题名

自我超越的情緒與超越自我的表現：敬畏情緒的正向影響效果

并列篇名

The Self-transcendent Emotion and the Transcending One's Self Performance: A Study of Positive Effect of the Emotion of Awe

DOI

10.53106/172851862023090068003

作者

余民寧(Min-Ning Yu)；熊師瑤(Shih-Yao Hsiung)；許雅涵(Ya-Han Hsu)；翁雅芸(Ya-Yun Weng)

关键词

主觀幸福感 ； 自我超越的情緒 ； 利社會行為 ； 感恩 ； 敬畏情緒 ； Awe-emotion ； gratitude ； prosocial behavior ； self-transcendent emotion ； well-being

期刊名称

中華輔導與諮商學報

卷期/出版年月

68期（2023 / 09 / 01）

页次

71 - 113

内容语文

繁體中文;英文
中文摘要

敬畏情緒為自我超越之情緒，是正向心理學新興議題，能促進個體心理健康，並協助人類度過如Covid-19疫情等艱困時刻。本研究認為敬畏情緒能引發正向情緒與行為，區分兩項子研究探討其影響效果。研究一採前實驗研究設計單組後測設計以及調查法進行，邀請720名大專院校學生參與網路調查，並使用結構方程式模型建構敬畏情緒影響模型。研究一整體模型適配，研究結果認為敬畏情緒引發個體感恩情緒，促進利社會行為，最終產生幸福感受，且敬畏情緒需透過感恩與利社會行為才能促進幸福感，經敬畏情緒所引發的感恩，也須透過利社會行為方可激發幸福感，上述結果顯示利社會行為是敬畏情緒促進幸福感的關鍵中介角色。研究二接續上述成果，採實驗法分析不同情緒（敬畏情緒、正向情緒和負向情緒）對利社會具體表現因果影響，將90位參與者區分三個組別，分別觀賞誘發不同情緒影片後，填答心理評量問題並接受利社會行為具體表現測量（捐款與否）。研究二結果認為，自然環境影片可誘發正向敬畏情緒，自然環境威脅影片則誘發負向情緒與敬畏情緒，而幽默影片則引發正向情緒。雖然敬畏情緒皆可引發感恩與利社會行為傾向，但只有正向敬畏情緒才會將利社會行為付諸具體行動，表達捐贈更多金額之意願。本研究根據上述研究結果，提出教育與輔導應用的具體建議，以供未來研究與實務工作參考運用。
英文摘要

In positive psychology, we are self-transcendent emotions that promote individual mental health. Theory and research have supported the idea that awe can help humanity through difficult times during the Covid-19 pandemic. Awe arises when individuals encounter perceptually vast stimuli that overwhelm their existing knowledge and mental structures. In our country, awe has been composed of five latent factors, including "curiosity and exploration," "a feeling of wonderment regarding nature," "appreciation of artwork," "a feeling of smallness," and "social connection." However, little attention has been paid to its effects. Recent studies have suggested that awe emotions can strengthen positive emotions and behaviors. We continued to study the impact and causal processes underlying the emotion of awe to expand its application and understanding of positive human behaviors and to promote the development of a harmonious and peaceful society. The aim of the current study was to examine the relationship between awe, gratitude, prosocial behavior, and well-being across two studies. In Study 1, we examined the mediating roles of gratitude and prosocial behavior in the relationship between awe and subjective well-being. A total of 720 college students completed online questionnaires to determine the constructs of the awe model. The data were analyzed using Structural Equation Modeling (SEM). The model was found to be the best fit based on the overall model verification. The results of Study 1 demonstrated that awe was significantly associated with gratitude, prosocial behavior, and subjective well-being. Individuals with higher awe exhibited more positive emotions and positive tendencies. Furthermore, prosocial behavior completely mediated the relationship between awe, gratitude, and subjective well-being. Thus, prosocial behavior plays a key role in promoting well-being. In Study 1, we tested the causal role of different emotions (awe, positive emotions, and negative emotions) on prosocial behavior using an experimental method. We used video clips (nature, threats to nature, and silent comedy) to evoke the three emotions. After inducing emotions, we examined participants' emotional states using an opening question and emotional self-report scales, including the General Awe Scale, Gratitude Scale, Positive and Negative Affect Scales, and Prosocial Scale, and asked them about their willingness to donate money to present their prosocial behavior. First, we performed a sentiment analysis of participants' comments on videos using word cloud analytics. Second, data were collected and analyzed using descriptive statistics, Pearson's correlation coefficient, ANOVA, and PROCESS model analysis. The results of Study 2 showed that natural videos could evoke awe, threats to nature videos could evoke both negative and awe emotions, and silent comedy videos could evoke general positive emotions. Participants in both the positive and negative awe conditions had higher feelings of gratitude and prosocial tendencies. The results showed that positive awe, which was induced experimentally rather than through negative awe, and generally positive emotions caused people to donate more money. In summary, these findings suggest that awe generally makes people more prosocial, but only positive awe produces behaviors that are more prosocial. Positive awe may help to situate individuals in broader social contexts and enhance their collective concerns. Finally, the conclusion offers some suggestions. Future studies should focus on other criterion variables, such as learning satisfaction, curiosity, and learning outcomes, as these areas are also associated with a greater sense of awe. Future researchers could also compare differences in social behavior, such as volunteering to help other people, increasing the willingness to volunteer time, engaging in green consumption, and volunteering to solve environmental problems. Awe can also be combined with virtual reality technology, as it has been proposed that the use of VR could be an effective way to induce awe in controlled experimental settings.
主题分类 社會科學 > 心理學
社會科學 > 教育學
参考文献
  1. 方紫薇, T.-W.(2012)。完美主義與學習困擾、正負向情感之關係：反芻思考之中介效果。教育心理學報，43，735-762。
    連結：
  2. 余民寧, M.-N.,陳柏霖, P.-L.,陳玉樺, Y.-H.(2017)。量表長度簡化研究：「簡式中小學教師主觀幸福感量表」修訂。教育研究與發展期刊，13(4)，27-56。
    連結：
  3. 余民寧, M.-N.,熊師瑤, S.Y.,許雅涵, Y. H.,翁雅芸, Y. Y.(2022)。敬畏情緒量表的編製發展與驗證之研究。教育心理學報，53(3)，643-664。
    連結：
  4. 林江亮, C.-L.(2009)。資訊透明度對捐款收入影響之實證研究以臺灣公益團體為例。經濟研究，45(1)，65-102。
    連結：
  5. 傅祖壇, T.-T.,楊文山, W.-S.,葉寶文, P.-W(2006)。921大地震災後重建經費之民眾捐款意願 CVM法之應用。經濟研究，42(1)，57-74。
    連結：
  6. Aknin, L. B.,Van de Vondervoort, J. W.,Hamlin, J. K.(2018).Positive feelings reward and promote prosocial behavior.Current Opinion in Psychology,20,55-59.
  7. Algoe, S. B.(2012).Find, remind, and bind: The functions of gratitude in everyday relationships.Social and Personality Psychology Compass,6(6),455-469.
  8. Ardenghi, S.,Rampoldi, G.,Bani, M.,Strepparava, M. G.(2021).Personal values as early predictors of emotional and cognitive empathy among medical students.Current Psychology,42,253-261.
  9. Armenta, C. N.,Fritz, M. M.,Lyubomirsky, S.(2017).Functions of positive emotions: Gratitude as a motivator of self-improvement and positive change.Emotion Review,9(3),183-190.
  10. Armstrong, T.,Detweiler-Bedell, B.(2008).Beauty as an emotion: The exhilarating prospect of mastering a challenging world.Review of General Psychology,12(4),305-329.
  11. Bai, Y.,Maruskin, L. A,Chen, S.,Gordon, A. M.,Stellar, J. E.,McNeil, G. D.,Peng, K.,Keltner, D.(2017).Awe, the diminished self, and collective engagement: Universals and cultural variations in the small self.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,113,185-209.
  12. Bartlett, M. Y.,DeSteno, D.(2006).Gratitude and prosocial behavior: Helping when it costs you.Psychological Science,17,319-325.
  13. Batson, C. D.(1991).The altruism question: Toward a social-psychological answer.Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Inc..
  14. Boehm, J. K.,Lyubomirsky, S.,Sheldon, K. M.(2011).A longitudinal experimental study comparing the effectiveness of happiness-enhancing strategies in Anglo Americans and Asian Americans.Cognition and Emotion,25(7),1263-1272.
  15. Bollen, K. A.,Stine, R. A.(1992).Bootstrapping goodness-of-fit measures in structural equation models.Sociological Methods and Research,21(2),205-229.
  16. Bonner, E. T.,Friedman, H. L.(2011).A conceptual clarification of the experience of awe: An interpretative phenomenological analysis.The Humanistic Psychologist,39,222-235.
  17. Büssing, A.,Rodrigues Recchia, D.,Dienberg, T.,Surzykiewicz, J.,Baumann, K.(2021).Awe/gratitude as an experiential aspect of spirituality and its association to perceived positive changes during the COVID-19 pandemic.Frontiers in Psychiatry,12,642716.
  18. Campbell, W. K.,Bonacci, A. M.,Shelton, J.,Exline, J. J.,Bushman, B. J(2004).Psychological entitlement: Interpersonal consequences and validation of a self-report measure.Journal of Personality Assessment,83,29-45.
  19. Campos, B.,Shiota, M. N.,Keltner, D.,Gonzaga, G. C.,Goetz, J. L.(2013).What is shared, what is different? Core relational themes and expressive displays of eight positive emotions.Cognition and Emotion,27,37-52.
  20. Caprara, G. V.,Alessandri, G.,Eisenberg, N.(2012).Prosociality: The contribution of traits, values, and self-efficacy beliefs.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,102(6),1289-1303.
  21. Caprara, G. V.,Steca, P.,Zelli, A.,Capanna, C.(2005).A new scale for measuring adults' prosocialness.European Journal of Psychological Assessment,21(2),77-89.
  22. Carr, A.(2011).Positive psychology: The science of happiness and human strengths.Routledge.
  23. Carr, D.(Ed.)(2016).Perspectives on gratitude: An interdisciplinary approach.Routledge.
  24. Castelo, N.,White, K.,Goode, M. R.(2021).Nature promotes self-transcendence and prosocial behavior.Journal of Environmental Psychology,76,101639.
  25. Chaplin, C. (1916). The count. [Video]. Mutual Film Corporation. https://www.dailymotion.com/video/x6gldiw
  26. Chen, S. K.,Mongrain, M.(2021).Awe and the interconnected self.The Journal of Positive Psychology,16(6),770-778.
  27. Chirico, A.,Ferrise, F.,Cordella, L.,Gaggioli, A.(2018).Designing awe in virtual reality: An experimental study.Frontiers in Psychology,8,2351.
  28. Condon, P.,Feldman Barrett, L.(2013).Conceptualizing and experiencing compassion.Emotion,13(5),817-821.
  29. Curry, O. S.,Rowland, L. A.,Van Lissa, C. J.,Zlotowitz, S.,McAlaney, J.,Whitehouse, H.(2018).Happy to help? A systematic review and meta-analysis of the effects of performing acts of kindness on the well-being of the actor.Journal of Experimental Social Psychology,76,320-329.
  30. Cutts, S. (2012).Animation created in flash and after effects looking at mans relationship with the natural world . [Video]. https://www.stevecutts.com/animation.html
  31. Danvers, A. F.,Shiota, M. N.(2017).Going off script: Effects of awe on memory for scripttypical and irrelevant narrative detail.Emotion,17(6),938-952.
  32. Davidson, R. J.(Ed.),Scherer, K. R.(Ed.),Goldsmith, H. H.(Ed.)(2003).Handbook of affective sciences.Oxford University.
  33. Emmons, R. A.,McCullough, M. E.(2003).Counting blessings versus burdens: An experimental investigation of gratitude and subjective well-being in daily life.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,84(2),377-389.
  34. Fogarty, C. T.(2020).Compassion, gratitude and awe: The role of pro-social emotions in training physicians for relational competence.The International Journal of Psychiatry in Medicine,55(5),314-320.
  35. Folkman, S.,Lazarus, R. S.(1984).Stress, appraisal, and coping.Springer Publishing Company.
  36. Fredrickson, B. L.(2001).The role of positive emotions in positive psychology: The broaden-and-build theory of positive emotions.The American Psychologist,56(3),218-226.
  37. Fredrickson, B. L.,Tugade, M. M.,Waugh, C. E.,Larkin, G. R.(2003).What good are positive emotions in crisis? A prospective study of resilience and emotions following the terrorist attacks on the United States on September 11th, 2001.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,84(2),365-376.
  38. Gordon, A. M.,Impett, E. A.,Kogan, A.,Oveis, C.,Keltner, D.(2012).To have and to hold: Gratitude promotes relationship maintenance in intimate bonds.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,103(2),257-274.
  39. Gordon, A. M.,Stellar, J. E.,Anderson, C. L.,McNeil, G. D.,Loew, D.,Keltner, D.(2017).The dark side of the sublime: Distinguishing a threat-based variant of awe.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,113(2),310-328.
  40. Guan, F.,Chen, J.,Chen, O.,Liu, L.,Zha, Y.(2019).Awe and prosocial tendency.Current Psychology,38,1033-1041.
  41. Halstead, J. M.,Halstead, A. O.(2004).Awe, tragedy and the human condition.International Journal of Children's Spirituality,9,163-175.
  42. Hayes, A. F.(2022).Introduction to mediation, moderation, and conditional process analysis: A regression-based approach.Guilford Publications.
  43. Hill, P. L.,Allemand, M.,Roberts, B. W.(2013).Examining the pathways between gratitude and self-rated physical health across adulthood.Personality and Individual Differences,54(1),92-96.
  44. Hui, B.,Ng, J.,Berzaghi, E.,Cunningham-Amos, L. A.,Kogan, A.(2020).Rewards of kindness? A meta-analysis of the link between prosociality and well-being.Psychological Bulletin,146(12),1084-1116.
  45. Ibanez, L.,Moureau, N.,Roussel, S.(2017).How do incidental emotions impact pro-environmental behavior? Evidence from the dictator game.Journal of Behavioral and Experimental Economics,66,150-155.
  46. Izard, C. E.(1977).Human emotions.Plenum.
  47. Jiang, L.,Yin, J.,Mei, D.,Zhu, H.,Zhou, X.(2018).Awe weakens the desire for money.Journal of Pacific Rim Psychology,12,1-10.
  48. Joye, Y.,Bolderdijk, J. W.(2015).An exploratory study into the effects of extraordinary nature on emotions, mood, and prosociality.Frontiers in Psychology,5,1577.
  49. Joye, Y.,Dewitte, S.(2016).Up speeds you down. Awe-evoking monumental buildings trigger behavioral and perceived freezing.Journal of Environmental Psychology,47,112-125.
  50. Kasser, T.(2017).Living both well and sustainably: A review of the literature, with some reflections on future research, interventions and policy.Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society: A Mathematical Physical and Engineering Sciences,375,20160369.
  51. Keltner, D.,Haidt, J.(2003).Approaching awe, a moral, spiritual, and aesthetic emotion.Cognition and Emotion,17,297-314.
  52. Kiang, L.,Merçon-Vargas, E. A.,Mendonça, S. E.,Payir, A.,O'Brien, L.(2018).the development of gratitude and its relation to spending preferences and materialism.Developing gratitude in children and adolescents
  53. Korndörfer, M.,Egloff, B.,Schmukle, S. C.(2015).A large scale test of the effect of social class on prosocial behavior.Plos One,10(7),e0133193.
  54. Lazarus, R. S.(1991).Emotion and adaptation.Oxford University.
  55. Linley, P. A.(Ed.),Joseph, S.(Ed.)(2004).Positive psychology in practice.John Wiley & Sons.
  56. Maslow, A. H.(1969).Various meanings of transcendence.Journal of Transpersonal Psychology,1,56-66.
  57. Maslow, A. H.(1964).Religions, values, and peak-experiences.Ohio State University.
  58. McCullough, M. E.,Emmons, R. A.,Tsang, J.(2002).The grateful disposition: A conceptual and empirical topography.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,82,112-127.
  59. McDougall, W. (1910).An introduction to social psychology (3rd ed.). John W. Luce.
  60. McPhetres, J.(2019).Oh, the things you don't know: Awe promotes awareness of knowledge gaps and science interest.Cognition and Emotion,33(8),1599-1615.
  61. Nakayama, M.,Nozaki, Y.,Taylor, P. M.,Keltner, D.,Uchida, Y.(2020).Individual and cultural differences in predispositions to feel positive and negative aspects of awe.Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology,51(10),771-793.
  62. Neill, C.,Gerard, J.,Arbuthnott, K. D.(2019).Nature contact and mood benefits: Contact duration and mood type.The Journal of Positive Psychology,14(6),756-767.
  63. Nelson-Coffey, S. K.,Ruberton, P. M.,Chancellor, J.,Cornick, J. E.,Blascovich, J.,Lyubomirsky, S.(2019).The proximal experience of awe.Plos One,14(5),e0216780.
  64. Pappas, J. D.,Friedman, H. L.(2007).The construct of self-expansiveness and the validity of the transpersonal scale of the self-expansiveness level form.The Humanistic Psychologist,35(4),323-347.
  65. Peng, L.,Hu, X.,Lan, L.,Xu, C.,Li, M.(2022).The moderating role of resilience in the relationship between state and trait anxiety and post-traumatic growth of medical freshmen.Acta Psychologica,230,103741.
  66. Perlin, J. D.,Li, L.(2020).Why does awe have prosocial effects? New perspectives on awe and the small self.Perspectives on Psychological Science,15(2),291-308.
  67. Piff, P. K.,Dietze, P.,Feinberg, M.,Stancato, D. M.,Keltner, D.(2015).Awe, the small self, and prosocial behavior.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,108,883-899.
  68. Pilgrim, L.,Norris, J. I.,Hackathorn, J.(2017).Music is awesome: Influences of emotion, personality, and preference on experienced awe.Journal of Consumer Behaviour,16(5),442-451.
  69. Portocarrero, F. F.,Gonzalez, K.,Ekema-Agbaw, M.(2020).A meta-analytic review of the relationship between dispositional gratitude and well-being.Personality and Individual Differences,164,110101.
  70. Prade, C.,Saroglou, V.(2016).Awe's effects on generosity and helping.The Journal of Positive Psychology,11,522-530.
  71. Razavi, P.,Zhang, J. W.,Hekiert, D.,Yoo, S. H.,Howell, R. T.(2016).Cross-cultural similarities and differences in the experience of awe.Emotion,16,1097-1101.
  72. Rosen, H. S.,Sims, S. T.(2011).Altruistic behavior and habit formation.Nonprofit Management and Leadership,21(3),235-253.
  73. Rudd, M.,Vohs, K. D.,Aaker, J.(2012).Awe expands people's perception of time, alters decision making, and enhances well-being.Psychological Science,23,1130-1136.
  74. Saroglou, V.,Buxant, C.,Tilquin, J.(2008).Positive emotions as leading to religion and spirituality.The Journal of Positive Psychology,3,165-173.
  75. Schneider, K.(2017).The resurgence of awe in psychology: Promise, hope, and perils.The Humanistic Psychologist,45(2),103-108.
  76. Schneider, K. J.(2004).Rediscovery of awe: Splendor, mystery and the fluid center of life.Paragon House.
  77. Schneider, K. J.(2009).Awakening to awe: Personal stories of profound transformation.Jason Aronson.
  78. Schwartz, S. H.(2012).An overview of the Schwartz theory of basic values.Online Readings in Psychology and Culture,2(1),11.
  79. Seligman, M. E. P.(2011).Flourish: A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being.Free Press.
  80. Shaver, P. R.,Schwartz, J.,Kirson, D.,O'Connor, C.(1987).Emotion knowledge: Further exploration of a prototype approach.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,52,1061-1086.
  81. Shiota, M. N.,Keltner, D.,Mossman, A.(2007).The nature of awe: Elicitors, appraisals, and effects on self-concept.Cognition and Emotion,21,944-963.
  82. Snyder, C. R.(Ed.),Lopez, S. J.(Ed.)(2005).Handbook of positive psychology.Oxford University.
  83. Stellar, J. E.,Gordon, A. M.,Piff, P. K.,Cordaro, D.,Anderson, C. L.,Bai, Y.,Maruskin, L. A.,Keltner, D.(2017).Self-transcendent emotions and their social functions: Compassion, gratitude, and awe bind us to others through prosociality.Emotion Review,9,200-207.
  84. Stellar, J. E.,Gordon, A.,Anderson, C. L.,Piff, P. K.,McNeil, G. D.,Keltner, D.(2018).Awe and humility.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,114(2),258-269.
  85. Stellar, J. E.,John-Henderson, N.,Anderson, C. L.,Gordon, A. M.,McNeil, G. D.,Keltner, D.(2015).Positive affect and markers of inflammation: Discrete positive emotions predict lower levels of inflammatory cytokines.Emotion,15(2),129-133.
  86. Sundararajan, L.(2002).Religious awe: Potential contributions of negative theology to psychology, "positive" or otherwise.Journal of Theoretical and Philosophical Psychology,22(2),174-197.
  87. Thomson, A. L.,Siegel, J. T.(2017).Elevation: A review of scholarship on a moral and other-praising emotion.The Journal of Positive Psychology,12,628-638.
  88. Tomaszek, K.,Muchacka-Cymerman, A.(2020).Thinking about my existence during COVID-19, I feel anxiety and awe-The mediating role of existential anxiety and life satisfaction on the relationship between PTSD symptoms and post-traumatic growth.International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health,17(19),7062.
  89. Tudge, J. R. H.,Freitas, L. B. L.,O'Brien, L. T.(2015).The virtue of gratitude: A developmental and cultural approach.Human Development,58(4-5),281-300.
  90. Vaillant, G. E.(2008).Spirituality evolution: A scientific defense of faith.Doubleday.
  91. Vaillant, G. E.(2008).Positive emotions, spirituality and the practice of psychiatry.Mens Sana Monographs,6(1),48-62.
  92. Valdesolo, P.,Graham, J.(2014).Awe, uncertainty, and agency detection.Psychological Science,25(1),170-178.
  93. Valdesolo, P.,Park, J.,Gottlieb, S.(2016).Awe and scientific explanation.Emotion,16,937-940.
  94. Valdesolo, P.,Shtulman, A.,Baron, A. S.(2017).Science is awe-some: The emotional antecedents of science learning.Emotion Review,9(3),215-221.
  95. Van Cappellen, P.,Saroglou, V.(2012).Awe activates religious and spiritual feelings and behavioral intentions.Psychology of Religion and Spirituality,4(3),223-236.
  96. Wang, L.,Zhang, G.,Shi, P.,Lu, X.,Song, F.(2019).Influence of awe on green consumption: The mediating effect of psychological ownership.Frontiers in Psychology,10,2484.
  97. Watson, D.,Clark, L. A.,Tellegen, A.(1988).Development and validation of brief measures of positive and negative affect: The PANAS scales.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,54,1063-1070.
  98. Weinstein, N.,Przybylski, A. K.,Ryan, R. M.(2009).Can nature make us more caring? Effects of immersion in nature on intrinsic aspirations and generosity.Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin,35(10),1315-1329.
  99. Wood, A. M.,Froh, J. J.,Geraghty, A. W.(2010).Gratitude and well-being: A review and theoretical integration.Clinical Psychology Review,30(7),890-905.
  100. Wu, Q.,Zhang, Y.,He, W.,Cui, L.(2022).The relationship between adolescents' materialism and cooperative propensity: The mediating role of greed and the moderating role of awe.Personality and Individual Differences,189,111484.
  101. Yang Y.,Hu, J.,Jing, F.,Nguyen, B.(2018).From awe to ecological behavior: the mediating role of connectedness to nature.Sustainability,10(7),2477.
  102. Yang, Y.,Yang, Z.,Bao, T.,Liu, Y.,Passmore, H. A.(2016).Elicited awe decreases aggression.Journal of Pacific Rim Psychology,10,e11.
  103. Yu, M. N.,Hsiung, S. Y.,Hsu, Y. H.,Chen, P. L.(2019).Can we activate the awe-emotion through a series of picture-watching?.The Annual Conference of The New Zealand Psychological Society,Rotorua, New Zealand:
  104. Zelenski, J. M.,Desrochers, J. E.(2021).Can positive and self-transcendent emotions promote pro-environmental behavior?.Current Opinion in Psychology,42,31-35.
  105. Zhang, J. W.,Howell, R. T.,Januchowski, J. A.,Ramis, T.,Mello, Z.,Monroy, M.(2023).Awe, curiosity, and multicultural experience.Journal of Personality,91,667-682.
  106. Zhao, H.,Zhang, H.,Xu, Y.,Lu, J.,He, W.(2018).Relation between awe and environmentalism: The role of social dominance orientation.Frontiers in Psychology,9,2367.
  107. 余民寧, M.-N.(2020).量表編製與發展—Rasch 測量模型的應用.心理出版社=Psychological Publishing.
  108. 林志哲, C.-C.(2012)。「感恩量表」之中文化修訂。教育與心理研究，35(4)，103-134。
被引用次数
  1. (2024)。沉浸式虛擬實境應用：軍校生敬畏情緒對利社會行為之影響。教育科學研究期刊，69(2)，69-100。
print cancel