產業空間群聚機制之解析－以楠梓加工出口區IC封測群聚為例

An Analysis of the Formative Mechanisms of Spatial Clustering of Industries-Evidence from the IC Assembling and Testing Industries in Nantze Export Processing Zone

10.30087/APEMR.201103.0001

閻永祺；王惠汝；孔憲法

產業群聚 ； IC封裝測試業 ； 楠梓加工出口區 ； Industrial clusters ； Export Processing Zone ； IC Assembling and Testing Industry

亞太經濟管理評論

14卷2期（2011 / 03 / 01）

1 - 30

繁體中文

本文從「廠商」的層次出發，並以「空間區位－網絡結構－市場結構」的分析架構，以解析「IC封測群聚」形成的重要因素與機制。透過量化的問卷調查與質性的廠商深入訪談，得到以下五點重要發現。首先，產業發展初期階段，土地、勞動、資本仍是廠商區位選擇的重要條件，當產業進入發展階段，鄰近旗艦廠商與上下游廠商、鄰近生產與消費市場，逐漸成為廠商區位選擇之關鍵因素，其中旗艦廠商更是影響產業群聚形成的重要機制；第二，旗艦廠商會因市場結構、生產技術的研發與掌握程度、資金等優勢，使其具有穩定的權力支配，進而影響其上下游廠商的市場策略、生產網絡佈局、專業化發展模式，最後改變這些上下游廠商的空間區位選擇；第三，由在地企業轉型而成的旗艦廠商，因其與在地的社會與文化制度間特殊的網絡關係，透過其企業決策並結合在地網絡，使其在楠梓加工區形成特殊的區域資產，創造出不易移動的生產因素，此為促進廠商在特定空間群聚的重要動力來源；第四，IC封測之創新來源主要來自國外與區內的廠商網絡，不同於以大學和研究機構為主之創新模式；第五，旗艦廠商透過建立上下游合作與創新的網絡，進而促進廠商間朝向專業化發展與吸引專業服務廠商進駐，最後創造出在地的產業群聚。

The paper aims at analyzing the factors affecting the location choice of firms by using ”glocalization, network structure and market structure” as an analytical framework to study the IC assembling and testing industries in the Nantze Export Processing Zone. Through questionnaires and interviews, there are five important findings as follows. Firstly, land, labor and capital are still the important factors in the early stage of industrial development while the proximity with flagship firms and upstream and downstream industries are becoming key factors in the formation stage of spatial clustering of Industries. Secondly, because of holding advantages of production and consumer market share, innovation and catching ability of technology, flagship firms have the stable power to influence their upstream and downstream firms' location choice by affect their marketing strategies, location distribution and professionalized development model. Thirdly, the specific regional assets created by the local flagship firms that used to be local firms are the important driving force for making firms into a cluster at a certain place because flagship firm have the ability to combine together business decision with local network, a specific network forming by local cultural and social institution. Fourthly, different from the past finding, major innovation resources of IC assembling and testing industries were coming from the local inter-firm networks and international networks while they were used to be universities and research center. Fifthly, the local flagship firms can form a localized industrial cluster by constructing the cooperation and innovation network of upstream and downstream industries in order to force the industries to specialize their further development, and attract supplier firms to enter the network.

1. 楊友仁、夏鑄九(2005)。跨界生產網絡之在地鑲嵌與地方性制度之演化：以大東莞地區為例。都市與計劃，32(3)，275-299。
   連結：
2. Marshall, A., Principles of Economics: An Introductory Volume, New York: Free Press, 1890.
3. Amsden, A. H.,Chu, W.W.(2003).Beyond Late Development: Taiwan's Upgrading Policies.Cambridge:MIT Press.
4. Arita, T.,McCann, P.(2000).Industrial Alliances and Firm Location Behaviour: Some Evidence from the US Semiconductor Industry.Applied Economics,32,1391-1403.
5. Asanuma, B.,Kikutani, T.(1992).Risk Absorption in Japanese Subcontracting: A Microeconometric Study of the Automobile Industry.Journal of the Japanese and International Economies,6,1-29.
6. Asheim, B.(ed.),Cooke, P.(ed.),Martin, R.(ed.)(2006).Clusters and Regional Development: Critical Reflections and Explorations.London:Routledge.
7. Barba-Navaretti, G.,Venables, A. J.(2004).Multinational Firms in the World Economy.NJ:Princeton University Press.
8. Bathelt, H.,Malmberg, A.,Maskell, P.(2004).Clusters and Knowledge: Local Buzz, Global Pipelines and Process of Knowledge Creation.Progress in Human Geography,28(1),31-56.
9. Becattini, G. (ed.),Pyke, F. (ed.),Sengenberger, W. (ed.)(1990).Industrial districts and Inter-firm co-operation in Italy.Geneva:International Institute for Labour Studies.
10. Camagni, P.(1995).The Concept of "Innovative Milieu" and its Relevance for Public Policies in European Lagging Regions.Papers in Regional Science,74,317-340.
11. Castells, M.、夏鑄九譯、王志弘譯(1998)。網絡社會之崛起，資訊時代：經濟、社會與文化。台北:唐山出版社。
12. Caves, R. E.(1971).International Corporations: The Industrial Economics of Foreign Investment.Economica,38(149),1-27.
13. Coe, N.M.,Hess, M.,Yeung, H.W.-C.,Dicken, P.,Henderson, J.(2004).Globalizing Regional Development: A Global Production Networks Perspective.Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers,29(4),468-484.
14. Cook, P.,Morgan, K.(1998).The Associational Economy: Firms, Regions and Innovation.Oxford:Oxford University Press.
15. DTI(2001).Business Clusters in the UK - A First Assessment.DTI, London:Department of Trade and Industry.
16. Dunning, J. H.(1993).Multinational Enterprises and the Global Economy.Reading, MA:Addison Wesley.
17. Ernst, D.,Kim, L.(2002).Global Production Networks, Knowledge Diffusion, and Local Capability Formation.Research Policy,31(8-9),1417-1429.
18. European Commission(2002).Regional Cluster in Europe.Brussel:European Commission.
19. Feldman, M. P.(2001).The Entrepreneurial Event Revisited: An Examination of New Firm Formation in the Regional Context.Industrial and Corporate Change,10(4),861-891.
20. Feldman, M. P.,Francis, J.,Bercovitz, J.(2005).Creating a Cluster While Building a Firm: Entrepreneurs and the Formation of Industrial Clusters.Regional Studies,39(1),129-141.
21. Fujita, M.,Krugman, P. R.,Venables, A. J.(1999).The Spatial Economy.Cambridge, Mass:MIT Press.
22. Gordon, I. R.,McCann, P.(2000).Industrial Clusters: Complexes, Agglomeration and/or Social Networks.Urban Studies,37(3),513-532.
23. Harrigan, K.R.(1985).Strategies for Joint Ventures.Lexington, MA:Lexington Books.
24. Howells, J.,James, A.,Malik, K.(2003).The Sourcing of Technological Knowledge: Distributed Innovation Processes and Dynamic Change.R&D Management,33(4),395-409.
25. Isaksen, A.(2004).Knowledge-based Clusters and Urban Location: the Clustering of Software Consultancy in Oslo.Urban Studies,41(5/6),1157-1174.
26. IT IS Industry & Technology Intelligence Service(2008)。半導體年鑑。新竹市:工研院電子所。
27. Joseph, D. C.,Rugman, A.(1993).Business Network for International Competitiveness.Business Quarterly,56(4),101-107.
28. Keeble, D.,Wilkinson, F.(1999).Collective Learning and Knowledge Development in the Evolution of Regional Clusters of High-technology SMEs in Europe.Regional Studies,33(4),295-303.
29. Klepper, S.(2002).The Capabilities of New Firms and the Evolution of the US Automobile Industry.Industrial and Corporate Change,11,645-666.
30. Knoben, J.,Oerlemans, L.A.G.(2006).Proximity and Inter-organizational Collaboration: A literature Review.International Journal of Management Reviews,8(2),71-89.
31. Kung, S.-F.(1995).Cambridge,University of Cambridge.
32. Kung, S.-F.,Yen, Y.-C.(2009).A Sustainable Planning Approach for Science Parks: A Case of Southern Taiwan Science Park.WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment,120(1),141-150.
33. Liu, P.-W.,Yang, X.-K.(2000).The Theory of Irrelevance of the Size of the Firm.Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization,42,145-65.
34. Lorenzen, M.(2005).Why Do Clusters Change.European Urban and Regional Studies,12(3),203-208.
35. Malmberg, A.,Maskell, P.(2002).The Elusive Concept of Localization Economies: Towards a Knowledge-based Theory of Spatial Clustering.Environment and Planning A,34,429-449.
36. Markusen, A.(1996).Sticky Places in Slippery Space: A Typology of Industrial Districts.Economic Geography,72,293-313.
37. Markusen, J. R.(2002).Multinational Firms and the Theory of International Trade.Cambridge:MIT Press.
38. Martin, R.,Sunley, P.(2003).Deconstructing Cluster: Chaotic Concept or Policy Panacea.Journal of Economic Geography,3(1),5-36.
39. Maskell, P.(2001).Towards a Knowledge-based Theory of the Geographical Cluster.Industrial and Corporate Change,10,921-943.
40. Maskell, P.,Lorenzen, M.(2004).The Cluster as Market Organization.Urban Studies,41(5/6),991-1009.
41. McCalla, R. J.(1990).The Geographical Spread of Free Zones Associated with Ports.Geoforum,21(1),121-134.
42. Nachum, L.,Keeble, D.(2003).Neo-Marshallian Clusters and Global Networks: The Linkages of Media Firms in Central London.Long Range Planning,36(5),459-480.
43. Nooteboom, B.(1999).Inter-Frm Alliances: Analysis and Design.London:Routledge.
44. OECD(2007).Competitive Regional Clusters: National Policy ApproachesCompetitive Regional Clusters: National Policy Approaches,OECD Publishing.
45. OECD=Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development(2005).Business Clusters: Promoting Enterprise in Central and Eastern EuropeBusiness Clusters: Promoting Enterprise in Central and Eastern Europe,OECD Publishing.
46. Owen-Smith, J.,Powell, W. W.(2004).Knowledge Networks as Channels and Conduits: the Effects of Spillovers in the Boston Biotechnology.Organization Science,15,2-21.
47. Parr, J. B.,Wood, G. A.(2005).Transaction Costs, Agglomeration Economies, and Industrial Location.Growth and Change,36(1),1-15.
48. Piore, M. J.,Sabel, C. F.(1984).The Second Industrial Divide: Possibilities for Prosperity.New York:Basic Books.
49. Porter, M. E.(2000).Location, Competition, and Economic Development: Local Clusters in a Global Economy.Economic Development Quarterly,14(1),15-34.
50. Porter, M. E.(1990).The Competitive Advantage of Nations.New York:Free Press.
51. Powell, W. W.(1990).Neither Market nor Hierarchy: Network Forms of Organization.Research in Organizational Behavior,12,295-336.
52. Romijn, H.,Albu, M.(2002).Innovation, Networking, and Proximity: Lessons from Small High technology Firms in the United Kingdom.Regional Studies,36(1),81- 86.
53. Saxenian, A.(1994).Regional Advantage: Culture and Competition in Silicon Valley and Route 128.Cambridge:Harvard University.
54. Simmie, J.(2004).Innovation and Clustering in the Globalised International Economy.Urban studies,41(5/6),1095-1112.
55. Storper, M.(1997).The Regional World: Territorial Development in a Global Economy.New York:Guilford.
56. Storper, M.,Chen, Y.,Paolis, E. D.(2002).Trend and the Location of Industries in the OECD and European Union.Journal of Economic Geography,2,73-107.
57. Sturgeon, T. J.(2003).What Really Goes on in Silicon Valley? Spatial Clustering and Dispersal in Modular Production Networks.Journal of Economic Geography,3,199-225.
58. Taylor, M. J.(1975).Organizational Growth, Spatial Interaction and Location Decision-making.Regional Studies,9(4),313-323.
59. Tether, B. S.(2000).Employment Creation in Small Technological and Design Innovators in the U.K. During the 1980s.Small Business Economics,11(4),353-370.
60. Thorelli, H. B.(1986).Networks: Between Markets and Hierarchies.Strategic Management Journal,7,37-51.
61. Von Thüne, J. H.、吳衡康譯(1997)。孤立國同農業和國民經濟的關係。北京:商務印書館。
62. Weber, A.、李剛劍譯(1997)。工業區位理論。北京:商務印書館。
63. Wolfe, D. A.,Gertler, M. S.(2004).Clusters from the Inside and Out: Local Dynamics and Global Linkages.Urban Studies,41(5/6),1071-1093.
64. Yi, K.(2003).Can Vertical Specialization Explain the Growth of World Trade.Journal of Political Economy,111(1),52-102.
65. 張永生(2003)。廠商規模無關論－理論與經驗證據。中國人民大學出版社。
66. 張家銘(2006)。台商在蘇州：全球化與在地化的考察。台北市:桂冠出版社。
67. 陳東升(2003)。積體網絡：台灣高科技產業的社會學分析。台北市:群學出版社。
68. 陳玫錦(2002)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。國立高雄師範大學地理學系。
69. 葛震歐(1983)。加工出口區的創設。台北:聯經出版公司。
70. 簡旭伸、洪瑞國(1998)。90 年代台灣經濟特區之轉變-以1995 年加工出口區為例。經濟情勢暨評論季刊，3(4)，152-177。

1. 閻永祺、孔憲法(2014)。產業水平空間群聚型態與其空間結構之辨識：以台灣製造業為例。都市與計劃，41(2)，117-148。
2. 閻永祺、王鳳生、孔憲法(2015)。垂直生產行為與空間鄰近關係之辨識以臺灣製造業為例。地理學報，77，1-30。