覓情與營生交融開展：矯正學校離校青年再求學生涯發展經驗之現象學探究

A Phenomenological Inquiry into the Career Development and Reentering College Experience of Youths from a Juvenile Correctional School

10.53106/172851862023010066002

曹訓嘉(Xun-Jia Tsao)；許育光(Yu-Kuang Hsu)；劉淑慧(Shu-Hui Liu)

生活世界 ； 生涯發展 ； 自我 ； 現象學 ； 矯正學校青年 ； Career development ； lifeworld ； phenomenological inquiry ； self ； youth in juvenile correctional school

中華輔導與諮商學報

66期（2023 / 01 / 01）

41 - 79

繁體中文;英文

本研究採用現象學方法探究矯正學校離校青年的再求學生涯發展經驗。共訪談三位離開矯正學校後曾就讀大學之青年，結果發現：他們的生涯發展蘊含以下傾向：（1）為了關係營生移動出法制規則世界；（2）從野地世界開展出屬己的自我價值、興趣與生涯風格；（3）考量處境中他人期待自己讀書，重新建構在法制規則世界的新成功經驗；（4）在多元生活世界之落差與拉扯中整合經驗，發展出獨有生涯籌劃。透過前述發現與文獻之對話，本研究提出「營生」與「覓情」作為這些青年與置身處境交往中的核心環節，並勾勒出他們在生涯發展中進出學校體制之處境結構：（1）投入不同生活世界的契機之「覓情」需求；（2）何以離開原本生活世界之「營生」需求；（3）營生（生涯發展）在關係之中（我他交往）開展；（4）關係在「營生」和「覓情」的交織中開展；（5）自我由「覓情」與「營生」交織而成，並在關係時間中發展出生涯方向。最後，本研究翻轉了展開探究之初未曾覺察的意識形態，跳脫崇尚文憑的價值框架，發現就讀大學在這群青年的生涯發展經驗中的真正意義是作為連接法治規則世界的通行證，並據此建議矯治焦點應放在如何協助他們找到合適的連接方法，青少年犯罪防治的焦點則在協助增加法治規則世界、弱化野地世界之「覓情」與「營生」，乃能以貼近犯罪少年生活世界的方式來協助他們安身立命。

According to previous research, almost all youths in juvenile correctional school drop out before committing crimes. However, some youths in the school study for attending university. This career change invoked the researcher's curiosity. The researcher aims to explore the experience of career development and return to school of youths from juvenile correctional schools, understand how these youths constructed different career paths compared with their past, and put forward the results as a reference for practitioners. The researcher interviewed three youths who left juvenile correctional school and attended university, asking them to tell their stories and describe their experiences of returning to school. The researcher used a phenomenological approach to analyze the self-expression of these youths and their interaction with the environment in the course of their career, leading to the revelation of the existing structure of the youths' career development. The result showed that the youths' career development contained the following four tendencies: (1) leaving the lifeworld of rules of law to make a living through relationships; (2) developing their self-esteem, interests, and career styles in the wild lifeworld; (3) considering others' expectations for them to study and reconstructing new successful experiences in the lifeworld of rules of law; and (4) integrating different lifeworld experiences while falling in the gap among various lifeworld and being pushing around, and developing their unique career projection. Considering these findings along with relevant literature, this study proposed that "making a living" and "seeking a sense of belonging" were two core links of youths' from juvenile correctional school interacting with others in their situations. The situational structure of the passing in and out school system in their career development showed the following: (1) The need of "seeking a sense of belonging" was an opportunity for them to invest in various lifeworld; (2) The need of "making a living" was the reason to leave their previous lifeworld; (3) "Making a living" (career development) developed via relationships (how they interacted with others in their situations); (4) The relationship developed via interweaving of "making a living" and "seeking a sense of belonging"; and (5) Self was constituted via interweaving of "seeking a sense of belonging" and "making a living." Then, the researcher responded to the research questions and constructed the career development situation structure of the youths from juvenile correctional school who attended university. Finally, this study turned around the ideology that had not been noticed at the beginning of this inquiry and escaped from the bondage resulted from advocating diploma. It was found that, for these youth, in their career development experience, the meaning of attending university was as a means to connect to the lifeworld of the rules of law. Accordingly, it is suggested that corrective treatment should focus on assisting them to find an appropriate means of connection. The focus of juvenile delinquency prevention is to strengthen the youths' "seeking a sense of belonging" and "making a living" in the lifeworld of rules of law, and weaken these in the wild lifeworld. To enable practitioners to have a more detailed understanding of the career development of youths from juvenile correctional school, come closer to the lifeworld of these youths, and think about how to help these youths settle down in the world and live their life with meaning, as suggestions and strategies for living on their own.

1. 李國隆, K. L.(2012)。犯罪生涯之存活分析—以中止犯、持續犯與一般青少年十年追蹤資料為例。數據分析，7(4)，125-171。
   連結：
2. 李維倫, W. L.(2004)。以置身所在做為心理學研究的目標現象及其相關之方法論。應用心理研究，22，157-200。
   連結：
3. 李維倫, W. L.(2017)。受傷的時間性：受性侵害及家庭關係斷損少女之生活經驗的存在現象學分析。中華心理學刊，59(3)，145-161。
   連結：
4. 李維倫, W. L.,賴憶嫺, Y. H.(2009)。現象學方法論：存在行動的投入。中華輔導與諮商學報，25，275-321。
   連結：
5. 洪雅琴, Y. C.,李維倫, W. L(2007)。一位犯罪少女的置身所在：家的錯落與回返。本土心理學研究，28，141-196。
   連結：
6. 翁士恆, S. H.,彭榮邦, R. B.(2018)。以「非我」為引探究受苦經驗與療癒實踐行動：從現象學取徑。中華心理衛生學刊，31(3)，253-274。
   連結：
7. 翁健力, C. L.(2018)。生命歷程犯罪學的回首與展望。犯罪學期刊，20(2)，3-28。
   連結：
8. 陳榮華, W. W.(2004)。海德格與高達美的時間概念。國立臺灣大學哲學論評，28，1-38。
   連結：
9. 黃芳玫, F. M.,陳唯真, W. J.,黃芳雅, F. Y.(2006)。臺灣男性勞動市場參與之研究－人口、市場機會及參與行。臺灣經濟預測與政策，37(1)，1-48。
   連結：
10. 劉淑慧, S. H.,夏允中, Y. J.,王智弘, C. H.,孫頌賢, S. H.(2019)。自我及其在生活世界中的運作：從存在現象學處境結構觀之。中華輔導與諮商學報，555，11-226。
    連結：
11. 顧以遷, Y. C.,戴申峰, S. F.(2016)。受刑人社會排斥感受對預期管理策略之影響。犯罪學期刊，18(2)，51-77。
    連結：
12. Akers, R. L.,Sellers, C. S.(2009).Criminological theories: Introduction, evaluation, andapplication.Oxford University Press.
13. Andrews, D. A.,Bonta, J.(2010).The psychology of criminal conduct.Anderson.
14. Blokland, A.,De Schipper, N.(2016).How important are life-course transitions inexplaining desistance? Examining the extent to which marriage, divorce and parenthoodaccount for the age–crime relationship in former juvenile delinquents.Global perspectives on desistance: Reviewing what weknow and looking to the future
15. Costello, B. J.,Laub, J. H.(2020).Social control theory: The legacy of Travis Hirschi's causes of delinquency.Annual Review of Criminology,3,21-41.
16. DeLisi, M.,Neppl, T. K.,Lohman, B. J.,Vaughn, M. G.,Shook, J. J.(2013).Early starters:Which type of criminal onset matters most for delinquent careers?.Journal of Criminal Justice,41(1),12-17.
17. Hirschi, T.(2002).Causes of delinquency.Transaction Publishers.
18. Lincoln, Y. S.,Guba, E. G.(1985).Naturalistic inquiry.Sage.
19. Loeber, R.,Menting, B.,Lynam, D. R.,Moffitt, T. E.,Stouthamer-Loeber, M.,Stallings, R.,Farrington, D. P.,Pardini, D.(2012).Findings from the pittsburgh youth study:Cognitive impulsivity and intelligence as predictors of the age-crime curve.Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry,51(11),1136-1149.
20. Mallett, C. A.(2012).Linking disorders to delinquency: Treating high-risk youth in thejuvenile justice system.Lynne Rienner Publishers.
21. Mandracchia, J. T.,Morgan, R. D.(2011).Understanding criminals' thinking: Further examination of the measure of offender thinking styles–revised.Assessment,18(4),442-452.
22. Pyrooz, D. C.,Mcgloin, J. M.,Decker, S. H.(2017).Parenthood as a turning point in thelife course for male and female gang members: A study of within-individual changes ingang membership and criminal behavior.Criminology,55(4),869-899.
23. Salvatore, C.,Markowitz, M. W.(2014).Do life course transitions and social bonds influence male and female offending differently? Gender contrasts and criminality.Deviant Behavior,35(8),628-653.
24. Sampson, R. J.,Laub, J. H.(2005).A life-course view of the development of crime.The ANNALS of the American Academy of Political and Social Science,602(1),12-45.
25. Spencer, G. N.,Norman E. A.,Neault, R.(2011).Career flow: A hope-centered approach tocareer development.Pearson.
26. Super, D. E.(1990).A life-span, life-space approach to career development.Career choice and development: Applying contemporary theories topractice
27. Vazsonyi, A. T.,Mikuška, J.,Kelley, E. L.(2017).It's time: A meta-analysis on the selfcontrol-deviance link.Journal of Criminal Justice,48,48-63.
28. Wojciechowski, T. W.(2018).The development of deviant peer association across the lifecourse and its relevance for predicting offending in early adulthood.Journal of Developmental and Life-Course Criminology,4,73-91.
29. Wright, K. A.,Kim, B.,Chassin, L.,Losoya, S. H.,Piquero, A. R.(2014).Ecologicalcontext, concentrated disadvantage, and youth reoffending: Identifying the socialmechanisms in a sample of serious adolescent offenders.Journal of Youth and Adolescence,43(10),1781-1799.
30. 沈清松, Q. S.(2000).呂格爾.東大書局=The Grand EastBook.
31. 林其薇, C. W.(2014)。國立彰化師範大學=National Changhua University of Education。
32. 林坤隆, K. L.(2016)。少年首犯年齡、類型及處遇之研究－以少年法院之個案分析為例。青少年犯罪防治研究期刊，8(2)，1-52。
33. 洪漢鼎, H. D.(2008).重新回到現象學的原點：現象學十四講.世新大學出版中心=Shih Hsin University.
34. 劉淑慧, S. H.(2020)。德性存在生涯模式：易經和現象學之啟發。華人生涯理論與實踐：本土化與多元性視野
35. 劉淑慧, S. H.,王智弘, C. H.,黃宗堅, T. C.,白倩如, C. J.,洪瑞斌, J. P.,Tsai, S. C.(2016)。科技部專題研究計劃科技部專題研究計劃,科技部=Ministry of Science and Technology。
36. 盧怡任, Y. J.,劉淑慧, S. H.(2015)。處境結構分析：經由語義學分析與反思抵達存有學理解。教育與心理研究，38(2)，31-57。

1. 劉淑慧,曹訓嘉(2023)。自我探索與發展之經驗結構：奠基於辯證存在生命生涯模式之輔導方案。輔導季刊，59(2)，29-44。
2. (2023)。「角色義務」與「獨立自主」的相生相依：矯正學校青年自我「關聯身分」野地闖蕩實踐歷程的現象學探究。本土心理學研究，59，191-257。
3. (2023)。生涯發展處境中「享變」之經驗結構：奠基於辯證存在生命生涯模式之輔導方案。輔導季刊，59(4)，15-29。
4. (2024)。體驗中開展和諧轉化的生涯籌劃風格：解析辯證存在生命生涯模式之輔導理念。輔導季刊，60(1)，1-15。