伴隨與未伴隨品行問題之ADHD兒童的反社會型態比較

A Study of Antisocial Pattern of ADHD Children With/Without Conduct Problems

10.7082/CJGC.200909.0121

吳依璇(Yi-Hsuan Wu)；林玉華(Yu-Hwa Lin)

攻擊 ； 注意力缺失／過動疾患 ； 品行問題 ； 道德感 ； 對動物殘忍 ； aggression ； Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder ； conduct problems ； cruelty to animals ； morality

中華輔導與諮商學報

26期（2009 / 09 / 01）

121 - 162

繁體中文

注意力缺失／過動疾患（Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder，簡稱ADHD）與伴隨品行問題（conduct problems，簡稱CP）之ADHD兒童的外顯行為相似，皆會出現攻擊、違抗等反社會行為，因此鑑別診斷經常面臨相當大的困難。是故，本研究之目的即為探究ADHD及ADHD/CP共發兒童於反社會型態中的區辨性特徵，以期提供臨床實務另一鑑別診斷之參考。回顧ADHD與ADHD/CP共發的反社會行為之相關文獻後，本研究採「攻擊」、「道德感」及「對動物殘忍」三特質作為ADHD與ADHD/CP共發兒童的區辨特徵。 本研究於北部地區招募25位ADHD-only組國小兒童（平均年齡8.82歲），22位ADHD+CP組國小兒童（平均年齡8.88歲），採用投射測驗「Tell-Me-A-Story」評估受試者之攻擊與道德感特質，及「兒童與動物量表(Children and Animals Inventory)」瞭解受試者對動物殘忍行為之訊息。 研究結果顯示，ADHD-only組與ADHD+CP組兩組兒童之攻擊特質、道德感、對動物殘忍行為皆達顯著差異，證實此三項特質可作為伴隨與未伴隨CP之ADHD兒童的重要區辨特徵；此結果亦隱含在攻擊兒童群體中，ADHD+CP兒童之心理病理發展可能為一獨立、特殊之建構。未來研究建議增加受試人數和組別，並進一步探究反社會型態之核心區辨特徵。

The observed behaviors in Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD) and ADHD with conduct problems (CP) are rather similar. Both of them present antisocial behaviors such as aggression and disobedience. Therefore it's difficult to make discriminate diagnoses among children with aggressive behaviors. The purpose of this study was to examine the differences of antisocial patterns between ADHD children with/without CP. After reviewing related researches, three traits had been selected in this study: aggression, morality and cruelty to animals. The subjects were recruited from hospitals and special education system of elementary schools in metropolitan Taipei area. Twenty-five children (mean age=8.82) were included in ADHD-only group and twenty-two children (mean age=8.88) were included in ADHD+CP group. All the subjects were given a projective test ”Tell Me A Story” to assess aggression and morality, and the ”Children and Animals Inventory” was administered to assess the subjects' behaviors of cruelty to animals. The results of the present study revealed that ADHD-only group and ADHD+CP group showed significant differences in aggression (p＜.05), morality (p＜.001), and cruelty to animals (p＜.01). This study proved that ”aggression”, ”morality”, and ”cruelty to animals” are good discriminating indicators for ADHD children with/without CP. These findings also bear potentially important implications for the distinctive psychological etiology of the ADHD children with conduct problems. Limitations are discussed and recommendations are made for future research.

1. 林美珠、劉秋木(2004)。兒童在Tel1-Me-A-Story上所呈現的人格側影之初探。中國測驗學會測驗學刊，51(2)，249-284。
   連結：
2. Anchor, K. N.,Cross, H. J.(1974).Maladaptive aggression, moral perspective, and the socialization process.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,30(1),163-168.
3. Anderson, R. B. W.(1967).On the comparability of meaningful stimuli in cross-cultural research.Sociometry,30(2),124-136.
4. Ascione, F. R.,Thompson, T. M.,Black, T.(1997).Childhood cruelty to animals: Assessing cruelty dimensions and motivations.Anthrozoos,10(4),170-179.
5. Bear, G. G.,Richard, H. C.(1981).Moral reasoning and conduct problems in the classroom.Journal of Educational Psychology,73(5),664-670.
6. Blair, R. J. R.(1995).A cognitive developmental approach to morality: Investigating the psychopath.Cognition,57,1-29.
7. Blair, R. J. R.,Monson, J.,Frederickson, N.(2001).Moral reasoning and conduct problems in children with emotional and behavioral difficulties.Personality and Individual Differences,31,799-811.
8. Connor, V. F,Steingard, R. J.,Cunningham, J. A.,Anderson, J. J.(2004).Proactive and reactive agression in referred children and adolescents.American Journal of Orthopsychiatry,74(2),129-136.
9. Costantino, G,Malgady, R. G.,Colon-Malgady, G.,Bailey, J.(1992).Clinical utility of the TEMAS with nonminority children.Journal of Personality Assessment,59(3),433-438.
10. Costantino, G,Malgady, R. G.,Rogler, L. H.(1988).TEMAS (Tell-Me-A-Story) manual.LA:Western Psychological Services.
11. Costantino, G,Malgady, R. G.,Rogler, L. H.,Tsui, E. C.(1988).Discriminant analysis of clinical outpatients and public school children by TEMAS: A thematic apperception test for hispanics and blacks.Journal of Personalily Assessment,52(4),670-678.
12. Dadds, M. R.,Whiting, C.,Bunn, P.,Fraser, J. A.,Charlson, J. H.,Pirola-Merlo, A.(2004).Measurement of cruelty in children: The cruelty to animals inventory.Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology,32(3),321-334.
13. Davison, G. C.,Neale J. M.,Kring, A. M.(2004).Abnormal Psychology.New York:Wiley.
14. Dodge, K. A.,Coie, J. D.(1987).Social information processing factors in reactive and proactive aggression in children's peer group.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,53,1146-1158.
15. Dodge, K. A.,Lochman, J. E.,Harnish, J. D.,Bates, J. F.,Pettit, G. S.(1997).Reactive and proactive aggression in school children and psychiatrically impaired chronically assaultive youth.Journal of Abnormal Psychology,106(1),35-71.
16. Farrington, D. P.(2005).The importance of child and adolescent psychopathy.Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology,33(4),489-497.
17. Fasnacht-Hill, L. A.(2000).San Diego,Unpublished doctorial dissertation, California School of Professional Psychology.
18. Fisher, L.,Blair, R. J. R.(1998).Cognitive impairment and its relationship to psychopathic tendencies in children with emotional and behavioral difficulties.Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology,26(6),511-519.
19. Frick, P. J.(1998).Conduct disorder and serious antisocial behavior.New York:Plenum.
20. Frick, P. J.,Horn, Y. V.,Lahey, B. B.,Christ, M. A. G,Loeber, R.,Hart, E. A.,Tammembaum, L.,Hanson, K.(1993).Oppositional defiant disorder and conduct disorder: A meta-analytic review of factor analyses and cross-validation in a clinic sample.Clinical Psychology Review,13,319-340.
21. Frick, P. J.,Marsee, M. C.,C. J. Patrick(Ed.)(2006).Handbook of psychopathy.New York:Guilford.
22. Frick, P. J.,Morris, A. S.(2004).Temperament and developmental pathways to severe conduct problems.Journal of Clinical Child and Adolescent Psychology,33,54-68.
23. Frick. P. J.,O''Brien, B. S.,Wootton, J. M.,McBurnett, K.(1994).Psychopathy and conduct problems in children.Journal of Abnormal Psychology,103(4),700-707.
24. Giotakos, O.,Markianos, M.,Vaidakis, N.(2005).Aggression, impulsivity and plasma sex to their history of childhood attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder symptoms.The Journal of Forensic and Psychology,16(2),426-433.
25. Gresham, F M.,Lane, K. L.,Mclntyre, L. L.,Oison-Tinker H.,Dolstra, L.,MacMillan, D. M.,Lambros, K. M.,Bocian, K.(2001).Risk factors associated with co-occurance of hyperactivity-impulsitivity-inattention and conduct problems.Behavioral Disorders,26(3),189-199.
26. Guymer, E. C.,Mellor, D.,Luk, E. S. L.,Pearse, V.(2001).The Development of a screening questionnaire for childhood cruelty to animals.Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry,42(8),1057-1063.
27. Hinshaw, S.(1987).On the distinction between attention deficits/hyperactivity and conduct problems/aggression in child psychopathology.Psychological Bulletin,101,443-463.
28. Hughes, C.,Oksanen, H.,Taylor, A.,Jackson, J.,Murray, L.,Caspi, A.,Moffitt, T. E.(2002).'I'm gonna beat you!' SNAP!: An observational paradigm for assessing young children's disruptive behaviour in competitive play.Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry,43(4),507-516.
29. Kellert, S. R.,Felthous, A. R.(1985).Childhood cruelty toward animals among criminals and noncriminals.Human Relations,38(12),1113-1129.
30. Kempes, M.,Matthys, W.,Maassen, G.,Goozen, S. V.,England, H. V.(2006).A parent questionnaire for distinguishing between reactive and proactive aggression in children.European Child Adolesence Psychiatry,15,38-45.
31. Key, J. M.,Sawyer, M. G,Prior, M. R.(2005).Similarities and differences between aggressive and delinquent children and adolescents in a national sample.Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry,39,366-372.
32. Kohlberg, L.,Hersh, R. H.(1977).Moral development: A review of the theory.Theory into Practice,16(2),53-59.
33. Kutcher, S.,Aman, M.,Brooks, S. J.,Buitelaar, J.,van Daalen, E.,Feqert, J.,Findling, R. L.,Fisman, S.,Greenhill, L. L.,Huss, M., Kusumakar, V.,Pine, D.,Taylor, E.,Tyano, S.(2004).International consensus statement on attention-deficit /hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) and disruptive behaviour disorders (DBDs): Clinical implications and treatment practice suggestions.European Neuropsychopharmacology,14(1),11-28.
34. Lahey, B. B.,Loeber, R.,Hart, E. L.,Frick, P. J.,Applegate, B.,Zhang, Q.,Green, S. M.,Russo, M. F.(1995).Four-year longitudinal study of conduct disorder in boys: Patterns and predictions of persistence.Journal of Abnormal Psychology,104,83-93.
35. Luk, E. S. L.,Staiger, P. K.,Wong, L.,Mathai, J.(1999).Children who are cruel to animals: Arevist.Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry,33,29-36.
36. Lynam, D. H.(1996).Early identification of chronic offenders: Who is the fledging psychopath?.Psychological Bulletin,20,209-234.
37. Lynam, D. R.(1998).Early identification of the fledging psychopath: Locating the psychopathic children in the current nomenclature.Journal of Abnormal Psychology,107,566-575.
38. Milich, R. M.,Dodge, K. A.(1984).Social information processing in child psychiatric populations.Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology,12,471-490.
39. Miller, C.(2001).Childhood animal cruelty and interpersonal violence.Clinical Psychology Review,21(5),735-749.
40. Pepler, D.,Craig, W. M.(1995).A peek behind the frence: Naturalistic observations of aggressive children with remote audiovisual recording.Developmental Psychology,31(4),548-553.
41. Sinaiko, H. W.,Brislin, R. W.(1973).Evaluating language translation: Experiments on three assessment method.Journal of Applied Psychology,57(3),328-334.
42. Tavecchio, L. W. C.,Stams, G. J. J. M.,Brugman, D.,Thomeer-Bonwens, M. A. E.(1999).Moral judgement and delinquency in homeless youth.Journal of Moral Education,28(1),63-79.
43. Toth, S. L.,Cicchetti, D.,Macfie, J.,Rogosch, F. A.,Maughan, A.(2000).Narrative representations of moral affiliative and conflictual themes and behavioral problems in maltreated preschoolers.Journal of Clinical Child Psychology,29(3),307-318.
44. Walker, J. L.,Lahey, B. B.,Hynd, G. W.,Frame, C. L.(1987).Comparison of specific patterns of antisocial behavior in children with conduct disorder with or without coexisting hyperactivity.Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology,55(6),910-913.
45. Waschbusch, D. A.,Pelbam, W. E.,Jennings, J. R.,Greiner, A. R.,Tarter, R. E.,Moss, H. B.(2002).Reactive aggression in boys with disruptive behavior disorders: Behavior, physiology, and affect.Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology,30(6),641-656.
46. Waschbusch, D. A.,Willoughby, M. T.,Pelham, W. E.(1998).Criterion validity and the utility of reactive and proactive aggression: Comparisons to attetntion deficit hyperactivity disorder, oppositional defiant disorder, conduct disorder and other measures of functioning.Journal of Clinical Child Psychology,27(4),396-405.
47. 侯伯勳、林志堅、遲景上、陳展航(2003)。台中地區某國小低年級學童注意力不足過動症候群盛行率初探。慈濟醫學，15(3)，163-167。
48. 洪儷瑜、丘產南、張郁雯、孟瑛如、蔡明富(2004)。問題行爲篩選量表指導手冊。台北:教育部特教組。
49. 廖鳳池、王文秀、田秀蘭(1998)。兒童輔導原理。台北:心理。

1. 蔡明富(2011)。特殊教育中有無伴隨品性疾患之注意力缺陷過動症學生的學校與家庭適應。應用心理研究，49，31-63。
2. (2010)。有無伴隨品行疾患之注意力缺陷過動症學生與普通學生行為問題之比較。東臺灣特殊教育學報，12，109-126。