Subject Specificity, Predicate Distributivity, and Scope Interpretation

10.6519/TJL.2005.3(1).5

Barry Chung-Yu Yang

Taiwan Journal of Linguistics

3卷1期（2005 / 06 / 01）

133 - 173

英文

This paper proposes a syntactic account for the licensing conditions and interpretations of indefinite subjects in Mandarin Chinese. Three dimensions are explored: subject specificity, predicate distributivity, and scope interpretation. We suggest that the indefinite subject be best treated as a variable, which has to be bound by certain operator, to account for its various readings. The property of its corresponding operator in turn determines the specificity of the indefinite subject: The specific/presuppositional reading is licensed by the existential predicate you 'have/exist' serving as an existential quantifier YOU, while the nonspecific/cardinal reading is licensed by either the implicit existential closure (Diesing 1992) at Mod' (Tsai 2001) or you serving as the overt realization of the existential closure. Furthermore, the predicate distributivity plays a nontrivial role in licensing indefinite subjects. I propose a hierarchical account to clarify the two confusing notions, i.e. specificity and distributivity, on the interpretation of indefinite subjects. The distributive reading of indefinite subjects is licensed at a higher position than the collective reading. Finally, the wide-scope indefinite phenomenon is attributed to the scope-independent reading (Liu 1997) which in turn is licensed by specificity and distributivity. In a word, each of the three dimensions mentioned above contributes to the interpretation of the indefinite subject in Mandarin Chinese.

1. Abush, Dorit.(1994).The scope of indefinite.Natural Language Semantics,2,83-135.
2. Aoun, Joseph,Yen-hui Audrey Li.(1993).The Syntax of Scope.Cambridge:MlT Press.
3. Barwise, Jon.(1979).On branching quantifiers in English.Journal of Philosophical Logic,8,48-80.
4. Beghelli, Filippo,Tim Stowell,A. Szabolcsi (ed.)(1997).Ways of Scope Taking.Dordrecht:Kluwer.
5. Chomsky, Noam.,Kenneth Hale,Samuel Jay Keyser (ed.)(1993).The View from Building 20: Essays in Linguistics in Honor of Sylvain Bromberger.Cambridge:MIT Press.
6. Diesing, Molly.(1992).Indefinites.Cambridge:MIT Press.
7. Dowty, David.,F. Marshall (ed.)(1986).Collective predicates, distributive predicates, and all.Proceedings of the 1986 Eastern State Conference on Linguistics
8. Evans, Gareth.(1980).Pronouns.Linguistic Inquiry,11,337-362.
9. Evans, Gareth.(1977).Pronouns, quantifiers, and relative clauses.Canadian Journal of Philosophy,7,467-536.
10. Fauconnier, G(1975).Do quantifier branch?.Linguistic Inquiry,6,555-578.
11. Fodor, Janet,Ivan Sag.(1982).Referential and quantificational indefinites.Linguisncs and Philosophy,5,355-398.
12. Heim, Irene.(1982).The Semantics of Definite and Indefinite Noun Phrases.Amherst:Umass dissertation.
13. Heycock, Caroline.(1995).Asymmetries in reconstruction.Linguistic Inquiry,24(1),103-138.
14. Hornstein, Nobert.(1995).Logical Form: From GB to Minimalism.Cambridge:Blackwell.
15. Huang, C.-T. James.(1993).Reconstruction and the structure of VP.Linguistic Inquiry,24(1),103-138.
16. Huang, C.-T. James.(1982).Logical Relations in Chinese and The Theory of Grammar.Cambridge:MIT dissertation.
17. Huang, C.-T. James.(1988).On `be` and `have` in Chinese.The Bulletin of the Institute of History and Philology,59,43-64.
18. Huang, C.-T. James.,Sze-wing Tang,Luther Liu (ed.)(2002).The Formal Way to Chinese Languages.Standford:CSLI and Cambridge University Press.
19. Kadmon, Nirit.(1987).On Unique and Non-Unique Reference and Asymmetric Quantification.Amherst:Umass dissertation.
20. Kamp, Hans.,J. Groenendijk, T. M. V. Janssen,M. Stokhof (ed.)(1981).Formal Methods in the Study of Language, Part 1. Mathematical Centre Tracts.Amsterdam:Mathematisch Centrum.
21. Kratzer, Angelika.,S. Rothstein (ed.)(1998).Event in Grammar.Dordrecht:Kluwer.
22. Landman, F.(1989).Groups I, Groups II.Linguistics and Philosophy,12
23. Landman, Fred.,S. Lappin (ed.)(1996).Handbook of Contemporary Semantics.Blackwell:Oxford.
24. Li, Xiaoguang.(1997).Deriving Distributtv, in Mandarin Chinese.CA:UC Irvine dissertation.
25. Li, Y.-H. Audrey(1992).Indefinite wh in Mandarin Chinese.Journal of East Asian Linguistics,1,125-155.
26. Li, Y.-H. Audrey.(1999).A number projection.Selected Papers from he Fifth International Conference on Chinese Linguistics,Taipei:
27. Link, Gödehard.,Schwarze,von Stechow (ed.)(1983).Meaning, Use, and the Interpretation of Language.Berlin:de Gruyter.
28. Liu, Feng-His(1997).Scope and Specificity.Amsterdam:John Benjamins.
29. Milsark, Gary.(1974).Existential Sentences in English.Cambridge:MIT dissertation.
30. Partee, Barbara. (ed.),Bach, Emmon,Angelika Kratzer(1995).Quantification in Natural Languages.Dordrecht:Kluwer.
31. Reichenbach, Hans.(1947).Elements of Symbolic Logic.London:Macmillan.
32. Reinhart, Tanya.(1997).Quantifier scope: how labor is divided between QR and choice functions.Linguistics and Philosophy,20,335-397.
33. Shi, Dingxu.(1996).The definiteness requirement on Chinese subject.Paper presented at Symposium on Referential Properties of Chinese Noun Phrases,Hongkong:
34. Shyu, Shu-ing.(1995).The syntax of Focus and Topic in Mandarin Chinese.CA:USC dissertation.
35. Tsai, W.-T. Dylan.(2001).On subject specificity and theory of syntax-semantics interface.Journal of East Asian Linguistics,10,129-168.
36. Tsai, W.-T. Dylan.(1994).On Economizing the Theory of A-dependencies.Cambridge:MUT dissertation.
37. Xu, Liejiong.(1996).Limitations on subjecthood of numerically quantified Noun Phrases: a pragmatic approach.Paper presented at Symposium on Referential Properties of Chinese Noun Phrases,Hongkong: