論電子支付機構之差異化管制手段

An Analysis of the Regulatory Approach of Electronic Payment Institutions: Focusing on the Proportionality Supervision Theory of Simple Financial Institutions

10.53106/172876182023040079004

朱瑞翔(Jui-Hsiang Chu)

電子支付 ； 資金移轉 ； 匯兌 ； 管制手段 ； 系統性風險 ； 差異化監理 ； 資金傳遞者 ； 支付指令 ； 電子錢指令 ； 審慎監理 ； E-payment ； Money Transmission ； Exchange ； Regulatory Approach ； Systemic Risk ； Proportionality Supervision Theory ； Money Transmitter ； Payment Services Directive ； E-money Directive ； Prudential Regulation

中正大學法學集刊

79期（2023 / 04 / 01）

183 - 257

繁體中文;英文

網路的普及與使用者習慣的改變加速實現非現金支付社會的進程，我國政府同樣希望進一步發展資金移轉業務。然而，我國雖於2015年開放電子支付機構的牌照，卻未見業者踴躍申請電子支付機構牌照，且取得牌照者之營業表現亦不佳。有鑑於法律規範係建構商業環境的要角，此些經營面向的困境，應部分與電子支付機構管理條例的立法設計有所關聯。而在規範中最直接對於業者造成影響者，即為管制手段的嚴密程度。基於此，本文將基於簡易金融機構所應適用的差異化監理概念，並參酌美國法與歐盟法的設計，以適切監理風險為目標，檢討電子支付機構管理條例現行之管制手段設計。期望探尋對於電子支付機構較合適的管制手段，進而提出我國法的修正建議方向。

In recent years, the popularity of the Internet and changes in users' habits have accelerated the progress of the non-cash payment society. The government in Taiwan likewise hopes to develop the money transmission business further. However, while the E-payment licenses were open for application in 2015, the enterprises were not much interested in applying for such licenses. For those who have obtained licenses, their business performances were also poor. Given that regulation is the key to building any business's environment, the failures mentioned above should be partly related to the legislative design of the E-payment Act. Moreover, since the regulatory approach would have the most direct impact on the industry, this article will review the current regulatory approach of the E-payment Act based on the concept of the proportionality supervision theory of simple financial institutions. In addition, this article will also conduct a comparative legal analysis by referring to the regulatory design of the U.S. and EU laws. Finally, with the objective of achieving proper risk management, this article will attempt to find an optimal regulatory approach for E-payment institutions and propose amendments to the current E-payment Act.

1. 中央通訊社，街口支付瘋狂行銷燒錢太快今年兩度增資共4億元 ， 2019 年 5 月 28 日 ， https://www.cna.com.tw/news/afe/201905280273.aspx（最後瀏覽日：2022年5月8日）。Central News Agency, Street Payment’s Marketing Frenzy Is Burning Money Too Fast, Two Capital Increases Totaling $400 Million This Year, May 28, 2019, https://www.cna.com.tw/news/afe/201905280273.aspx (last visited May 8, 2022).
2. Georgia Money Transmitter License, Description, https://mortgage.nationwidelicensingsystem.org/slr/PublishedStateDocuments/GA-Money-Transmitter-Company-Description.pdf (Nov. 7, 2016, last visited May 8, 2022).
3. 自由時報，金管會︰非現金支付明年底拚交易78億筆，2022年4月10日，https://ec.ltn.com.tw/article/paper/1510829（最後瀏覽日：2022年5月8日）。Liberty Times, FSC: Non-cash Payments: 7.8 Billion Transactions by End of Next Year, April 10, 2022, https://ec.ltn.com.tw/article/paper/1510829 (last visited May 8, 2022).
4. 公司登記（依營業項目別）──第三方支付服務業，https://data.gov.tw/dataset/22184（最後瀏覽日：2022年5月8日）。Company Registration (by Business Category) - Third Party Payment Service Industry, https://data.gov.tw/dataset/22184 (last visited May 8, 2022).
5. 鉅亨網，電子支付燒錢街口、橘子支付大股東今年接連掏錢辦現增， 2019 年 5 月 28 日 ， https://news.cnyes.com/news/id/4327557（最後瀏覽日：2022年5月8日）。Chichen.com, E-Payment Burns Money STreet, Orange Payment Big Shareholders Shell Out Money to Do Cash Increase This Year, May 28, 2019, https://news.cnyes.com/news/id/4327557 (last visited May 8, 2022).
6. 電子支付機構支付款項信託契約範本，http://www.rootlaw.com.tw/LawArticle.aspx?LawID=A040390041064800-1040805 （最後瀏覽日：2022年5月8日）。 Template of Trust Contract for Payment Fund Collected by Electronic Payment Institutions, http://www.rootlaw.com.tw/LawArticle.aspx?LawID=A040390041064800-1040805 (last visited May 8, 2022).
7. 中時新聞網，外籍移工匯兌納洗錢管制統振之後東聯也搶進，2021年12月3日，https://www.chinatimes.com/realtimenews/20211203004881-260410?chdtv（最後瀏覽日：2022年5月8日）。China Times News Network, Foreign Migrant Workers’ Remittance and Money Laundering Controls, December 3, 2021, https://www.china times.com/realtimenews/20211203004881-260410?chdtv (last visited May 8, 2022).
8. Emerging Payments Task Force Conference of State Bank Supervisors, http://financialinnovationnow.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/04/fin-csbs-comment-letter-final.pdf (Apr. 12, 2019, last visited May 8, 2022).
9. Acharya, Viral(2009).A Theory of Systemic Risk and Design of Prudential Bank Regulation.J. of Fin. Stability,5,224.
10. ACPR, Payment institution and account information service provider, https://acpr.banque-france.fr/en/authorisation/banking-industry-procedures/licensing-authorisation-and-registration/payment-institution-and-account- information-service-provider (Oct. 21, 2021, last visited May 8, 2022).
11. Akindemowo, Olujoke E.(2000).Electronic Money Regulation: A Comparative Survey of Policy Influences in Australia, the European Union and the United States of America.J.L. & Inf. Sci.,11,61.
12. Anderson, Thomas(2019).New Actors, New Money, New Methods, Same Business: Salvaging Money Transmitter Regulation in Idaho for the 21st Century and Beyond.Idaho L. Rev.,55,339.
13. Awrey, Dan,Zwieten, van Kristin(2018).The Shadow Payment System.J. Corp. L.,43,775.
14. BIS(2011).Basel III: A Global Regulatory Framework for More Resilient Banks and Banking Systems.
15. BIS, Proportionality in Banking Regulation, https://www.bis.org/speeches/sp180704b.htm (Jul. 4, 2018, last visited May 8, 2022).
16. Brown, Thomas, 50-State Survey: Money Transmitting Licensing Requirements, https://abnk.assembly.ca.gov/sites/abnk.assembly.ca.gov/files/50%20State%20Survey%20-%20MTL%20Licensing%20Requirements(72986803_4).pdf (Mar. 11, 2013, last visited May 8, 2022).
17. Bundesbank, Übersicht über die Berechnungsmethoden der Zahlungsinstituts-Eigenmittelverordnung (ZIEV), https://www.bundesbank.de/resource/blob/598384/dfa1e2fd939bd4da360976e1e9aa7687/mL/berechnungsbeispiele-eigenmittelanfoderungen-data.pdf (Oct. 15, 2009, last visited May 8, 2022).
18. Carey, Mark(2001).Dimensions of Credit Risk and Their Relationship to Economic Capital Requirements.Prudential Supervision What Works and What Doesn’t
19. Dewatripont, Mathias,Tirole, Jean(1994).The Prudential Regulation of Banks.MIT Press.
20. ECB(2014).Financial Stability Review.ECB Research & Publication.
21. European Commission(2018).European Commission, Report from the Commission to the European Parliament and the Council on the Implementation and Impact of Directive 2009/110/Ec in Particular on the Application of Prudential Requirements for Electronic Money Institutions (2018)..
22. European Commission(2007).European Commission, Payment Services Directive: Frequently Asked Questions (See also IP/07/550) (2007)..
23. FCA, Payment Services and Electronic Money - Our Approach (2017), https://www.fca.org.uk/publication/finalised-guidance/fca-approach-payment-services-electronic-money-sept-2017.pdf (Nov. 19, 2021, last visited May 8, 2022).
24. Gimigliano, Gabriella(2016).Mobilizing Payments Within the European Union Framework: A Legal Analysis.Bitcoin and Mobile Payments
25. Gimigliano, Gabriella(2016).Money, Payment Systems and the European Union.Cambridge Scholars Publishing.
26. Goodjriend, Marvin,Hargraves, Monica(1983).FRB Richmond Working PaperFRB Richmond Working Paper,未出版
27. Hamburger, Jacob(2015).Bitcoins vs. State Money Transmission Laws: Protecting Consumers or Hindering Innovation.J.L. Econ. & Pol’y,11,229.
28. Hurst, James Willard(1973).A Legal History of Money in the United States 1774-1970.Beard Books.
29. Janczuk, Agnieszka(2010).The Single Payments Area in Europe.Colum. J. Eur. L.,16,326.
30. Joosen, Bart,Lamandini, Marco,Lehmann, Matthias,Lieverse, Kitty,Tirado, Ignacio(2018).EBI Working Paper SeriesEBI Working Paper Series,未出版
31. Lo, Benjamin(2017).Fatal Fragments: The Effect of Money Transmission Regulation on Payments Innovation.Yale J.L. & Tech.,18,111.
32. Lowry, Carolyn(2016).What’s in Your Mobile Wallet? An Analysis of Trends in Mobile Payments and Regulation.Fed. Comm. L.J.,68,353.
33. Malaguti, Maria Chiara(2009).The Payment Services Directive: Pitfalls Between the Acquis Communautaire and National Implementation.
34. Mann, Ronald J.(1999).Payment Systems and Other Financial Transactions.Aspen Publishing.
35. Mishkin, Frederic S.(2001).Prudential Supervision Why Is It Important and What Are the Issues?.Prudential Supervision What Works and What Doesn’t
36. Moore, Roksana,Halpin, Ruth(2009).Developments in Electronic Money Regulation - The Electronic Money Directive: A Better Deal for E-Money Issuers?.Computer L. & Sec. Rev.,25(6),563.
37. National Conference of Commissioners on Uniform State Laws(2005).National Conference of Commissioners on Uniform State Laws, Uniform Money Services Act with Prefatory Note and Comments (2005)..
38. Nationwide Multistate Licensing System & Registry, Multistate MSB Licensing Agreement Program, https://mortgage.nationwidelicensingsystem.org/slr/Pages/Multistate-MSB-Licensing-Agreement-Program.aspx (Jun. 24, 2019, last visited Jul. 10, 2022).
39. Robinson, M. MacRae(2014).Easing the Burden on Mobile Payments: Resolving Current Deficiencies in Money Transmitter Regulation.N.C. Banking Inst.,18,553.
40. Rochet, Jean-Charles,Tirole, Jean(2008).Controlling Risk in Payment Systems.Why Are There So Many Banking Crises?
41. Scott, Hal S.(2016).Connectedness and Contagion: Protecting the Financial System from Panics.MIT Press.
42. Smaga, Paweł(2014).The Concept of Systemic Risk.Systemic Risk Centre Special Paper,5
43. Tu, Kevin V.(2018).Regulating the New Cashless World.Ala. L. Rev.,65,77.
44. Uniform Law Commission, Money Services Act, https://www.uniformlaws.org/committees/community-home?CommunityKey=cf8b649a-114c-4bc9-8937-c4ee17148a1b (Dec. 5, 2018, last visited May 8, 2022).
45. Wandhöfefer, Ruth(2010).EU Payment Integration.Waterstone.
46. 一卡通，110年財務報告及營業報告書，https://www.i-pass.com.tw/News/Detail/103052（最後瀏覽日：2022年5月8日）。OneCard, 2021 Annual Financial Report and Business Report, https://www.i-pass.com.tw/News/Detail/103052 (last visited May 8, 2022).
47. 中央銀行，準備金制度，https://www.cbc.gov.tw/tw/cp-1003-39757-7661B-1.html（最後瀏覽日：2022年5月8日）。Central Bank, Reserve System, https://www.cbc.gov.tw/tw/cp-1003-39757-7661B-1.html (last visited May 8, 2022).
48. 王文宇, Wen-Yeu,林育廷, Yu-Ting(2008).票據與支付工具.元照=Angle Publishing.
49. 王志誠, Chih-Cheng(2014).銀行法.新學林=New Sharing.
50. 李開遠, Kai-Yuan(2019).台灣金融票據支付與電子支付法律基礎：票據法與電子支付機構管理條例合論.五南=Wu-Nan.
51. 李榮謙, Rong-Cian,方耀, Yao(2001)。電子支付系統與電子貨幣：發展、影響及適當的管理架構。中央銀行季刊，23(3)，7-50。
52. 林育廷, Yu-Ting(2022)。2021電子支付機構管理條例之修正（一）。當代法律，2，127-131。
53. 林育廷, Yu-Ting(2022)。2021電子支付機構管理條例之修正（二）。當代法律，4，131-138。
54. 林育廷, Yu-Ting(2022)。從蝦皮事件初評2021電子支付機構管理條例之修正。月旦法學雜誌，321，183-202。
55. 林育廷, Yu-Ting(2002)。電子資金移轉交易相關立法例介紹與淺析。經社法制論叢，29，299-366。
56. 林育廷, Yu-Ting(2015)。台灣第三方支付中介之管理與規範。全國律師，19(2)，48-55。
57. 林育廷, Yu-Ting(2001)。電子支付相關法律問題之初探──以消費性電子資金移轉為例。律師雜誌，256，47-61。
58. 金管會，預告修正「電支條例」之新聞稿，2019年7月30日，https://www.fsc.gov.tw/ch/home.jsp?id=96&parentpath=0,2&mcustomize=news_view.jsp&dataserno=201907300004&toolsflag=Y&dtable=News（最後瀏覽日：2022年7月10日）。Financial Service Commission, Press Release on Notice of Amendments to the Electricity Support Ordinance, July 30, 2019, https://www.fsc.gov.tw/ch/home.jsp?id=96&parentpath=0,2&mcustomize=news_view.jsp& dataserno=201907300004&toolsflag=Y&dtable=News (last visited Jul. 10, 2022).
59. 金管會，金融機構基本資料查詢，https://www.banking.gov.tw/ch/home.jsp?id=60&parentpath=0,4&mcustomize=FscSearch_BankType.jsp&type=H1&display=false（最後瀏覽日：2022年5月8日）。 Financial Service Commission, Financial Institutions Basic Information Inquiry, https://www.banking.gov.tw/ch/home.jsp?id=60&parentpath=0,4&mcustomize=FscSearch_BankType.jsp&type=H1&display=false (last visited May 8, 2022).
60. 金管會，111年2月份信用卡、現金卡及電子支付機構業務資訊，https://www.fsc.gov.tw/ch/home.jsp?id=96&parentpath=0,2&mcustomize=news_view.jsp&dataserno=202204140003&dtable=News （最後瀏覽日：2022年5月8日）。 Financial Service Commission, Operation Information of Credit Card, Debit Card, and Electronic Payment Institution in February 2022, https://www.fsc.gov.tw/ch/home.jsp?id=96&parentpath=0,2&mcustomize=news_view.jsp&dataserno=202204140003&dtable=News (last visited May 8, 2022).
61. 陳志武, Jhih-Wu(2019).耶魯最受歡迎的金融通識課.今周刊=Business Today.
62. 街口電子支付有限公司，110年度財務報表，https://www.jkopay.com/pdf/110年度財務報表.pdf（最後瀏覽日：2022年5月8日）。Street Electronic Payment Co., 2021 Annual Financial Statements, https://www.jkopay.com/pdf/110年度財務報表.pdf (last visited May 8, 2022).
63. 楊岳平, Yue-Ping(2022)。預存款項業務與我國匯兌儲值法制的金融監理疆域──評臺灣高等法院106年度金上重訴字第24號刑事判決數字科技案與新電子支付機構管理條例。月旦法學雜誌，324，162-180。
64. 楊岳平, Yue-Ping(2019)。問違法收受存款罪的目的性限縮──評最高法院106年度台上字第3713號判決。裁判時報，90，46-53。
65. 廖崇宏, Chong-Hong(2020)。論電子支付的基礎法律關係──以PChome線上支付與PayPal支付服務為例。興大法學，27，157-254。
66. 廖崇宏, Chong-Hong(2021)。論支付服務程序瑕疵對金錢之債償效力的影響。中原財經法學，47，113-172。
67. 劉建良, Jian-Liang(2017)。電子支付法律關係之研究。司法新聲，122，48-64。