A History of Saimin Soup Noodle in Hawaii: Ethnic Marker or Local Identity?

淺談夏威夷Saimin湯麵的歷史：族群標記或在地認同？

日野みどり(Midori HINO)

Hawaii ； saimin ； origin of food ； Chinese ； Japanese ； 夏威夷 ； saimin ； 食物的起源 ； 中國人 ； 日本人

中國飲食文化

15卷1期（2019 / 04 / 01）

79 - 121

英文

Saimin is a 'soup noodle unique to Hawaii,' says Arnold Hiura, writer of Hawaiian food history. Being popular on the Hawaiian Islands for more than 100 years, it started in the early 20th century among immigrant Asian laborers on sugar plantations. To this day, saimin can be frequently consumed in small noodle shops, or found in home cooking. Whereas the name saimin appears to come from Cantonese, this popular dish has been sold not exclusively by Chinese immigrants, but also often by ethnic Japanese. Today Hawaiian residents widely recognize saimin as ＂local,＂ ＂comfort＂ food, and care less about its ethnic origins. Saimin has such a long history as an important part of the local food culture and tradition, yet it is almost never heard of outside of the islands, for reasons in part because no serious or academic studies could be located. This paper is the result of fieldwork and literature searches over the past three years; and presents new findings about saimin's development in Hawaiian history, as well as its symbolic meanings in a dynamic multi-ethnic society of immigrants. Recent theoretical discourses in food studies often are concerned with the question of ＂origin＂ or ＂authenticity＂ of a popular food with a long history. This paper begins to investigate such questions about saimin. However, at the end we discovered that it is not an issue among different ethnic groups in Hawaii. It is more important for people in Hawaii to value becoming a proud member of the ＂local＂ Hawaiian community, and to share a common local food tradition in a multi-cultural society without a majority ethnic population.

Saimin是「夏威夷特有的湯麵」，一百多年以來很受夏威夷居民的歡迎，據說自20世紀初由在甘蔗田裡做工的亞洲移民勞工非常愛吃開始。現時的saimin，人們常在小麵館消費，也在家裡煮食。雖然saimin這個名稱來自廣東話（細麵），但這種麵並不只有中國移民販賣銷售，而日本後裔也是主要的供應者。今天，當地居民普遍認為saimin是「本地」、「令人懷舊的舒適」食品，並不太注重其起源屬於哪個族群。Saimin雖然作為當地飲食文化傳統很重要的一部分，有長久歷史，但夏威夷以外的人幾乎完全沒有機會知曉，部分原因恐怕是沒有人認真作過關於這個湯麵的學術研究。本篇論文通過3年來的田野調查和文獻研究，闡明有關saimin的新發現，包括saimin在夏威夷的歷史發展、以及它如何代表由多元移民組成的社會動態的象徵意義。近年來飲食文化研究的理論話語，往往注重關於要界定某些歷史悠久食物的「起源」或「正宗性」的問題。本篇論文以saimin為對象進行調查，起先準備找出其答案。然而，我們卻發現，這個問題對夏威夷的各個族群並不重要；而在夏威夷，人們認為更重要的是每一個在當地紮根的居民均樂於成為夏威夷「在地」社區的驕傲成員，而在多元文化社會裡分享共同的當地飲食傳統。

1. Wu, David Y. H.(2008).All You Can Eat Buffet: The Evolution of Chinese Cuisine in Hawaii.Journal of Chinese Dietary Culture,4(1),1-24.
   連結：
2. “American Community Survey 2016.” (ACS_16_1YR_DP_county_all, ACS_16_1YR_DP_state_all) Department of Business, Economic Development & Tourism, http://census.hawaii.gov/acs/acs-2016/, accessed 2018/6/4.
3. “HI Steaks Menu: Steaks, Sauces and Sides.” HI Steaks, http://www.histeaks.com/ menu/, accessed 2018/6/7.
4. “How Sun Noodle's Saimin Became Hawaii's Favorite Noodle.” Cooking in America (season 1, episode 5), 2017/2/21, https://youtu.be/HtZZYhCCfKo, accessed 2018/5/22.
5. “Top quality grilled steak in Hawaii - HI Steaks.” HI Steaks, http://www.histeaks.com/, accessed 2018/6/7.
6. “History.” Sun Noodle, http://sunnoodle.com/about/history/, accessed 2018/5/22.
7. “End of an era: Hawaii's last sugar mill wraps up final harvest.” Honolulu Star Advertiser, December 12, 2016, http://www.staradvertiser.com/2016/12/12/business/business-breaking/end-of-an-era-hawaiis-last-sugar-mill-wraps-up-final-harvest/, accessed 2017/1/5.
8. Ashman, Mike(2004).Kauai: As It Was in the 1940s and ’50s.Lihue, Kauai, HI:The Kauai Historical Society.
9. Carr, Elizabeth Ball(1972).Da Kine Talk: From Pidgin to Standard English in Hawaii.Honolulu, HI:The University Press of Hawai.
10. Corum, Ann Kondo(1987).Hawaii's SPAMⓇ Cookbook.Honolulu, HI:Bess Press.
11. Corum, Ann Kondo(1983).Ethnic Foods of Hawai‘i.Honolulu, HI:Bess Press.
12. Corum, Ann Kondo(2000).Ethnic Foods of Hawai‘i.Honolulu, HI:Bess Press.
13. Errington, Frederick,Gewertz, Deborah,Fujikura, Tatsuro(2013).The Noodle Narratives: The Global Rise of an Industrial Food into the Twenty-First Century.CA:University of California Press.
14. Fasone, Cara. n.d. “Saimin Soup for the Soul.” Hawaiian Culture Stories, http://www.hawaiian-culture-stories.com/saimin.html, accessed 2017/10/09.
15. Fojas, Camilla(ed.),Guevarra, Rudy P., Jr.(ed.),Sharma, Nitasha Tamar(ed.)(2018).Beyond Ethnicity: New Politics of Race in Hawaiʻi.Honolulu, HI:University of Hawaiʻi Press.
16. Fujimori, Leila. 2002. “AIKO HAMURA / 1910-2002 Saimin shop co-founder created Kauai institution with hard work.” Star Bulletin, January 27, http://archives.starbulletin.com/2002/01/27/news/story10.html, accessed 2016/12/ 18.
17. Glick, Clarence E.(1980).Sojourners and Setters: Chinese Migrants in Hawaii.Honolulu, HI:Hawaii Chinese History Center.
18. Hiura, Arnold(2009).Kau Kau: Cuisine & Culture in the Hawaiian Islands.Honolulu, HI:Watermark Publishing.
19. Holmes, Bob,Wood, Paul(2001).Escape to the Hawaiian Islands.New York, NY:Fodor's Travel Publications.
20. Hutchins, Feng Feng(2010).Plenty Saimin.Hawaii:Island Paradise Publishing.
21. Kirkendall, Judith M.(1985).Honolulu,University of Hawai‘i.
22. Kirkendall, Judith M.(2010).Eating History: Chinese American Gastronomy in Hawaii.Chinese America: History and Perspectives, The Journal of the Chinese Historical Society of America,123-132.
23. Kodama-Nishimoto, Michi(ed.),Nishimoto, Warren S(ed.),Oshiro, Cynthis A.(ed.)(1984).Hanahana: An Oral History Anthology of Hawaii's Working People.Honolulu, HI:Ethnic Studies Oral History Project, University of Hawaii at Manoa.
24. Kushner, Barak(2012).Slurp!: A Social and Culinary History of Ramen, Japan's Favorite Noodle Soup.Leiden:Global OrientalGlobal Oriental.
25. Laudan, Rachel(1996).The Food of Paradise: Exploring Hawaii's Culinary Heritage.Honolulu, HI:University of Hawai‘i Press.
26. Matsuo, Shiro,Sherman, Eddie(ed.),Chapman, Don(ed.)(1999).Dear Hearts: Common Sense + Realistic Thinking (with a tickle of humor): The Wit & Wisdom of Shiro "Mistah Saimin" Matsuo.Honolulu, HI:Love Me Too as I Love You Publishing.
27. McDermott, John F.(ed.),Andrade, Naleen Naupaka(ed.)(2011).People and Cultures of Hawaiʻi: The Evolution of Culture and Ethnicity.Honolulu, HI:University of Hawaiʻi Press.
28. Miura, Muriel,Mōʻiliʻili Community Center(1997).The Tastes and Tales of Mōʻiliʻili.Honolulu, HI:Mutual Publishing.
29. Ng, Franklin(2010).“Food and Culture: Chinese Restaurants in Hawaii.Chinese America: History and Perspectives, The Journal of the Chinese Historical Society of America,113-122.
30. Nichols, Katherine. 2006. “Hamura's Wins National Award.” Star Bulletin, April 30, http://archives.starbulletin.com/2006/04/30/news/story04.html, accessed 2016/12/18.
31. Okamura, Jonathan Y.(2014).From Race to Ethnicity: Interpreting Japanese American Experiences in Hawaiʻi.Honolulu, HI:University of Hawaiʻi Press.
32. Okamura, Jonathan Y.(2008).Ethnicity and Inequality in Hawaiʻi.Philadelphia, PA:Temple University Press.
33. Roth, William M. and Jane Swinerton. n.d. [first edition 1938] The Epicure in Hawaii. San Francisco, CA: Colt Press.
34. Solt, George(2014).The Untold History of Ramen: How Political Crisis in Japan Spawned a Global Food Craze.Berkeley, CA:University of California Press.
35. The Honolulu Advertiser(1985).Taste of Hawaii.Indianapolis, IN:News Books International, Inc..
36. Tranquada, Jim,King, John(2012).The ‘Ukulele: A History.Honolulu, HI:University of Hawai‘i Press.

1. 陳建源(2023)。刺激與調和：初探日本飲食中的「辣」。民俗曲藝，219，69-116。
2. 郭忠豪(2020)。傳說與滋味：追尋臺灣「三杯雞」菜餚之演變。中國飲食文化，16(1)，9-53。