從顧客角度檢視公關隱瞞行爲對組織－群衆關係之影響：以便利商店爲例

The Impact of Concealment on Organization-Public Relationships form the Perspective of Customers: The Case of Convenience Store

10.6195/cjcr.2007.11.08

劉正道(Cheng-Tao Liu)

公共關係 ； 隱瞞 ； 組織－群眾關係 ； 公關道德 ； public relations ； concealment ； organization-public relationships ； public relations ethics

中華傳播學刊

11期（2007 / 06 / 01）

209 - 241

繁體中文

本文給頸客觀黑術視公關隱瞞行為對企業－群眾關係的影響。根據某便利商店顧客的看法，公關隱瞞事由－「利他」及「雇主利益」考量，會減緩原本不認同企業隱瞞行為的程度。對企業隱瞞為抱持「可接受」看法的顧客而言，其接受程度則會依序受到「利他」、「雇主利益」及「自由利益」等考量的影響而提高。此外，企業－群眾關係－「承諾」的程度，會依序受到公關隱瞞事由－「利他」、「雇主利益」及「自身利益」考量的影響而提升，而「相互制衡」及「信任」的程度只會受到「利他」考量的影響而上升。

This study examines the impact of concealment on organization-public relationships as seen from the perspective of customers. This study, based on the survey of a convenience store's customers suggested that if concealment on the part of PR professionals is motivated by a concern for the interests of employees and employer, customers may be less likely to condemn concealment. The determinants of acceptance are, in ascending order of importance, are concern for the interests of employees, employer, and self. The study also found that commitment varies with concern for employees, employer and self. Mutual control and trust, however, are correlated with concern for the interest of other employees.

1. 呂之蕙(2006)。台灣公共關係道德教育的初探研究。傳播與管理研究，6(1)，101-130。
   連結：
2. Atkinson, A. S.(2002).Ethics in financial reporting and corporate communication professional.Corporate Communications: An International Journal,7(4),212-218.
3. Baker, S.,Martinson, D. L.(2001).The TARES test: Five principles for ethical persuasion.Mass Media Ethics,16(2&3),148-175.
4. Barney, R. D.,Black, J.(1994).Ethics and professional persuasive communications.Public Relations Review,20(3),233-248.
5. Batory, S. S.,Neese, W.,Batory, A. H.(2005).Ethical marketing practices: An investigation of antecedents, innovativeness and business performance.Journal of America Academy of Business,6(2),135-142.
6. Berry, C. T.(2004).Perceptions of the ethics of specific insurance practices: Discrepancies between students and professionals.CPCU eJournal,57(2),1-12.
7. Bivins, T. H.(1993).Public relations, professionalism, and the public interest.Journal of Business Ethics,12(2),117-126.
8. Bowen, S. A.(2005).A practical model for ethical decision making in issue management and public relations.Journal of Public Relations Research,17(3),191-216.
9. Broom, G. M.,Casey, S.,Ritchey, J.(1997).Toward a concept and theory of organization-public relationship.Journal of Public Relations Research,9(2),83-98.
10. Brunging, S. D.,Galloway, T.(2003).Expanding the organization-public relationship scale: Exploring the role that structural and personal commitment play in organization-public relationships.Public Relations Review,29(3),309-319.
11. Bruning, S. D.(2002).Relationship building as a retention strategy: Linking relationship attitudes and satisfaction evaluations to behavioral outcomes.Public Relations Review,28(1),39-48.
12. Bruning, S. D.,Ledingham, J. A.(1999).Relationships between organizations and publics: Development of a multi-dimensional organization-public relationship scale.Public Relations Review,25(2),157-170.
13. Burnett, M.,Keith, N.,Pettijohn, C.(2003).An empirical analysis of factors influencing student reactions to ethical advertising dilemmas: Educational experience, work experience, ethical philosophy, and demographics.Marketing Education Review,13(1),33-46.
14. Deaver, F.(1990).On defining truth.Journal of Mass Media Ethics,5(3),168-177.
15. Drobis, D. R.(1993).Duty to inquire benefits organizations.Public Relations Journal,July,31-32.
16. Edgett, R.(2002).Toward an ethical framework for advocacy in public relations.Journal of Public Relations Research,14(1),1-26.
17. Ekman, P.(1992).Telling lies.New York:Norton.
18. Englehardt, E. E.,Evans, D.(1994).Lies, deception, and public relations.Public Relations Review,20(3),249-266.
19. Fitzpatrick, K. R.(1996).The role of public relations in the institutionalization of ethics.Public Relations Review,22(3),249-258.
20. Fitzpatrick, K. R.,Gauthier, C.(2001).Toward a professional responsibility theory of public relations ethics.Journal of Mass Media Ethics,16(2&3),193-212.
21. Grunig, J. E.,Huang, Y.,J. A. Ledingham,S. D. Bruning (Eds.)(2000).Public relations as relationship management: A relational approach to the study and practice of public relations.Hillsdale, NJ:Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Inc..
22. Hair, J. F.,Anderson, R. E.,Tatham, R. L.,Black, W. C.(1998).Multivariate data analysis: with readings.Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey:Prentice-Hall, Inc..
23. Hon, L. C.,Grunig, J. E.(1999).Guidelines for measuring relationships in public relations.Report for the Commission on Public Relations Measurement and Evaluation, the Institute for Public Relations.
24. Huang, Y.(2001).Values of public relations: Effects on organization-public relationships mediating conflict resolution.Journal of Public Relations Research,13(4),265-301.
25. Huang, Y.(2001).OPRA: A cross-cultural, multiple-item scale for measuring organization-public relationships.Journal of Public Relations Research,13(1),61-90.
26. Kaydo, C.(2000).Are your PR people lying for you?.Sales & Marketing Management,152(7),16.
27. Kim, Y.,Choi, Y.(2003).Ethical standards appear to change with age and ideology: A survey of practitioners.Public Relations Review,29,79-89.
28. Kleiser, S. B.,Sivadas, E.,Kellaris, J. J.,Dahlstrom, R. F.(2003).Ethical ideologies: Efficient assessment and influence on ethical judgments of marketing practices.Psychology & Marketing,20(1),1-21.
29. Ledingham, J. A.(2003).Explicating relationship management as a general theory of public relations.Journal of Public Relations Research,15(2),181-198.
30. Martinson, D. L.(2000).Ethical decision making in public relations: What would Aristotle say?.Public Relations Quarterly,45(3),18-21.
31. Meltzer, B. N.(2003).Lying: Deception in human affairs.The International Journal of Sociology and Social Policy,23(6/7),61-79.
32. Miyamoto, C.(1996).Public relations ethics 201: Challenges we can`t ignore.Paper presented at Mega Comm `96, Sheraton Waikiki Hotel.
33. Olasky, M. N.(1985).Inside the amoral world of public relations: Truth molded for corporate gain.Business & Society Review,52,41-44.
34. Parkinson, M.(2001).The PRSA code of professional standard and member code of ethics: Why they are neither professional nor ethical.Public Relations Quarterly,46(3),27-31.
35. Pratt, C. B.(1991).Public relations: The empirical research on practitioner ethics.Journal of Business Ethics,10(3),229-236.
36. Pratt, C. B.,Im, S.,Montague, S. N.(1994).Investigating the application of deontology among U.S. public relations practitioners.Journal of Public Relations Research,6(4),241-266.
37. Rafe, S. C.(2000).What is a lie?.Public Relations Tactics,7(12),21-22.
38. Shick, T. A.(1994).Truth, accuracy, and withholding information.Public Relations Quarterly,Winter,7-10.
39. Tammy, P.,Kiser, S. B.(2002).Lies, lies, and more lies.S.A.M. Advanced Management Journal,67(2),9-14, 36.
40. Thomas, H.(2002).Ethics and PR.Journal of Communication Management,6(4),308-310.
41. Tsai, M.,Shih, C.(2005).The influences of organizational and personal ethics on role conflict among marketing managers: An empirical investigation.International Journal of Management,22(1),54-61.
42. 呂之蕙(2001)。公共關係專業人員的道德規範。公關雜誌，45，8-10。
43. 周伯濤(1997)。公關道德與企業利潤孰重？良心乎？飯碗乎？。公關雜誌，20，39-41。
44. 邱皓政(2002)。量化研究與統計分析。台北:五南。
45. 孫秀蕙(2000)。公共關係：理論、策略與研究實例。台北:正中。
46. 袁自玉(1992)。公共關係。台北:前程企業管理公司。
47. 張在山(2000)。公共關係學。台北:五南。
48. 張依依(2005)。公共關係專業倫理初探－「形象論」及其適用情境。廣告學研究，23，35-60。
49. 黃懿慧(2001)。公共關係之「關係」研究－研究方向的省思與展望。廣告學研究，17，21-44。
50. 趙學舜(2001)。做是不做，該是不該。公關雜誌，45，20-23。
51. 劉美琪(1994)。廣告從業人員專業道德認知研究。廣告學研究，3，145-158。