Landscapes, Animals and Human Beings: Elizabeth Bishop's Poetry and Ecocentrism

10.6387/INTERGRAMS.201012.0021

Iris Shu-O Huang

Elizabeth Bishop ； deep ecology ； ecocentrism ； anthropocentrism

intergrams

10卷2期&11卷1期（2010 / 12 / 01）

21 - 44

英文

Elizabeth Bishop's poetry is characterized by a deep gaze at the landscapes, containing animals and human beings - i.e. the vivid actuality of the earth as a biosphere, rather than anthropocentric absorption in idealism, logos or ideologies of human society. Although deviating from contemporary confessional poets, Bishop might be ranked among American nature writers due to her attachment to nature. Symptomatic of modern American nature writings, Bishop foregrounds nature; in Bishop's poetry nature is not an ornamental background upon which human dramas are played. Detailed facts of a natural scene or animals themselves often constitute the main texture of Bishop's poems, while human wills become insignificant. Critics describe these qualities of Bishop as reticence, impersonality or painters' craft. In this essay I seek to relate these characteristics of Bishop to an ecocentric worldview in terms of deep ecology. An ecocentric vision is seen in Bishop's poetry, in which other creatures register autonomy, while man is a mere component rather than dominant protagonist of the landscapes. Bishop's poetics illustrates an interactive egalitarianism, rather than sterile, hierarchical relationship between man and nature. Instead of the alienation resulting from authoritarian imposition of anthropocentrism, a reciprocal relationship between man and nature is brought about by Bishop's selfless stance of mutual esteem. Thus, in Bishop's scenes, there is a higher harmony, in which human consciousness ceases trying to give order to but surrenders itself to nature. Bishop's poetry evokes the reader's innocent, wholesome kinship to the land and other creatures of the earth, although the inherent link between man and nature may not be retrieved.

1. Berry, Wendell(1983).Standing by Words.San Francisco:North Point Press.
2. Bishop, Elizabeth(1986).On 'Confessional Poetry'.Elizabeth Bishop and Her Art,Ann Arbor:
3. Bishop, Elizabeth(1986).The 'Darwin' Letter.Elizabeth Bishop and Her Art,Ann Arbor:
4. Bishop, Elizabeth(1983).The Complete Poems: 1927-1979.New York:Farrar, Straus and Giroux.
5. Bishop, Elizabeth,Giroux, Robert(ed.)(1984).The Collected Prose.New York:Farrar, Straus and Giroux.
6. Bloom, Harold(1986).Foreword.Elizabeth Bishop and Her Art,Ann Arbor:
7. Bogan, Louise(1986).On North & South.Elizabeth Bishop and Her Art,Ann Arbor:
8. Buell, Lawrence(1995).The Environmental Imagination: Thoreau, Nature Writing, and the Formation of American Culture.London:The Belknap Press of Harvard UP.
9. Campbell, Sueellen(1996).The Land and Language of Desire: Where Deep Ecology and Post-Structuralism Meet.The Ecocriticism Reader,London:
10. Capra, Fritjof(1995).Deep Ecology: A New Paradigm.Deep Ecology for the Twenty-First Century,Boston:
11. Colwell, Anne(1997).Inscrutable Houses: Metaphors of the Body in the Poems of Elizabeth Bishop.London:The U of Alabama P.
12. Costello, Bonnie(1993).Elizabeth Bishop: Questions of Mastery.Cambridge:Harvard UP.
13. Coupe, Laurence(ed.)(2004).The Green Studies Reader: From Romanticism to Ecocriticism.London:Routledge.
14. Doreski, C. K.(1993).The Restraints of Language.New York:Oxford UP.
15. Ellis, Jonathan(2006).Art and Memory in the Work of Elizabeth Bishop.Hampshire, England:Ashgate.
16. Estess, Sybil P.(1986).Description and Imagination in Elizabeth Bishop's 'The Map'.Elizabeth Bishop and Her Art,Ann Arbor:
17. Evernden, Neil(1996).Beyond Ecology: Self, Place and the Pathetic Fallacy.The Ecocriticism Reader,London:
18. Gaard, Greta(ed.)(1993).Ecofeminism: Women, Animals, Nature.Philadelphia:Temple UP.
19. Glotfelty, Cheryll(ed.),Fromm, Harold(ed.)(1996).The Ecocriticism Reader,London:
20. Gordon, Jan B.(1985).Day and Distance: The Cartographic Imagination of Elizabeth Bishop.Elizabeth Bishop,New York:
21. Harrison, Victoria(1993).Elizabeth Bishop's Poetics of Intimacy.New York:Cambridge UP.
22. Meeker, Joseph W.(1996).The Comic Mode.The Ecocriticism Reader,London:
23. Oelschlaeger, Max(1991).The Idea of Wilderness.New Haven:Yale UP.
24. Rotella, Guy(1991).Reading & Writing Nature: The Poetry of Robert Frost, Wallace Stevens, Marianne Moore, and Elizabeth Bishop.Boston:Northeastern UP.
25. Rueckert, William(1996).Literature and Ecology: An Experiment in Ecocriticism.The Ecocriticism Reader,London:
26. Sanders, Scott Russell(1996).Speaking a Word for Nature.The Ecocriticism Reader,London:
27. Schwartz, Lloyd(ed.),Estess, Sybil P.(ed.)(1986).Elizabeth Bishop and Her Art.Elizabeth Bishop and Her Art,Ann Arbor:
28. Selden, Raman(ed.)(1988).The Theory of Criticism.New York:Longman.
29. Shigley, Sally Bishop(1997).Dazzling Dialectics: Elizabeth Bishop's Resonating Feminist Reality.New York:Peter Lang.
30. Starbuck, George(1986).The Work!': A Conversation with Elizabeth Bishop.Elizabeth Bishop and Her Art,Ann Arbor:
31. Travisano, Thomas J.(1988).Elizabeth Bishop: Her Artistic Development.Carlottesville:UP of Virginia.