Examining Trade-Offs in Hospital Operations Using a Systems Approach in an Acute Care Setting

10.6702/ijbi.2016.11.2.6

Huay Ling Tay

Trade-offs ； systems approach ； resource thresholds ； hospital operations

International Journal of Business and Information

11卷2期（2016 / 06 / 01）

264 - 283

英文

Hospitals are often faced with operational challenges that require them to make compromises and tough decisions among multiple competing needs. This is particularly true in acute care hospitals, where practitioners often operate under resource-constrained conditions and are required to fulfill multiple work requirements. To manage such trade-offs, it is important to understand both the operating system as a whole and the contextual factors that drive the behavior of discrete units within the system. This paper examines the nature of trade-offs scenarios and how they play out in complex hospital operations. An in-depth case study approach is used to examine the trade-off phenomenon in a focused-care service delivery context in an acute care hospital in Singapore; namely, a specialized clinical function designed to serve the needs of acute care elderly patients. Data for the case study was collected from hospital interviews, surveys, site observations, and document analysis over a three-month period in 2012. The study uses a system conceptualization involving causal loop diagrams in order to achieve a deeper understanding of the trade-off phenomenon identified from the case study. This study found that the act of balancing trade-offs is context-dependent and dynamic and that it evolves over time. Overall, this study provides a finer-grained view of the trade-offs phenomenon in hospital operations and reveals novel insights on the management of resource thresholds in acute care settings.

1. Zimmerman, B.; C. Lindberg; and P. Plsek. 2009. A Complexity Science Primer: What is Complexity Science and Why Should I Learn about It?.
2. Aiken, L.H.(2012).Patient safety, satisfaction, and quality of hospital care: Crosssectional surveys of nurses and patients in 12 countries in Europe and the United States.British Medical Journal,344,1717.
3. Amoako-Gyampah, K.,Meredith, J.R.(2007).Examining cumulative capabilities in a developing economy.International Journal of Operations & Production Management,27,928-950.
4. Anderson, J.C.,Cleveland, G.,Schroede, R.G.(1989).Operations strategy: A literature review.Journal of Operations Management,8,133-158.
5. Anderson, R.A.(2003).Nursing homes as complex adaptive systems: Relationship between management practice and resident outcomes.Nursing Research,52,12.
6. Anderson, R.A.,Crabtree, B.F.,Steele, D.J.,McDaniel, R.R., Jr(2005).Case study research: The view from complexity science.Qualitative Health Research,15,669-685.
7. Avella, L.,Vazquez-Bustelo, D.,Fernandez, E.(2011).Cumulative manufacturing capabilities: An extended model and new empirical evidence.International Journal of Production Research,49,707-729.
8. Barro, J.R.,Huckman, R.S.,Kessle, D.P.(2006).The effects of cardiac specialty hospitals on the cost and quality of medical care.Journal of Health Economics,25,702-721.
9. Butler, T.W.,Leong, G.K.(2000).The impact of operations competitive priorities on hospital performance.Health Care Management Science,3,227-235.
10. Butler, T.W.,Leong, G.K.,Everett, L.N.(1966).The operations management role in hospital strategic planning.Journal of Operations Management,14,137-156.
11. Campbell, G.M.(2012).On-call overtime for service workforce scheduling when demand is uncertain.Decision Sciences,43,817-850.
12. Chandrasekaran, A.,Senot, C.,Boyer, K.K.(2012).Process minagement impact on clinical and experiential quality: Managing tensions between safe and patientcentered healthcare.Manufacturing & Service Operations Management
13. Da Silveira, G.,Slack, N.(2001).Exploring the trade-off concept.International Journal of Operations and Production Management,21,949-964.
14. Eisenhardt, K.M.(1989).Building theories from case study research.The Academy of Management Review,14,532-550.
15. Forrester, J.W.(1961).Industrial Dynamics.Portland, Oregon:Productivity Press.
16. Ginsburg, P.(2000).Are focused factories the wave of the future?.Frontiers of Health Services Management,16,41-46.
17. Gioia, D.A.,Corley, K.G.,Hamilton, A.L.(2012).Seeking qualitative rigor in inductive research: Notes on the Gioia methodology.Organizational Research Methods
18. Glaser, B.G.,Strauss, A.L.(1967).The discovery of grounded theory: Strategies for qualitative research.Aldine de Gruyter.
19. Goldstein, S.M.,Iossifova, A.R.(2012).Ten years after: Interference of hospital slack in process performance benefits of quality practices.Journal of Operations Management,30,44-54.
20. Hollnagel, E.(2009).The ETTO principle: Efficiency-thoroughness trade-off: Why things that go right sometimes go wrong.Burlington, VT:Ashgate.
21. Huckman, R.S.,Pisano, G.P.(2006).The firm specificity of individual performance: Evidence from cardiac surgery.Management Science,52,473-488.
22. Huckman, R.S.,Zinner, D.E.(2007).Does focus improve operational performance? Lessons from the management of clinical trials.Strategic Management Journal,29,179-193.
23. Kontogiannis, T.(2011).A systems perspective of managing error recovery and tactical re-planning of operating teams in safety critical domains.Journal of Safety Research,42,73-85.
24. Leveson, N.G(2011).Applying systems thinking to analyze and learn from events.Safety Science,49,55-64.
25. McDaniel, R.R.(2001).Complexity science and health care management.Advances in Health Care Management,2,37.
26. Meredith, G.,Cansdell, D.,Willis, J.,MacLellan, D.,Cregan, P.,Deane, S.(2011).Emergency surgery: Measure, change and benefit.Australian Journal of Advanced Nursing,28,68-74.
27. Miles, M.B.,Huberman, A.M.(1984).Qualitative Data Analysis: A Surcebook of New Methods.California:Sage Publications.
28. Miller, A.,Xiao, Y.(2007).Multi-level strategies to achieve resilience for an organisation operating at capacity: A case study at a trauma centre.Cognition, Technology, and Work,9,51-66.
29. Morrison, B.(2015).The problem with workarounds is that they work: The persistence of resource shortages.Journal of Operations Management,39-40,79-91.
30. Nair, A.,Narasimhan, R.,Choi, T.Y.(2009).Supply networks as a complex adaptive system: Toward simulation-based theory building on evolutionary decision making.Decision Sciences,40,783-815.
31. Pagell, M.,Melnyk, S.,Handfield, R.(2000).Do trade-offs exist in operations strategy? Insights from the stamping die industry.Business Horizons,43,69-77.
32. Paivo, E.L.,Roth, A.,Fensterseifer, J.E.(2008).Organizational knowledge and the manufacturing strategy process: A resource-based new analysis.Journal of Operations Management,26(1),115-132.
33. Parvan, K.,Rahmandad, H.,Haghani, A.(2015).Inter-phase feedbacks in construction projects.Journal of Operations Management,39-40,48-62.
34. Perlow, L.A.,Okhuysen, G.A.,Nelson, P.R.(2002).The speed trap: Exploring the relationship between decision making and temporal context.The Academy of Management Journal,45,931-955.
35. Plsek, P.E.(2001).The challenge of complexity in health care.British Medical Journal,323,625.
36. Rosenzweig, E.D.,Easton, G.S.(2010).Tradeoffs in manufacturing? A metaanalysis and critique of the literature.Production and Operations Management,19,127-141.
37. Roth, A.V.,Dierdonck, R.(1995).Hospital resource planning: Concepts, feasibility, and framework.Production and Operations Management,4,2.
38. Sarmiento, R.,Sarkis, J.,Byrne, M.(2010).Manufacturing capabilities and performance: A critical analysis and review.International Journal of Production Research,48,1267-1286.
39. Schmenner, R.W.,Swink, M.L.(1998).On theory in operations management.Journal of Operations Management,17,97-113.
40. Silvester, K.,Lendon, R.,Bevan, H.,Steyn, R.,Walley, P.(2004).Reducing waiting times in the NHS: Is lack of capacity the problem?.Clinician in Management,12,105-109.
41. Skinner, W.(1969).Manufacturing: The missing unknown in corporate strategy.Harvard Business Review,47(3),136-145.
42. Sterman, J.D.(2000).Business Dynamics: Systems Thinking and Modeling for a Complex World.Chicago:Irwin-McGraw Hill.
43. Sterman, J.D.(1994).Learning in and about complex systems.System Dynamics Review,10,291-332.
44. Strauss, A.,Corbin, J.(1990).Basics of Qualitative Research.Newbury Park, CA:Sage Publications.
45. Teow, K.L.,El-Darzi, E.,Foo, C.,Jin, X.,Sim, J.(2012).Intelligent analysis of acute bed overflow in a tertiary hospital in singapore.Journal of Medical Systems,1-10.
46. Vastag, G.(2000).The theory of performance frontiers.Journal of Operations Management,18,353-360.
47. Vokurka, R.J.,Zank, G.M.,Lund, C.M., III(2002).Improving competitiveness through supply chain management: A cumulative improvement approach.Competitiveness Review: An International Business Journal,12,14-25.
48. Watson, S.K.,Rudge, J.W.,Coker, R.(2013).Health Systems' "Surge Capacity": State of the Art and Priorities for Future Research.Milbank Quarterly,91,78-122.
49. Yin, R.K(2003).Case Study Research: Design and Methods.California:Sage Publications, Inc.
50. Zhou, H.,Li, C.,Yan, Y.(2014).The emergency department in China: Status and challenges.Emergency Medicine Journal,31,85-86.
51. Zimmerman, B.,Lindberg, C.,Plsek, P.(2001).Edgeware: Insights from Complexity Science for Health Care Leaders.VHA.