企業公民與媒體報導：一個公民社會的觀點

Corporate Citizenship and Media Coverage: From the Perspective of Civil Society

10.6195/cjcr.2010.17.05

楊意菁(Yie-Jing Yang)

公民社會 ； 企業公民 ； 企業社會責任 ； 媒體報導 ； corporate citizenship ； civil society ； corporate social responsibility ； media coverage

中華傳播學刊

17期（2010 / 06 / 01）

95 - 138

繁體中文

本研究以公民社會概念為基礎的企業公民意涵，說明媒體報導企業公民新聞所呈現的內涵與意義，並藉此了解媒體報導企業公民新聞與公民社會之間的可能關連。本研究採用內容分析方法，分析1996年以及2006年台灣兩家報紙－聯合報以及工商時報，總樣本數為610則。研究結果顯示報紙媒體越來越重視企業公民的新聞報導，但多數新聞仍主要出現在財經新聞版面，且較少採用「企業公民」一詞。以三大議題層面結果分析，「擴展與社會參與層面」之議題受到媒體較多的報導，「經濟層面」次之，「法律道德層面」最少。而個別企業公民議題方面，早期（1996年）以「經濟層面」的「生產良好產品」為最多，近期（2006年）則是「社會參與」層面的「慈善贊助」議題為最多。另外，大型企業較關注「藝文教育」與「環保」等社會參與議題，中小型企業則偏重於自利之「生產良好產品」等經濟層面議題。至於消息來源方面，相關新聞仍以企業人士為主，其他消息來源相對較少。而新聞議題所呈現的受益對象，從早期關注於企業本身及員工、投資人與消費者的面向，到近期已轉移到非消費之個人、社會以及公益團體。

This study examined the meaning of corporate citizenship (CC) and its relationship with media coverage. The study focused on the perspective of CC by civil society. The research methodology used in was content analysis. The researchers selected articles from two major Taiwanese newspapers from two different years 1996 and 2006. The total number of samples was 610. The results showed that newspapers began to place greater emphasis on corporate citizenship concerning civil issues. The newspaper articles infrequently used the term corporate citizenship” Most subjects of the ne s stories concerned issues of social involvement and economics. Few news articles focused on issues of ethics and law. Most of the news articles in 1996 dealt with issues of producing good products. The issue of corporate responsibility to the support of charities moved to the number one news subject in 2006.Press coverage of large corporations focused on issues of social involvement. Corporate CEOs and corporate employees were the major news sources for CC.

1. BBC Chinese.com（2002）。〈什麼是公民社會〉，上網日期：2009年8月25日，取自 http://news.bbc.co.uk/hi/chinese/news/newsid_1802000/18022652.stm
2. 企業永續發展全球資訊網（2010.2.1）。〈全球蘇利文原則〉。上網日期：2010 年2 月1 日，取自http://www.csr.tw/Page_Show.asp?Page_ID=318
3. 江逸之（2006.04.18）。〈上市企業道德分數68.2 分……企業社會責任當道〉，《經濟日報》，A14 版
4. 林倖妃（2004.04.27）。〈信義房屋一億贊助社區活動：社區營總體營造十年最大規模企業捐獻，期盼打破人際冰凍疆局鼓勵家留台灣〉，《中國時報》，A1 版
5. 姚盈如（2007.07.05）。〈募得水蜜桃嬤善款6 百萬 購買自家出版品捐學校 高金素梅批自肥 商周質疑動機。〉，《中國時報》，A8 版
6. 張順傑（2006）。〈企業無法逃避的話題―社會企業責任〉。上網日期：2009 年8 月25 日，取自「台灣企業社會責任」http://csr.idic.gov.tw/articles_content.asp?_ID=1057
7. Alexander, J. C.(1998)。Real civil societies: Dilemmas of institutionalization。London:Sage。
8. Ashforth, B. E.,Mael, F.(1989).Social identity theory and the organization.Academy of Management Review,12,20-39.
9. Bae, J.,Cameron, G. T.(2006).Conditioning effect of prior reputation on perception of corporate giving.Public Relations Review,32,144-150.
10. Burchell, J.,Cook, J.(2006).Confronting the "corporate citizen" shaping the discourse of corporate social responsibility.International Journal of Sociology and Social Science,26,121-137.
11. Carroll, A. B.(1979).A three-dimensional conceptual model of corporate social performance.Academy of Management,4,497-505.
12. Carroll, A. B.(1999).Corporate social responsibility.Business and Society,38,268-295.
13. Cohen, B. C.(1963).The press and foreign policy.Princeton, NJ:Princeton University Press.
14. David, P.,Kline, S.,Dai, Y.(2005).Corporate social responsibility practices, corporate identity, and purchase intention: A dual-process model.Journal of Public Relations Research,17,291-313.
15. De George, R. T.(2008).Reflections on "citizenship, Inc.".Business Ethics Quarterly,18(1),43-50.
16. Dewey J.(1954).The public and its problems.Chicago:The Swallow Press.
17. Diamond, L.(1996).Toward democratic consolidation.The global resurgence of democracy,Baltimore:
18. Dominick, R. J.,Wimmer, R. D.(2006).Mass media research-An introduction.Belmont, CA:Thomson Wadsworth.
19. Dutta-Bergman, M. J.(2005).Civil society and public relations: Not so civil after all.Journal of Public Relations Research,17,267-289.
20. Edwards, M.(2004).Civil society.Cambridge, UK:Polity Press.
21. Esrock, S. L.,Leichty, G. B.(1998).Social responsibility and corporate web pages: Self-presentation or agenda-setting?.Public Relations Review,24,305-319.
22. Fraser, N.(1992).Rethinking the public sphere: A contribution to the critique of actually existing democracy.Habermas and the public sphere,Cambridge, MA:
23. Freimond, C.(2007).Global warming reaches the boardroom.Communication World,24(6),22-24.
24. Gaunt, P.,Ollenburger, J.(1995).Issues management revisited: A tool that deserves another look.Public Relations Review,21(3),199-210.
25. Golob, U.,Bartlett, J.(2007).Communicating about corporate social responsibility: A comparative study of CSR reporting in Australia and Slovenia.Public Relations Review,33(1),1-9.
26. Googins, B. K.,Mirvis, P. H.,Rochlin, S. A.(2007).Beyond "good company"-Next generation corporate citizenship.New York:Palgrave-MacMillan.
27. Habermas, J.,Burger, T.(trans.)(1962).The structural transformation of the public sphere.London:Polity Press.
28. Hall, M.(2006).Corporate philanthropy and corporate community relations: Measuring relationship-building results.Journal of Public Relations Research,18(1),1-21.
29. Hancock, J.(ed.)(2005).Investing in corporate social responsibility.London & Sterling:Kogan Page.
30. Hay, R.,Gray, E. R.(1974).Social responsibilities of business manager.Academic of Management Review,1,135-143.
31. Heath, R. L.,Ryan, M.(1989).Public relations' role in defining corporate social responsibility.Journal of Mass Media Ethics,4(1),21-38.
32. Holsti, O. R.(1969).Content analysis for the social sciences and humanities.Menlo Park, CA:Addison Wesley.
33. Ihator, A. S.(2004).Corporate communication: Reflection on twentieth century change.Corporate Communications: An International Journal,9,243-253.
34. Jeurissen, R.(2004).Institutional conditions of corporate citizenship.Journal of Business Ethics,53,87-96.
35. Maignan, I.,Ferrell, O. C.(2001).Antecedents and benefits of corporate citizenship: An investigation of French businesses.Journal of Business Research,51,37-51.
36. Matten, D.,Crane, A.(2005).Corporate citizenship: Toward an extended theoretical conceptualization.Academy of Management Review,30,166-179.
37. Matten, D.,Crane, A.,Chspple, W.(2003).Behind the mask: Revealing the true face of corporate citizenship.Journal of Business Ethics,45,109-120.
38. Meijer, M. M.,Kleinnijenhuis, J.(2006).News and corporate reputation: Empirical findings from the Netherlands.Public Relations Review,32,341-348.
39. Néron, P.,Norman, W.(2008).Citizenship, INC. Do we really want business to be good corporate citizens?.Business Ethics Quarterly,18(1),1-26.
40. Sabeh, Z.,Flora, M.,Khairan, F.(2000).Corporate citizenship as a factor of corporate communicate.Corporate Communications: An International Journal,5,210-213.
41. Tester, K.(2004).Civil society.Acta Sociologica,48,378-379.
42. Tracey, P.,Phillips, N.,Haugh, H.(2005).Beyond philanthropy: Community enterprise as a basis for corporate citizenship.Journal of Business Ethics,58,327-344.
43. Waddock, S.(2008).The development of corporate responsibility-corporate citizenship.Organization Management Journal,5,29-39.
44. Wallack, L.(2002).Public health, social change, and media advocacy.Social Marketing Quarterly,8(2),25-31.
45. Wood, D. J.,Logsdon, J. M.(2001).Theorizing business citizenship.Perspectives on corporate citizenship,London:
46. Wood, D. J.,Logsdon, J. M.(2008).Business citizenship as metaphor and reality.Business Ethics Quarterly,18(1),51-59.
47. 江明修、陳定銘(2001)。組織與公民社會—以社區大學運動為例。中央大學社會文化學報，12，15-43。
48. 別蓮蒂、游舒惠(2002)。企業贊助公益活動之動機、決策與影響因素。廣告學研究，18，53-94。
49. 吳靜惠、張菀倫(2005)。企業社會責任：新一波的企業經營課題。永續產業發展雙月刊，24，4-9。
50. 李丁讚(2004)。市民社會與公共領域在台灣的發展。公共領域在台灣—困境與契機，台北市:
51. 李珊(2006)。善與利：道德企業崛起。光華雜誌，31(5)，6-15。
52. 莫冬立(2006)。追求典範：企業社會責任評等系統的發展與應用。證卷櫃檯月刊，122，62-73。
53. 陳其南(1992)。公民國家意識與台灣政治發展。台北市:允晨。
54. 陳威融、劉念琪(2002)。企業公民之實踐：以Ford Lio HO為例。第8屆企業人力資源管理實務專題研究成果發表會，台灣，中壢:
55. 楊意菁(2008)。企業公民、公民社會與社會議題建構：以「KeepWalking 夢想資助計畫」為例。廣告學研究，60，85-120。
56. 楊意菁(2006)。公民社會與企業公民：從議題管理與社會議題建構談起。第14 屆廣告與公共關係學術與實務研討會，台灣，台北市:

1. 楊意菁(Yie-Jing Yang)(2023)。從CSR到CSiR：企業不負社會責任的概念初探與媒體關注。臺灣傳播學刊。(44)。217-259。