觀眾體驗期待滿足因素之探討

Exploring the Factors to Satisfy the Experience Expectations of Museum Visitors

10.6432/TMR.201112.0097

沈介文(Chieh Wen Sheng)

觀眾研究 ； 體驗期待 ； 敘說分析 ； visitor study ； experience expectations ； narrative analysis

科技博物

15卷4期（2011 / 12 / 01）

99 - 122

繁體中文

近代博物館越來越以觀眾為主體，從而帶動觀眾研究的興起。過去，對於觀眾體驗期待的研究相對較少。其中，Sheng and Chen（2011）的研究將觀眾體驗期待進行分類，但沒有清楚說明，哪些博物館情境有助於觀眾滿足其體驗期待。本研究針對此一缺口進行探討，亦即探究博物館的哪些情境與觀眾體驗期待有關。首先，我們進行五場焦點座談以收集資料，並進行敘說分析，整理出不同體驗期待的滿足因素。例如，現場人員的態度與親切感，愉悅的音樂、場景或表演，誘發與滿足好奇心的場景，以及輕鬆適當的休憩安排等等，都能滿足觀眾對於輕鬆自在的體驗期待，而對於文化娛樂、身份認同、歷史懷舊以及跳脫現實這四種體驗期待，本研究也彙整出相關的滿足因素。最後，我們將這些滿足因素分成兩類，包括博物館單方面可以做到的以及必須透過行銷規劃與活動才有可能實現的滿足因素，並建議博物館可以先思考自己定位，然後調查觀眾期待，再就其間的差距進行管理，例如先就一些博物館單方面可實現的滿足因素著手，並持續針對第二類滿足因素進行改善。如此，將有助於建立與滿足符合其定位的觀眾期待。

Modern museum places much importance on visitors and such a phenomenon brings lots of visitor study. Many researchers argued that to understand the experience of visitors and to satisfy the expectations of visitors is valuable. But related researches are less. Sheng and Chen's research in 2011 classified the experience expectations of visitors into five categories. Nevertheless, they didn't clarify what kind of museum situations can satisfy the experience expectations of visitors. This study tries to make up this gap. Firstly, we carried out five focus group meetings and then using narrative analysis to extract the factors satisfying the experience expectations of visitors. For example, staff's kindly attitude, delighted music, curiosity satisfied situation, and a place for recreation are the factors possibly to satisfy the expectation of easiness and fun. Factors for other four categories are also extracted and after all we have some discussions and propose a few suggestions for museum management and further studies.

1. 王啟祥(2008)。博物館觀眾學習成果與影響研究的發展與啟示。博物館學季刊，22(4)，91-107。
   連結：
2. 劉婉珍(2008)。觀眾研究與博物館的營運發展。博物館學季刊，22(3)，21-37。
   連結：
3. CARE (2009). CARE home. Retrieved from http://www.care-aam.org/default.aspx
4. Aronson, E.,Wilson, T. D.,Akert, R. M.(2007).Social psychology.N.J.:Prentice Hall.
5. Baloglu, S.,Uysal, M.(1996).Market segments of push and pull motivations: A canonical correlation approach.International Journal of Contemporary Hospitality Management,8(3),32-38.
6. Berg, B. L.(1998).Qualitative research methods for the social sciences.Boston:Allyn and Bacon.
7. Borrie, W. T.,Roggenbuck, J. W.(2001).The dynamic emergent, and multi-phasic nature of one-site wilderness experiences.Journal of Leisure Research,33(2),202-228.
8. Burcaw, G. E.(1997).Introduction to museum work.London:AltaMira Press.
9. Carman, J.(2010).Promotion to heritage: How museum objects are made.Encouraging collections mobility - A way forward for museums in Europe
10. Chan, T. W.,Goldthorpe, J. H.(2007).The social stratification of cultural consumption: Some policy implications of a research project.Cultural Trends,16(4),373-384.
11. Chiou, W. B.,Wan, C. S.,Lee, H. Y.(2008).Virtual experience vs. brochures in the advertisement of scenic spots: How cognitive preferences and order effects influence advertising effects on consumers.Tourism Management,29(1),146-150.
12. Cohen, E.(2008).The changing faces of contemporary tourism.Society,45(4),330-333.
13. Culler, J. D.(1981).The pursuit of signs: Semiotics, literature, deconstruction.N.Y.:Cornell University Press.
14. Falk, J. H.,Dierking, L. D.(1992).The museum experience.Washington, D.C.:Whalesback Books.
15. Hertzman, E.,Anderson, D.,Rowley, S.(2008).Edutainment heritage tourist attractions: A portrait of visitors' experiences at Storyeum.Museum Management and Curatorship,23(2),155-175.
16. Hood, M. G.(1989).Leisure criteria of family par ticipation and nonpar ticipation in museums.Marriage & Family Review,13(3-4),151-169.
17. Housen, A.(1987).Three methods for understanding museum audiences.Museum Studies Journal,2(4),41-49.
18. Krueger, R. A.(1986).Focus group interviewing: A helpful technique for agricultural educators.The Visitor,73(7),1-4.
19. Larsen, S.(2007).Aspects of a psychology of the tourist experience.Scandinavian Journal of Hospitality and Tourism,7(1),7-18.
20. Larsen, S.,Mossberg, L.(2007).Editorial: The diversity of tourist experiences.Scandinavian Journal of Hospitality and Tourism,7(1),1-6.
21. Lieblich, A.(Ed.),Tuval-Mashiach, R. (Ed.),Zilber, T.(Ed.)(1998).Narrative research: Reading, analysis, and interpretation.CA:Sage Publications, Inc..
22. Lin, Y. N.(2009).Importance-performance analysis of the Taipei Fine Arts Museum's services.Museum Management and Curatorship,24(2),105-121.
23. Loomis, R. J.(1993).Planning for the visitor: The challenge of visitor studies.Museum visitor studies in the 90s,London:
24. MacDonald, S.(Ed.)(2006).A companion to museum studies.London:Blackwell publishing.
25. Merriman, N.(1991).Beyond the glass case: The public, museums, and heritage in Britain.London:Leicester University Press.
26. Nowacki, M. M.(2005).Evaluating a museum as a tourist product using the servqual method.Museum Management and Curatorship,20(3),235-250.
27. O''Dell, T.(2007).Tourist experiences and academic junctures.Scandinavian Journal of Hospitality and Tourism,7(1),34-45.
28. Pine, J.,Gilmore, G. H.(1998).Welcome to the experience economy.Harvard Business Review,76(4),97-105.
29. Robbins, S. P.,Judge, T.(2007).Essentials of organizational behavior (9th ed.).N. Y.:Prentice Hall.
30. Schmitt, B. H.(1999).Experiential marketing.Journal of Marketing,15(1),53-67.
31. Shaw, C.,Ivens, J.(2002).Building great customer experiences.N.Y.:Palgrave MacMillen.
32. Sheng, C. W.,Chen, M. C.(2011).A study of experience expectations of museum visitors.Tourism Management
33. Sheng, C. W.,Shen, M. J.,Chen, M. C.(2008).Special interest tour preferences and voluntary simplicity lifestyle.International Journal of Culture, Tourism and Hospitality Research,2(4),389-409.
34. Sheppard, B.(Ed.)(2000).Perspectives on outcome based evaluation for libraries and museums.Washington, D. C.:Institute of Museum and Library Services.
35. Trauer, B.(2006).Conceptualizing special interest tourism: Frameworks for analysis.Tourism Management,27(2),183-200.
36. Uriely, N.(2005).The tourist experience: Conceptual developments.Annals of Tourism Research,32,199-216.
37. Weaver, P. A.,Weber, K.,McCleary, K. W.(2007).Destination evaluation: The role of previous travel experience and trip characteristics.Journal of Travel Research,45(3),333-344.
38. 高辛勇(1987)。形名學與敘事理論：結構主義的小說分析法。台北市:聯經出版社。
39. 黃鈺琴(2006)。美術館的魅力。台北市:藝術家出版社。
40. 劉婉珍(2007)。博物館就是劇場。台北市:藝術家出版社。

1. 沈介文(2015)。博物館觀眾體驗與重遊意願之研究。科技博物，19(3)，99-125。