness),225,554-565.
  33. Ziv A,Boulet IR,Slap GB(1998).Emergency department utilization by adolescents in the United States.Pediatrics,101,987-994.
  34. 吳明玲、季璋珠、王榮德(1993)。1964-1990年間臺灣地區兒童意外事故死亡趨勢及潛在生命損失分析。中華衛誌,12,421-434。
  35. 杜友蘭、葉金川、林芸芸、趙秀雄(1980)。台北市幼稚園托兒所兒童意外災害流行病學之研究。醫學研究,3,951-966。
  36. 易鳴羽、吳玉村(1993)。兒童溺水。國防醫學,17,353-357。
  37. 高裕美、林慧珠(1992)。急診中毒病患的評估與處理。榮總護理,9,33-35。
  38. 張彩秀(1996)。全民健康保險對學生團體就醫行為之影響。弘光醫專學報,28,151-166。
  39. 張理君(1992)。溺水病患的處理及護理。榮總護理,9,441-445。
  40. 許金旺、劉敏英(1999)。從未知毒藥物中毒,談急診病患如何評估及初步處置。國防醫學,29,537-541。
  41. 陳子儀、邱文達主編(1996)。交通事故傷害研究輯
  42. 葛應欽、謝淑芬、陳拱北預防醫學基金會(1997)。傷害事故防制。公共衛生學,523-549。
  43. 鄒榮生(1991)。兒童意外中毒的處理。北市醫誌,35,37-40。
  44. 衛生署。衛生統計。行政院衛生署。
  45. 鍾明惠(1996)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。國防醫學院公共衛生研究所。
被引用次数
  1. 蕭景祥、陳淑貞、孫自宜、林佳蓉(2011)。南台灣某縣市托兒所兒童遊戲場安全因子現況分析。嘉南學報(人文類),37,286-296。