Nonlinear Impacts of Real Income on Healthcare Expenditure: Evidence from Panel Smooth Transition Regression Approach

實質所得對健康支出的非線性影響：縱橫平滑移轉迴歸模型之實證

陳鳳琴

健康支出 ； 實質所得 ； 預期壽命 ； 縱橫平滑移轉迴歸模型 ； Healthcare Expenditure ； Real Income ； Life Expectancy ； Panel Smooth Transition Regression Model

亞太經濟管理評論

18卷2期（2015 / 03 / 01）

23 - 44

英文

本研究採用González et al. (2005)提出的縱橫平滑移轉迴歸模型，並考慮內生性偏誤問題，以1995-2011年的155個國家為實證樣本，探討健康支出的所得彈性，實證模型以人均實質所得和預期壽命為解釋變數，預期壽命為門檻變數，人均健康支出為內生變數，探討人均健康支出與人均實質所得的非線性關係及健康支出的所得彈性。實證結果顯示，存在兩個門檻值(3.830與4.303)，表示在此兩個點存在結構性轉變，將此縱橫資料分成低、中、高三個狀態。健康支出與實質所得在預期壽命的三個狀態均為正向顯著關係，意謂在低預期壽命狀態下(低於46歲)，實質所得愈高，健康支出急速增加；當預期壽命介於46~74歲中間狀態時，健康支出增加速度趨緩；但是到了高生命預期狀態時(超過74歲)，健康支出增加速度又逐漸加快。健康支出對人均實質所得的彈性在低預期壽命與高預期壽命兩種狀態時為「奢侈品」。此實證模型進一步檢測從低生命預期到高生命預期轉換的平滑度。

This study applies a Panel Smooth Transition Regression (PSTR) model which developed by González et al. (2005) and takes into account the potential endogeneity biases in order to establish country-specific and time-specific elasticities of healthcare expenditure with respect to real income for 155 selected countries for the period 1995–2011. This study sets real income per capital and life expectancy as the explanatory variable, life expectancy as the transition variable, and healthcare expenditure per capital as dependent variable to investigate the nonlinear relationship between healthcare expenditure per capital and real income per capital. Our empirical results indicate that there exist two threshold values of 3.830 and 4.303, which shows that there are structural changes at these two points. Both thresholds divide our panel into three regimes. There is a significantly positive relationship between healthcare expenditure and real income since the estimated coefficients of LGDP are significantly positive (2.319, 0.613 and 1.677) in the three regimes, suggesting that as real income rises, healthcare expenditure rapidly increases in low life expectancy countries, then slowly increases in the middle stage when life expectancy between approximately 46 and 74, and last gradually increases in the high regime after the values of life expectancy exceed approximately 74 old. The healthcare expenditure is elastic with to real income for the low and high regime, suggesting that they are a luxury good. This technique further estimates the smoothness of the transition from a low life expectancy to a high life expectancy regime.

1. Colletaz, G. and C. Hurlin, Threshold Effects of the Public Capital Productivity: An International Panel Smooth Transition Approach, University of Orleans Working Paper. Document de Recherche du Laboratoire d'Economie d'Orléans 2006. (pp. 2006-1).
2. Chakroun, M., Health Care Expenditure and GDP: an International Panel Smooth Transition Approach, Munich Personal RePEc Archive, 14322, 2009.
3. Acemoglu, D.,Johnson, S.(2007).Disease and Development: The Effect of Life Expectancy on Economic Growth.Journal of Political Economy,115,925-985.
4. Baltagi, B. H.,Moscone, F.(2010).IZA Discussion Paper SeriesIZA Discussion Paper Series,未出版
5. Barro, R. J.(1997).Determinants of Economic Growth: A Cross-county Empirical Study.Cambridge, MA:MIT Press.
6. Bereau, S.,Villavicencio, A. L.,Mignon, V.(2010).Nonlinear Adjustment of the Real Exchange Rate Towards its Equilibrium Value: A Panel Smooth Transition Error Correction Modelling.Economic Modelling,27(1),404-416.
7. Blomqvist, A. G.,Carter, R. A. L.(1997).Is Health Care Really a Luxury?.Journal of Health Economics,16,207-229.
8. Carrion-i-Silvestre, J. L.(2005).Health Care Expenditure and GDP: are they Broken Stationary?.Journal of Health Economics,24,839-854.
9. Chang, T.,Chiang, G.(2011).Regime-switching Effects of Debt on Real GDP per Capita the Case of Latin American and Caribbean Countries.Economic Modelling,28,2404-2408.
10. Davies, R. B.(1987).Hypothesis Testing when a Nuisance Parameter is Present Only under the Alternative.Biometrika,74,33-43.
11. Dregerd, C.,Reimers, H. E.(2005).IZA Discussion Paper SeriesIZA Discussion Paper Series,未出版
12. Eggoh, J.(2011).Inflation Effects on Finance-growth Link: A Panel Smooth Threshold Approach.International Economic Journal,16(4),1-15.
13. Fouquau, J.,Hurlin, C.,Rabaud, I.(2008).The Feldstein-Horioka Puzzle: A Panel Smooth Transition Regression Approach.Economic Modelling,25(2),284-299.
14. Gerdtham, U. G.,Löthgren, M.(2000).On Stationarity and Cointegration of International Health Expediture and GDP.Journal of Health Economics,19,461-475.
15. González, A.,Teräsvirta, T.,van Dijk, D.(2005).Panel Smooth Transition Regression Models.SE/EFI Working Paper Series in Economics and Finance,604
16. Granger, C. W. J.,Teräsvirta, T.(1993).Modelling Nonlinear Economic Relationships.Oxford:Oxford University Press.
17. Grossman, M.(1972).On the Concept of Health Capital and the Demand for Health.Journal of Political Economy,80,223-255.
18. Hansen, B. E.(1999).Threshold Effects in Non-dynamic Panels: Estimation, Testing and Inference.Journal of Econometrics,93,345-368.
19. Hansen, P.,King, A.(1996).The Determinants of Health Care Expenditure: A Cointegration Approach.Journal of Health Economics,15,127-137.
20. Haug, A. A.,Siklos, P. L.(2006).The Behavior of Short-term Interest Rates: International Evidence of Non-linear Adjustment.Studies in Nonlinear Dynamics & Econometrics,10(4),1-32.
21. Hitiris, T.(1997).Health Care Expenditure and Integration in the Countries of the European Union.Applied Economics,29,1-6.
22. Hitiris, T.,Nixon, J.(2001).Convergence of Health Care Expenditure in the EU Countries.Applied Economic Letters,8,223-228.
23. Hitiris, T.,Posnett, J.(1992).The Determinants and Effects of Health Expenditure in Developed Countries.Journal of Health Economics,11,173-181.
24. Hsiao, Cheng(2003).Analysis of Panel Data.New York:Cambridge University Press.
25. Huang, B. N.,Hwang, M. J.,Yang, C. W.(2008).Does more Energy Consumption Bolster Economic Growth? An Application of the Nonlinear Threshold Regression Model.Energy Policy,36,755-767.
26. Im, K. S.,Pesaran, M. H.,Shin, Y.(2003).Testing for Unit Roots in Heterogeneous Panels.Journal of Econometrics,115,53-74.
27. Jansen, E. S.,Teräsvirta, T.(1996).Testing Parameter Constancy and Super Exogeneity in Econometric Equations.Oxford Bulletin of Economics and Statistics,58,735-763.
28. Jewell, T.,Lee, J.,Tieslau, M.,Strazicich, M.C.(2003).Stationarity of Heath Expenditures and GDP: Evidence from Panel Unit Root Tests with Heterogeneous Structural Breaks.Journal of Health Economics,22,313-323.
29. Lago-Peñas, S.,Cantarero-Prieto, D.,Blázquez-Fernández, C.(2013).On the Relationship between GDP and Health Care Expenditure: A New Look.Economic Modelling,32,124-129.
30. Levin, A.,Lin, C. F.,Chu, C.(2002).Unit Root Tests in Panel Data: Asymptotic and Finite-sample Properties.Journal of Econometrics,108,1-24.
31. Liu, D.,Li, R.,Wang, Z.(2011).Testing for Structural Breaks in Panel Varying Coefficient Models: with an Application to OECD Health Expenditure.Empirical Economics,40(1),95-118.
32. Lopez-Casanovas, G.(ed.),Rivera, B.(ed.)(2005).Health and Economic Growth: Findings and Policy Implications.Massachusetts:MIT Press.
33. Luukkonen, R.,Saikkonen, P.,Teräsvirta, T.(1988).Testing Linearity Against Smooth Transition Autoregressive Models.Biometrika,75,491-499.
34. Mankiw, G.,Romer, D.,Weil, D.(1992).A Contribution to the Empirics of Economic Growth.Quarterly Journal of Economics,107(2),407-437.
35. Mehrara, M.,Musai, M.,Amiri, H.(2010).The Relationship between Health Expenditure and GDP in OECD Countries Using PSTR.European Journal of Economics, Finance and Administrative Sciences,24,1450-2275.
36. Newhouse, J. P.(1977).Medical Care Expenditure: A Cross National Survey.Journal of Human Resources,12,115-125.
37. Perlman, M.(ed.)(1974).The Economics of Health and Medical Care.London:Macmillan.
38. Seleteng, M.,Bittencourt, M.,Eyden, van R.(2013).Non-linearities in Inflation-growth Nexus in the SADC Region: A Panel Smooth Transition Regression Approach.Economic Modelling,30,149-156.
39. Sen, A.(2005).Is Health Care a Luxury? New Evidence from OECD Data.International Journal of Health Care Finance and Economics,5,147-164.
40. Teräsvirta, T.(1994).Specification, Estimation, and Evaluation of Smooth Transition Autoregressive Models.Journal of the American Statistical Association,89,208-218.
41. Ullah, A.(ed.),Giles, D. E. A.(ed.)(1998).Handbook of Applied Economic Statistics.New York:Marcel Dekker.
42. van Dijk, D.,Teräsvirta, T.,Franses, P. H.(2002).Smooth Transition Autoregressive Models-a Survey of Recent Developments.Econometric Reviews,21,1-47.
43. Wu, P. C.,Liu, S. Y.,Pan, S. C.(2013).Nonlinear Bilateral Trade Balance-fundamentals Nexus: A Panel Smooth Transition Regression Approach.International Review of Economics and Finance,27,318-329.