共同製造商與零售商競爭策略之內生選擇

Endogenous Choice of Retailers Competition with a Common Manufacturer

賀光輝；許竹筌

製造商領導 ； 價格競爭 ； 數量競爭 ； Manufacturer Leadership ； Price Competition ； Quantity Competition

亞太經濟管理評論

17卷2期（2014 / 03 / 01）

17 - 32

繁體中文

本文在一家共同製造商與兩家零售商的通路架構下，探討零售商市場競爭策略的選擇。結果發現，在線性需求函數設定下，零售商將會採取數量競爭的方式，但此一競爭策略不利於製造商。同時，得出製造商會提供數量折扣（quantity discounts）的誘因，零售商之間的競爭會由數量競爭轉變成價格競爭。本文因此提出了製造商給與零售商數量折扣的理論基礎。

In the model of one manufacturer and two retailers, this paper investigated how retailers determine their market competition strategies. This finding disclosed that theses two retailers will adopt quantity competition. However, this competition is unfavorable to the manufacturer. This paper also pointed out that the manufacture will offer quantity discount as the motivation to interfere in the competition between retailers. The quantity competition will then turn into price competition which explains why the manufacturer provides quantity discount to his retailers.

1. Choi, S. C.(1996).Price Competition in a Duopoly Common Retailer Channel.Journal of Retailing,72(2),117-134.
2. Choi, S. C.(1991).Price Competition in a Channel Structure with a Common Retailer.Marketing Science,10(4),271-296.
3. Correa-López, M.,Naylor, R. A.(2004).The Cournot-Bertrand Profit Differential: A Reversal Result in a Differentiated Duopoly with Wage Bargaining.European Economic Review,48,681-696.
4. Gerstner, E.,Hess, J.(1991).A Theory of Channel Price Promotions.American Economic Reviews,81(4),872-886.
5. Grant, S.,Quiggin, J.(1994).Nash Equilibrium with Mark-up-pricing Oligopolists.Economics Letters,45,245-251.
6. Irmen, A.(1997).Mark-up Pricing and Bilateral Monopoly.Economics Letters,54,179-184.
7. Jeuland, A. P.,Shugan, S. M.(1988).Channel of Distrubution Profits when Channel Members Form Conjectures.Marketing Science,7(2),202-210.
8. Lai, K. K.,Leung, S. C.,Xiao, D.(2010).Revenue-Sharing versus Wholesale Price Mechanisms under Different Channel Power Structures.European Journal of Operational Research,203,532-538.
9. Lee, E.,Staelin, R.(1983).Vertical Strategic Interaction: Implications for Channel Pricing Strategy.Marketing Science,16(3),185-207.
10. McGuire, T.,Staelin, R.(1983).An Industry Equilibrium Analysis of Downstream Vertical Integration.Marketing Science,2(2),161-192.
11. Mukherjee, A.,Mukherjee, S.(2012).Bertrand versus Cournot Competition in a Vertical Structure: A Note.The Manchester School,80(5),545-559.
12. Raju, J. S.,Sethuraman, R.,Dhar, S.(1995).The Introduction and Performance of Store Brands.Marketing Science,41(6),957-978.
13. Shugan, S. M.(1985).Implicit Understandings in Channels of Distribution.Management Science,31(4),435-460.
14. Singh, N.,Vives, X.(1984).Price and Quantity Competition in a Differentiated Duopoly.Rand Journal of Economics,15,546-554.
15. Tyagi, R. K.(2005).Do Strategic Conclusions Depend on How Price Is Defined in Models of Distribution Channels?.Journal of Marketing Research,42,228-32.
16. Tyagi, R. K.(1999).A Characterization of Retailer Response to Manufacturer Trade Deals.Journal of Marketing Research,36,510-516.
17. 吳怡萱(2008)。精算到0.0001元才叫成本。商業周刊，1093，68-72。
18. 許竹筌、李仁耀、黃金樹、施惠秋(2009)。零售商領導下之訂價策略選擇：成本加成訂價與零售利差訂價之比較分析。台灣經濟學會年會，台北:
19. 廖俊雄、曾貝莉(2008)。複式通路下通路權力之福利分析。公平交易季刊，16(3)，21-52。

1. 黃金樹、許竹筌、方惠毅(2017)。獨家經銷下雙佔零售商領導訂價及其競爭方式。亞太經濟管理評論，20(2)，1-38。