媒介與性別研究的在地紮根

Local Grounding of Media and Gender Studies

10.6195/cjcr.2009.16.02

蕭蘋(Ping Shaw)

中華傳播學刊

16期（2009 / 12 / 01）

15 - 23

繁體中文

本文主要在回應楊芳枝教授探討台灣傳播與性別研究成果的論文，本文認為楊教授的論文雖然提供了對於性別研究在傳播與文化研究學門中居於少數弱勢地位態勢的基本描繪，但卻缺乏與台灣過去相關研究文獻的對話和比較。本文因此選擇四篇從1990年代至今最為有關的文獻内容，就其研究方法、結果與建議加以說明，進而共同比較楊教授的論文和過去四篇論文的主要發現，並討論其中所具有的意涵。

This article is a response to professor Fang-chi Yang's paper which explores the development of media and gender studies in Taiwan. Although Yang's paper presents the picture of the underdevelopment of media and gender studies, it lacks the comparison and dialogue with other relevant local studies. Therefore, this article selects four most relevant local papers since 1990s, makes comparisons among them and Yang's study, and discusses the significant implications.

1. Television New Zealand Act.
2. Adorno, T.,Horkheimer, M.,O. Boyd-Barrett (Eds.),C. Newbold (Eds.)(1995).Approaches to media.London:Edward Arnold.
3. Barrowclough, D.,W. Bartlett (Eds.),J. A. Roberts (Eds.),J. L. Grand (Eds.)(1998).A revolution in social policy: Quasi-market reforms in the 1990s.Bristol:The Policy Press.
4. Bauman, Z.(1998).Work, consumerism and the new poor.Buckingham:Open University Press.
5. Green light for quotas
6. Bens, E. D.,Kelly, M.,Bakke, M.,K. Siune (Eds.),W. Truetzschler (Eds.)(1992).Dynamics of media politics: Broadcast and electronic media in Western Europe.London:Sage.
7. Bourdieu, P.(1998).Contre-feux: Propos pour servir à la résistance contre l'invasion néo-libérale.Raisons D'agir.
8. Nationals defeated in New Zealand elections
9. Brants, K.,Hulten, O.,K. Siune (Eds.),W. Truetzschler (Eds.)(1992).Dynamics of media politics: Broadcast and electronic media in Western Europe.London:Sage.
10. Brants, K.,Siune, K. (Eds.),W. Truetzschler (Eds.)(1992).Dynamics of media politics: Broadcast and electronic media in Western Europe.London:Sage.
11. TVNZ a 'dentist with rusty pliers'
12. Govt moves quickly on programme of positive change
13. Building cultural identity
14. Prime Minister's statement to parliament
15. Heart of the nation project
16. Government announces major investment in arts, culture and heritage
17. Paper presented at the GPN Asia/Pacific regionalmeeting
18. Cuilenburg, J. V.,Slaa, P.(1993).From media policy towards a national communications policy: Broadening the scope.European Journal of Communication,8,149-176.
19. Media International Australia, Incorporating Culture and Policy
20. Curran, J.,Seaton, J.(1997).Power without responsibility: The Press and broadcasting in Britain.London:Routledge.
21. The creative industries mapping document
22. A public service for all: The BBC in the digital age
23. Culture and creativity: In the next ten years
24. New Zealand music
25. Debrett, M.(2004).Branding documentary: New Zealand's minimalist solution to cultural subsidy.Media, Culture and Society,26(1),5-23.
26. Flew, T.(2002).Beyond ad hocery: Defining creative industries.Paper presented to Cultural sites, cultural theory, cultural policy, the second international conference on cultural policy research.
27. FOPB latest news
28. FOPB Newsletter
29. Garnham, N.(1987).Concepts of culture: Public policy and the cultural industries.Cultural Studies,1(1),23-37.
30. Garnham, N.(1990).Capitalism and communication.London:Sage.
31. Garnham, N.(2005).From cultural to creative industries: An Analysis of the implications of the "creative industries" approach to arts and media policy making in the United Kingdom.International Journal of Cultural Policy,11(2),15-29.
32. State about TVNZ blurs real picture
33. Giddens, A.(2000).The third way and its critics.Cambridge:Polity Press in association with Big Apple Tutle-Mori Agency, Inc..
34. Giddens, A.(1998).The third way: The Renewal of social democracy.Cambridge:Polity Press.
35. Unitec forum on public broadcasting
36. TVNZ draft charter released
37. TVNZ Charter
38. Capital development agency forum on film and television
39. Hope, W.,A. Calabrese (Eds.),J. C. Burgelman (Eds.)(1999).Communication, citizenship and social policy.New York:Rowman and Littlefield.
40. Horrocks, R.(2004).Turbulent television: The New Zealand experiment.Television and New Media,5(1),55-68.
41. ISP Working Papers
42. Paper presented for the "Changing Media-Changing Europe" research programme of the European Science Foundation
43. Jin, D.(2006).Cultural politics in Korea's contemporary films under neoliberal globalization.Media, Culture and Society,28(1),5-23.
44. Jones, G.(2006).Future funding of PSBs.Commonwealth Broadcaster,152,4-5.
45. KBS韓國放送(2006)。2004/2005 KBS年度報告。
46. Keane, J.(1995).Structural transformations of the public sphere.The Communication Review,1(1),1-22.
47. L.E.K. Consulting(2001).New Zealand and talent initiative: Strategies for building a talented nation.Wellington:L.E.K. Consulting.
48. Lealand, G.,J. Farnsworth (Eds.),I. Hutchison (Eds.)(2001).New Zealand television: A Reader.Palmerston North:Dunmore Press Limited.
49. Television New Zealand and the current broadcasting context
50. McQuail, D.,Siune, K. (Eds.),Truetzschler, W. (Eds.)(1992).Dynamics of media politics: Broadcast and electronic media in Western Europe.London:Sage.
51. Ministry for Culture and Heritage(1999).Survey on local content: Summary of views.Wellington:New Zealand Government.
52. Government's role in the cultural sector: A Survey of the issues
53. Murdock, G.,M. Ferguson (Ed.)(1990).Public communication.London:Sage.
54. Paper presented at ANZCA 2003 Conference
55. Chief outlines 'major problem' at TVNZ
56. Reshaping public broadcasting: The New Zealand experience 1988-2003
57. Public broadcasting in the digital age: Issues for New Zealand
58. NZ Institute of Economic Research Inc.(2002).Scoping the lasting effects of the Lord of the Rings.Wellington:NZ Institute of Economic Research Inc..
59. Local content 2004
60. Local content 2000
61. Social democracy and market reform in Australia and New Zealand
62. Roscoe, J.(2000).Documenting the immigrant nation: Tensions and contradictions in the representation of immigrant communities in a New Zealand television documentary series.Media, Culture and Society,22(3),243-261.
63. Shim, D.(2006).Hybridity and the rise of Korean popular culture in Asia.Media, Culture and Society,28(1),25-44.
64. Shim, D.(2002).South Korean media industry in the 1990s and the economic crisis.Prometheus,20(4),337-350.
65. SpadaNEWS
66. SpadaNEWS
67. Syvertsen, T.(2003).Challenges to public television in the era of convergence and commercialization.Television and New Media,4(2),155-175.
68. Time to admit that the TVNZ Charter was a disaster
69. 2002 arts and culture policy
70. The Report of the Screen Production Taskforce: Taking on the world
71. The Treasury(1984).Economic management.Wellington:New Zealand Government.
72. Unto God or unto Caesar? Television after the TVNZ Charter
73. Thompson, P. A.(2000).A Road to nowhere? Broadcasting and the 'Third Way' in New Zealand.Paper presented at the 'Mediating Democracy-Cultural Perspectives on Political Participation' conference.
74. Throsby, D.(2001).Economics and culture.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
75. Cultural sector in great shape one year on from Cultural Recovery Package
76. TVNZ(2003).Statement of intent: For Year to June 2004.Television New Ltd..
77. TVNZ annual report
78. TVNZ annual report
79. TVNZ interim report
80. TVNZ and producers agree on terms of trade: TVNZ media releases
81. Minority-interest programmes may suffer in TVNZ sale
82. Report: TVNZ v.s. independent producers
83. Van Cuilenburg, J.,McQuail, D.(2003).Media policy paradigm shifts: Toward a new communication policy paradigm.European Journal of Communication,18(2),181-207.
84. TV News: Points of view on The Point
85. Thousands join New Zealand anti-poverty march
86. A new rift in New Zealand's government
87. New Zealand Labour Party reassure big business
88. Yim, H.(2003).The emergency and change of cultural policy in South Korea.Seoul:Jin Han Book.
89. 王志弘譯(2002)。工作、消費與新貧。台北:巨流。
90. 行政院開發基金投資數位內容、軟體及文化創意產業計畫
91. 宋東(2004)。紐西蘭變身「電影大國」？。天下雜誌，295，42-43。
92. 李欣岳(2004)。魔戒　燒熱紐西蘭文化工業。數位時代，73，24。
93. 孫智綺譯(2002)。防火牆：抵擋新自由主義的入侵。台北:麥田。
94. 高安邦(2005)。廣播電視產業國外資訊採購案。行政院新聞局委託調查研究案。
95. 張維倫譯(2003)。文化經濟學。台北:典藏藝術。
96. 張瑩(2003)。「魔戒」魔法　點亮紐西蘭電影業。商業周刊，838，186-187。
97. 許家豪譯(2002)。第三條路及其批評。台北:聯經。
98. 陳依秀(2004)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。淡江大學大眾傳播學系。
99. 建構台灣媒體新地景：關鍵時刻的關鍵角色
100. 國政分析
101. 馮建三(1992)。資訊‧錢‧權。台北:時報文化。
102. 苦勞網
103. 監察院文化與教育委員會(2005)。我國影音媒體政策及其執行績效總體檢。台北:監察院文化與教育委員會。
104. 管中祥(1997)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。政治大學新聞研究所。
105. 鄭武國譯(1999)。第三條路：社會民主的更新。台北:聯經。
106. 魏玓譯、劉昌德譯(2001)。有權無責：英國的報紙與廣電媒體。台北:國立編譯館。