區塊鏈智能合約的契約法問題

Legal Issues of Blockchian-based Smart Contracts in Contract Law

林玫君(Mei-Chun Lin)

區塊鏈 ； 比特幣 ； 分散式帳本 ； 智能合約 ； 以太坊 ； 契約法 ； 契約 ； 債務 ； Blockchain ； Bitcoin ； Distributed Ledger ； Smart Contract ； Ethereum ； Contract Law ； Contract ； Debt

中正大學法學集刊

63期（2019 / 04 / 01）

127 - 183

繁體中文

近年來，區塊鏈技術的崛起引發各個產業莫大的興趣，甚至有預言區塊鏈將徹底翻轉許多產業生態。而在區塊鏈的各種應用中，又以智能合約最受到矚目。新的科技技術可能會帶來新的法律上的挑戰。有關智能合約的法律議題多樣，其涵蓋面向包括民刑法、智慧財產權法、個資保護到金融監理以及其他產業特別法規，但礙於篇幅無法逐一討論。因此本文討論範圍將聚焦於智能合約與契約法相關的一些基本的法律問題。本文主要由伍部分組成。首先簡要介紹智能合約之應用和現行契約法條款相關的法律問題。第貳部分則介紹區塊鏈（分散式帳本技術）的主要特徵及其運作原理。繼而就智能合約之定義為探討，並分析智能合約的潛在用途及其益處和侷限性。第肆部分則從契約法的角度就智能合約相關之契約法的法律問題逐一討論。最後，綜合上述提出結論和建議。由於智能合約仍處於早期發展的階段，因此現行法是否需大規模的調整或是另立專法以為因應，目前尚言之過早，但隨著智能合約的運用之普及，仍應密切關注其發展。

In recent years, the rise of blockchain technology has sparked great interest in various industries and even predicted that the blockchain will completely reverse many industrial ecosystems. In the various applications of the blockchain, smart contracts have attracted the most attention. New technology can bring new legal challenges. There are various legal issues related to smart contracts, ranging from civil law, criminal law, intellectual property law, personal information protection to financial supervision as well as other industry special regulations. Due to paragraph limitation, it is implausible to discuss these issues one by one. Therefore, the scope of this article will focus on some basic legal issues related to smart contracts and contract law. Specifically, this article primarily consists of five parts. First, a brief introduction to the application of smart contracts and the legal issues related to the current contract law provisions will be reviewed. Secondly, the main features of the blockchain (distributed ledger technology) and its operating principles will be introduced. The definition of smart contracts will be further explored and the potential uses of smart contracts and their benefits and limitations will be analyzed. Fourthly, from the perspective of contract law, the legal issues related to smart contracts will be consecutively discussed. Lastly, based on the above-mentioned reviews, conclusions and recommendations will be presented. Because the smart contract is still in the early stage of development, it is too early to say whether the current law requires a large-scale adjustment or another special law. However, with the popularization and uses of smart contracts, it is worth paying close attention to its future development.

1. 林詠章,林久弘(2018)。以太坊智能合約安全之研究。資訊安全通訊，24(3)，16-33。
   連結：
2. 郭戎晉(2016)。區塊鏈技術與智能合約應用之法律議題分析。科技法律透析，28(12)，32-42。
   連結：
3. World Economic Forum White Paper, Blockchain Beyond the Hype-A Practical Framework for Business Leaders (Apr. 2018), http://www3.weforum.org/docs/48423_Whether_Blockchain_WP.pdf (last visited Aug. 21, 2018).
4. Bana, Anurag/Viertmann, Maxine, The Not-So-Distant Future: Blockchain and the legal profession, International Bar Association (Feb. 3, 2017), https://mlaus.org/wp-content/uploads/ p-attachments/7057/Thenotsodostantfuture16457.pdf (last visited June 11, 2018).
5. Buchleitner, Christina/Rabls, Thomas: Blockchain und Smart Contracts, Fachzeitschrift fuer Wirtschaftsrecht (Jan. 2017), https://www.kwr.at/.../res/.../ecolex_2017-01__4_Thomas_Rabl.pdf (last visited June 21, 2018).
6. Clack, Christopher D., Bakshi, Vikram A. & Braine, Lee, Smart Contract Templates: foundations, design landscape and research directions, http://www.resnovae.org.uk/fccsuclacuk/images/article/sct2016.pdf (last visited Aug. 8, 2018).
7. Clifford Chance LLP, Are Smart Contracts Contracts? (Aug. 2, 2017), https://www.cliffordchance.com/briefings/2017/08/are_ smart_contractscontracts.html (last visited June 30, 2018).
8. Cohn, Alan,West, Travis,Parker, Chelsea(2017).Smart After All: Blockchain, Smart Contracts, Parametric Insurance, and Smart Energy Grids.Geo. L. Tech. Rev.,1(2)
9. Cortese, Amy, Blockchain Technology Ushers in “The Internet of Value”, CISCO (Feb. 10, 2016), https://newsroom.cisco.com/feature-content?articleId=1741667 (last visited May 12, 2018).
10. De, Nikhilesh: UK Land Registry Begins New Phase of Blockchain Research Project (Oct. 5, 2018), https://www.coindesk.com/uk-land-registry-begins-new-phase-of-blockchain-research-project (last visited Jan. 20, 2019).
11. Dogan, Orkan: Blockchain: Chancen und Risiken für Datenschutz, Smart Contracts & Co., OKAN DOGAN (Nov. 26, 2017), https://dogan.legal/2017/11/26/blockchain-chancen-risiken-datenschutz-smart-contracts/ (last visited June 24, 2018).
12. Duisberg, Alexander: Blockchain und Smart Contracts – Rechtsfragen einer digitalen Schlüsseltechnologie, http://digitaleweltmagazin.de/2017/07/18/blockchain-und-smart-contracts-rechtsfragen-einer-digitalen-schluesseltechnologie/ (last visited June 21, 2018).
13. Essebier, Jana,Wyss, Dominic A.(2017).Von der Blockchain zu Smart Contracts.Jusletter,1.
14. Fairfield, Joshua(2014).Smart Contracts, Bitcoin Bots, and Consumer Protection.Wash & Lee L. Rev. Online,71
15. Falkon, Samuel, The Story of the DAO - Its History and Consequences (Dec. 24, 2017), https://medium.com/swlh/thestory-of-the-dao-its-history-and-consequences-71e6a8a551ee (last visited Oct. 9, 2018).
16. Fries, Martin(2018).Smart Contracts: Brauchen schlaue Verträge noch Anwälte?.AnwBl,86.
17. Fulbright, Norton Rose, Can Smart Contracts be Legally Binding Contracts?, An R3 and Norton Rose Fulbright White Paper, https://sites-nortonrosefulbright.vuturevx.com/49/4087/landing-pages/can-smart-contracts-be-legally-binding-contracts-.asp (last visited Sept. 6, 2018).
18. Furrer, Andreas: Die Einbettung von Smart Contracts in das Schweizerische Privatrecht, ANWALTS REVUE DE L’AVOCAT (Mar. 2018), https://www.mme.ch/fileadmin/files/documents/MME_Compact/2018/1803_Smart_Contracts_Anw altsrevue.pdf (last visited Aug. 25, 2018).
19. Gronemann, Tobias: Smart Contracts – Vertragsgestaltung in der Zukunft auch für Kreditinstitute?, https://blog.tsp-law.com/smart-contracts-vertragsgestaltung-in-der-zukunft-auch-fuer-kreditinstitute/ (last visited July 21, 2018).
20. Hansen, J. Dax,Reyes, Carla L.(2017).,未出版
21. Heckmann, Dirk/Schmid, Alexander: Blockchain und Smart Contracts: Recht und Technik im Überblick, https://vbw-bayern.de/Redaktion/Frei-zugaengliche-Medien/Abteilungen-S/Planung-und-Koordination/2017/Downloads/2017-09-12-NH-vbw-Blockchain-und-Smart-Contracts_ChV-Fu%C3%9Fnoten.pdf (last visited Aug. 21, 2018).
22. Holden, Richard & Malani, Anup, Can Blockchain Solve the Holdup Problem in Contracts?, University of Chicago Coase-Sandor Institute for Law & Economics Research Paper No. 846, SSRN (Dec. 28, 2017), https://ssrn.com/abstract=3093879 (last visited Sept. 14, 2018).
23. Hsiao, Jerry I-H(2017)."Smart" Contract on the Blockchain-Paradigm Shift for Contract Law?.US-CHINA L. Rev.,14,685.
24. ISDA Linklaters.Smart Contracts and Distributed Ledger-A Legal Perspective.
25. Jaccard, Gabriel Olivier Benjamin, Smart Contracts and the Role of Law, 23 Jusletter IT (2017), https://ssrn.com/abstract=3099885 (last visited June 23, 2018).
26. Kaminska, Izabella, Legal Exploits and Arbitrage, DAO Edition, FIN. TIMES (June 21, 2016), https://ftalphaville.ft.com/2016/06/21/2166941/legal-exploits-and-arbitrage-daoedition/ (last visited July 24, 2018).
27. Kaulartz, Markus(2016).Rechtliche Grenzen bei der Gestaltung von Smart Contracts.Smart World – Smart Law?, DSRI Tagungsband Herbstakademie
28. Kaulartz, Markus,Heckmann, Jörn(2016).Smart Contracts-Anwendungen der Blockchain-Technologie.CR,618.
29. Lauslahti, Kristian,Mattila, Juri,Seppälä, Timo(2017).Smart Contracts—How will Blockchain Technology Affect Contractual Practices?.ETLA Reports,68
30. Lloyd, Ellen, Incredible Ancient Machines Invented by Hero of Alexandria-An Engineer Far Ahead of His Time, http://www.ancientpages.com/2014/11/12/incredible-ancient-machines-invented-hero-alexandria-engineer-far-ahead-time/ (last visited Sept. 12, 2018).
31. Lobe, Adrian: Wenn der Algorithmus Selbstjustiz übt (Apr. 8, 2018), https://www.sueddeutsche.de/digital/2.220/smart-contracts-wenn-der-algorithmus-selbstjustiz-uebt-1.3934283 (last visited Aug. 2, 2018).
32. Marnau, Ninja(2017).Die Blockchain im Spannungsfeld der Grundsätze der Datenschutzgrundverordnung.INFORMATIK 2017
33. Marr, Bernard, A Complete Beginner's Guide to Blockchain, FORBES (Jan. 24, 2017), http://www.forbes.com/sites/bernard marr/2017/01/24/a-complete-beginners-guide-toblockchain/#36e42ce666a6 [https://perma.cc/6NVB-W8YB] (last visited June 21, 2018).
34. Marvin, Rob(2017).The Invisible Technology That's Changing the World.PC MAGAZINE,Feb. 6
35. Maxwell, Winston,Salmon, John(2017).A Guide to Blockchain and Data Protection.
36. McKinney, Scott A.,Landy, Rachel,Wilka, Rachel(2018).Smart Contracts, Blockchain, and the Next Frontier of Transactional Law.Wash. J.L. Tech. & Arts,13,313.
37. Nakamoto, Satoshi, WIKIPEDIA, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Satoshi_Nakamoto (last visited May 23, 2018).
38. Nakamoto, Satoshi, Bitcoin, A Peer-to-Peer Electronic Cash System, Bitcoin Project Whitepaper (2008), https://bitcoin.org/bitcoin.pdf (last visited May 23, 2018).
39. Orcutt, Mike, Ethereum's smart contracts are full of holes (Mar. 1, 2018), https://www.technologyreview.com/s/610392/ethereums-smart-contracts-are-full-of-holes/ (last visited Aug. 8, 2018).
40. O'shields, Reggie(2017).Smart Contracts: Legal Agreements for the Blockchain.N.C. Banking Inst.,21
41. Raskin, Max(2017).The Law and Legality of Smart Contract.GEO. L. TECH. REV.,1
42. Rogers, James,Jones-Fenleigh, Harriet,Sanitt, Adam(2017).Arbitrating Smart Contract Disputes.International Arbitration Report,9
43. Rotter, Michael: Verträge ohne Notar? Smart Contracts via Blockchain – Chancen und Grenzen (May 28, 2018), https://www.computerwoche.de/a/smart-contracts-via-blockchain-chancen-und-grenzen,3331967 (last visited Sept. 28, 2018).
44. Roughton, Tim, Applying blockchain to insurance contracts (May 4, 2017), https://www.out-law.com/en/articles/2017/may/applying-blockchain-to-insurance-contracts/ (last visited July 21, 2018).
45. Savelyev, Alexander(2017).Contract Law 2.0: ‘Smart’ Contracts as the Beginning of the End of Classic Contract Law.Information & Communications Tech. L.,26(2),116.
46. Schäfer, Yvonne: Smart Contracts – Intelligente Verträge der Zukunft?, https://www.skwschwarz.de/aktuelles/artikel/artikel-detail/news/smart-contracts-intelligente-vertraege-der-zukunft/4/detail/News/ (last visited June 11, 2018).
47. Sherborne, Andreas, Blockchain, Smart Contracts and Lawyers (Dec. 2, 2017), https://www.ibanet.org/Document/Default.aspx?DocumentUid=17badeaa-072a (last visited Aug. 16, 2018).
48. Sklaroff, Jeremy M.(2017).Smart Contracts and the Cost of Inflexibility.U. Pa. L. Rev.,166
49. Stark, Josh, Making Sense of Blockchain Smart Contracts, COINDESK (June 4, 2016), http://www.coindesk.com/making-sensesmart-contracts/ (last visited Mar. 13, 2018).
50. Stark, Josh, How Close Are Smart Contracts to Impacting Real-World Law?, COINDESK (Apr. 11, 2016), http://www.coindesk.com/blockchain-smarts-contractsreal-world-law/ (last visited Mar. 13, 2018).
51. Swan, Melanie,沈佩誼（譯）(2018).區塊鏈─未來經濟的藍圖.碁峰.
52. Szabo, Nick, The Idea of Smart Contracts, http://szabo.best.vwh.net/smart.contracts.html (last visited July 10, 2018).
53. Szabo, Nick(1997).Formalizing and Securing Relationships on Public Networks.First Monday Internet Journal,2(9)
54. Trueb, Hans Ruodlf: Smart Contracts, https://www.walderwyss.com/publications/2278.pdf (last visited June 23, 2018).
55. von Haller Gronbaek, Martin, Blockchain 2.0, Smart Contracts and Challenges, BIRD & BIRD, http://www.twobirds.com/en/news/articles/2016/uk/blockchain-2-0--smart-contracts-and-challenges (last visited Aug. 9, 2018).
56. von Perfall, Axel(2016).Uebersicht ueber Internationale Erfahrungen mit Blockchain im Energiebereich, mit Fokus auf die Verbruacherperspektive, Blockchain – Chance für Energieverbraucher? – pwc Kurzstudie für die Verbraucherzentrale.NRW,15.
57. Werbach, Kevin,Cornelll, Nicholas(2017).Contracts ex Machina.Duke L.J.,37
58. 曲建仲，比特幣的核心技術，區塊鏈的原理與應用（上）：比黃金還貴的比特幣，2017年5月11日，http://finance.technews.tw/2017/05/11/block-chain-principle-and-application- bitcoin-pt1/（最後瀏覽日2018/07/11）
59. 李英正(2009)。由消保法觀點論網路交易契約相關問題。消費者保護研究
60. 唐‧泰普史考特,雅力士‧泰普史考特,陳以禮（譯）,李芳齡（譯）(2017).區塊鏈革命──比特幣如何影響貨幣、商業和世界運作.天下文化.
61. 郭戎晉,李震華,吳李祺(2017)。接軌國際──從監理與法制環境談我國區塊鏈生態體系的建構。財金資訊季刊，90，28-32。
62. 陳自強(2002).契約之成立與生效.學林.
63. 陳恭(2017)。智能合約的發展與應用。財金資訊季刊，90，33-39。
64. 湛址傑，區塊鏈讓契約變得更聰明：認識智慧契約，2018年5月21日，https://plainlaw.me/2018/05/21/%E6%99%BA% E6%85%A7%E5%A5%91%E7%B4%84/（最後瀏覽日2018/07/04）。
65. 辜騰玉，區塊鏈運作原理大剖析：從一筆交易看區塊鏈運作流程，2016年4月23日，https://www.ithome.com.tw/news/105373（最後瀏覽日2018/06/21）。
66. 劉承愚，智能合約與區塊鏈──從國際貿易供應鏈金融談起，2018年4月9日，https://zi.media/@is-law/post/GW8KDt（最後瀏覽日2018/08/10）。

1. 蔡佩芬(2022)。跨國司法互助或訴訟利用區塊鏈送達和電子送達之運作原理區別與優缺。東吳法律學報，33(4)，79-141。
2. 莊永丞(2023)。論商業組織的演化－從共識決到中央集權再到DAO？。東吳法律學報，35(1)，69-120。