Boshan Tone Sandhi

博山方言的連讀變調現象

10.6519/TJL.2004.2(2).4

林蕙珊(Hui-Shan Lin)

Taiwan Journal of Linguistics

2卷2期（2004 / 12 / 01）

75 - 125

英文

本篇論文的主旨在於討論漢語方言中，博山方言的連讀變調現象。深究的重點是博山方言連讀變調現象中難以預測的變調方向性及變調方向性背後之意義。本篇論文所採用的理論模式是優選理論。本文認為，博山變調的方向性基本上是由左而右。因為這個方向性可以使得輸出聲調和其參考的聲調(base)比較相同。當這個方向性會衍生出高度有標(highly marked)的形式時，連讀變調規則就會轉而由右而左運作。變調的方向性可以由音韻制約(markedness constraint)和輸出－輸出信實制約(OO-faithfulness constraint)之間的排列順序而得到預測。變調方向性背後的動機最主要是為了促成輸出聲調和其參考聲調之間的對應性。為了達成這個對應關係，變調規則必須由左而右運作。不過，這個對應性的達成並非全然無條件的。當連讀變調現象中更高的準則會因對應性的達成而受到違反時，變調的規則就會由相反的方向運行。

This paper investigates the tone sandhi phenomenon in Boshan, which is remarkable for its seemly unpredictable rule application directionalities observed in tri-tonal strings. Based on the constraint-based theory of OT, this paper shows that the rule application directionalities in Boshan are by no means ungoverned. Normally tone sandhi applies from left to right for identity reasons, unless highly marked forms would be generated. In that case, tone sandhi applies reversely from right to left. Thus, the rule application directionalities are naturally predicted by the interaction of the identity and markedness constraints. The investigation of the issue of directionality in Boshan also supports the view that identity preservation between prosodically related outputs is important in tone sandhi. The output-to-output correspondence relation may force a tonal output to deviate from the canonical surface patterns of the language, so that it becomes more like a tonal base to which it prosodically relates. Identity preservation is highly respected in tone sandhi, unless this would produce forms that are highly marked.

1. Bao, Zhiming.(1999).Tonal contour and register harmony in Chaozhou.Linguistic Inquiry,30,485-492.
2. Bao, Zhiming.(2003).Tone, accent, and stress in Chinese.Journal of Linguistics,39,147-166.
3. Beckman, Jill N.(1998).University of Massachusetts Amherst.
4. Benua Laura.(1997).Amherst,University of Massachusetts.
5. Benua Laura.,J. Beckman,L. Walsh-Dickey,S. Urbanczyk (eds.)(1995).University of Massachusetts Occasional Papers in Linguistics: Papers in Optimality Theory.Amherst:GLSA.
6. Buckley, Eugene.(1995).Constraint domains in Kashaya.The Proceedings of the Fourteenth West Coast Conference on Formal Linguistics,Stanford:
7. Chen, Matthew Y.(1987).The syntax of Xiamen tone sandhi.Phonology Yearbook,4,109-115.
8. Chen, Matthew Y.(1987).A symposium on Tianjin tone sandhi: introductory remarks.Journal of Chinese Linguistics,15,203-227.
9. Chen, Matthew Y.(2000).Tone Sandhi: Patterns Across Chinese Dialects.Oxford University Press.
10. Chen, Matthew Y.(2002).Changting Hakka tone sandhi: analytical challenges.Paper for the 8th International Symposium on Chinese Languages and Linguistics
11. Chen, Matthew Y.,Ben Hermans,Marc van Oostendorp (eds.)(1999).The Derivational Residue in Phonological Optimality Theory.John Benjamins Publishing Company.
12. Duanmu, San.(1994).Against contour tone units.Linguistic Inquiry,25(4),555-608.
13. Duanmu, San.(1990).A Formal Study of Syllable, Tone, Stress and Domain in Chinese anguages.Cambridge:MIT dissertation.
14. Gerken, LouAnn.(1996).Prosodic structure in young children's language production.Language,72(4),683-711.
15. Hayes, Bruce.,Inkelas,Zec (eds.)(1990).The Phonology Syntax Connection.
16. Heli Harrikari.(1999).The gradient OCP-tonal evidence from Swedish.ROA-355.
17. Horwood, Graham.(2000).Anti-Identity and Taiwanese Tone Sandhi.Rutgers Univ.
18. Hsiao, E. Yuchau.(1995).Southern Min Tone Sandhi and Theories of Prosodic Phonology.
19. Hsiao, E. Yuchau.(1991).Syntax, Rhythm and Tone: A Triangular Relationship.Taipei:Crane Publishing Co.
20. Hung, Tony T. N.(1987).Tianjin tone sandhi: towards a unified approach.Journal of Chinese Linguistics,15,274-305.
21. Hyman, Larry.,K. Snider,H. van der Hulst (eds.)(1993).The Phonology of Tone: The Representation of Tonal Register.Mouton de Gruyter:Berlin.
22. Li, X. J.,S. X. Liu.(1985).Tone sandhi in the Tianjin dialect.Chinese Language,1,76-80.
23. Lin, Hui-shan.(2000).National Chengchi University.
24. UST Working Papers In Linguistics
25. Lin, Hui-shan.(2003).Identity and Tianjin tone sandhi.Paper presented at the 36th ICSTLL Conference,Australia:
26. Lin, Hui-shan.(2000).Layered OCP, unparsed preposition, and local constraint conjunction in Mandarin tone sandhi.Proceeding of the33rd ICSTLL Conference
27. Lin, Hui-shan.(2004).Conflicting directionalities in Tianjin tone sandhi.
28. Lin, Hui-shan.(2002).Tianjin tone sandhi.Proceedings of the 8th International Symposium on Chinese Languages and Linguistics
29. Lombardi, Linda.,Linda Lombardi (ed.)(2001).Segmental Phonology in Optimality Theory: Constraints and Representations.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
30. Extensions of faithfulness: Rotuman revisited
31. McCarthy, John.(1997).Process specific constraints in Optimality Theory.Linguistic Inquiry,28,231-251.
32. McCarthy, John.(1999).Sympathy and phonological opacity.Phonology,16,331-399.
33. McCarthy, John.,Goldsmith (ed.)(1995).The Handbook of Phonological Theory.Oxford:Blackwell.
34. McCarthy, John,Alan Prince.(1993).Prosodic morphology I: constraint interaction and satisfaction.New Brunswick, NJ:Rutgers University Center for Cognitive Science.
35. McCarthy, John,Alan Prince.(1994).Proceedings of the 24th North East Linguistic Society.Amherst:GLSA.
36. McCarthy, John,Alan Prince.,G. Booij,J. Van Marle (eds.)(1993).Year Book of Morphology.Dordrecht:Kluwer.
37. McCarthy, John,Alan Prince.,Jill Beckman,Laura Walsh Dickey,Suzanne Urbanczyk (eds.)(1995).Faithfulness and reduplicative identity.University of Massachusetts Occasional Papers in Linguistics 18: Papers in Optimality Theory,249-384.
38. McCarthy, John,Alan Prince.,Kager, Hulst,Zonneveld (eds)(1999).The Prosody-morphology.
39. Nespor, M.,I. Vogel.(1986).Prosodic Phonology.Dordrecht:Foris.
40. Price, Alan,Paul Smolensky.(1993).Optimality Theory: Constraint Interaction in Generative Grammar.Boulder:Rutgers University and University of Colorado.
41. Qian, Zengyi.(1993).Studies in the Boshan Dialects.Beijing:Shehuikexue Wenxian Chubanshe.
42. Selkirk, Elizabeth.(1986).On Derived Domains in Sentence Phonology.Phonology Year Book,3,371-405.
43. Selkirk, Elizabeth.(1984).(Dis)juncture in sentence phonology as a temporal phenomenon.Paper for the 5th Phonologie-tagung.
44. Selkirk, Elizabeth.(1984).Phonology and Syntax: The Relation Between Sound and Structure.The MIT Press.
45. Selkirk, Elizabeth.(1995).University of Massachusetts Occasional Paper 18: Papers in Optimality Theory.Amherst:University of Massachusetts.
46. Shattuck-Hufnagel, Stefanie,Alice E. Turk.(1996).A prosody tutorial for investigators of auditory sentence processing.Journal of Psycholinguistic Research,25,193-247.
47. Shi, Feng.(1990).Studies in Tone and Stops.Beijing University Press.
48. Shi, Feng.(1990).Studies in Tone and Stops.Beijing University Press.
49. Shih, Chi-lin.(1986).UCSD.
50. Snider, Keith L.(1999).The Geometry and Features of Tone.Summer Institute of Linguistics and the University of Texas at Arlington Publications in Linguistics
51. Snider, Keith L.(1990).Tonal upstep in Krachi: evidence for a register tier.Language,66,453-474.
52. Speer, Shari R.,Chi-lin Shih,Maria L. Slowiaczek.(1989).Prosodic structure in language understanding: evidence from tone sandhi in Mandarin.Language and Speech,32(4),337-354.
53. Tan, Fu.(1987).Tone sandhi in the Tianjin dialect.Journal of Chinese Linguistics,15,228-246.
54. Truckenbrodt, Hubert.(1999).On the relation between syntactic phrases and phonological phrases.Linguistic Inquiry,30(2),219-255.
55. Truckenbrodt, Hubert.(1994).The OCP, underspecification, and articulatory faithfulness.MIT Working Papers in Linguistics,21,355-371.
56. Tsay, Jane.,Jean Ann,Kyoko Yoshimura (eds.)(1991).Tone sandhi in Taiwanese.Arizona Phonology Conference
57. Tsay, Jane,James Myers.(1996).Taiwanese tone sandhi as allomorph selection.Berkeley Linguistics Society,22,394-405.
58. Yip, Moira.(1980).Massachusetts Institute of Technology.
59. Yip, Moira.(2002).Tone.Cambridge University Press.
60. Yip, Moira.(1989).Contour Tones.Phonology,6,149-174.
61. Yip, Moira.(2002).Phonological markedness and allomorph selection in Zahao.Paper for the 8th International Symposium on Chinese Languages and Linguistics
62. Yip, Moira.,Goldsmith, John (ed.)(1995).The Handbook of Phonological Theory.Cambridge, Mass and Oxford, UK:Blackwell.
63. Zhang, Zheng Sheng.(1987).The paradox of Tianjin: another look.Journal of Chinese Linguistics,15,247-273.
64. Zoll, Cheryl.(1996).Berkeley,University of California.
65. Zoll, Cheryl.(1998).Positional asymmetries and licensing.Ms. of paper presented at the annual meeting of the LSA,New York:

1. Lin, Hui-Shan(2005).IDENTITY PRESERVATION IN HAKHA-LAI TONE SANDHI.臺灣語言學期刊,3(2),1-43.
2. Lin, Hui-Shan(2006).Directionality in Chengdu Tone Sandhi.同心圓：語言學研究,32(1),31-67.
3. Lin, Hui-shan(2011).SPECIAL TONAL ALTERNATIONS IN DONGSHI HAKKA REDUPLICATION.臺灣語言學期刊,9(2),1-65.
4. Lin, Hui-shan(2012).CONSTRUCTION SENSITIVITY IN PINGYAO TONE SANDHI.臺灣語言學期刊,10(1),143-210.
5. 林蕙珊(2011)。長沙連讀變調之謎。華語文教學研究，8(2)，27-64。
6. 林蕙珊(2012)。天津話連讀變調與構詞句法關聯性。漢學研究，30(1)，271-307。