Bu 'Not' in Mandarin Chinese: A Lexical Stative Negator

中文的“不”：詞庫裡衍生的狀態否定詞

10.6519/TJL.2006.4(2).2

林惠玲(Huei-Ling Lin)

Taiwan Journal of Linguistics

4卷2期（2006 / 12 / 01）

67 - 83

英文

「不」作為中文的否定詞並無法與時態詞如「了」共用，此外，「不」也無法與描述/結果結構中的第一動詞共同出現。黃(1988)認為[不V了]以及[不描述/結果結構]之所以不被接受是由於語意上的問題。黃認為「不」必須先附著於V上，然後「了」再附於[不V]上。然而[[不V]了]所合成的語意很怪異，因為未發生的事件不可說是已經完成了。[不描述/結果結構]也因類似的原因而不被接受。這篇文章所要探討的是：「不」是在何層次附著於V的？本文提出兩個證據來證明「不」在詞庫中即附著於V。第一個證據來自對「不」以及「了」兩個字身份的探討，討論結果顯示「不」必須是在詞庫中即附著於V才可解釋[不V了]的異常。另一證據則是來自焦點/對比標記，「是」以及「不是」，它們有著彈性的分佈位置。如果「不」是在詞庫中即附著於「是」，之後「不是」再以焦點/對比標記的身份加在句中，那麼「是」以及「不是」的彈性分佈位置便可獲得解釋。這篇文章的討論中並且顯示，「不」可代表三種組合：「不」單獨一字，「不」加語氣詞，以及「不是」。換言之，「不」並不如表面所顯示僅代表「不」一字。

Bu as a negator in Mandarin Chinese cannot co-occur with an aspect marker such as le. Moreover, bu cannot occur with the first verb in a descriptive/resultative construction. Huang (1988) suggests that the sequences [bu V le] and [bu descriptive/resultative construction] are ruled out for semantic reasons. That is, bu is first attached to V and then le is attached to the negated verb. Such a sequence [[bu-V]-le] is semantically absurd since the event that has not happened cannot be said to have been completed. [Bu descriptive/resultative construction] is ruled out for similar semantic reasons. The problem this paper proposes to tackle is: At which level is bu attached to V? Two arguments may be posited for the proposal that bu is lexically attached to V. The first argument comes from a consideration of the status of both bu and le and it is shown that only when bu is attached to V in the lexicon can the ungrammatical sequence [bu V le] be explained. Further evidence comes from the focus/contrast markers, shi and bu-shi, which have a flexible distribution. If bu is lexically attached to shi and then together bu-shi is inserted as a focus/contrast marker, then the flexible distribution can be explained. Throughout the discussion, it will be shown that bu can be the manifestation of bu alone, bu-Modal, or bu-shi. That is, unlike what it appears to be, bu is not just bu.

1. Chomsky, Noam.,Kenneth Hale (ed.),Samuel Jay Keyser(1993).A minimalist program for linguistic theory.The View from Building,20,1-52.
2. Chomsky, Noam.,Robert Freidin (ed.)(1991).Principles and Parameters in Comparative Grammar.Cambridge:The MIT Press.
3. Ernst, Thomas.(1995).Negation in Mandarin Chinese.Natural Language and Linguistic Theory,13,665-707.
4. Gu, Yang.(1992).Cornell University dissertation.Ithaca:
5. Huang, C.-T. James.(1988).Wo pao de kuai and Chinese phrase structure.Language,64,274-311.
6. Huang, Chu-Ren,Louis Mangione.(1985).A reanalysis of de: Adjunct and subordinate clauses.Proceedings of the Fourth West Coast Conference on Formal Linguistics
7. Klein, Wolfgang,Ping Li,Henriette Hendriks.(2001).Aspect and assertion in Mandarin Chinese.Natural Language & Linguistic Theory,18,723-770.
8. Lee, Peppina Po-Lun,Haihua Pan.(2001).The Chinese negation marker bu and its association with focus.Linguistics,39,703-731.
9. Li, Yen-Hui Audrey.(1990).Order and Constituency in Mandarin Chinese.Dordrecht:Kluwer.
10. Lin, Jo-Wang.(2003).Aspectual selection and negation in Mandarin Chinese.Linguistics,41,425-459.
11. Radford, Andrew.(1988).Transformational Grammar: A First Course.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
12. Rizzi, Luigi.(1990).Relativized Minimality.Cambridge:The MIT Press.
13. Tang, Chih-Chen Jane.(1990).Cornell University dissertation.Ithaca:
14. Travis, Lisa deMena.(1984).MIT dissertation.Cambridge:
15. Wang, William S-Y.(1965).Two aspect markers in Mandarin.Language,41,457-470.
16. Zhou, Xinping.(1990).University of Illinois dissertation.Urbana-Champaign:
17. Zou, Ke.(1995).Negation in the Chinese BA-construction.Paper presented at the 7th North American Conference on Chinese Linguistics

1. (2009).Unifying the Long Passive and the Short Passive: On the Bei Construction in Taiwan Mandarin.語言暨語言學,10(3),421-470.