熊十力思想“最後定論”論

Hsiung Shih-li's Conceptualism of Final Conclusion

10.30407/BDCL.200706_(7).0005

林世榮(Shi-Rong Lin)

體用不二 ； 最後定論 ； 乾坤衍 ； Unity in essence and action ； Final conclusion ； Ch'ien K'un Yen

政大中文學報

7期（2007 / 06 / 01）

115 - 152

繁體中文

熊十力之《新唯識論》，提出了「體用不二」論，自有其不可磨滅之經典地位，但所引發之儒佛之爭，以及熊氏本身對其之揚棄，此即顯示應對之重新評估。而晚年著作，《原儒》、《體用論》、《明心篇》及《乾坤衍》，雖仍發揮「體用不二」此一根本義，但已大量刊落佛學內容，《乾坤衍》更無資於此，純由乾坤兩〈彖傳〉以言，可見不由佛家轉手，仍可言「體用不二」。且熊氏自言，《乾坤衍》雖「寫於危病之中」，然「心地坦然，神思弗亂」，是以「此為余之衰年定論」。故言熊氏思想之晚年定論，甚至其一生思想之最後定論，自當以《乾坤衍》為準，方可如理相應。

In Hsin Wei Shih Lun, Hsiung Shih-li presents the theory of ”unity in essence and action” which has its own significance and undeniable value; however, the argument between Confucianism and Buddhism caused by this theory and Hsiung's modification of his original ideas reveal that there is a need for reexamination on it. Although his later works, such as Yuan Ju, T'i Yung Lun, Ming Hsin P'ien and Ch'ien K'un Yen still develop the spirit of this theory, the study of Buddhism has embodied in them deeply. Especially in Ch'ien K'un Yen which is purely elaborated from ”Tuan Juan” of Ch'ien and K'un, it is perceivable that the theory of ”unity in essence and action” can still be discussed without referring to the study of Buddhism. Hsiung also confessed that although Ch'ien K'un Yen was written while he was seriously ill, he was at ease with various thoughts thinking, ”This is a year of bad luck.” Therefore, when it comes to the final conclusion of Hsiung's concepts in his later years or even through his lifetime, Ch'ien K'un Yen would certainly be the central idea to focus on.

1. (2003)。李光地《周易折中》發微－以乾坤二卦為示例的探討。第一屆青年儒學國際學術會議論文集，中壢:
2. (1996)。熊十力論著集之二－體用論。北京:中華書局。
3. (2002)。朱熹《周易本義》發微－以乾坤二卦為示例的探討。第一屆中國文學與文化全國學術研討會論文專集，桃園:
4. 孔穎達(1982)。《十三經注疏》本。台北:藝文印書館。
5. 王夫之(1998)。船山全書。長沙:嶽麓書社。
6. 司馬遷(1975)。史記。台北:鼎文書局。
7. 安居香山、中村璋八輯(1994)。緯書集成。北京:河北人民出版社。
8. 朱熹、嚴靈峰編(1976)。無求備齋易經集成。台北:成文出版社。
9. 牟宗三(2003)。牟宗三先生全集。台北:聯經出版公司。
10. 林世榮(1998)。熊十力早年思想研究。第四屆近代中國學術研討會論文集，中壢:
11. 班固(1995)。漢書。台北:鼎文書局。
12. 郭齊勇(1990)。熊十力與中國傳統文化。台北:遠流出版公司。
13. 傅偉勳(1991)。批判的繼承與創造的發展。台北:東大圖書公司。
14. 景海峰(1991)。熊十力。台北:東大圖書公司。
15. 景海峰、王守常(1988)。熊十力先生論著考略。中國哲學史研究
16. 焦循(1977)。雕菰集。台北:鼎文書局。
17. 程顥、程頤(1982)。二程集。台北:漢京文化事業公司。
18. 熊十力(2001)。熊十力全集，10(10)
19. 蔡仁厚(1987)。熊十力先生學行年表。台北:明文書局。