题名

問題本位學習對學生學業成就與高層次思考能力影響之後設分析

并列篇名

The Effect of PBL on Student Academic Achievement and Higher-Order Thinking Ability: A Meta-Analysis

DOI

10.6151/CERQ.2013.2104.01

作者

廖遠光(Yuen-Kuang Liao)；張澄清(Cheng-Ching Chang)

关键词

問題本位學習 ； 問題導向學習 ； 後設分析 ； 學業成就 ； 高層次思考能力 ； PBL ； problem-based learning ； meta-analysis ； academic achievement ； higher-order thinking ability

期刊名称

當代教育研究季刊

卷期/出版年月

21卷4期（2013 / 12 / 01）

页次

1 - 40

内容语文

繁體中文
中文摘要

本研究透過系統化的文獻分析探討問題本位學習（PBL）對學生學業成就及高層次思考能力的影響。本研究以後設分析法分析了國內PBL成效相關研究共67篇（學業成就計有45篇、高層次思考能力則為31篇），結果顯示PBL對於學生學業成就及高層次思考能力具有顯著地正向效應，整體效應量（ES）分別為0.41及0.70。本研究進一步發現，學業成就會受到兩個調節變項（學科領域及教學期間）之調節作用而呈現差異；高層次思考能力則會受到七個調節變項（學習階段、學科領域、PBL類型、數位平台與教材、教學期間、評量方式、及能力類型）之調節作用而呈現差異。
英文摘要

This study examines the effects of problem-based learning (PBL) on students' academic achievement and higher-order thinking abilities through a systematic review of existing literature in Taiwan. A meta-analysis of 67 studies (45 studies for the academic achievement, and 31 for higher-order thinking abilities) indicated statistically significant positive effects of PBL on academic achievement (ES = 0.41) and higher-order thinking abilities (ES = 0.70). In addition, two moderator variables (i.e., subject area and during of treatment) selected for examining students' academic achievement, and seven moderator variables (i.e., grade level, subject area, type of PBL, digital platform and instructional materials, during of treatment, method of evaluation, and type of ability) selected for examining students' higher-order thinking abilities had a statistically significant impact on the mean ES.
主题分类 社會科學 > 教育學
参考文献
  1. 教育部（2004）。國民教育社群網─九年一貫課程綱要。2009 年 12 月15 日，取自：http://teach.eje.edu.tw/9CC/[Ministryof Education. (2004). Taiwan elementary and secondary educator community -- Grade 1-9 curriculum guidelines. Retrieved December 15, 2009, from http://teach.eje.edu.tw/9CC/]
  2. Albanese, M. A.,Mitchell, S.(1993).Problem-based learning: A review of literature on its outcomes and implementation issues.Academic Medicine,68,52-81.
  3. Barrows, H. S.(1985).How to design a problem-based curriculum for the preclinical years.New York:Springer.
  4. Barrows, H. S.(1996).Problem-based learning in medicine and beyond: A brief overview.New Directions for Teaching and Learning,68,3-11.
  5. Baxter, G. P.,Shavelson, R. J.(1994).Science performance assessments: Benchmarks and surrogates.International Journal of Educational Research,21,279-299.
  6. Berkson, L.(1993).Effectiveness of problem-based curricula: Research and theory.Academic Medicine,68,579-588.
  7. Birenbaum, M.(Ed.),Dochy, F.(Ed.)(1996).Alternatives in assessment of achievements, learning processes and prior learning.Boston, MA:Kluwer Academic Press.
  8. Bridges, E. M.(1992).Problem based learning for administrators.Eugene, OR:ERIC Clearinghouse on Educational Management.
  9. Cohen, J.(1988).Statistical power analysis for the behavioral sciences.Hillsdale, NJ:Lawrence Earlbaum Associates.
  10. Colliver, J. A.(2000).Effectiveness of problem-based learning curricula: Research and theory.Academic Medicine,75,259-266.
  11. Dennis, J. K.(2003).Problem-based learning in online vs. face-to-face environments.Education for Health,16,198-209.
  12. Dochy, F.,Segers, M.,Van den Bossche, P.,Gijbels, D.(2003).Effects of problem- based learning: A meta-analysis.Learning and Instruction,13,533-568.
  13. Gallagher, S. A.,Stepien, W. J.(1996).Content acquisition in problem-based learning: Depth versus breadth in American Studies.Journal for the Educational Gifted,19,257-275.
  14. Gijbels, D.,Dochy, F.,Van den Bossche, P.,Segers, M.(2005).Effects of problem-based learning: A meta-analysis from the angle of assessment.Review of Educational Research,75,27-61.
  15. Hartling, L.,Spooner, C.,Tjosvold, L.,Oswald, A.(2010).Problem-based learning in pre-clinical medical education: 22 years of outcome research.Medical Teacher,32,28-35.
  16. Hedges, L.,Olkin, I.(1985).Statistical methods for meta-analysis.San Diego, CA:Academic.
  17. Hmelo, C. E.,Ferrari, M.(1997).The problem-based learning tutorial: Cultivating higher order thinking skills.Journal for the Education of the Gifted,20,401-422.
  18. Jonassen, D. H.(2000).Toward a design theory of problem solving.Educational Technology Research and Development,48(4),63-85.
  19. Maung, M.,Abas, Z. W.,Abdullah, A.(2006).Utilisation of different resources for self-directed learning by students undergoing an integrated problem-based medical curriculum.Journal of Institutional Research in South East Asia,4,17-24.
  20. Michel, M. C.,Bischoff, A.,Jakobs, K. H.(2002).Comparison of problem-and lecture-based pharmacology teaching.Trends in Pharmacological Sciences,23,168-170.
  21. Peters, A. S.,Greenberger-Rosovsky, R.,Crowder, C.,Block, S. D.,Moore, G. T.(2000).Long-term outcomes of the new pathway program at Harvard Medical School: A randomized controlled trial.Academic Medicine,75,470-479.
  22. Rosenthal, R.(1991).Meta-analytic procedures for social research.Newbury Park, CA:Sage.
  23. Schmidt, H. G.,van der Molen, H. T.,Te Winkel, W. W. R.,Wijnen, W. H. F. W.(2009).Constructivist, problem-based learning does work: A meta-analysis of curricular comparisons involving a single medical school.Educational Psychologist,44,227-249.
  24. Segers, M.,Dochy, F.,de Corte, E.(1999).Assessment practices and students' knowledge profiles in a problem-based curriculum.Learning Environments Research,2,191-213.
  25. Sendag, S.,Odabashi, H. F.(2009).Effects of an online problem based learning course on content knowledge acquisition and critical thinking skills.Computers & Education,53,132-141.
  26. Stepien, W. J.,Pyke, S. L.(1997).Designing problem-based units.Journal for the Education of the Gifted,20,380-400.
  27. Strobel, J.,van Barneveld, A.(2009).When is PBL more effective? A meta-synthesis of meta-analyses comparing PBL to conventional classrooms.The Interdisciplinary Journal of Problem-Based Learning,3(1),44-58.
  28. Tiwari, A.,Lai, P.,So, M.,Yuen, K.(2006).A comparison of the effects of problem-based learning and lecturing on the development of students' critical thinking.Medical Education,40,547-554.
  29. Torp, L.,Sage, S.(2002).Problems as possibilities: Problem-based learning for K-16 Education.Alexandria, VA:Association for Supervision & Curriculum Deve.
  30. Udall, A. J.,Daniels, J. E.(1991).Creating the thoughtful classroom.Tucson, AR:Zephyr Press.
  31. Vernon, D. T.,Blake, R. L.(1993).Does problem-based learning work? A meta-analysis of evaluative research.Academic Medicine,68,550-563.
  32. Walker, A.,Leary, H.(2009).A problem based learning meta-analysis: Differences across problem types, implementation types, disciplines, and assessment levels.The Interdisciplinary Journal of Problem-Based Learning,3(1),12-43.
  33. Wirkala, C.,Kuhn, D.(2011).Problem-based learning in K-12 education: Is it effective and how does it achieve its effects?.American Educational Research Journal,48,1157-1186.
  34. 王聰智(2005)。彰化市=Changhua, Taiwan，國立彰化師範大學工業教育與技術學系=Department of Industrial Education and Technology, National Changhua University of Education。
  35. 江鴻仁(2001)。臺中縣=Taichung, Taiwan，靜宜大學應用化學研究所=Graduate Institut of Applied Chemistry, Providence University。
  36. 吳清山(2002)。問題導向學習。教育研究月刊，97，120。
  37. 吳耀明(2008)。嘉義縣=Chiayi, Taiwan，國立嘉義大學國民教育研究所=Graduate Institut of Civil Education, National Chiayi University。
  38. 李志忠(2004)。彰化市=Changhua, Taiwan，國立彰化師範大學工業教育學系=Department of Industrial Education, National Changhua University of Education。
  39. 李欣憶(2006)。臺北市=Taipei, Taiwan，國立臺灣師範大學地理學系=Department of Geography, National Taiwan Normal University。
  40. 李海燕(2010)。苗栗縣=Taichung, Taiwan，國立聯合大學資訊與社會研究所=Institute of Information and Society, National United University。
  41. 李筱雲(2009)。桃園縣=Taoyuan, Taiwan，中原大學教育研究所=Graduate School of Education, Chung Yuan Christian University.。
  42. 沈戊忠(2005)。簡介 PBL 以及在臺灣實施的情形。教育研究月刊，129，40-47。
  43. 林沛萱(2008)。臺北市=Taipei, Taiwan，國立臺灣師範大學科學教育研究所在職進修班=In-service Master's Program in Graduate Institut of Science Education, National Taiwan Normal University。
  44. 林春壬(2009)。高雄市=Kaohsiung, Taiwan，國立高雄師範大學特殊教育學系=Department of Special Education, National Kaohsiung Normal University。
  45. 林詩華(2004)。新竹縣=Hsinchu, Taiwan，國立交通大學理學院網路學習在職專班=In-service Master's Program in Internet learn of College of Science, National Chiao Tung University。
  46. 張淑宜(2007)。臺中市=Taichung, Taiwan，國立臺中教育大學特殊教育學系在職專班=In-service Master's Program in Department of Special Education, National Taichung University of Education。
  47. 莊舒閔(2005)。高雄市=Kaohsiung, Taiwan，國立高雄師範大學科學教育研究所=Graduate Institut of Science Education, National Kaohsiung Normal University。
  48. 陳怡伶(2009)。雲林縣=Yunlin, Taiwan，國立雲林科技大學技術及職業教育研究所=Graduate Institut of Technological and Vocational Education, National Yunlin University of Science and Technology。
  49. 陳玨名(2006)。桃園縣=Taoyuan, Taiwan，中原大學教育研究所=Graduate School of Education, Chung Yuan Christian University。
  50. 陳建樺(2009)。桃園縣=Taoyuan, Taiwan，中原大學教育研究所=Graduate School of Education, Chung Yuan Christian University。
  51. 陳美華(2009)。桃園縣=Taoyuan, Taiwan，中原大學教育研究所=Graduate School of Education, Chung Yuan Christian University。
  52. 陳毓凱(2004)。桃園縣=Taoyuan, Taiwan，中原大學教育研究所=Graduate School of Education, Chung Yuan Christian University。
  53. 陳鼎仁(2003)。彰化縣=Changhua, Taiwan，國立彰化師範大學工業教育學系=Department of Industrial Education, National Changhua University of Education。
  54. 曾孟慧(2006)。桃園縣=Taoyuan, Taiwan，中原大學教育研究所=Graduate School of Education, Chung Yuan Christian University。
  55. 曾婉宜(2007)。桃園縣=Taoyuan, Taiwan，中原大學教育研究所=Graduate School of Education, Chung Yuan Christian University。
  56. 曾鈴惠(2006)。臺北市=Taipei, Taiwan，國立臺北教育大學藝術與藝術教育學系=Department of Arts and Arts Education, Taipei National University of the Arts。
  57. 黃詠順(2008)。桃園縣=Taoyuan, Taiwan，中原大學教育研究所=Graduate School of Education, Chung Yuan Christian University。
被引用次数
  1. 洪雯柔(2019)。探析國際服務學習／實習儲訓課程的問題導向專題學習設計。課程與教學，22(3)，1-30。
  2. 李翠玲(2019)。問題本位學習（PBL）在特殊教育師資培育之意涵與應用初探。特殊教育季刊，153，1-13。
  3. 劉先翔、陳珮驊(2018)。問題導向體育教學對國中學生問題解決能力影響之研究。臺灣運動教育學報，13(2)，41-53。
  4. 楊淳皓(2017)。促進學生主動學習通識課程的教學策略：問題本位學習、專題式學習法與翻轉教室的整合。通識學刊:理念與實務，5(2)，1-40。
  5. 張媛甯(2021)。運用問題導向學習於跨領域學習課程之教學實踐研究。教育理論與實踐學刊，44，1-28。
  6. (2017)。質性研究綜合在教學研究上的運用。教育研究月刊，278，60-78。
  7. (2024)。透過國中STEAM跨域專題導向學習提升學生社會及科學創意問題解決之研究。測驗學刊，71(3)，393-422。
  8. (2024)。問題導向學習結合國家考試雲端系統的教學模式－以公共管理課程為例。中華行政學報，34，37-57。
print cancel