會計實務與學習行為道德態度之探討

The Study of Ethical Attitudes of Accounting Practice and Academic Behavior

10.30139/JACG.200406.0003

顏信輝(Sin-Hui Yen)；楊淑玲(Shu-Ling Yang)

會計實務 ； 學習行為 ； 道德態度 ； DIT ； accounting practice ； academic behavior ； ethical attitudes ； DIT

會計與公司治理

1卷1期（2004 / 06 / 01）

47 - 71

繁體中文

有鑑於財務報表使用者對於報表誠信問題日益關切，本研究主要探討企業主辦會計、會計師及會計系學生對會計實務（會計處理目的及會計處理方式）與學習行為之道德態度。根據國內65位上市公司主辦會計人員、63位會計師與287位會計系大四學生之有效問卷回函分析，結果顯示： 1.不同身分會影響受試者對道德之態度，企業主辦會計人員與會計師，均較學生對會計處理方式與會計處理目的之道德態度持較高之標準，企業主辦會計人員也比學生對學習行為之道德態度較為嚴謹，惟若控制學習行為之道德態度，學生對於會計處理方式能較主辦會計人員持更高之道德標準。 2.企業主辦會計人員與會計系學生對會計處理方式與學習行為之道德態度，均呈顯著之正相關，且二種道德態度間互有解釋力。 3.道德發展發展層次為成規後期之受試者，對學習行為有更高之道德標準，惟在會計處理方式之道德判斷上，則與其他道德發展層次之受試者，發現並無顯著差異。

The purpose of this study is to examine the ethical attitudes toward accounting purposes, accounting treatments and academic behavior amongst chief accountants, CPAs and students majored in accounting. According to the questionnaire responses from 65 chief accountants in the listed companies, 63 CPAs and 287 accounting students, the research results are as follows: 1. Different roles present significant different ethical attitudes. The chief accountants and CPAs have higher ethical standards for both accounting practice and academic behavior than those of students. However, after controlling the effect of academic ethics, the students exhibit more rigid accounting practice ethical standard. 2. The relationship between the ethical attitudes of accounting practice and academic behavior is significant positive. 3. The subjects of post-conventional moral development level exhibit a higher ethical standard on the attitudes of academic behavior, but not on those of accounting treatment.

1. 杜榮瑞(2002)。理事長的話。中華會計教育學會會訊季刊，1-2。
   連結：
2. Abdolmohammadi, M.(2002).Ethical reasoning and the use of insider information in stock trading.Journal of Business Ethics,37(2),165-173.
3. Ameen, E. C.,D. M. Guffey,J. J. Mcmillan.(1996).Accounting Students' Perceptions of Questionable Academic Practices and Factors Affecting Their Propensity to Cheat.Accounting Education,5(3),191-205.
4. American Accounting Association,Committee on the Future Structure,Content, and Scope of Accounting Education The Bedford Committee(1986).Future Accounting Education: Preparing for the Expanding Profession.Issues in Accounting Education,1,168-195.
5. Armstrong, M. B.(1987).Moral Development and Accounting Education.Journal of Accounting Education,5,27-43.
6. Arnold, V.,S. G. Sutton.(1997).Behavioral Accounting Research: Foundations and Frontiers.American Accounting Association.
7. Arthur Andersen & Co.,Arthur Young, Coopers,Lybrand, Deloitte Haskins,Sells, Ernst,Whinney, Peat Marwick Main & Co.,Price Waterhouse and Touche Ross.(1989).Perspectives on Education: Capabilities for Success in the Accounting Profession.
8. Bernardi, R.(1991).Schenectady, NY.,Union College.
9. Bigel, K. S.(2002).The Impact of a Business Ethics Course on the Moral Development of Undergraduate and Graduate Business Students.The Delta Pi Epilon Journal,44(2),125-138.
10. Brabeck, M.(1984).Ethical characteristics of Whistle-blowers.Journal of Research in Personality,18,41-53.
11. Brooks, L. J.(2000).Business and Professional Ethics for Accountants. 2/e.Cincinnati, OH:South-Western College.
12. Chang, Fon-Yean.(1994).The Defining Issues Test.Symposium on Cognitive Development Approach to Morality: Measurement and Educational Application
13. Clarke, R.,J. Aram.(1997).Universal Values, Behavioral Ethics and Entrepreneurship.Journal of Business Ethics,16(5),561-572.
14. Cummings, R.,L. Dyas,C. D. Maddux,A. Kochman.(2001).Principled Moral Reasoning and Behavior of Preservice Teacher Education Students.Accounting Educational Research Journal,38(1),143-158.
15. Elias, R. Z.(2002).Determinants of Earnings Management Ethics Among Accountants.Journal of Business Ethics,40(1),33-45.
16. Fischer, M.,K. Rosenzweig.(1995).Attitudes of Students and Accounting Practitioners Concerning the Ethical Acceptability of Earnings Management.Journal of Business Ethics,14(6),433-444.
17. Helps, L.(1994).Should We Teach Ethics in Accounting Education?.Management Accounting,72(6),46.
18. Jakubowski, S. T.,P. Chao.,S. K. Huh.,S. Maheshwari.(2002).A Cross-country Comparison of the Codes of Professional Conduct of Certified Chartered Accountants.Journal of Business Ethics,35(2),111-129.
19. Kohlberg, L.,D. Goslin (ed.)(1969).Handbook of Socialization Theory and Research.Chicago, IL:Rand MeNally.
20. Lampe, J.,D. Finn.(1992).A Model of Auditors' Ethical Decision Process.Auditing: A Journal of Theory & Practice,11,33-59.
21. Levitt, A.(1988).The Numbers Game.The CPA Journal,68,14-19.
22. Lord, A. T.,F. T. DeZoort.(2001).The impact of commitment and moral reasoning on auditors responses to social influence pressure.Accounting, Organizations and Society,26,215-235.
23. Louwers, T.,L. Ponemon,R. Radtke.,Arnold, V. (eds.),S. Sutton (eds.)(1997).Behavioral Accounting Research: Foundations and Frontiers.Sarasota, FL:
24. Merchant, K. A.,J. Rockness.(1994).The Ethics of Managing Earnings: An Empirical Investigation.Journal of Accounting and Public Policy,13(1),79-94.
25. National Commission on Fraudulent Financial Reporting.(1987).Report of the National Commission on Fraudulent Financial Reporting.New York:American Institute of Certified Public Accountants.
26. Nonis, S.,C. O. Swift.(2001).An Examination of the Relationship Between Academic Dishonesty and Workplace Dishonesty: A Multicampus Investigation.Journal of Business Ethics,77(2),69-77.
27. Ogilby, S. M.(1995).The Ethics of Academic Behavior: Will it Affect Professional Behavior?.Journal of Education for Business,71(2),92-96.
28. Ponemon, L.(1995).The objectivity of accountings' litigation support judgments.The Accounting Review,70,467-488.
29. Ponemon, L. A.,D. R. L. Gabhart.(1990).Auditor Independence Judgments: A Cognitive-developmental Model and Experimental Evidence.Contemporary Accounting Research,7,227-251.
30. Ponemon, L.,A. Glazer.(1990).Accounting Education and Ethical Development: The Influence of Liberal Learning on Students and Alumni in Accounting Practice.Issues in Accounting Education,5,195-208.
31. Rest, J. R.(1986).DIT Manual.Minneapolis:University of Minnesota.
32. Shaub, M.(1994).An Analysis of the Association of Traditional Demographic Variables with the Moral Reasoning of Auditing Students and Auditors.Journal of Accounting Education,12(1),1-26.
33. Sierles, F.,I. Hendrickx,S. Circle.(1980).Cheating in Medical School.Journal of Medical Education,55,124-125.
34. Sims, R. L.(1993).The Relationship Between Academic Dishonesty and Unethical Business Practices.Journal of Education for Business,68(4),207-211.
35. Smith, K. J.,J. A.Davy,D. L. Rosenberg,G. T. Haight.(2002).A Structural Modeling Investigation of the Influence of Demographic and Attitudinal Factors and In-class Deterrents on Cheating Behavior Among Accounting Majors.Journal of Accounting Education,20(1),45-65.
36. Sunder, S.(1997).Theory of Accounting and Control.Cincinnati, Ohio:South-Western College.
37. Thorne, L.(2001).Refocusing Ethics Education in Accounting: An Examination of Accounting Students' Tendency to Use Their Cognitive Moral Capability.Journal of Accounting Education,19(2),103-117.
38. Wood, J. A.,J. G. Longenecker,J. A. McKinney,C. W. Moore.(1988).Ethical Attitudes of Students and Business Professionals: A Study of Moral Reasoning.Journal of Business Ethics,7(4),249-257.
39. 吳清山(2002)。知識經濟社會的校園倫理。學生輔導，82，18-29。
40. 杜榮瑞(2002)。企業盈餘操縱：企業經理人、會計準則與審計。會計研究月刊，203，14-18。
41. 林志仁(1999)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。國立政治大學會計學系碩士班未出版碩士論文。
42. 林松宏、葉誌崇、吳祥發(2002)。中美會計專業人員之價值觀、社會心理態度、宗教觀與道德判斷之跨文化比較研究。國立成功大學學報，37，137-167。
43. 孫梧庭(2002)。職業倫理與資本市場－以美國Enron公司破產醜聞為例。今日合庫，28(1)，24-32。
44. 馬秀如(1992)。績效衡量與職業道德。主計月報，73(4)，33-35。
45. 張鳳燕(2000)。教師道德推理與教學關係之初探。教育資料集刊，25，21-45。
46. 陳依蘋(2002)。利字當頭怎能不慎？。會計研究月刊，202，12。
47. 薛富井、林千惠(2003)。美國2002年沙氏法案(Sarbanes-Oxley Act)對會計師事務所與發行公司影響之探討。會計研究月刊，209，102-130。
48. 鍾惠珍、李香瑩(2003)。會計教育新挑戰。會計研究月刊，206，60-66。
49. 顏信輝、楊淑玲(2002)。商管學生對不當學習行為之態度與行動：以淡江大學為例。第六屆兩岸會計與管理學術研討會論文集
50. 顏信輝、楊淑玲(2003)。我國會計系實施道德倫理教育現況及教師態度之探索性研究。第二屆21世紀產業經營管理國際學術研討會論文集
51. 顏信輝、簡穗(2004)。我國會計人員道德發展之探討：科系、年級、性別與事務所工作經驗之影響。會計評論，38，1-29。

1. 傅澤偉(2007)。道德判斷、上司壓力、時間壓力及工作複雜性對政府機關預算籌編及執行適切性認知的影響。東吳經濟商學學報，59，29-56。
2. 顏信輝、張瑀珊、吳美奇(2016)。盈餘管理之行為意圖：代理情境、道德發展與計畫行為理論之解釋。臺大管理論叢，26(2)，107-138。