會計師事務所組織型態與審計品質：來自中國證據

Auditors' Organizational Form and Audit Quality: Evidence from China

翁慈青(Tzu-Ching Weng)

合夥 ； 有限責任合夥 ； 審計品質 ； Partnerships ； limited liability partnerships ； Audit quality ； Discretionary accruals

會計與公司治理

12卷2期（2017 / 12 / 01）

37 - 66

繁體中文

中國於1994年開始實施中華人民共和國註冊會計師法，該法規規定註冊會計師可以選擇申請設立合夥（partnership）會計師事務所或有限責任的法人型態的事務所。由於這兩類組織型態的事務所會計師所面臨的法律環境不同，因此本研究主要在探討合夥事務所所屬會計師，審計品質是否與有限責任事務所所屬的會計師有差別，本研究援引2000至2014年在中國深圳及上海交易所掛牌上市發行A股之的公司作為研究樣本，並以裁決性應計盈餘大小與會計師事務所是否發佈無保留意見，作為審計品質之代理變數。實證結果發現，自從中國會計師法實行以來，為降低法律責任，註冊會計師多偏好選擇有限責任的事務所組織型態。進一步研究顯示，由於合夥會計師事務所所屬的會計師負有無限清償責任，相對的，有限責任事務所所屬的會計師僅負有有限的清償責任，因而合夥組織型態的會計師事務所，其所屬的會計師審計品質優於有限責任事務所所屬的會計師。

Audit firms in China have been given option to choose legal forms, partnership or limited liability (LLP) depending on their organizations since 1994. Different from LLC with limitation of partnership liability, each partner is liable for all the audit services, which raise an incentive for individual partner to monitor the audit quality provided by their fellow partners in the partnership structure. It hypothesizes that auditor independence is lower for legal structure of LLP than for legal forms of partnership. This study uses discretionary accrual (therefore DA) and the likelihood of auditor firms issuing clean opinion as proxies for audit quality, respectively. Using a sample of listed firms in China, this study finds that auditees of audit firms adopting legal forms of partnership report higher the levels of both the income-increasing DA and the absolute DA, compared to clients of audit firms adopting LLP legal forms. This study also finds that the likelihood of issuing unqualified opinion is higher for partner of general partnership relative to one of LLP.

1. 張瑞當、沈文華、張菁萍、魏若婷(2009)。台灣會計學術研究回顧與展望。中山管理評論，17(2)，453-481。
   連結：
2. 陳素緞、陳鈺薏(2014)。會計師簽證制度與法律責任之探討：以力霸案之觀點。會計與公司治理，9(1)，63-78。
   連結：
3. 劉嘉雯、王泰昌(2005)。繼續經營有重大疑慮審計意見：第33號審計準則公報之影響。管理學報，22(4)，525-548。
   連結：
4. Chen, C. J. P., Chen, S., and X. Su. Independent auditing and modified audit opinions in China: facts, reasons, and implications. Working paper. City University of Hong Kong.
5. Chen, X., and Q. Cheng. Abnormal accrual based anomaly and managers' motivation to record abnormal accruals. Working paper, University of British Columbia.
6. Gensler, M. and J. Yang. 1996. Auditing Standards of the People's Republic of China, FT Law and Tai, Asia Pacific..
7. Hansen, G. A., and C. F. Noe. 1998. Do managers' accrual decision speak louder than words? Working paper, Pennsylvania State University.
8. Li, C., F. M. Song, , and S. M. Wong. 2004. Audit firm size effects in China's emerging audit markets. Working Paper. The university of Hong Kong.
9. Ali, A.,Kallapur, S.(2001).Securities price consequences of the private securities litigation reform Act of 1995 and related events.The Accounting Review,76,431-461.
10. Ashbaugh, H.,Lafond, R.,Mayhew, B. W.(2003).Do nonaudit services compromise auditor independence? Further evidence.The Accounting Review,78,611-639.
11. Barzel, Y.(1982).Measurement cost and the organization of the market.Journal of Law of Michigan,25,27-48.
12. Beck, P. J.,Frecka, T. J.,Solomon, L.(1988).An empirical analysis of the relationship between MAS involvement and auditor tenure: implications for auditor independence.Journal of Accounting Literature,7,65-84.
13. Becker, C. L.,DeFond, M. L.,Jiambalvo, J.,Subramanyam, K. R.(1998).The effect of audit quality on earnings management.Contemporary Accounting Research,14,1-24.
14. Belsley, D. A.,Kuh, E.,Welsch, R. E.(2000).Regression Diagnostics: Identifying Influenctial Data and Sources of Collinearity.New York:Wiley.
15. Burgstahler, D.,Dichev, I.(1997).Earnings management to avoid earnings decreases and losses.Journal of Accounting and Economics,24,99-126.
16. Chen, G.(ed.),Chen, X.(ed.),Cheung, J.K.(ed.)(1999).Contemporary Issues in China Accounting and Finance Policy and Practice.Oxford University Press.
17. Chung, H.,Kallapur, S.(2003).Client importance, nonaudit services, and abnormal accrual.The Accounting Review,78,931-955.
18. Collins, D.,Hribar, P.(2000).Earnings-based and accrual-based market anomalies: one effect or two?.Hribar,,29,101-123.
19. DeAngelo, H.,DeAngelo, L.,Skinner, D.J.(1994).Accounting choice in troubled companies.Journal of Accounting and Economics,177,113-144.
20. Dechow, P. M.,Sloan, R. G.,Sweeney, A. P.(1995).Detecting earnings management.The Accounting Review,17,193-225.
21. DeFond, M.,Jiambalvo, J.(1994).Debt covenant violation and manipulation of accruals, accounting choices in troubled companies.Journal of Accounting and Economics,17,145-176.
22. DuCharme, L.,Malatesta, P.,Sefcik, S.(2004).Earnings management, stock issues, and shareholder lawsuits.Journal of Financial Economics,71,27-49.
23. Dye, R.(1995).Incorporation and the audit market.Journal of Accounting and Economics,19,75-114.
24. Francis, J.(1984).The effect of audit firm size and audit prices.Journal of Accounting and Economics,6,133-152.
25. Francis, J.,Philbrick, D.,Schipper, K.(1994).Shareholder litigation and corporate disclosures.Journal of Accounting Research,32,137-164.
26. Frankel, R.,Johnson, M.,Nelson, K.(2002).The relation between auditors' fees for nonaudit services and earnings management.The Accounting Review,77,71-105.
27. Ghosh, Aloke,Moon, D.(2005).Auditor Tenure and Perceptions of Audit Quality.The Accounting Review,80,585-612.
28. Greene, W. H.(2003).Econometric Analysis.Prentice Hall.
29. Guay, W.,Kothair, S. P.,Watts, R.(1996).A market-based evaluation of discretionary accrual models.Journal of Accounting Research,34,83-116.
30. Habib, Ahsn(2007).Legal Environment, accounting information, auditing and information intermediaries: Survey of the empirical literature.Journal of Accounting literature,26,1-75.
31. Healy, P. M.(1985).The effect of bonus schemes on accounting decision.Journal of Accounting and Economics,7,85-107.
32. Jaggi, B.,Lee, P. P.(2003).Earning forecast regulation and earnings management by IPO firms.International Accounting Section of the 2003 American Accounting Association Meeting,USA:
33. Jones, J. J.(1991).Earnings management during import relief investigations.Journal of Accounting Research,29,193-228.
34. Kothari, S. P.,Leone, A. L.,Wasley, C. E.(2005).Performance matched discretionary accrual measures.Journal of Accounting and Economics,39,163-197.
35. Lang, M.,Lins, K.,Miller, D.(2003).ADR's, analysts, and accuracy: does cross listing in the United States improve a firm's information environment and increase market value?.Journal of Accounting Research,41,317-345.
36. Lee, H. Y.,Mande, V.(2003).The effect of the private securities litigation reform act of 1995 on accounting discretion of client managers of big 6 and non-big 6 auditors.Auditing: A Journal of Practice and Theory,22,93-108.
37. Lent, L. V.(1999).The economics of an audit firm: the benefits of partnership governance.British Accounting Review,31,225-254.
38. Lys, T.,Watts, R. L.(1994).Lawsuits against auditors.Journal of Accounting Research,32,65-93.
39. Matsumoto, D.(2002).Management's incentives to avoid negative earnings surprises.The Accounting Review,77,483-514.
40. Muzatko, S. R.,Johnstone, K. M.,Mayhew, B. W.,Rittenberg, L. E.(2004).An empirical investigation of IPO underpricing and the change to the LLP organization of audit firms.Auditing: A Journal of Practice and Theory,23,53-67.
41. Myers, J. N.,Myers, L. A.,Omer, T. C.(2003).Exploring the Term of the Auditor: Client Relationship and the Quality of Earnings: A Case for Mandatory Auditor Rotation?.The Accounting Review,78,779-799.
42. Nelson, J.,Ronen, J.,White, L.(1988).Legal liabilities and the market for auditing services.Journal of Accounting and Finance,3,255-285.
43. Reynolds, K.,Francis, J.(2001).Does size matter? The influence of large clients on office-level auditor reporting decisions.Journal of Accounting and Finance,30,375-400.
44. Schwartz, R.(1997).Legal regimes, audit quality, and investment.The Accounting review,60,248-261.
45. Simunic, D.(1980).The pricing of audit services: theory and evidence.Journal of Accounting research,18,161-190.
46. Soffer, L. C.,Thiagarajan, S. R.,Walther, B. R.(2000).Earnings preannouncements.Review of Accounting Studies,5,5-26.
47. Watts, R. L.,Zimmerman, J. L.(1983).Agency Problems, Auditing, and the Theory of the Firm: Some Evidence.Journal of Law and Economics,26,613-633.
48. White H.(1980).A hereroscedasticity consistent covariance matrix estimator and a direct test for heteroscedasticity.Econometrica,40,817-838.
49. Yang, J.W.,Yang, J. L.(1999).The Handbook of Chinese accounting.Oxford University Press (China) Ltd..
50. 李建然、林秀鳳(2007)。大型會計師事務所之審計品質真的比非大型會計師事務所好嗎？從盈餘管理的角度探討─內生性二元處理模型之應用。中華會計學刊，9(1)，77-110。
51. 李建然、陳政芳(2004)。審計客戶重要性與盈餘管理：以五大事務所組別為觀察標的。會計評論，38，59-80。
52. 傅鍾仁、張福星、陳慶隆(2005)。審計失敗對會計師保守主義的影響？Enron案是否存在產業蔓延效果？。會計評論，40，32-67。