洪水風險交易制度之建構與分析

Risk Trading in Flood Management

10.29629/TEFP.200707.0004

張瓊婷(Chiung-Ting Chang)

風險交易制度 ； 洪水管理 ； 自然防災法 ； 傳統防災工法 ； Tradeable permit ； Flood management ； Soft engineering measure ； Hard engineering measure

臺灣經濟預測與政策

37卷3期（2007 / 07 / 01）

83 - 105

繁體中文

為降低複雜的地理和經濟條件所構成的訊息成本、善用地方資源及知識，並分攤中央治洪的財政負擔，本文提倡以洪水風險交易制度(tradeable flood Permits)作為一個符合成本有效性分析(cost-effectiveness analysis)和分權式管理之工具。本文之貢獻在於改進洪水風險交易制度的理論模型，並加強闡釋制度之設計。首先以排放權交易市場模型為基礎，融合各區自然與人文條件所影響的入滲能量和所希望承受的風險程度等限制，進而納入土地開發、自然防災法，和傳統防災工法等決策變數。再者，除援用並調整既有之發展權交易(transferable development rights)外，另研擬防災措施交易和風險中立化交易等兩種制度型態，以配合不同的制度條件和需求。

This paper improves the theoretical model that presents the importance of applying tradeable flood permits (TFPs) for efficiency improvement in flood management and the designs of the tradeable flood permits, based on Chang (2005). Land use patterns, and soft and hard engineering measures for flood management are the choice variables. Three types of TFPs are developed under three sets of institutional conditions accordingly. The TFP system is virtually untried. It aims at compensating instead of substituting for the current planning system.

1. 蕭代基、張瓊婷、郭彥廉(2003)。自然資源的參與式管理與地方自治制度。臺灣經濟預測與政策。
   連結：
2. Alaton, P.,B. Djehiche,D. Stillberger(2002).On Modelling and Pricing Weather Derivatives.Applied Mathematical Finance.
3. Transfer of Development Rights
4. Bredin, J. B.(2000).Transfer of Development Rights: Cases, Statutes, Examples, and a Model.2000 APA National Planning Conference.
5. Burd, F.(1995).Managed Retreat: A Practical Guide.
6. Chang, C.(2005).University of York.
7. Managed Realignment: Land Purchase, Compensation and Payment for Alternative Beneficial Land Use
8. DEFRA(2002).Managed Realignment Research.Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs Report.
9. Førsund, F. R.,E. Nævdal(1998).Efficiency Gains under Exchange-Rate Emission Trading.Environmental and Resource Economics.
10. Horan, R. D.,F. Lupi(2005).Tradeable Risk Permits to Prevent Future Introductions of Invasive Alien Species into the Great Lakes.Ecological Economics.
11. Horton, R. E.(1933).Transactions, American Geophysical Union.
12. Hung, M.-F.,D. Shaw(2005).A Trading-Ratio System for Trading Water Pollution Discharge Permits.Journal of Environmental Economics and Management,49(1),83-102.
13. Klaassen, Ger A. J.,F. R. Førsund,M. Amann(1994).Emission Trading in Europe with an Exchange Rate.Environmental and Resource Economics.
14. Krupnick, A. J.,W. E. Oates,E. V. D. Verg(1983).On Marketable Air-Pollution Permits: The Case for a System of Pollution Offsets.Journal of Environmental Economics and Management,10(3),233-247.
15. MacMillan, D(2004).Tradeable Hunting Obligations: A New Approach to Regulating Red Deer Numbers in the Scottish Highlands?.Journal of Environmental Management,71(3),261-270.
16. Mills, D. E.(1980).Transferable Development Rights Markets.Journal of Urban Economics,7(1),63-74.
17. Mitsch, W. J.,J. W. Day Jr.(2004).Thinking Big with Whole-Ecosystem Studies and Ecosystem Restoration: A Legacy of H.T. Odum.Ecological Modelling.
18. Montgomery, W. D.(1972).Markets in Licenses and Efficient Pollution Control Programs.Journal of Economic Theory,5(3),395-418.
19. Pinelands Development Cuedits Summary Report Through December 31, 2006
20. Pruetz, R.(1997).Saved by Development: Preserving Environmental Areas, Farmland and Historic Landmarks with Transfer of Development Rights.
21. Stavins, R. N.(1995).Transaction Costs and Tradeable Permits.Journal of Environmental Economics and Management,29(2),133-148.
22. Winn, P. J. S.,R. M. Young,A. M. C. Edwards(2003).Planning for the Rising Tides: The Humber Estuary Shoreline Management Plan.The Science of the Total Environment.
23. 經濟部水利署(2001)。生態工法技術參考手冊2000年版。臺北:

1. 楊曉文、黃雅文、楊曉文、黃雅文(2015)。洪水保險風險衡量與動態財務模擬分析：以基隆河流域住宅洪災為例。臺大管理論叢，25(2)，83-118。