梁楷《八高僧圖》繪畫探究

A study of the Eight famous Monks of the Liang (502-534) and Tang (618-906) Dynasties by Liang Kai

10.29480/CPAR.200904.0001

陳俊吉(Chun-Chi Chen)

樑楷 ； 八高僧圖 ； Liang Kai ； the Eight famous Monks of the Liang and Tang Dynasties

藝術論文集刊

12期（2009 / 04 / 01）

1 - 27

繁體中文

《八高僧圖》現在兩岸學者多認為梁楷早期精細風格的真跡，但畫面傳達出的訊息總是令人困惑，真的出自梁楷之手嗎？大陸與台灣學者大都以畫面有梁楷簽名、及清高宗題名為《宋人畫八高僧故實》，以此認為是宋畫梁楷真跡無疑，筆者對此感到十分的困惑。筆者對於此《八高僧圖》是否出於梁楷真跡感到懷疑，將對此幅畫作仔細比對，配合文獻資料的佐證，以還原其歷史接近歷史原貌。根據探討分析比對的結果，此幅畫作並非出自梁楷之手。原因有畫面風格前後不一致、落款偽造、畫面裁切裝裱處理、畫面風格不符南宋時代風氣…等。而經筆者的探討分析，認為此畫作極有可能是明代的作品。

Most of the Mainland China and Taiwan scholars considered the Eight famous Monks of the Liang and Tang Dynasties was painted by Liang Kai in the Song dynasty. Their reasons are as follows: 1. There is the signature of Liang Kai in the painting. 2. Because the signature of Liang Kai was too small, Qing Gaozong didn't find. Qing Gaozong thought the painting was painted by an unknown painter in the Song dynasty. But the composition of the painting shows features quite different from the widely accepted Liang Kai style. Therefore the study intends to discuss the real author of the painting. In order to find out the authorship of the painting, the study not only explores the autistic style of the painting, but also leads some textual research related to the painting. The study found that the Eight famous Monks of the Liang and Tang Dynasties was not painted by Liang Kai. The reasons being the following: 1. The painting was not done by one single painter. 2. The signature of Liang Kai was forged. 3. The composition of the painting had been cut and then reorganized. 4. The painting style does not correspond to the painting style of the Southern Song dynasty. The author thinks that it is very likely that the Eight famous Monks of the Liang and Tang Dynasties was painted in the Ming dynasty.

1. (1993)。中國名畫鑑賞辭典。上海:上海辭書出版社。
2. 上海書畫出版社編(2003)。僧佛羅漢─國寶在線。上海:上海書畫出版社。
3. 于安瀾(1994)。畫史叢書。台北:文史哲出版社。
4. 于安瀾(1994)。畫史叢書。台北:文史哲出版社。
5. 王靜靈(2006)。〈東籬高士〉的風格與圖像─兼談梁楷「精妙之筆」的問題。故宮文物，208
6. 四川大學古籍整理研究所(2004)。宋集珍本叢刊。北京:線裝書局。
7. 立中(2005)。從細筆畫到減筆畫─論梁楷畫風的轉戾。紫禁城，2005(增刊期)
8. 沈以正(1996)。梁楷在繪畫史中的重要性。美育，77
9. 俞崑編(1984)。中國畫論類編。台北:華正書局。
10. 俞崑編(2003)。中國畫論類編。台北:華正書局。
11. 柯基生(2003)。千載金蓮風華─纏足文物展。台北:歷史博物館。
12. 柯基生(1995)。三寸金蓮─奧秘‧魅力‧禁忌。台北:產業情報雜誌社。
13. 洪修平(1999)。禪宗思想的形成與發展。台北縣:佛光文化事業有限公司。
14. 孫曉光(2005)。論梁楷及他的繪畫藝術。通話師范學院學報，26(3)
15. 張照輯(2004)。秘殿珠林石渠寶笈匯編。北京:新華書店。
16. 陳階晉編、賴毓芝編(2008)。追索浙派。台北:國立故宮博物院。
17. 鄔國寶(2005)。真性樹新風─對梁楷繪畫風格的解讀。美與時代，2005(9)
18. 劉心武(1995)。小腳與辮子。台北:幼獅文化事業公司。
19. 談錫永(1979)。梁楷及八高僧故實圖卷。藝術家，50
20. 謝稚柳(1998)。《梁楷全集》序。中國古代書畫研究十論，上海:
21. 嚴雅美(2000)。潑墨仙人圖研究─兼論宋元禪宗繪畫。台北:法鼓文化事業股份有限公司。

1. 陳俊吉(2011)。元代顏輝於畫史上定位與評價之探討。書畫藝術學刊，11，147-182。