翻轉課堂教學對學習成效影響之後設分析

A Meta-Analysis Study of the Impact for the Flipped Classroom Teaching on Learning Outcomes

10.6235/TVE.201712_7(3).0002

曾明山(Meng-Shan Tseng)；李懿芳(Yi-Fang Lee)

翻轉課堂教學 ； 後設分析 ； 學習成效 ； flipped classroom teaching ； meta-analysis ； learning outcomes

技術及職業教育學報

7卷3期（2017 / 12 / 01）

21 - 43

繁體中文

近年來翻轉課堂教學模式發展迅速受到教育界的高度重視，此模式將傳統由教師於課堂上單向傳授知識的教學方式，轉換由學生於課前主動自學，在課堂上則透過老師引導與提問，進行師生或同儕間的討論與問題解決，成效頗受肯定。本研究旨在運用後設分析法（meta-analysis），對相關實徵研究資料進行客觀及計量性的分析，以瞭解翻轉課堂教學對於學生學習成效的影響。研究者從Web of Science和EBSCOhost-Academic Search Premier等資料庫進行搜尋，挑選符合研究主題並具有充足的實徵數據之文獻為分析樣象，共計13篇；採用Comprehensive Meta-Analysis軟體分析各篇文章之Hedges' g效應值，並進行出版偏誤、異質性考驗、累積分析、敏感度分析及次群體分析等，以考驗各項研究之間是否存在異質性及出版性偏誤等問題。根據研究結果指出，翻轉課堂教學對於學生的學習成效具有正向的效應，整體效應值為0.822，意即翻轉課堂教學模式對於情意及學業成就的提升，多數優於傳統講述式教學法。

The flipped-classroom has been promoted in recent years and quickly became a popular teaching model in the world. The model reverses traditional teaching where students gain exposure of material outside of class by reading textbook or watching videos before class; then class time is used to doing problem-solving, discussion, or debates leading by teachers. The purpose of this study was to understand the impacts of this teaching method based on the existing empirical studies. A meta-analysis approach was performed to synthesize quantitative research that investigated the effects of flipped classroom teaching on learning outcomes. The target studies were selected primarily from Web of Science and EBSCOhost-Academic Search Premier and resulted in 13 paper fitted in the criteria. Comprehensive Meta-Analysis software was used to analyze the effects of publication bias, heterogeneity tests, cumulative analysis, sensitivity analysis, and subgroup analysis within the study. The results demonstrated that flipped classroom model provided considerable benefits than traditional instruction did on students' learning outcomes (effect size = 0.822). To the end, the notable suggestions and limitations of this study were discussed.

1. CHEA (2006). Special Report: Accreditation and Accountability. Retrieve from: http://www.chea.org/pdf/Accreditation_and_Accountability.pdf
2. Fisher, R. A. (1932). Statistical methods for research workers. London, England: Oliver & Boyd.
3. 田美雲（2013）。「翻轉教室」（Flipped Classroom）介紹。國立臺灣大學教學發展中心電子報，71。取自http://ctld.ntu.edu.tw/_epaper/news_detail.php?nid=452
4. 劉伊霖（2012）。Flipped classroom 徹底顛覆你的思維。數位學習品質服務中心，取自http://www.elq.org.tw/notes_detail.php?info3_id=55
5. 廖怡慧（2012）。教學新思維-翻轉課堂。耕教與學電子報，31。取自http://www.teachers.fju.edu.tw/epapers/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=366&Itemid=369 第三十一期。
6. Classroom window. (2012). Flipped classrooms: Improved test scores and teacher satisfaction. Retrieved from classroomwindow.com/flipped-classrooms-improved-test-scores-and-teacher-satisfaction/
7. Bergmann, J., Overmyer, J., & Wilie, B. (2012). The flipped class: Myths versus reality. The Daily Riff. Retrieved from http://www.thedailyriff.com/articles/the-flipped-class-conversation-689.php.
8. Alliance for Excellent Education. (2012). Culture shift: Teaching in a learner-centered environment powered by digital learning. Retrieved from http://all4ed.org/reports-factsheets/culture-shift-teaching-in-a-learner-centered-environment-powered-by-digital-learning/
9. Baker, J. W.(2000).The "classroom flip": Using web course management tools to become a guide by the side.11th international conference on college teaching and learning,Jackson ville, FL:
10. Beesley, A.(Ed.),Apthorp, H.(Ed.)(2010).Classroom instruction that works, second edition: Research report.Denver, CO:McRel.
11. Bergmann, J.,Sams, A.(2012).Before you flip, consider this.Phi Delta Kappan International,94(2),25.
12. Bishop, J. L.(2013).The flipped classroom: A survey of the research.the 120th American Society for Engineering Education Annual Conference and Exposition
13. Blumberg, P.(2008).Developing learner-centered teachers: A practical guide for faculty.San Francisco:Jossey-Bass.
14. Borenstein, M.,Hedges, L. M.,Higgins, J.,Rothstein, H.(2009).Introduction to Meta-Analysis.A John Wiley and Sons, Ltd.
15. Borenstein, M.,Hedges, L. V.,Higgins J.,Rothstein, H.(2007).Comprehensive meta-analysis.Englewood, NJ:Biostst.
16. Bruff, D. O.,Fisher, D. H.,McEwen, K. E.,Smith, B. E.(2013).Wrapping a MOOC: Student perceptions of an experiment in blended learning.Journal of Online Learning and Teaching,9,187.
17. Cohen, J.(1988).Statistical power analysis for the behavior sciences.New York:Academic Press.
18. Cooper, H. M.(2010).Research synthesis and meta-analysis: A step-by-step approach.Thousand Oaks, CA:Sage.
19. Cooper, H.(ed.),Hedges, L. V.(ed.),Valentine, J. C.(ed.)(2009).The handbook of research synthesis and meta-analysis.New York:Russell Sage Foundation.
20. Cornelius, S.,Gordon, C.(2008).Providing a flexible, learner-centered programme: Challenges for educators.Internet and Higher Education,11,33-41.
21. Davies, R.(2011).Understanding technology literacy: A framework for evaluating educational technology integration.TechTrends,55(5),45-52.
22. Davies, R. S.,Dean, D. L.,Ball, N.(2013).Flipping the classroom and instructional technology integration in a college-level information systems spreadsheet course.Educational Technology Research and Development,61(4),563-580.
23. Fulton, K.(2012).Upside down and inside out: Flip your classroom to improve student learning.Learning& Leading with Technology,39(8),12-17.
24. Fulton, K. P.(2012).10 reasons to flip.New Styles of Instruction,94(2),20-24.
25. Glass, G. V.(1976).Primary, secondary, and meta-analysis of research.Educational Research,5,3-8.
26. Glass, G. V.,McGaw, B.,Smith, M. L.(1981).Meta-analysis in social research.Beverly Hills, CA:Sage.
27. Hattie, J.(2008).Visible learning: A synthesis of over 800 meta-analyses relating to achievement.New York:Routledge.
28. He, Y.,Swenson, S.,Lents, N.(2012).Online video tutorials increase learning of difficult concepts in an undergraduate analytical chemistry course.Journal of Chemical Education,89,1128-1132.
29. Hedges, L. V.,Olkin, I.(1985).Statistical methods for meta-analysis.New York:Academic Press.
30. Hill, J. L.,Nelson, A.(2011).New technology, new pedagogy? Employing video podcasts in learning and teaching about exotic ecosystems.Environmental Education Research,17,393-408.
31. Holbrook, J.,Dupont, C.(2010).Making the decision to provide enhanced podcasts to post-secondary science students.Journal of Science Education and Technology,20,233-245.
32. Hunter, J. E.,Schmidt, F. L.(2004).Methods of meta-analysis: Correcting error and bias in research findings.Thousand Oaks, CA:Sage.
33. Hunter, J. E.,Schmidt, F. L.,Jackson, G. B.(1982).Meta-analysis: Cumulating research findings across studies.Beverly Hills, CA:Sage.
34. Jamaludin, R.(2014).The use of a flipped classroom to enhance engagement and promote active learning.Journal of Education and Practice,5(2),124-131.
35. Kay, R.,Kletskin, I.(2012).Evaluating the use of problem-based video podcasts to teach mathematics in higher education.Computers & Education,59,619-627.
36. Keefe, J.(2007).What is personalization?.Phi Delta Kappan,89(3),217-223.
37. Khan, S.(2012).The one world schoolhouse: Education reimagined.London:Hodder and Stoughton.
38. Larson, S.,Yamamotom, J.(2013).Flipping the college spreadsheet skills classroom: initial empirical results.Journal of Emerging Trends in Computing and Information Sciences,4,10.
39. Mason, G.,Shuman, T. R.,Cook, K. E.(2013).Comparing the effectiveness of an inverted classroom to a traditional classroom in an upper-division engineering course.Journal of IEEE Transactions on Education,56(4),430-435.
40. McLaughlin, J. E.(2014).The flipped classroom: A course redesign to foster learning and engagement in a health professions school.Journal of Academic Medicine,89(2),236-43.
41. McLaughlin, J. E.,Griffin, L. M.,Esserman, D. A.,Davidson, C. A.,Glatt, D. M.,Roth, M. T.,Gharkholonarehe, N.,Mumper, R. J.(2013).Pharmacy student engagement, performance, and perception in a flipped satellite classroom.Journal of Pharmaceutical Education,77(9),196.
42. Missildine, K.,Fountain, R.,Summers, L.,Gosselin, K.(2013).Flipping the classroom to improve student performance and satisfaction.Journal of Nursing Education,52,10.
43. Patterson, G. A.(2012).An interview with michael horn: Blending education for high-octane motivation.Phi Delta Kappan,94(2),14-18.
44. Pierce, R.,Fox, J.(2012).Podcasts and active-learning exercises in a "flipped classroom" model of a renal pharmacotherapy module.Journal of American Journal of Pharmaceutical Education,76(10),196.
45. Rosenthal, R.(1991).Meta-analytic procedures for social research.Beverly Hills, CA:Sage.
46. Rosenthal, R.(1979).The file drawer problem and tolerance for null results.Psychological Bulletin,86(3),638-641.
47. Ruddick, K. W.(2012).University of Memphis.
48. Sams, A.,Bergmann, J.(2013).Flip your students' learning.Educational Leadership,70(6),16-20.
49. Strayer, J.(2012).How learning in an inverted classroom influences cooperation, innovation and task orientation.Learning Environments Research,5(2),171-193.
50. Talley, C. P.,Scherer, S.(2013).The enhanced flipped classroom- increasing Academic performance with student-recorded lectures and practice testing in a flipped STEM course.The Journal of Negro Education,82(3),339-347.
51. Tune, J. D.,Sturek, M.,Basile, D. P.(2013).Flipped classroom model improves graduate student performance in cardiovascular, respiratory, and renal physiology.Physiology Education,37(4),316-320.
52. Wilson, S. G.(2013).A method to address the challenges of an undergraduate statistics course.Journal of Teaching of Psychology,40(3),193-199.
53. Zappe, S.,Leicht, R.,Messner, J.,Litzinger, T.,Lee, H.(2009)."Flipping" the classroom to explore active learning in a large undergraduate course.Proceedings of the 2009 American Society for Engineering Education Annual Conference and Exhibition
54. 李茂能(2014)。整合軟體CAM 簡介與操作實務。台北:五南。
55. 張明玲譯、Cooper, Harris(2013)。研究統合與後設分析。臺北市:揚智文化。
56. 莊其穆(2011)。臨床醫師如何閱讀統合分析（Meta-analysis）的論文。臺灣醫界，54(2)，18-26。
57. 黃政傑(2014)。翻轉教室的理念、問題與。臺灣教育評論月刊，3(12)，161-186。
58. 黃寶園、林世華(2002)。合作學習對學習效果之影響：統合分析。國立臺灣師範大學教育心理學報，34(1)，21-42。
59. 廖遠光、許宛琪(2010)。以創造思考教學提升學生學習成效之後設分析。教育研究月刊，199，23-31。
60. 應立志、鍾燕宜(2001)。整合分析方法與應用。臺灣:華泰文化。

1. 賴阿福,鄭益華(2020)。翻轉教室模式下同儕教導對高職生電腦軟體應用技能之學習態度及學習成就影響。課程與教學，23(4)，89-126。
2. 林哲立(2021)。Examining Teachers' Acceptance of Flipped Learning by Using Technology Acceptance Model。數位學習科技期刊，13(4)，27-61。
3. (2020)。德國技職教育制度之暢通性對我國技職教育實現社會正義與適性發展之啟示。比較教育，88，1-46。