感激在關係行銷中的角色－以特殊教育學校為例

The Role of Gratitude in Relationship Marketing: An Example of Special Education Schools

丁學勤(Shueh-Chin Ting)；黃亭蓉(Ting-Rong Huang)

忠誠度 ； 特殊教育 ； 感激 ； 關係行銷 ； gratitude ； loyalty ； relationship marketing ； special education

中華輔導與諮商學報

43期（2015 / 08 / 01）

35 - 60

繁體中文

本研究以台灣地區所有特殊教育學校的學生家長為研究對象，充分調查感激在關係行銷中的角色，尤其探討關係行銷中關係利益、教師專業、及親師溝通這三個變項對家長感激的影響，並討論家長感激與家長忠誠度的關聯性。本研究採問卷調查法，並採立意抽樣的方式進行問卷調查，回收有效問卷410份，以結構方程模式（SEM）進行潛在變項間的路徑分析。本研究主要發現為：（1）影響家長感激的具體原因為關係利益、教師專業及親師溝通，且此三變項對於家長感激皆有正向的影響；（2）家長感激並非只產生正向情緒－回報感，亦會產生負向情緒－罪惡感；（3）家長感激會直接正向的影響家長忠誠度；（4）正向情緒－回報感會正向影響家長的忠誠度，但負面情緒－罪惡感對家長的忠誠度卻沒有顯著影響。

In this study, the subjects were the parents of the students who had been receiving the special education in Taiwan. This study thoroughly investigated the role played by gratitude in relationship marketing. In other words, explored in relationship marketing, the influences of relational benefit, teacher expertise, and parent-teacher communication on parent gratitude and discussed the association of parent gratitude and parent loyalty. Under purposive sampling, we collected 410 questionnaires, and used structural equation modeling to do path analysis within latent variables. The findings of the study were (1) The major reasons which affected parent gratitude were relationship benefit, teacher expertise and parent-teacher communication, and these three variables all had positive influences on parent gratitude. (2) Parent gratitude produced not only positive emotion-reciprocity but also negative emotion-guilty. (3) Parent gratitude directly and positively affected parent loyalty. (4) Positive emotion-reciprocity had positive influence on parent loyalty but negative emotion-guilty did not have significant influence on parent loyalty.

1. Li, S. C.(2013).Exploring the relationships among service quality, customer loyalty and word-of-mouth for private higher education in Taiwan.Asia Pacific Management Review,18(4),375-389.
   連結：
2. Li, S. C.(2013).Exploring the relationships among service quality, customer loyalty and word-of-mouth for private higher education in Taiwan.Asia Pacific Management Review,18(4),375-389.
   連結：
3. 程婉毓、孫淑柔(2008)。國小啟智班學生家庭需求及家庭支援服務之調查研究。特殊教育研究學刊，33(3)，55-75。
   連結：
4. Baker, T. R.,Palmer, A. M.,Kerski, J. J.(2009).A national survey to examine teacher professional development and implementation of desktop GIS.Journal of Geography,108(4),174-185.
5. Chen, L. H.,Kee, Y. H.(2008).Gratitude and adolescent athletes' well-being.Social Indicator Research,89(2),361-373.
6. Crosby, L. A.,Evans, K. R.,Cowles, D.(1990).Relationship quality in services selling: An interpersonal influence perspective.Journal of Marketing,54(3),68-81.
7. Dahl, D. W.,Honea, H.,Manchanda, R. V.(2005).Three Rs of interpersonal consumer guilt: Relationship, reciprocity, reparation.Journal of Consumer Psychology,15(4),307-315.
8. Dryden, J. R.,Wilkinson, D. S.(1997).Three-dimensional analysis of the creep due to a viscous grain boundany phase.Acta Materialia,45(3),1259-1273.
9. Dunlap, G.,Fox, L.(2007).Parent-professional partnerships: A valuable context for addressing challenging behaviours.International Journal of Disability, Development and Education,54(3),273-285.
10. Higgins, T.(Eds.),Kruglanski, A.(Eds.)(1997).Social psychology: Handbook of basic mechanisms and processes.New York, NY:Guilford Press.
11. Kasahara, M.,Turnbull, A. P.(2005).Meaning of family-professional partnerships: Japanese mothers' perspectives.Exceptional Children,71(3),249-265.
12. Kayama, M.(2010).Parental experiences of children's disabilities and special education in the United States and Japan: Implications for school social work.Social Work,55(2),117-125.
13. Lui, S. S.,Wong, Y. Y.,Liu, W.(2009).Asset specificity roles in interfirm cooperation: Reducing opportunistic behavior or increasing cooperative behavior.Journal of Business Research,62(11),1214-1219.
14. McCullough, M. E.,Kilpatrick, S. D.,Emmons, R. A.,Larson, D. B.(2001).Is gratitude a moral affect?.Psychological Bulletin,127(2),249-266.
15. McCullough, M. E.,Kimeldorf, M. B.,Cohen, A. D.(2008).An adaptation for altruism? The social causes, social effects, and social evolution of gratitude.Association for Psychological Science,17(4),281-285.
16. Morgan, R. M.,Hunt, S. D.(1994).The commitment-trust theory of relationship marketing.Journal of Marketing,58(3),20-38.
17. Mueller, T. G.,Singer, G. H. S.,Draper, L. M.(2008).Reducing parental dissatisfaction with special education in two school districts: Implementing conflict prevention and alternative dispute resolution.Journal of Educational and Psychological Consultation,18(3),191-233.
18. Owston, R.,Wideman, H.,Murphy, J.,Lupshenyuk, D.(2008).Blended teacher professional development: A synthesis of three program evaluations.Internet and Higher Education,11(3),201-210.
19. Palmatier, R. W.,Dant, R. P.,Grewal, D.,Evans, K. R.(2006).Factors influencing the effectiveness of relationship marketing: A meta-analysis.Journal of Marketing,70(4),136-153.
20. Palmatier, R. W.,Jarvis, C. B.,Bechkoff, J. R.,Kardes, F. R.(2009).The role of customer gratitude in relationship marketing.Journal of Marketing,73(5),1-18.
21. Pang, I. W.,Watkins, D.(2000).Towards a psychological model of teacher-parent communication in Hong Kong primary schools.Educational Studies,26(2),141-163.
22. Pianta, R. C.,Mashburn, A. J.,Downer, J. T.,Hamre, B. K.,Justice, L.(2008).Effects of web-mediated professional development resources on teacher-child interactions in pre-kindergarten classrooms.Early Childhood Research Quarterly,23(4),431-451.
23. Pinkus, S.(2005).Bridging the gap between policy and practice: Adopting a strategic vision for partnership working in special education.British Journal of Special Education,32(4),184-187.
24. Prince-Paul, M.(2008).Understanding the meaning of social well-being at the end of life.Oncology Nursing Forum,35(3),365-371.
25. Soscia, I.(2007).Gratitude, delight, or guilt: The role of consumers' emotions in predicting postconsumption behaviors.Psychology & Marketing,24(10),871-894.
26. Spillers, R. L.,Wellisch, D. K.,Kim, Y.,Matthews, A.,Baker, F.(2008).Family caregivers guilt in the context of cancer care.Psychosomatics,49(6),511-519.
27. Srinivasan, R.,Moorman, C.(2005).Strategic firm commitments and rewards for customer relationship management in online retailing.Journal of Marketing,69(4),193-200.
28. Trussell, R. P.,Hammond, H.,Ingalls, L.(2008).Ethical practices and parental participation in rural special education.Rural Special Education Quarterly,27(1/2),19-23.
29. Turnbull, A.,Turnbull, R.(2001).Families, professionals and exceptionality.Upper Saddle River, NJ:Merrill Prentice Hall.
30. Watkins, P.,Scheer, J.,Ovnicek, M.,Kolts, R.(2006).The debt of gratitude: Dissociating gratitude and indebtedness.Cognition and Emotion,20(2),217-241.
31. Wood, A. M.,Joseph, S.,Maltby, J.(2008).Gratitude uniquely predicts satisfaction with life: Incremental validity above the domains and facets of the five factor model.Personality and Individual Differences,45(1),49-54.
32. Wood, A. M.,Maltby, J.,Gillett, R.,Linley, P. A.,Joseph, S.(2008).The role of gratitude in development of social support, stress, and depression: Two longitudinal studies.Journal of Research in Personality,42(4),854-871.
33. Wulf, G.,Clauss, A.,Shea, C. H.,Whitacre, C. A.(2001).Benefits of self-control in dyad practice.Research Quarterly for Exercise and Sport,72(3),299-303.
34. 朱舟譯、黃瑞虹譯、Groenewegen, J.(2002)。交易成本經濟學及其超越。上海:上海財經大學。
35. 吳曲輝譯、Turner, J. H.(1996)。社會學理論的結構。台北:桂冠。
36. 周雪光(2003)。組織社會學十講。北京=Beijing, China:社會科學文獻=Social Science Document Publishing House。
37. 馬康莊譯、陳信木譯、Ritzer, G.(1995)。社會學理論。台北:巨流。
38. 張滿玲譯、Taylor, S. E.、Peplau, L. A.、Sears, D. O.(1999)。社會心理學。台北:雙葉。
39. 許天威、徐享良、張勝成(2005)。新特殊教育通論。台北=Taipei, Taiwan:五南=Wunan。
40. 楊淑嬌譯、Ritzer, G.(2003)。當代社會學理論。台北:麥格羅希爾。
41. 趙居蓮譯、Weber, A. L.(1995)。社會心理學。台北:桂冠。

1. 陳慧華、張文權、范熾文(2016)。當代績效責任領導：概念、理論及對校長領導之啟示。學校行政，101，34-54。
2. 劉益蓉,張恒豪,柯秋雪,邱春瑜(2020)。家成、業就？擔任特教老師的非障礙手足之邊界跨越經驗探究。特殊教育研究學刊，45(3)，29-51。