题名

福島危機中台灣民眾對核能的風險感知與態度：政黨傾向、核能知識、信任與科學傳播的角色

并列篇名

Risk Perception and Attitude toward Nuclear Energy during the Fukushima Crisis: The Role of Party Identification, Trust, Nuclear Power Knowledge and Science Communication

DOI

10.6195/cjcr.2014.26.07

作者

陳憶寧(Katherine Yi-Ning Chen)

关键词

信任 ； 政黨傾向 ； 核能知識 ； 科學傳播 ； 福島 ； political trust ； party identification ； nuclear power knowledge ； science communication ； Fukushima

期刊名称

中華傳播學刊

卷期/出版年月

26期（2014 / 12 / 01）

页次

223 - 265

内容语文

繁體中文
中文摘要

本研究在福島核災之後，檢視民眾對核能議題之風險感知與態度。於核災爆發後一周之內，進行全國1,093位民眾的電話調查。結果顯示，政治信任程度愈低，愈是認為核能風險重要性高；民眾對政府的信任程度愈高，則愈支持核能。在傳播層面上，對核災的電視新聞愈注意，則愈覺得風險重要性高，也愈反對核能。客觀知識程度較高者，愈支持核能，也較接受核能風險。在性別差異上，男性比起女性較能接受核能風險。在政黨差異上，泛藍較泛綠支持核能。
英文摘要

This study explored how people in Taiwan perceived the risk of nuclear power during the Fukushima disaster in March 2011. An island-wide telephone survey of 1,093 residents in Taiwan was conducted within one week after the disaster occurred. The results showed that people's perception of the risk was primarily determined by their political trust. People who had lower political trust were likely to be more concerned, whereas those who trusted the government more tended to support nuclear energy. Attention to television news was positively correlated with risk perception; those who paid more attention to television news were likely to oppose nuclear energy. Additionally, people with more objective knowledge about nuclear energy tended to accept its risk and support its use. Male respondents exhibited a higher tolerance of the risk than their female counterparts did. Consistent with past literature, Pan-Blue party supporters were more in favor of nuclear energy than Pan-Green party supporters.
主题分类 社會科學 > 傳播學
参考文献
  1. 劉祥熹、莊慶達、陳均龍(2007)。從核四建廠風險認知觀點探討貢寮地區漁業經營對漁村經濟之影響。農業與經濟，38，119-159。
    連結：
  2. 林進修（2011.03.13）。〈原能會：福島輻射「完全不可能」飄向台灣〉，《聯合晚報》。上網日期：2011 年3 月13 日，取自http://udn.com/NEWS/WORLD/WORS4/6207922.shtml
  3. Science and Engineering Indicators. (2006). Science and technology: Public attitudes and understanding. Science and Engineering Indicators 2006. Retrieved October 16, 2011, from http://www.nsf.gov/statistics/seind06/c7/c7s1.htm
  4. Allison, P. D.(1999).Multiple regression: A primer.London:Pine Forge Press.
  5. Ball-Rokeach, S. J.,Defleur, M. L.(1976).A dependency model of massmedia effects.Communication Research,3,3-21.
  6. Bauer, M.W.(Ed.),Gaskell, G.(Ed.)(2002).Biotechnology: The making of a great controversy.Cambridge, UK:Cambridge University Press.
  7. Beck, U.(1999).World risk society.Cambridge, UK:Polity.
  8. Binder, A. R.,Scheufele, D. A.,Brossard, D.,Gunther, A. C.(2011).Interpersonal amplification of risk? Citizen discussions and their impact on perceptions of risks and benefits of a biological research facility.Risk Analysis,31,324-334.
  9. Bolsen, T.,Cook, F. L.(2008).The polls- trends: Public opinion on energy policy: 1974-2006.Public Opinion Quarterly,72,364-388.
  10. Bredahl, L.(1999).Explaining consumer attitudes to genetic modification in food production.European Advances in Consumer Research,4,130-134.
  11. Bryant, J.(Ed.),Zillmann, D.(Ed.)(2002).Media effects: Advances in theory and research.Mahwah, NJ:Lawrence Elbaum Associates.
  12. Burningham, K.(2000).Using the language of NIMBY: A topic for research not an activity for researchers.Local Environment,5,55-67.
  13. Cappella, J. N.,Jamieson, K. H.(1997).Spiral of cynicism: The press and the public good.New York:Oxford University Press.
  14. Chaffee, S. H.,Schleuder, J.(1986).Measurements and effects of attention to media news.Human Communication Research,13,76-107.
  15. Chanley, V. A.(2002).Trust in government in the aftermath of 9/11: Determinants and consequences.Political Psychology,23,469-483.
  16. Christoph, I. B.,Bruhn, M.,Roosen, J.(2007).Knowledge, attitudes towards and acceptability of genetic modification in Germany.Appetite,51,58-68.
  17. Cobb, M. D.,Macoubrie, J.(2004).Public perceptions about nanotechnology: Risks, benefits and trust.Journal of Nanoparticle Research,6,395-405.
  18. Costa-Font, M.,Gil, J. M.,Traill, W. B.(2008).Consumer acceptance, valuation of and attitudes towards genetically modified food: Review and implications for food policy.Food Policy,33,99-111.
  19. Covello, V. T.(Ed.),McCallum, D. B.(Ed.),Pavlova, M. T.(Ed.)(1989).Effective risk communication.New York:Plenum.
  20. Davidson, D. J.,Freudenburg, W. R.(1996).Gender and environmental risk concerns: A review and analysis of available research.Environment and Behavior,28,302-339.
  21. Dennis, J.,Webster, C.(1975).Children's images of the president and of government in 1962 and 1974.American Politics Quarterly,3,386-405.
  22. Dudo, A. D.,Dahlstrom, M. F.,Brossard, D.(2007).Reporting a potential pandemic: A risk-related assessment of Avian influenza coverage in U.S. newspapers.Science Communication,28,429-454.
  23. Dunwoody, S.,Peters, H. P.(1992).Mass media coverage of technological and environmental risks: A survey of research in the United States and Germany.Public Understanding of Science,1,199-230.
  24. Durant, J.(Ed.),Bauer, M. W.(Ed.),Gaskell, G.(Ed.)(1998).Biotechnology in the public sphere: A European sourcebook.London:Science Museum.
  25. Evans, G.,Durant, J.(1995).The relationship between knowledge and attitudes in the public understanding of science in Britain.Public Understanding of Science,4,57-74.
  26. Eveland, W. P., Jr.(2003).A "Mix of Attributes" approach to the study of media effects and new communication technologies.Journal of Communication,53,395-410.
  27. Fischhoff, B.,Slovic, P.,Lichtenstein, S.,Read, S.,Combs, B.(1978).How safe is safe enough? A psychometric study of attitudes towards technological risks and benefits.Policy Science,9(2),127-152.
  28. Fiske, S. T.,Taylor S. E.(1991).Social cognition.New York:McGraw-Hill.
  29. Frewer, L. J.,Howard, C.,Shepherd, R.(1995).Genetic engineering and food: What determines consumer acceptance.British Food Journal,97,31-36.
  30. Frost, K.,Frank, E.,Maibach, E.(1997).Relative risk in the news media: A quantification of misrepresentation.American Journal of Public Health,87,842-845.
  31. Gamson, W. A.,Modigliani, A.(1989).Media discourse and public opinion on nuclear power: A constructionist approach.American Journal of Sociology,95,1-37.
  32. Gans, H. J.(1980).Deciding what's news: A study of CBS evening news, NBC nightly news, Newsweek, and Time.New York:Vintage Books.
  33. Giddens, A.(1991).Modernity and self-identity: Self and society in the late modern age.Cambridge, UK:Polity.
  34. Giddens, A.(1990).The consequences of modernity.Cambridge, UK:Polity.
  35. Gumpert, G.(Ed.),Cathcart, R.(Ed.)(1986).Inter/Media: Interpersonal communication in a media world.Oxford, UK:Oxford University Press.
  36. Hair, J. F., Jr.,Anderson, R. E.,Tatham, R. L.(1987).Multivariate data analysis with readings.New York:Macmillan.
  37. Hallman, W. K.,Hebden, W. C.,Aquino, H. L.,Cuite, C. L.,Lang, J. T.(2003).Public perceptions of genetically modified foods: A national study of American knowledge and opinion.New Brunswick, NJ:Food Policy Institute, Cook College Rutgers, The State University of New Jersey.
  38. Hansson, S. O.(2002).Uncertainties in the knowledge society.International Social Science Journal,54,39-46.
  39. Hayes, B. C.,Tariq, V. N.(2000).Gender differences in scientific knowledge and attitudes toward science: A comparative study of four Anglo-American nations.Public Understanding of Science,9,433-447.
  40. Hoban, T. J.(1998).Trends in consumer attitudes about agricultural biotechnology.AgBioForum,1(1),3-7.
  41. House, R. J.,Hanges, P. J.,Javidan, M.,Dorfman, P. W.,Gupta V.(2004).Culture, leadership, and organizations: The GLOBE study of 62 societies.Thousand Oaks, CA:Sage.
  42. Huurne, E. F. J.,Griggin, R. J.,Gutteling, J. M.(2009).Risk information seeking among U.S. and Dutch residents: An application of the model of risk information seeking and processing.Science Communication,31,215-237.
  43. Iyengar, S.(1991).Is anyone responsible? How television frames political issues.Chicago, IL:University of Chicago Press.
  44. Jeffres, L. W.(1997).Mass media effects.Prospect Heights, IL:Waveland.
  45. Kasperson, R. E.(Ed.),Stallen, P. J. M.(Ed.)(1991).Communicating risks to the public: International perspectives.Dordrecht, the Netherlands:Kluwer.
  46. Klerck, D.,Sweeney, J. C.(2007).The effect of knowledge types on consumer-perceived risk and adoption of genetically modified foods.Psychology and Marketing,24,171-193.
  47. Krewski, D.(1993).Health risk perception.Comments on Toxicology,4,519-524.
  48. Lee, C. J.,Scheufele, D. A.,Lewenstein, B. V.(2005).Public attitudes toward emerging technologies: Examining the interactive effects of cognitions and affect on public support for nanotechnology.Science Communication,27,240-267.
  49. Lenart, S.(1994).Shaping political attitudes: The impact of interpersonal communication and mass media.Thousand Oaks, CA:Sage.
  50. Lews, R. E.,Tyshenko, M. G.(2009).The impact of social amplification and attenuation of risk and the public reaction to mad cow disease in Canada.Risk Analysis,29,714-728.
  51. Liu, H.,Priest, S.(2009).Understanding public support for stem cell research: Media communication, interpersonal communication and trust in key actors.Public Understanding of Science,18,704-718.
  52. Macoubrie, J.(2006).Nanotechnology: Public concerns, reasoning and trust in government.Public Understanding of Science,15,221-241.
  53. Maeseele, P. A.,Schuurman, D.(2008).Biotechnology and the popular press in Northern Belgium. A case study of hegemonic media discourses and the interpretive struggle.Science Communication,29,435-471.
  54. Magnusson, M. K.,Hursti Koivisto, U. K.(2002).Consumer perceptions of foods produced by means of genetic engineering.Appetite,39,9-24.
  55. Mazur, A.(1981).Media coverage and public opinion on scientific controversies.Journal of Communication,31(2),106-115.
  56. Mazur, A.,Hall, G. S.(1990).Effects of social influence and measured exposure level on response to radon.Sociological Inquiry,60,274-284.
  57. McComas, K. A.(2006).Defining moments in risk communication research: 1996-2005.Journal of Health Communication,11,75-91.
  58. McInerney, C.,Bird, N.,Nucci, M.(2004).The flow of scientific knowledge from lab to the lay public: The case of biotechnology food.Science Communication,26,44-74.
  59. Mcknight, D. H.,Cummings, L. L.,Chervany, N. L.(1998).Initial trust formation in new organizational relationship.Academy of Management Review,23,473-490.
  60. Miller, J. D.,Augenbraun, E.,Schulhof, J.,Kimmel, L. G.(2006).Adult science learning from local television newscasts.Science Communication,28,216-242.
  61. Miller, J. D.,Kimmel, L. G.(2001).Biomedical communications: Purposes, audiences, and strategies.New York:Academic Press.
  62. Nelkin, D.(1995).Selling science: How the press covers science and technology.New York:Freeman.
  63. Nisbet, M. C.(2005).The competition for worldviews: Values, information, and public support for stem cell research.International Journal of Public Opinion,17,90-112.
  64. Nisbet, M. C.,Goidel, R. K.(2007).Understanding citizen perceptions of science controversy: Bridging the ethnographic-survey divide.Public Understanding of Science,6,421-440.
  65. Ostrom, E.(Ed.),Walker, J.(Ed.)(2001).Trust and reciprocity: Interdisciplinary lessons from experimental research.New York:Russell Sage.
  66. Philo, G.(Ed.)(1999).Message received: Glasgow media group research 1993-1998.Harlow, UK:Addison Wesley Longman.
  67. Powell, M.,Dunwoody, S.,Griffin, R.,Neuwirth, K.(2007).Exploring lay uncertainty about an environmental health risk.Public Understand of Science,16,323-343.
  68. Priest, S. H.(2006).The public opinion climate for gene technologies in Canada and the United States: Competing voices, contrasting frames.Public Understanding of Science,15,55-71.
  69. Priest, S. H.(1990).Television's nova and the construction of scientific truth.Critical Studies in Mass Communication,7,11-23.
  70. Priest, S. H.(2001).Misplaced faith: Communication variables as predictors of encouragement for biotechnology development.Science Communication,23,97-110.
  71. Priest, S. H.(1995).Information equity, public understanding of science, and the biotechnology debate.Journal of Communication,45(1),39-54.
  72. Priest, S. H.,Bonfadelli, H.,Rusanen, M.(2003).The 'trust gap' hypothesis: Predicting support for biotechnology across national cultures as a function of trust in actors.Risk Analysis,23,751-766.
  73. Ramana, M. V.(2011).Nuclear power and the public.Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists,67(4),43-51.
  74. Robinson, J. P.(Ed.),Shaver, P. R.(Ed.),Wrightsman, L. S.(Ed.)(1999).Measures of political attitudes.San Diego, CA:Academic Press.
  75. Rosa, E. A.,Dunlap, R. E.(1994).Nuclear power: Three decades of public opinion.Public Opinion Quarterly,58,295-324.
  76. Rotter, J. B.(1971).Generalized expectancies for interpersonal trust.American Psychologist,26,443-450.
  77. Rowe, G.,Frewer, L.,Sjöberg, L.(2000).Newspaper reporting of hazards in the UK and Sweden.Public Understanding of Science,9,59-78.
  78. Scheufele, D. A.,Lewenstein, B. V.(2005).The public and nanotechnology: How citizens make sense of emerging technologies.Journal of Nanoparticle Research,7,659-667.
  79. Scholderer, J.,Frewer, L. J.(2003).The biotechnology communication paradox: Experimental evidence and the need for a new strategy.Journal of Consumer Policy,26,125-157.
  80. Scholz, J. T.,Lubell, M.(1998).Adaptive political attitudes: Duty, trust and fear as monitors of tax policy.American Journal of Political Science,42,903-920.
  81. Siegrist, M.,Cvetkovich, G.(2000).Perception of hazards: The role of social trust and knowledge.Risk Analysis,20,713-720.
  82. Singer, E.,Endreny, P.(1987).Reporting hazards: Their benefits and costs.Journal of Communication,7,10-26.
  83. Sjöberg, L.(2003).Attitudes and risk perceptions of stakeholders in a nuclear waste siting issue.Risk Analysis,23,739-749.
  84. Sjöberg, L.,Drottz-Sjöberg, B. M.(1991).Knowledge and risk perception among nuclear power plant employees.Risk Analysis,11,607-618.
  85. Slovic, P.(1999).Trust, emotion, sex, politics, and science: Surveying the risk-assessment battlefield.Risk Analysis,19,689-701.
  86. Solomon, M. R.(2004).Consumer behavior: Buying, having and being.Upper Saddle River, NJ:Prentice Hall.
  87. Sturgis, P.,Allum, N.(2004).Science in society: Re-evaluating the deficit model of public attitude.Public Understanding of Science,13,55-74.
  88. Ten Eyck, T. A.(2005).The media and public opinion on genetics and biotechnology: Mirrors, windows, or walls?.Public Understanding of Science,4,305-316.
  89. Ten Eyck, T. A.,Williment, M.(2003).The national media and things genetic: Coverage in the New York Times (1971-2001) and the Washington Post (1977-2001).Science Communication,25,129-152.
  90. Trettin, L.,Musham, C.(2000).Is trust a realistic goal of environmental risk communication?.Environment and Behavior,32,410-426.
  91. Verbeke, W.,Viaene, J.,Guiot, O.(1999).Health communication and consumer behavior on meat in Belgium: From BSE until Dioxin.Journal of Health Communication,4,345-357.
  92. Verdurme, A.,Viaene, J.(2003).Exploring and modeling consumer attitudes towards genetically modified food.Qualitative Market Research: An International Journal,6,95-110.
  93. Weinberg, A. M.(1976).The maturity and future of nuclear energy.Energy and physics, Proceedings of the Third General Conference,Bucharest, Rumania:
  94. Whitfield, D. P.,Reid, R.,Haworth, P. F.,Madders, M.,Marquiss, M.,Tingay, R.(2009).Diet specificity is not associated withiIncreased reproductive performance of golden eagles Aquila Chrysaetos in Western Scotland.IBIS,151,255-264.
  95. Wilkins, L. E.(Ed.),Patterson, P. E.(Ed.)(1991).Risk business: Communicating issues of science, risk, and public policy.New York:Greenwood.
  96. Yamagishi, T.,Yamagishi, M.(1994).Trust and commitment in the United States and Japan.Motivation and Emotion,28,129-166.
  97. 王榮德(2000)。核能風險與替代方案。月旦法學，67，72-83。
  98. 周桂田(2003)。全球在地化風險下之風險溝通與風險評估─以SARS 為Case 分析。2003 年台灣社會學年會，台灣，台北:
  99. 林群智(2006)。由核電爭議談核科學主軸之通識教育。通識教育與跨域研究，1(1)，19-36。
  100. 陳憶寧(2011)。美國牛肉進口台灣危機中的媒介使用、政治信任與風險感知的關係。傳播與社會學刊，17，31-60。
  101. 程詩郁(2001)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。台灣大學建築與城鄉研究所。
  102. 羅弘旭(2011)。揭開核四廠潛藏的四大「人為災難」。今週刊，744，72-77。
  103. 顧忠華(2003)。風險社會中的風險治理：SARS 事件的啟示。當代，194，54-61。
  104. 顧忠華編(2001)。第二現代：風險社會的出路？。台北市:巨流。
被引用次数
  1. 陳彥呈、車成緯、李青松(2017)。從推敲可能理論探討民宿業者在群聚現象之下的經營態度：兼論媒體依賴為調節變項。戶外遊憩研究，30(2)，91-125。
  2. 傅文成(2020)。以語料庫分析方法檢驗新南向政策的政府與媒體風險建構策略。中華傳播學刊，37，189-226。
  3. 顧志文,陳育正,孫懋嘉,林立偉(2020)。由社群媒體的觀點論習近平主政後對臺統戰策略對我國民眾的影響：以對臺31項措施為例。中國大陸研究，63(2)，111-150。
  4. 江俊宜(2018)。重新審視福島核災之後的台灣核能政治爭議：從「正當性」轉向「防止危害」。中國行政評論，24(3)，128-153。
  5. 劉正,殷志偉(2020)。非核家園的民衆意向：網路輿論的大數據分析。選舉研究，27(2)，49-92。
  6. (2022)。台灣亡國感？台灣民眾對香港反送中運動的媒體信任、風險感知、負面情感與行為意圖分析。傳播與社會學刊，61，161-195。
print cancel