题名

Genre and Text-Type: Putting Discourses Together

并列篇名

類型與本文型態:論述統整

DOI

10.7084/LIS.200406.0143

作者

Winifred Crombie;Diane Johnson

关键词

類型 ; 本文形態 ; Genre ; Text-type

期刊名称

語文與國際研究

卷期/出版年月

1期(2004 / 06 / 01)

页次

143 - 175

内容语文

英文

中文摘要

本論文分析大量學術性論文,針對「類型」(Genre)與「本文型態」(Text一Type)兩者之異同出初步研究發現“「類型」(包括說明與報告)在類別與認知過程互動上均具有其特定性,並展現其模式“其中,說明性類型與辯論性類型之首要差異在於後者具有極為強大之基礎與結論問之相互關係外,本論文也指出「本文形態」(包括學術性論文)與特定的宏觀模式相關,其中又可分為兩種學術文。一者,除提供資訊外,並著重詮釋;傾向於呈現普遍與特定之間(主題一規則一實例)的整構。二者,除提供資訊外,著重於問題解答;傾向於呈現問題解決模式的整體架構。

英文摘要

This article reports the preliminary findings of a research project involving the analysis of a large number of academic articles. It is proposed here that genres (such as explaining and reporting) can be related to particular types and interactions of cognitive process. They typically exhibit patterns of relationship that can be associated with these cognitive processes. Thus a primary difference between the explanation genre and the argument genre appears to relate to the preponderance of grounds-conclusion relationships in the latter. It is also proposed here that text-types (such as academic articles) can be related to particular types of macropattern. A primary difference between academic articles which report on information and emphasise explanation and academic articles which report on information and emphasise problem resolution is that the former tend to have an overall structure of General-Particular (Topic-Restriction-Illustration), whereas the latter tend to have an overall Problem-Solution structure.

主题分类 人文學 > 語言學
人文學 > 外國文學
参考文献
  1. Atkinson, J. M.,Drew, P.(1979).Order in court: The organisation of verbal interaction in judicial settings.London:Macmillan.
  2. Atkinson, J. M.,Heritage, J. (eds.)(1984).Structures of social studies in conversational analysis.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
  3. Ben Amos, D.(1976).Folklore genres.Austin:University of Texas Press.
  4. Connor, U.(1996).Contrastive rhetoric. Cross cultural aspects of second language writing.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
  5. Croce, B.,D. Ainslee. (Trans.)(1968).Aesthetic.New York:Doonday.
  6. Crombie, W. H.(1985).Process and language learning: a relational approach to syllabus design.Oxford:Oxford University Press.
  7. Crombie, W. H.(1987).Free verse and prose style.London:Croom Helm.
  8. Crombie, W. H.(1985).Process and relation in discourse and language learning.Oxford:Oxford University Press.
  9. Crookes, G.(1986).Towards a validated analysis of scientific text structure.Applied Linguistics,7(1),57-70.
  10. Crookes, G.(1985).Occasional Paper No. 4.Honolulu:Department of English as a Second Language, University of Hawaii at Manoa.
  11. Derewianka, B.(1994).Exploring how texts work.Sydney:Primary English Teaching Association.
  12. Drew P.,Heritage, J.(1992).Talk at work.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
  13. Dubrow, H.(1982).Genre.London:Methuen.
  14. Freedman, A.,Medway, P.(1994).Learning and teaching genre.Portsmouth:Boynton/Cook.
  15. Grimm, J.,Grimm, W.(1891).Deutsche Sagen.Berlin:
  16. Halliday, M.A.K.(1973).Exploration in the functions of language.London:Edward Arnold.
  17. Hoey, M.(1983).On the surface of discourse.London:George Allen & Unwin.
  18. Hume, D.(1911).A Treatise of Human Nature.London:Dent.
  19. Iser, W.(1978).The act of reading: A theory of aesthetic response.Baltimore:John Hopkins Press.
  20. Kehler, A.(2002).Coherence, reference and the theory of grammar.Stanford, California:Center for the Study of Language and Information.
  21. Knapp, P.,Watkins, M.(1994).Context-text-grammar: Teaching the genres and grammar of school writing in infants and primary classrooms.Sydney:Text Productions.
  22. Kress, G.(1989).Linguistic processes in sociocultural practice.Oxford:Oxford University Press.
  23. Lechte, J.(1994).Fifty key contemporary thinkers. From structuralism to postmodernity.London:Routledge.
  24. Lotman, Y.(1997).The structure of the artistic text.Ann Arbor:University of Michigan Press.
  25. Malinwoski, B.(1935).Coral gardens and their magic.London:George Allen and Unwin.
  26. Malinwoski, B..The magic of language and gardening.Bloomington, Ind.:Indiana University Press.
  27. Martin, J. R.(1995).Text and clause: fractal resonance.Text,15(1),5-42.
  28. Martin, J. R.(1986).Working papers in linguistics.Sydney:Dept of Linguistics, University of Sydney.
  29. Martin, J. R.(1989).Factual writing: exploring and challenging social reality.Oxford:Oxford University Press.
  30. Martin, J. R.(1992).English text. System and structure.Amsterdam:John Benjamins.
  31. Martin, J. R.(1991).Intrinsic functionality: implications for contextual theory.Social Semiotics,1(1),99-162.
  32. Martin, J. R. (eds.),C. Painter(1986).Intervening in the process of writing development.Writing to mean: teaching genres across tthe curriculum.
  33. Martin, J. R.,F. Christie (ed)(1984).Language Studies: Children`s writing: Reader.Geelong:Deakin University Press.
  34. Martin, J. R.,J.D. Benson,W.S. Greaves (eds.)(1985).Systemic perspectives on discourse.Norwood, N.J.:Ablex.
  35. Martin, J. R.,J.S. Petofi,E. Sozer (eds.)(1983).Micro and macro connexity of texts.Hamburg:Helmet Buske Verlag.
  36. Martin, J. R.,M. A. K. Halliday(1993).Writing Science: Literacy and discursive power.London:Falmer Press.
  37. Martin, J. R.,Peters, P.,R. Hasan (ed.)(1985).Discourse on discourse.Wollongong:Applied Linguistic Association of Australia.
  38. Martin, J. R.,Rothery, J.(1981).Writing Project Report No. 2.Working papers in linguistics.
  39. Martin, J. R.,Rothery, J.(1980).Writing Project Report. No. 1.Working papers in linguistics.
  40. Martin, J. R.,Rothery, J.,B. Couture (ed.)(1986).Functional approaches to writing.Norwood:N.J. Ablex.
  41. Martin, J. R.,T. Threadgold,E.A. Grosz,G. Kress,M.A.K. Halliday (eds.)(1986).Grammaticalising ecology: the politics of baby seals and Kangaroos.Semiotics, ideology, and language. Sydney studies in society and culture,3,225-267.
  42. McHoul, A.(1978).The organisation of turns at formal talk in the classroom.Language in Society,7,183-213.
  43. Olrik, A.(1992).Principles of oral narrative research.Bloomington:Indiana University Press.
  44. Oring, E.(ed)(1986).Folk groups and folklore genres.Logan:Utah State University Press.
  45. Propp, V. I.,L. Scott. (trans.)(1928).The morphology of the folktale.Austin:University of Texas Press.
  46. Swales, J.(1990).Genre analysis.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
  47. Swales, J.(1981).Aspects of article introductions.Aston ESP Research Reports, No 1.
  48. Swales, J.,Najjar, H.(1987).The writing of research writing article introductions.Written Communication,4,175-191.
  49. Willey, B.,Buckley, V.,T. S. Eliot,F. R. Leavis.(1959).Poetry and Morality: Studies on the criticism of Matthew Arnold.London:Chatto and Windus.