理財教育、理財素養、理財行為對學習成效影響之研究—以現金流桌遊為例

A Study of the Impacts of Financial Education, Financial Literacy and Financial Behavior on Learning Effectiveness-A Case of Cash Flow Board Game

歐陽豪(Ou-Yang Hou)；游翰霖(Han-Lin Yu)

理財教育 ； 理財素養 ； 理財行為 ； 學習成效 ； Financial Education ； Financial Literacy ； Financial Behavior ； Learning Effectiveness

會計與公司治理

17卷2期（2022 / 12 / 01）

51 - 77

英文

本研究在探究「現金流桌遊」作為理財教學上之效益。透過問卷調查法量化及質性深度訪談業界專業人士使用經驗及事實陳述。有效問卷401份，問卷發放回收期間為2018年12月12日至2018年12月27日。實證結果如下：「理財教育」對「理財素養」、「理財行為」及「學習成效」均有顯著正向影響；「理財素養」對「理財行為」、「學習成效」均有顯著正向影響，「理財行為」對「學習成效」有顯著正向影響；「理財教育」透過「理財素養」對「學習成效」具部分中介效果，其中介效果強度為43.58%。「理財教育」透過「理財行為」對「學習成效」具部分中介效果，其中介效果強度僅為5.01%。理財素養與理財行為對「理財教育與學習成效」間之關係具完全中介效果（遠程中介）。訪談中專家一致同意，透過現金流桌遊學習並累積足夠的理財知識和經驗後，每月現金流量和資產收入都有明顯增加。

This study explores the effectiveness of "Cash Flow Board Game" as a financial education. Quantitative and qualitative in-depth interviews with professionals in the industry through questionnaire surveys and factual statements. There were 401 valid questionnaires, and the questionnaire distribution and recovery period was from December 12, 2018 to December 27, 2018. The empirical results are as follows: "Financial management education" has a significant positive impact on "financial literacy", "financial management behavior" and "learning effect"; "financial literacy" has a significant positive impact on "financial management behavior" and "learning effect" , "Financial management behavior" has a significant positive impact on "learning outcomes"; "financial management education" has a partial mediation effect on "learning outcomes" through "financial literacy", and the mediation effect strength is 43.58%. "Financial education" has a partial mediating effect on "learning effect" through "financial management behavior", and the mediating effect strength is only 5.01%. Financial literacy and financial behavior have a complete mediating effect on the relationship between financial education and learning outcomes (distance mediation). The experts in the interview agreed that after learning and accumulating sufficient financial knowledge and experience through the cash flow board game, the monthly cash flow and asset income have increased significantly.

1. 王芳醴,張燦明,李玟憲(2015)。大學生性別角色、金錢態度與理財行為之研究: 以修平科大學生為例。修平學報，31，135-156。
   連結：
2. 汪瑞芝,廖玲珠(2008)。會計習作課程之學習行為與學習成效。當代會計，91，105-130。
   連結：
3. 洪榮昭,詹瓊華(2018)。共變推理遊戲: 遊戲自我效能與後設認知影響遊戲中的焦慮興趣及表現之研究。教育科學研究期刊，63(3)，131-162。
   連結：
4. 黃美筠(2008)。理財教育融入中小學課程的必要性——由其重要性與課程內涵析論之。公民訓育學報，19，25-54。
   連結：
5. 黃添丁(2015)。數位學習融入課程之學習動機及學習行為對學習成效的影響。慈濟科技大學學報，1，35-52。
   連結：
6. 蕭郁瑩,黃美筠(2014)。美國與臺灣高中理財教育課程之比較研究。公民教育與活動領導學報，23，103-138。
   連結：
7. Ackerman, R.,Parush, A.,Nassar, F.,Shtub, A.(2016).Metacognition and system usability: Incorporating metacognitive research paradigm into usability testing.Computers in Human Behavior,54,101-113.
8. Bellofatto, A.,D'Hondt, C.,De Winne, R.(2018).Subjective financial literacy and retail investors' behavior.Journal of Banking and Finance,92,168-181.
9. Browning, M. H.,Larson, L. R.,Sharaievska, I.,Rigolon, A.,McAnirlin, O.,Mullenbach, L.,Alvarez, H. O.(2021).Psychological impacts from COVID-19 among university students: Risk factors across seven states in the United States.PloS one,16(1),e0245327.
10. Coffman, B. A.,Trumbo, M. C.,Flores, R. A.,Garcia, C. M.,Van Der Merwe, A. J.,Wassermann, E. M.,Clark, V. P.(2012).Impact of tDCS on performance and learning of target detection: interaction with stimulus characteristics and experimental design.Neuropsychologia,50(7),1594-1602.
11. Eseryel, D.,Law, V.,Ifenthaler, D.,Ge, X.,Miller, R.(2014).An investigation of the interrelationships between motivation, engagement, and complex problem solving in game-based learning.Journal of Educational Technology and Society,17(1),42-53.
12. Grohmann, A.,Klühs, T.,Menkhoff, L.(2018).Does financial literacy improve financial inclusion? Cross country evidence.World Development,111,84-96.
13. Hanson, T. A.,Olson, P. M.(2018).Financial literacy and family communication patterns.Journal of Behavioral and Experimental Finance,19,64-71.
14. Hilgert, M. A.,Hogarth, J. M.,Beverly, S. G.(2003).Household financial management: The connection between knowledge and behavior.Federal Reserve Bulletin,89,309-322.
15. Ibrahim, D.,Harun, R.,Mohamed Isa, Z.(2009).Ibrahim, D., R. Harun, and Z. Mohamed Isa. 2009. The importance of financial literacy among degree students: a case study in UiTM Kedah campus..
16. Isomidinova, G.,Singh, J. S. K.,Singh, K.(2017).Determinants of financial literacy: a quantitative study among young students in Tashkent, Uzbekistan.Electronic Journal of Business & Management,2(1),61-75.
17. Joseph de la Torre Dwyer, J.,Field, S.,Thomas, U. G.,Flinner, K.(2021).,未出版
18. JumpStart Coalition for Personal Financial Literacy(2007).JumpStart Coalition for Personal Financial Literacy. 2007. National standards in K - 12 personal finance education 3rd..
19. Kaiser, T.,Menkhoff, L.(2017).Does financial education impact financial literacy and financial behavior, and if so, when?.The World Bank Economic Review,31(3),611-630.
20. Koestner, M.,Loos, B.,Meyer, S.,Hackethal, A.(2017).Do individual investors learn from their mistakes?.Journal of Business Economics,87(5),669-703.
21. Köklü, Ö.,Jakubowski, E.(2010).From Interpretations to Graphical Representations: A Case Study Investigation of Covariational Reasoning.Eurasian Journal of Educational Research,40
22. Kozina, F. L.,Ponikvar, N.(2015).Financial literacy of first-year university students: The role of education.International Journal of Management, Knowledge and Learning,4(2),241-255.
23. Krechovská, M.(2015).Financial literacy as a path to sustainability.Trendy v podnikání – Business Trends,2015(2),3-12.
24. Lin, L.,Atkinson, R. K.,Savenye, W. C.,Nelson, B. C.(2016).Effects of visual cues and self-explanation prompts: empirical evidence in a multimedia environment.Interactive Learning Environments,24(4),799-813.
25. Lusardi, A.,de Bassa Scheresberg, C.(2013).,National Bureau of Economic Research.
26. Lusardi, A.,Michaud, P. C.,Mitchell, O. S.(2017).Optimal financial knowledge and wealth inequality.Journal of Political Economy,125(2),431-477.
27. Lusardi, A.,Tufano, P.(2015).Debt literacy, financial experiences, and overindebtedness.Journal of Pension Economics and Finance,14(4),332-368.
28. Merchie, E.,Van Keer, H.(2016).Stimulating Graphical Summarization in Late Elementary Education: The Relationship between Two Instructional Mind-Map Approaches and Student Characteristics.the elementary school journal,116(3),487-522.
29. Moreno, R.(2006).Does the modality principle hold for different media? A test of the method-affects-learning hypothesis.Journal of Computer Assisted Learning,22(3),149-158.
30. Potosky, D.,Ramakrishna, H. V.(2002).The moderating role of updating climate perceptions in the relationship between goal orientation, self-efficacy, and job performance.Human Performance,15(3),275-297.
31. Remund, D. L.(2010).Financial literacy explicated: The case for a clearer definition in an increasingly complex economy.Journal of consumer affairs,44(2),276-295.
32. Schraw, G.,Dennison, R. S.(1994).Assesing Metacognitive Awareness.Contemporary Educational Pschology,19,460-475.
33. Strömbäck, C.,Lind, T.,Skagerlund, K.,Västfjäll, D.,Tinghög, G.(2017).Does self-control predict financial behavior and financial well-being?.Journal of Behavioral and Experimental Finance,14,30-38.
34. Tang, N.,Baker, A.(2016).Self-esteem, financial knowledge and financial behavior.Journal of Economic Psychology,54,164-176.
35. Torres Barreto, M.,Plata Gómez, K.,Núñez Rueda, S.(2021).Implementación de la fase uno del proyecto "Educación financiera gamificada como estrategia didáctica para el desarrollo de estilos de vida sostenibles".Proceedings INNODOCT / 20. International Conference on Innovation, Documentation and Education
36. Van Rooij, M. C.,Lusardi, A.,Alessie, R. J.(2012).Financial literacy, retirement planning and household wealth.The Economic Journal,122(560),449-478.
37. Webster, J.,Trevino, L. K.,Ryan, L.(1993).The dimensionality and correlates of flow in human-computer interactions.Computers in human behavior,9(4),411-426.
38. 王美娟,丁姵瑄(2021)。桌上遊戲融入國小六年級金融教育課程之個案研究。臺灣教育評論月刊，10(3)，196-227。
39. 吳帝葦(2018)。國立臺北教育大學社會與區域發展學系。
40. 莊咸中(2021)。桃園，健行科技大學財務金融系碩士班。
41. 許錦桂(2017)。高雄，樹德科技大學資訊工程系碩士班。
42. 楊軍（譯）,楊明（譯）(1999).富爸爸,窮爸爸.高寶出版社.
43. 葉育銘(2020)。南投，國立暨南國際大學財務金融學系。
44. 蔡華華,張雅萍(2007)。學習動機對學習成效之影響─以領導行為為干擾變數。中華管理學報，8(4)，1-17。