南方黑鮪全球總可捕量管理程序臺灣決策原則之評估

Evaluation of the Tai-Decision Rules of the Management Procedure of Total Allowable Catch of Southern Bluefin Tuna

10.29629/TEFP.200707.0003

孫金華(Chin-Hwa Sun)；林正鴻(Cheng-Hong Lin)

南方黑鮪 ； 管理程序 ； 運作模式 ； 決策原則 ； 總可捕量 ； Southern bluefin tuna ； Management procedure ； Operating model ； Decision rule ； Total allowable catch

臺灣經濟預測與政策

37卷3期（2007 / 07 / 01）

55 - 82

繁體中文

為保育與最適利用南方黑鮪的資源，南方黑鮪保育委員會(CCSBT)自2000年起開始發展管理程序(management procedure, MP)，以制定一套明確且透明之全球總可補量(total allowable catch, TAC)機制。CCSBT於2004年5月第三屆管理程序會議建構1969年至2000年南方黑鮪年齡結構化資源動態運作模式(operating model)，用以模擬至2032年間之漁業資源狀態之參考模組(reference Set)，測試在不同資源回復目標下，各套決策原則(decision rule)如何動態調整訂定TAC。最後，篩選出四套表現理想之決策原則做為未來執行MP之決策選項，其中TAI_03決策原則為臺灣科學家代表所發展，為依CPUE變動率及漁獲量與魚價波動之逆需求彈性調整TAC之決策原則。 依CCSBT決議於2005年2月管理程序特別技術會議將資源動態運作模式更新至2003年，本研究首先依更新後之參考模組，進行模擬TAI_03決策原則的表現，並進一步設定TAI_04決策原則以降低TAC跨期變異程度，及設定TAI_05決策原則以短、中、長期三段不同期間的設定調整TAC，以期兼顧資源保育及產業穩定經營並於2005年5月第四屆管理程序會議提供此TAI_05決策原則，以進行四組候選決策原則之再評比。本研究模擬結果顯示，TAI_05決策原則為四套候選決策原則中考量短期內緩降TAC以提供產業逐漸移出的機會，有效降低TAC跨期變異程度，降低產業所面對總收益的不確定性，並將長期資源匱乏之風險值控制在較低的水率，期以兼顧資源保育及漁業經濟活動，避免短、中、長期間社會經濟層面無謂的損失。

The Management Procedure of Southern Bluefin Tuna (SBT) was developed since 2000 by the Commission for Conservation of Southern Bluefin Tuna (CCSBT) to conserve and ensure optimum utilization of the global SBT fishery through a transparent mechanism for deciding the global total allowable catch (TAC). According to both the official report of CCSBT for the third Meeting of the Management Procedure Workshop in May 2004, the Age-Structured Population Operating Model (OM) was established by utilizing the harvest data from 1969 to 2000 and was used to simulate the future trajectory reference set of the biomass and total allowable catch (TAC) till 2032. Four candidate decision rules (DR) were selected to decide the appropriate TAC trajectory under various scenarios in order to achieve the recovery target of the biomass. Among the final four candidate decision rules, TAI_03, proposed by Sun (2004), is a CPUE-based DR with a negative built-in feedback component in terms of the theoretical economic consideration of the inverse relationship between price and demand. This study tries to apply the TAI_03 decision rule on the updated Reference Set which is updated by the scientific advisory panel with harvest data until 2003 in February 2005. This study specifies the TAI_04 decision rule to reduce the inter annual variation of TAC and the TAI_05 to adapt to the short-term, intermediate, and long-term situation in order to take into account both sustainability of resource management and industry operation. The simulation result of the TAI_05 decision rule was compared again with the other three candidate decision rules during the fourth management procedure workshop in 2005. The simulation results show that the TAI_05 decision rule would adjust TAC gradually for the industry to follow and to reduce the uncertainty in revenue in the short-term and to reduce the risk of resource deterioration and to fulfill the requirement that both the recovery of the biomass and the optimum utilization of the global SBT fishery in order to avoid the economic deadweight loss in the long run.

1. Basson, M.,P. Eveson,J. Hartog,D. Kolody,T. Polacheck(2005).Further Exploration and Evaluation of the FXR 01 Candidate Management Procedure Rule under the New Reference and Robustness Sets.The Fourth Meeting of the Management Procedure Workshop.
2. Butterworth, D. S.,A. E. Punt(1999).Experiences in the Evaluation and Implementation of Management Procedures.ICES Journal of Marine Science,56(6),985-998.
3. Butterworth, D. S.,K. L. Cochrane,J. A. A. De Oliveria,E. K. Pikitch,D. D. Huppert,M. P. Sissenwine(1997).Management Procedures: A Better Way to Manage Fisheries? The South African Experience.Global Trends: Fisheries Management.
4. Butterworth, D. S.,M. Mori(2004).Application of Variants of a Fox-Model Based MP to the "Christchurch" SBT Trials.The Third Meeting of the Management Procedure Workshop.
5. Butterworth, D. S.,M. Mori(2005).Results of Refined D&M Management Procedure Applied to the Seattle 2005 Trials.The Fourth Meeting of the Management Procedure Workshop.
6. CCSBT(2000).Report of the Sixth Annual Meeting: Second Part.The Sixth Annual Meeting.
7. CCSBT(2004).Report of the Ninth Meeting of the Scientific Committee.The Ninth Meeting of the Scientific Committee.
8. CCSBT(2005).Report of the Special Management Procedure Technical Meeting.The Special Management Procedure Technical Meeting.
9. CCSBT(2003).Report of the Second Meeting of the Management Procedure Workshop.The Second Meeting of the Management Procedure.
10. CCSBT(2005).Report of the Twelfth Annual Meeting of the Commission.The Twelfth Annual Meeting of the Commission.
11. CCSBT(2005).Report of the Fourth Meeting of the Management Procedure Workshop.The Fourth Meeting of the Management Procedure Workshop.
12. Hiramatsu, K.,H. Kurota,H. Shono,N. Takahashi(2004).Behaviors of CPUE-Based Management Procedures Examined through the CCSBT Final Trial Specifications.The Third Meeting of the Management Procedure Workshop.
13. Kurota, H.(2005).Performance of the HK5 Management Procedure under the New Operating Models.The Fourth Meeting of the Management Procedure Workshop.
14. Polacheck, T.,N. L. Klaer,C.Millar,A. L. Preece(1999).An Initial Evaluation of Management Strategies for the Southern Bluefin Tuna Fishery.ICES Journal of Marine Science,56(6),811-826.
15. Polacheck, T.,P. Eveson,J. Hartog, M. Basson,D. Kolody(2004).Comparison of the Performance of Tuned Candidate Management Procedures for Southern Bluefin Tuna Based on the Final Trial Specifications and Testing Procedures.The Third Meeting of the Management Procedure Workshop.
16. Sato, Y.(2002).Fishy Business: A Political-Economic Analysis of the Southern Bluefin Tuna Dispute.Asian Affairs: An American Review,28(4),217-237.
17. Sun, C.-H.(2005).An Evaluation of the TAI Candidate Management Procedure Rules for Southern Bluefin Tuna Based on the Updated Reference Set and Robustness Trails.The Fourth Meeting of the Management Procedure Workshop.
18. Sun, C.-H.(2004).Selection of the Decision Rules of Management Procedures for Southern Bluefin Tuna.The Third Meeting of the Management Procedure Workshop.
19. 孫金華、江福松(2004)。行政院農業委員會漁業署93年度委託研究計畫。
20. 孫金華、江福松(2004)。行政院農業委員會漁業署93年度委託研究計畫。