A Framework to Evaluate n-Tier Architecture ERP Systems

10.29767/ECS.200503.0005

Hua-Yang Lin；Ping-Yu Hsu

Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) ； n-Tier Architecture ； Software Classification ； Cluster Analysis

Electronic Commerce Studies

3卷1期（2005 / 03 / 31）

79 - 96

英文

ERP systems are information systems that support the integration of value-added processes of enterprises. Based on the concept of modular structures, n-tier client/server architecture and centralized databases, numerous ERP systems have been developed in the market. The vast number of ERP products available has given users the chances to select suitable products for implementation. However, the lack of evaluation framework has made the selection process difficult. In this paper, a framework for analyzing and distinguishing ERP systems based on IT attributes is proposed. This design of the framework is based on client/server architecture, browser based computing, system integration standards and business enabling features. The framework includes 61 attributes and thus allows it to differentiate large number of software. Major ERP systems sold in the greater China area are evaluated with the framework to evaluate the discriminating capability of the framework. The result implies that the framework can reasonably discriminate major ERP systems.

1. Abdinnour-Helm, S.,Lengnick-Hall, M. L.,Lengnick-Hall, C. A..Pre-implementation attitudes and organizational readiness for implementing and Enterprise Resource Planning.European Journal of Operational Research,146(2),258-273.
2. Akkermans, H. A.,Bogerd, P.,Yücesan, E.,Van Wassenhove, L. N.(2003).The impact of ERP on supply chain management: exploratory finding from a European Delphi study.European Journal of Operational Research,146(2),284-301.
3. Aldenderfer, M. S.,Blashfield, R. K.(1984).A Sage University Paper: Cluster analysis.SAGE Publications,35-40.
4. Al-Mashari, M.,Al-Mudimigh, A.,Zairi, M.(2003).Enterprise resource planning: a taxonomy of critical factors.European Journal of Operational Research,146(2),352-364.
5. Anderegg, T.(2000).ERP: A-Z implementer`s guide for success.Resource Publishing,625-653.
6. Bafoutsou, G.,Mentzas, G.(2002).Review and functional classification of collaborative systems.International Journal of Information Management,22,281-305.
7. Bingi, P.,Sharma, M.,Godla, J.(1999).Critical issues affecting an ERP implementation.Information Systems Management,16(3),7-14.
8. Chung, S.,Snyder, C.(1999).ERP initiation-a historical perspective.Proceedings of Americas Conference on Information Systems
9. Davenport, T. H.(2000).Mission critical-realizing the promise of enterprise systems.Harvard Business School Press.
10. Davenport, T. H.(1998).Putting the enterprise into the enterprise system.Harvard Business Review,76(4),121-131.
11. Dillon, C.(1999).Stretching toward enterprise flexibility with ERP.APICS-The Performance Advantage
12. Dreyfus, P.(1998).The second wave-Netscape on usability in the services-based Internet.IEEE Internet Computing,March-April,36-40.
13. Ein-Dor, P.,Segev, E.(1993).A classification of information systems: analysis and interpretation.Information System Search,4(2),166-205.
14. Esteves, J. M.,Pastor, J. A.(1999).First international workshop in enterprise management and resource planning: methods, tools and architectures.
15. Gupta, A.(2000).Enterprise resource planning: the emerging organizational value systems.Industrial Management & Data Systems,103(3),114-118.
16. Holt, S.(1999).Competition heats up in ERP.InfoWorld,21(6),65.
17. Jacobs, F. R.,Bendoly, E.(2003).Enterprise resource planning: developments and directions for operations management research.European Journal of Operational Research,146(2),233-240.
18. Janson, M. A.,Subramanian, A.(1996).Packaged software: selection and implementation policies.INFOR,34(2),133-151.
19. Johnson, R. A.,Wichern, D. W.(1998).Applied multivariate statistical analysis.Prentice-Hall.
20. Kalakota, R.,Robinson, M.(2001).The race to mobility.McGraw-Hill.
21. Mabert, V. A.,Soni, A.,Venkatarmanan, M.A.(2000).Enterprise resource planning survey of U.S. manufacturing firms.Production and Inventory Management Journal,41(2),52-58.
22. Newell, S.,Huang, J. C.,Galliers, R. D.,Pan, S. L.(2003).Implementing enterprise resource planning and knowledge management systems in tandem: fostering efficiency and innovation complementarity.Information and Organization,13,25-52.
23. Olhager, J.,Seildin, E.(2003).Enterprise resource planning survey of Swedish manufacturing firms.European Journal of Operational Research,146(2),365-373.
24. Rao, S. S.(2000).Enterprise resource planning: business needs and technologies.Industrial Management & Data Systems,100(2),81-88.
25. Raol, J. M.,Koong, K. S.,Liu, L. C.,Yu, C. S.(2002).An identification and classification of enterprise portal functions and features.Industrial Management & Data Systems,102(7),390-399.
26. Sinha, A.(1992).Client/Server computing.Communication of the ACM,35(7),77-98.
27. Sprott, D.(2000).Componentizing the enterprise application packages.Communication of the ACM,43(4),63-69.
28. Sundarraj, R. P.,Talluri, S.(2003).A multi-period optimization model for the procurement of component-based enterprise information technologies.European Journal of Operational Research,146(2),339-351.
29. Tarn, J. M.,Yen, D. C.,Beaumont, M.(2002).Exploring the rationales for ERP and SCM integration.Industrial Management & Data Systems,102(1),26-34.
30. Van Everdingen, Y.,Van Hillegersberg, J.,Waarts, E.(2000).ERP Adoption by European Midsize Companies.Communication of the ACM,43(4),27-31.
31. Willis, T. H.,Willis-Brown, A. H.(2002).Extending the value of ERP.Industrial Management & Data Systems,102(1),35-38.