题名

新聞教育的危機：中港台新聞系學生的未來職業抉擇

并列篇名

A Crisis of Journalism Education? Career Decisions of Journalism Students in Mainland China, Hong Kong, and Taiwan

DOI

10.6195/cjcr.2015.28.04

作者

張曉(Xiao Zhang)；羅文輝(Ven-Hwei Lo)；郭佳(Jia Guo)；汪婧(Jing Wang)；徐昌鵬(Chang-Peng Xu)；余舒虹(Shu-Hong Yu)；張芳(Fang Zhang)

关键词

生涯承諾 ； 就業動機 ； 就業意願 ； 新聞專業教育 ； career commitment ； job motivation ； career decision ； professional education

期刊名称

中華傳播學刊

卷期/出版年月

28期（2015 / 12 / 01）

页次

123 - 154

内容语文

繁體中文
中文摘要

本研究的主要目的在探究大陸、香港、台灣三地新聞專業學生未來進入新聞行業的就業意願及把新聞作為終身職業的意願，並探討相關影響因素。本研究採用問卷調查法，在中港台三地大學訪問482 位新聞專業學生。研究結果發現，三地新聞專業學生在畢業後希望進入新聞界工作的人數比例不高，三地新聞專業學生將新聞作為終身職業的人數比例非常低。此外，本研究亦發現，三地學生的就業動機對其畢業後進入新聞行業工作的意願具有顯著預測力。
英文摘要

This research examined the career decisions of journalism students in mainland China, Hong Kong, and Taiwan. The results of a survey of 482 students indicated that journalism students in these three societies expressed a relatively low level of willingness to work in the journalism industry after graduation. In the sample, Hong Kong respondents expressed the highest level of willingness, whereas mainland respondents expressed the lowest level of willingness. The results also indicated that the motivation for entering journalism as an occupation was a significant predictor of the willingness to work in the journalism industry after graduation. Course satisfaction and motivation for entering journalism as an occupation were significant predictors of the willingness to pursue journalism as a life-long career.
主题分类 社會科學 > 傳播學
参考文献
  1. 王毓莉(2014)。台灣記者對「業配新聞」的馴服與抗拒。新聞學研究，119，45-79。
    連結：
  2. Becker, L. B., Vlad, T., & Kalpen, K. (2012.08.09). 2011 annual survey of journalism & mass communication graduates. Retrieved August 3, 2013, from http://www.grady.uga.edu/annualsurveys/
  3. American Bar Association. (2013.03.29). ABA releases class of 2012 law graduate employment data. Retrieved August 2, 2013, from http://www.americanbar.org/news/abanews/aba-news-archives/2013/08/aba_releases_classo.html
  4. Becker, L. B., Vlad, T., Tucker, M., & Pelton, R. (2006.08.04). 2005 annual survey of journalism & mass communication graduates. Retrieved August 24, 2013, from http://www.grady.uga.edu/annualsurveys/Graduate_Survey/Graduate_2005/GraduateReport2005.pdf
  5. 台灣教育部統計處（2014）。〈大專院校概括統計（102 學年度）〉。上網日期：2014 年10 月2 日，取自https://stats.moe.gov.tw/files/ebook/higher/102/102higher.htm
  6. BBC 中文網（2014.11.07）。〈觀察：中國的新聞自由和記者的生存空間〉，《BBC 中文網》。上網日期：2015 年1 月15 日，取自 http://www.bbc.co.uk/zhongwen/simp/china/2014/11/141107_china_journalist_day
  7. 香港特別行政區大學教育資助委員會（2014）。〈按院校、修課程度、修課形式及學科類別劃分的教資會資助課程的學生人數，2013/14〉。上網日期：2014 年10 月2 日，取自http://www.ugc.edu.hk/eng/doc/ugc/publication/report/AnnualRpt1314/12.pdf
  8. American Association of Medical Colleges. (2014). Medical school graduation questionnaire 2014 all school summary report. Retrieved on October 2, 2014, from https://www.aamc.org/download/397432/data/2014gqallschoolssummaryreport.pdf
  9. 搜狐傳媒（2013.10.18）。〈全國新聞傳播類專業布點1080 個，在校本科生23 萬〉。上網日期：2014 年10 月2 日，取自http://media.sohu.com/20131018/n388467179.shtml
  10. BBC 中文網（2014.02.16）。〈香港記協馬拉松發藍絲帶促維護新聞自由〉，《BBC 中文網》。上網日期：2014 年9 月29 日，取自http://www.bbc.co.uk/zhongwen/simp/china/2014/02/140216_hongkong_press_freedom_marathon
  11. Aldridge, M.,Evetts, J.(2003).Rethinking the concept of professionalism: The case of journalism.British Journal of Sociology,54,547- 564.
  12. Allison, M.(1986).A literature review of approaches to the professionalism of journalists.Journal of Mass Media Ethics,1,5-19.
  13. American Medical Association(2009).State medical licensure requirements and statistics, 2009.Chicago, IL:American Medical Association.
  14. Bartol, K. M.(1979).Professionalism as a predictor of organizational commitment, role stress, and turnover: A multidimensional approach.Academy of Management Journal,22,815-821.
  15. Beam, R. A.(1990).Journalism professionalism as an organizational-level concept.Journalism Monographs,121,1-43.
  16. Beam, R. A.,Weaver, D. H.,Brownlee, B. J.(2009).Changes in professionalism of U.S. journalists in the turbulent twenty-first century.Journalism & Mass Communication Quarterly,86,277- 298.
  17. Becker, H. S.,Carper, J.(1956).The elements of identification with an occupation.American Sociological Review,21,341-348.
  18. Becker, L. B.,Sobowale, I. A.,Cobbey, R. E.(1979).Reporters and their professional and organizational commitment.Journalism & Mass Communication Quarterly,56,754-770.
  19. Bignell, A.,Crotty, M.(1988).Continuing education: Does it enhance patient care.Senior Nurse,8,26-29.
  20. Blau, G. J.(1985).The measurement and prediction of career commitment.Journal of Occupational Psychology,58,277-288.
  21. Bowers, T. A.(1974).Student attitudes toward journalism as a major and a career.Journalism Quarterly,51,265-270.
  22. Carr-Sauders, A. M.,Wilson, P. A.(1953).The professions.Oxford, UK:Clarendon Press.
  23. Carson, K. D.,Bedeian, A. G.(1994).Career commitment: Construction of a measure and examination of psychometric properties.Journal of Vocational Behavior,44,237-262.
  24. Chan, J. M.,Lee, F. L.(2011).The primacy of local interests and press freedom in Hong Kong: A survey study of professional journalists.Journalism,12,89-105.
  25. Detenber, B. H.,Cenite, M.,Malik, S.,Neo, R. L.(2012).Examining education and newsroom work experience as predictors of communication students' perceptions of journalism ethics.Journalism & Mass Communication Educator,67,45-69.
  26. Duffy, R. D.,Sedlacek, W. E.(2007).What is most important to students' long-term career choices: Analyzing 10-year trends and group differences.Journal of Career Development,34,149-163.
  27. Elizur, D.(1984).Facets of work values: A structural analysis of work outcomes.Journal of Applied Psychology,69,379-389.
  28. Evetts, J.(2011).A new professionalism? Challenges and opportunities.Current Sociology,59,406-422.
  29. Evetts, J.(2013).Professionalism: Value and ideology.Current Sociology,61,778-796.
  30. Freidson, E.(1986).Professional powers: A study of the institutionalization of formal knowledge.Chicago, IL:University of Chicago Press.
  31. Freidson, E.(2001).Professionalism: The third logic.Cambridge, UK:Polity.
  32. Freidson, E.(1999).Theory of professionalism: Method and substance.International Review of Sociology,9,117-129.
  33. Gaziano, C.,McGrath, K.(1986).Measuring the concept of credibility.Journalism Quarterly,63,451-462.
  34. George, C.(2011).Beyond professionalization: A radical broadening of journalism education.Journalism & Mass Communication Educator,66,257-267.
  35. Green, L.,Hemmings, B.,Green, A.(2007).Career change and motivation: A matter of balance.Australian Journal of Career Development,16,20-27.
  36. Greenwood, E.(1957).Attributes of a profession.Social Work,2,45-55.
  37. Hall, D. T.(1971).A theoretical model of career subidentity development in organizational settings.Organizational Behavior and Human Performance,6,50-76.
  38. Hallin, D.(1992).The passing of the "high modernism" of American journalism.Journal of Communication,42,14-25.
  39. Hanna, M.,Sanders, K.(2007).Journalism Education in Britain: Who are the students and what do they want?.Journalism Practice,1,404-420.
  40. Hanna, M.,Sanders, K.(2007).Did graduate journalism education make a differene? A study of journalism students' views on news media role.Journalism & Mass Communication Educator,62,344-359.
  41. Hauer, K. E.,Durning, S. J.,Kernan, W. N.,Fagan, M. J.,Mintz, M.,O'Sullivan, P. S.(2008).Factors associated with medical students' career choices regarding internal medicine.The Journal of the American Medical Association,300,1154-1164.
  42. Hopmann, D. N.,Elmelund-Præstekær, C.,Levinsen, K.(2010).Journalism students: Left-wing and politically motivated?.Journalism,11,661-674.
  43. Hwang, H.,Powell, W. W.(2009).The rationalization of charity: The influences and professionalism in the nonprofit sector.Administrative Science Quarterly,54,268-298.
  44. Jeffe, D. B.,Andriole, D. A.,Hageman, H. L.,Whelan, A. J.(2007).The changing paradigm of contemporary US allopathic medical school graduates' career paths: Analysis of the 1997-2004 national AAMC Graduation Questionnaire database.Academic Medicine,82,888-894.
  45. Kang, J.(1987).Reporters and their professional and occupational commitment in a developing country.International Communication Gazette,40,3-20.
  46. Leal-Muniz, V.,Constantine, M. G.(2005).Predictors of the career commitment process in Mexican American college students.Journal of Career Assessment,13,204-215.
  47. Lent, R. W.,Brown, S. D.(1996).Social cognitive approach to career development: An overview.The Career Development Quarterly,44,310-321.
  48. Lent, R. W.,Brown, S. D.,Hackett, G.(1994).Toward a unifying social cognitive theory of career and academic interest, choice, and performance.Journal of Vocational Behavior,45,79-122.
  49. Lowrey, W.,Becker, L. B.(2004).Commitment to journalistic work: Do high school and college activities matter?.Journalism & Mass Communication Quarterly,81,528-545.
  50. Nayman, O. B.(1973).Professional orientations of journalists: An introduction to communicator analysis studies.International Communication Gazette,19,195-212.
  51. Parsons, T.(1951).The social system.New York:Free Press.
  52. Pavlik, J. V.(2013).A vision for transformative leadership: Rethinking journalism and mass communication education for the twenty-first century.Journalism & Mass Communication Educator,68,211-221.
  53. Reinardy, S.(2011).Newspaper journalism in crisis: Burnout on the rise, eroding young journalists' career commitment.Journalism,12,33-50.
  54. Rhodes, S.,Doering, M.(1983).An integrated model of career change.Academy of Management Review,8,631-639.
  55. Ros, M.,Schwartz, S. H.,Surkiss, S.(1999).Basic individual values, work values, and the meaning of work.Applied Psychology: An International Review,48,49-71.
  56. Sanders, K.,Hanna, M.,Berganza, M. R.,Aranda, J. S.(2008).Becoming journalists: A comparison of the professional attitudes and values of British and Spanish journalism students.European Journal of Communication,23,133-152.
  57. Splichal, S.,Sparks, C.(1994).Journalists for the 21st century: Tendencies of professionalization among first-year students in 22 countries.Norwood, NJ:Ablex.
  58. Starck, K.,Sudhaker, A.(1979).Reconceptualizing the notion of journalistic professionalism across differing press systems.Journal of Communication Inquiry,4,33-52.
  59. Svensson, L. G.(2006).New professionalism, trust and competence: Some conceptual remarks and empirical data.Current Sociology,54,579-593.
  60. Volz, Y. Z.,Lee, C. C.(2009).American pragmatism and Chinese modernization: Importing the Missouri model of journalism education into modern China.Media, Culture & Society,31,711-730.
  61. Vroom, V. H.(1964).Work and motivation.New York:Wiley.
  62. Weaver, D. H.,Wilhoit, G. C.(1996).The American journalist in the 1990s: U.S. news people at the end of an era.Mahwah, NJ:Erlbaum.
  63. Wilensky, H. L.(1964).The professionalization of everyone?.American Journal of Sociology,70,137-158.
  64. Willis, J.(2010).The mind of a journalist: How reporters view themselves, their world, and their craft.London:Sage.
  65. Wilson, C. E.(1966).Why Canadian newsmen leave their papers.Journalism Quarterly,43,769-772.
  66. Wu, W.(2000).Motives of Chinese students to choose journalism career.Journalism & Mass Communication Educator,55,53-65.
  67. Wu, W.,Weaver, D. H.(1998).Making Chinese journalists for the next millennium: The professionalization of Chinese journalism students.International Communication Gazette,60,513-529.
  68. 朱立編、陳韜文編(1992)。傳播與社會發展。香港:香港中文大學新聞與傳播學系。
  69. 祝建華(2001)。中文傳播研究之理論化與本土化：以受眾及媒介效果的整合理論為例。新聞學研究，68，1-22。
  70. 陳韜文、羅文輝(2003)。比較研究的挑戰─大陸、香港、台灣新聞人員比較研究的反思。傳播研究簡訊，34，4-8。
  71. 程曉萱(2013)。博士論文(博士論文)。香港中文大學新聞與傳播學院。
  72. 劉兢(2012)。新聞評論教學的跨學科視野與研究思維性。新聞記者，9，68-71。
  73. 羅文輝(1996)。新聞事業與新聞人員的專業地位：逐漸形成的專業。台大新聞論壇，4，280-292。
  74. 羅文輝(1998)。新聞人員的專業性：意涵界定與量表建構。傳播研究集刊，2，1-47。
  75. 羅文輝、陳韜文(2004)。變遷中的大陸、香港、台灣新聞人。台北市:巨流。
被引用次数
  1. 蘇蘅(2021)。新聞教育在臺灣的轉變：政治大學新聞學系的發展與省思。傳播研究與實踐，11(2)，5-36。
print cancel