影響病房護理人員照護品質之相關因素研究

A Study of the Related Factors of Nursing Quality Provided by Ward Nurses

邱淑瑾(Shu-Chin Chiu)；王萬琳(Wan-Lin Wang)；應立志(Li-Chih Ying)；江蕙娟(Hui-Chaun Chiang)

護理人員 ； 工作環境 ； 工作負荷 ； 護理品質 ； nurses ； working environment ； workload ； nursing quality

嶺東學報

33期（2013 / 06 / 01）

73 - 95

繁體中文

由於住院病患非常仰賴護理人員之照護，並希望獲得優良之護理照護品質，此導致病房護理人員沉重之工作負荷。文獻顯示護理照護品質會受到護理人員之工作環境及工作負荷所影響，故本研究之目的乃針對個案醫院之內外科病房護理人員探討其工作環境及工作負荷與護理照護品質之關係。採問卷調查法，共獲86份有效問卷，並執行描述性統計、t檢定、單因子變異數分析、Pearson積差相關、因素分析及多元廻歸分析。研究結果為護理品質瑕疵之發生頻率平均每月少於一次；護理品質之過程達成情形良好；工作環境尚稱滿意。工作負荷構面中之下班時間經常逾時1小時以上及工作需要做事很快之現象確實存在。另外，護理人員之工作環境會影響其護理品質之過程以及直接負荷因素會影響護理品質瑕疵發生頻率。研究結論為院方應設法提高護理人員對工作環境之滿意程度以及降低護理人員之直接負荷，以提升護理品質過程之達成並減少護理品質瑕疵發生之頻率。

Hospitalized patients rely heavily on nursing care and want to get the excellent quality of nursing. It leads to a heavy workload of the ward nurses. The literatures show that the nursing quality will be affected by the working environment and workload of nurses. Hence the objective of this paper is to explore the relation between nursing quality and working environment and workload of the nurses in the medical and surgical wards. We use the questionnaires to collect data. 86 valid questionnaires were obtained and analyzed by descriptive statistics, t-test, one-way ANOVA, Pearson's r, factor analysis and multivariate regression. The results as following: Defects frequency of nursing quality was less than once per month on average. The achievement of process of nursing quality is good and the working environment is fairly satisfied. The situations of extra one working hour and quick action existed. In addition, the working environment significantly affects the process of nursing quality, and the direct load significantly affects the defects frequency of nursing quality. We conclude that the hospital should try to improve the satisfaction level of working environment and reduce the direct load of nurses in order to enhance achievement of process of nursing quality and reduce the defects frequency of nursing quality.

1. Yang, K.P.(2003).Relationships between nurse staffing and patient outcome.Journal of Nursing Research,11(3),149-157.
   連結：
2. 毛筱艷、梁應平(2003)。文化對於基層員工工作負荷過重、角色衝突、角色模糊與工作倦怠之影響研究。交大商管學報，8(1)，55-78。
   連結：
3. 謝生蘭、劉芹芳、李金德、林秀鳳、張肇松(2009)。護理人員給藥錯誤次數及其相關因素之探討。醫務管理期刊，10(1)，48-62。
   連結：
4. International Council of Nurses. (2007). Positive practice environments: Quality workplaces= quality patient care. Information and action tool kit developed by Andrea Baumann for ICN. Retrieved February 4, 2008, from the ICN Web site：http://www.icn.ch/indkit 2007.pdf
5. Aiken, L.,Havens, D.,Sloane, D.(2000).The Magnet Services Recognition Program: a comparison to 2 groups of Magnet hospitals.American Journal of Nursing,100(3),26-35.
6. Aiken, L.H.,Clarke, S.P.,Sloane, D.M.,Sochalski , J.,Silber, J.H.(2002).Hospital nurse staffing and patient mortality, nurse burnout, and job dissatisfaction.The Journal of the American Medical Association,288(16),1987-1993.
7. Archibald, L.K.,Manning, M.L.,Bell, L.M.,Banerjee, S.,Jarvis, W.R.(1997).Patient density, nurse-to-patient ratio and nosocomial infection in a Pediatric cardiac intensive care unit.Pediatric Infection Disease Journal,16,1045-1048.
8. Barry, W.J.(2000).The impact of systems redesign on staff, patient, and financial outcomes.The Journal of Nursing Administration,30(2),77-89.
9. Beckmann, U.,Baldwin, I.,Durie, M.,Morrison, A.,Shaw, L.(1998).Problems associated with nursing staff shortage: an analysis of the first 3600 incident reports submitted to the Australian Incident Monitoring Study (AIMS-ICU).Anaesth Intensive Care,26(4),396-400.
10. Benner, P.,Sheets, V.,Uris, P.,Malloch, K.,Schwed, K.,Jamison, D.(2002).Individual, practice, and system causes of errors in nursing: a taxonomy.The Journal of Nursing Administration,32(10),509-523.
11. Carayon, P.,Gurses, P.(2005).A human factors engineering conceptual framework of nursing workload and patient safety in intensive care units.Intensive and Critical Care Nursing,21(5),284-301.
12. Donchin, Y.,Gopher, D.,Olin, M.,Badihi, Y.,Biesky, M.,Sprung, C.L.,Pizov, R.,Cotev, S.(2003).A look into the nature and causes of human errors in the intensive care unit.Quality Safety Health Care,12(2),143-147.
13. Gunther, M.,Alligood, M.R.(2002).A discipline-specific determination of high quality nursing care.Journal of Advanced Nursing,38(4),353-359.
14. Houkes, I.,Janssen, P.M.,Bakker, A.B.(2003).Specific determinants of intrinsic work motivation, emotional exhaustion and turnover intention:A multisample longitudinal study.Journal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology,76,427-450.
15. Hsu, M.Y.(2003).A mixed methods study of hospital nurses' quality of working life in Taiwan.United Kingdom:University of Ulster.
16. Hugonnet, S.,Chevrolet, J.C.,Pittet, D.(2007).The effects of workload on infection risk in critically ill patients.Critical Care Medicine,35(1),76-81.
17. Jennings, B.M.,Loan, L.A.,Depaul, D.,Brosch, L.R.,Hildreth, P.(2001).Lessons learned while collecting ANA indicator date.Journal of Nursing Administration,31(3),121-129.
18. Karasek, R.A.,Brisson, C.,Kawakami, N.,Houtman, I.,Bongers, P.,Amick, B.(1998).The job content questionnaire (JCQ) : An instrument for internationally comparative assessments of psychosocial job characteristics.Journal Occupational Health Psychology,3,322-355.
19. Lang, T.A.,Hodge, M.,Olson, V.,Romano, P.S.,Kravitz, R.L.(2004).Nurse-patient ratios: A systematic review on the effects of nurse staffing on patient, nurse employee, and hospital outcomes.The Journal of Nursing Administration,34(7),326-337.
20. Laschinger, H.K.S.,Finegan, J.E.,Shamian, J.,Wilk, P.(2004).A longitudinal analysis of the impact of workplace empowerment on work satisfaction.Journal of Organizational Behavior,25,527-545.
21. Lynn, M.R.,McMillen, B.J.,Sidani, S.(2007).Understanding and measuring patients' assessment of the quality of nursing care.Nursing Research,56(3),159-166.
22. Needleman, J.,Buerhaus, P.,Mattke, S.,Stewart, M.,Zelevinsky, K.(2002).Nurse-staffing levels and the quality of care in hospitals.The New England Journal of Medicine,346(22),1715-1722.
23. Oermann, M.H.,Lambert, J.,Templin, T.(2000).Parents' perceptions of quality health care.American Journal of Maternal Child Nursing,25(5),242-247.
24. Stone, P.W.,Harrison, M.I.,Feldman, P.,Linzer, M.,Peng, T.,Roblin, D.(2005).Organizational Climate of Staff Working Conditions and Safety - An Integrative Model.Advances in Patient Safety,2,467-481.
25. Stone, P.W.,Mooney-Kane, C.,Larson, E.L.,Horan, T.,Glance, L.G.,Zwanziger, J.,Dick, A.W.(2007).Nurse working conditions and patient safety outcomes.Medicine Care,45(6),571-578.
26. Tarnow-Mordi, W.O.,Hau, C.,Warden, A.,Shearer, A. J.(2000).Hospital mortality in relation to staff workload: a 4-year study in an adult intensive-care unit.The Lancet,356(9225),185-189.
27. Ulrich, B.T.,Buerhaus, P.I.,Donelan, K.,Norman, L.,Dittus, R.(2007).Magnet status and registered nurse views of the work environment and nursing as a career.Journal of Nursing Administration,37(5),212-220.
28. Upenieks, V.V.(2002).Assessing differences in job satisfaction of nurses in magnet and nonmagnet hospitals.Journal of Nursing Administration,32(11),564-576.
29. Waltz, C.F.,Strickland, O.L.,Lenz, E.R.(2010).Measurement in Nursing and Health Research.New York:Springer.
30. Yin, J.C.,Yang, K.P.(2002).Nursing turnover in Taiwan: a meta-analysis of related factors.International Journal of Nursing Studies,39(6),537-581.
31. 尹祚芊、林小玲(2009)。醫學中心護理人員工作環境之研究。榮總護理，26(2)，177-187。
32. 尹裕君(2008)。護理人力、病人安全與護理品質。榮總護理，25(4)，350-355。
33. 余玉眉(2006)。護理人力基本資料建立的重要性。95年度行政院會生署護理人力資源管理資訊系統建置研討會，台北:
34. 李選、白香菊、顏文娟(2008)。台灣地區護理人員執業環境之現況調查。護理雜誌，55(4)，30-40。
35. 李選、張婷(2011)。以病人安全為服務導向之護理倫理議題。澄清醫護，7(4)，4-10。
36. 林秋芬、盧美秀、鍾春枝(2007)。護理品質指標之建構。長庚護理，18(4)，465-474。
37. 張慶南(2007)。台北，長榮大學護理學研究所。

1. 劉棻,陳麗娟,張怡菁(2021)。資深臨床護理人員工作感受及其相關因素探討。長庚護理，32(3)，14-28。
2. 盧幸茹、鄭雅珍、鄭文瑛、許月麗、朱翠萍(2017)。利用技術混合照護模式降低護理人員臨床照護負荷改善專案。長庚護理，28(3)，450-462。