戲曲跨界創新的反思─以梅蘭芳時裝作品中京劇與話劇的媒合嘗試為例

Peking Opera Straddling of Zones Reconsidering-The Peking Opera and the Modern Drama Intermediary Gathers the Attempt Take the Mei Lanfang Fashionable Clothing Work in As the Example

10.30407/BDCL.201112_(16).0008

侯雲舒(Yun-Shu Hou)

京劇 ； 梅蘭芳 ； 時裝新戲 ； 話劇 ； 跨界 ； Peking opera ； Mei Lanfang ； fashionable clothing modern Peking opera ； drama ； straddling of zones

政大中文學報

16期（2011 / 12 / 01）

203 - 231

繁體中文

1914－1918是京劇大師梅蘭芳以「時裝」為主軸，開始創作一連串時裝新戲的關鍵時期，雖然這段時間相較於梅蘭芳整體的藝術演出生命而言是短暫的，但卻是提供他後來在創作屬於梅氏經典劇目的古裝新戲時，一個相當重要的實驗經驗及參考值。而我們若把時間向後推移到現今，對於傳統戲曲的跨界創新是近二十幾年來臺灣戲曲界的發展重點之一，舉凡跨文化、跨形式、跨劇種等等的不同嘗試，都有眾多新作品因而產生。本文意欲接合這一前一後兩個戲曲改變的重要時期，來觀察在時間的遷移下，在前仆後繼的不斷實驗中，現今所謂對傳統的創新與改變，與20世紀初梅蘭芳思考創新時，有無可以借鏡或提供反思之處，例如在藝術形式與內容間的搭配與融合，以及「跨界」所面臨到的本質相容性，都是戲曲跨界所必須面對最根本的問題。20世紀初期，是一個新舊形式交替、新舊世代交替的關鍵時刻，梅蘭芳做為此時期代表京劇表演藝術最重要的演員之一，他在面對內外在環境劇烈改變時的思考理路是什麼？本文所採取的觀察點有四：一、京劇質性轉變；二、京劇跨界接觸的環境；三、梅蘭芳由「京話合流」的現象中所得到的觸發；四、梅蘭芳在京劇與話劇跨界媒合的實際操作。藉由審視一代大師在面對新舊衝擊及交替時，所做出的種種努力與嘗試，相信對於反思21世紀戲曲跨界媒合的進程，當具有某種承先啟後的意義。

1914-1918 is Peking opera master Mei Lanfang take ”the fashionable clothing” as the main axle, starts to create a succession of fashionable clothing modern play the crucial phase, although this period of time compares in the Mei Lanfang whole artistic performance life says is short, but was actually provides him afterwards belonged to Mei the classical play goal ancient costume modern play when the creation, a quite important experiment experiences and refers to the value. But we if backward passes the nowadays the time, regarding the Peking opera straddling of zones innovation is one of nearly twenty for several year Taiwan Peking opera development priorities, all Trans-Culture, cross form, cross kind of drama and so on different attempt, all has the multitudinous new works thus produces. This article cares for the important time which joins this tandem two dramas to change, observes under the time migration, in takes place of the fallen in unceasing experiment, nowadays so-called to traditional innovation and change, with the beginning of the 20th century Mei Lanfang pondered when innovation, whether there is can profit by observing others or provides place of the reconsidering, for example in the artistic form and content matching and the fusion, the essential compatibility which as well as ”the straddling of zones” faces, all is the Peking opera straddling of zones must face the most basic question. The 20th century initial period, are a new old form, new old generation in turn critical moment, Mei Lanfang do in turn for this time represent one of Peking opera performing arts most important actors, what he in inside and outside which faces in the environment fierce change time ponder principle road is? This article adopts the viewpoint has four: First, Peking opera nature transformation; second, Peking opera straddling of zones contact environment; third, Mei Lanfang triggering which obtains by ”the Peking opera and drama confluence” phenomenon in; fourth, Mei Lanfang the actual operation which gathers at the Peking opera and the modern drama straddling of zones intermediary. Because of carefully examines a generation of master when faces the new old impact and in turn, makes all sorts of endeavors and the attempt, believed regarding reconsiders the advancement which the 21st century Peking opera straddling of zones intermediary gathers, when has the significance which some kind inherits from the past and carries on for the future.

1. 陳獨秀Chen Duxiou 主編：《新青年》Xin qingnian 第5 卷第4 號，上海shanghai：群益書社Qunyi shushe，1918 年。
2. 中國人民政治協商會議上海市委員會編、文史資料工作委員會編(1989)。戲曲菁英。上海=Shanghai:人民出版社=Renmin chubanshe。
3. 王安祈(2004)。京劇梅派藝術中梅蘭芳主體意識之體現。中國文哲專刊，29
4. 李伶伶(2002)。梅蘭芳全傳。北京=Beijing:中國青年出版社=Zhongguo qingnian chubanshe。
5. 侯雲舒(2006)。由費穆〈中國舊劇的電影化問題〉看中國戲曲與電影的初步融合。傳播與交融─第二屆中國小說戲曲國際學術研討會論文集，臺北=Taipei:
6. 康保成(1991)。中國近代戲劇形式論。桂林=Gueilin:漓江出版社=Lijiang chubanshe。
7. 梅蘭芳(1987)。舞臺生活四十年。北京=Beijing:中國戲劇出版社=Zhongguo xiju chubanshe。
8. 梅蘭芳、中國戲劇家協會編(1962)。梅蘭芳文集。北京=Beijing:中國戲劇出版社=Zhongguo xiju chubanshe。
9. 許姬傳(1994)。許姬傳藝壇漫錄。北京=Beijing:中華書局=Zhonghua shuju。
10. 蓋叫天口述、沈祖安記錄整理(1986)。燕南寄廬雜譚─蓋叫天談藝錄。北京=Beijing:中國戲劇出版社=Zhongguo xiju chubanshe。
11. 錢久元(2003)。博士論文(博士論文)。上海=shanghai，上海戲劇學院。
12. 譚志湘、吳乾浩(1993)。二十世紀中國戲劇舞臺。青島=Qingdao:青島出版社=Qingdao chubanshe。
13. 蘇移(1989)。京劇二百年概觀。北京=Beijing:燕山出版社=Yianshan chubanshe。

1. 吳岳霖(2015)。演員劇場的消解與重解： 從魏海敏的表演藝術探究戲曲的「當代性」。民俗曲藝，189，157-215。