大學生課堂不禮貌行為與品德概念關係之研究

Undergraduate Students' Perceptions of Classroom Incivility and Character Concepts

10.6151/CERQ.2014.2203.04

徐綺穗(Chi-Sui Hsu)；吳佳臻(Chia-Chen Wu)

高等教育 ； 課堂不禮貌行為 ； 品德概念 ； higher education ； classroom incivility ； character concept

當代教育研究季刊

22卷3期（2014 / 09 / 01）

131 - 167

繁體中文

本研究探討大學生對課堂不禮貌行為的知覺與認同，及其與品德概念的關係。在大學生課堂不禮貌行為方面，分為激進型與消極型兩種類型；在品德概念方面，則以尊重、負責、及自律等三個核心價值為主要內涵。研究對象為臺灣之大學生，以六所大學，730名大學生進行調查。研究結果如下：1.大學生知覺消極型課堂不禮貌行為多於激進型課堂不禮貌行為，大學生對課堂不禮貌行為傾向不認同，其中對於激進型行為的不認同更勝於消極型。2.南部大學生較北、中部大學生知覺較多課堂不禮貌行為，其認同度也較低；公立學校大學生對課堂不禮貌行為的認同度低於私立學校大學生；大三學生較大一學生知覺較多課堂不禮貌行為；男、女大學生對課堂不禮貌行為的知覺及認同皆沒有顯著差異。3.大學生在尊重、負責及自律三個分層面的單題得分皆高於平均值。南部大學生品德概念得分高於中、北部大學生；公立學校大學生品德概念得分高於私立學校大學生；男、女不同性別之大學生其品德概念得分無顯著差異。4.大學生對課堂不禮貌行為知覺與其品德概念有顯著正相關，而認同程度則與品德概念呈現負相關。大學生品德整體可以正向預測其對課堂不禮貌行為的知覺；大學生的尊重概念則負向的預測課堂不禮貌行為的認同。

This study explored the perceptions of undergraduate students regarding the frequency and their approval of classroom incivilities, and examined the relation between classroom incivilities (i.e., passive and active incivilities) and character concepts (i.e., respect, responsibility, and self-discipline). The participants comprised 730 undergraduate students from 6 universities in Taiwan. The findings are as follows: (a) The students perceived more passive classroom incivilities compared with active classroom incivilities; they disapproved of all incivilities, but particularly disapproved of active incivilities. (b) The students in Southern Taiwan perceived more uncivil behaviors in class and disapproved of these behaviors more compared with the students in Central and Northern Taiwan, public school students disapproved incivilities more than private school students. Third year students perceived more uncivil behaviors than first year students. No difference occurred in the perceived frequency and approval of classroom incivilities between male and female students. (c) All students attained above average scores regarding the character concepts of respect, responsibility, and self-discipline. Students in Southern Taiwan attained higher scores than students in the Central and Northern Taiwan, public school students higher than private school students, and male and female students exhibited no differences. (d) Student perceptions of classroom incivilities and their frequencies were significantly and positively correlated with student character concepts, but the degree of student approval of classroom incivilities was significantly and negatively coorrelated with these character concepts; thus, student character concepts can predict perceptions of classroom incivilities and the way students conceive respect can negatively predict their approval of classroom incivilities.

1. 李奉儒(2012)。道德意志薄弱及其對於道德教育的啟示。課程與教學，15(2)，1-19。
   連結：
2. 李琪明(2003)。德行取向之品德教育理論與實踐。哲學與文化，351，153-174。
   連結：
3. 簡成熙(2006)。品格教育能夠促進公德嗎。課程與教學季刊，9(2)，13-30。
   連結：
4. Sorcinelli, M. D. (1990). Dealing with troublesome behaviors in the classroom. Workshop and unpublished manuscript presented at University of Massachusetts, Amherst.
5. Alkandari, N.(2011).The level of student incivility: The need of a policy to regulate college student civility.College Student Journal,45,257-268.
6. Altmiller, G.(2012).Student perceptions of incivility in nursing education: Implications for educators.Nursing Education Perspectives,33(1),15-20.
7. Appleby, D. C.(1990).Faculty and student perceptions of irritating behaviors in the college classroom.The Journal of Staff, Program, and Organization Development,8(1),41-46.
8. Berger, B. A.(2000).Incivility.American Journal of Pharmaceutical Education,64,445-450.
9. Berger, E.(1996).K-12 Character education in Locust Valley.The Fourth and Fifth Rs: Respect and Responsibility,2(2),3-4.
10. Bird, C.(2010).Self-respect and the respect of others.European Journal of Philosophy,18(1),17-40.
11. Bjorklund, W. L.,Rehling, D. L.(2010).Student perceptions of classroom incivility.College Teaching,58(1),15-18.
12. Boice, B.(1996).Classroom incivilities.Research in Higher Education,37,453-486.
13. Carbonne, E.(1999).Students behaving badly in large classes.New Directions for Teaching and Learning,1999(77),35-43.
14. Duckworth, A. L.,Seligman, M. E. P.(2006).Self-discipline gines girls the edge: Gender in self-discipline, grades, and achivement test scores.Journal of Education Psychology,98(1),198-208.
15. Feldmann, L. J.(2001).Classroom civility is another of our instructor responsibilities.College Teaching,49(4),137-140.
16. Gross, E. R.(2011).Clashing values: Contemporary views about cheating and plagiarism compared to traditonal beliefs and practices.Education,132,435-440.
17. Hall, A.,Holder, B.,Matthews, E.,McDowell, M.,Pyne, L.,Walker, S.(1998).Character education: Ideas and activities for the classroom.Greensboro, NC:Carson-Dellosa.
18. Hirschy, A. S.,Braxton, J. M.(2004).Effects of student classroom incivilities on students.New Directions for Teaching and Learning,99,67-76.
19. Karris, M. A.,Craighead, W. E.(2012).Differences in character among U.S. college students.Individual Differences Research,10(2),69-80.
20. Kiracofe, N. M.,Wells, L.(2007).Mandated disciplinary counseling on campus: Problems and possibilities.Journal of Counseling & Development,85,259-268.
21. Lickona, T.(2003).The content of our character: Ten essential virtues.The Fourth and Fifth Rs: Respect and Responsibility,10(1),1-3.
22. Lickona, T.(1991).Education for Character: How our schools can teach respect and responsibility.New York:Bantam.
23. Logan, D. E.,Kilmer, J. R.,Marlatt, G. A.(2010).The virtuous drinker: Character virtues as correlates and moderators of college student drinking and consequences.Journal of American College Health,58(4),317-324.
24. Lounsbury, J. W.,Fisher, L. A.,Levy, J. J.,Welsh, D. P.(2009).An investigation of character strengths in relation to the academic success of college students.Individual Differences Research,7(1),52-69.
25. Nordstrom, C. R.,Bartels, L. K.,Bucy, J.(2009).Predicting and curbing classroom incivility in higher education.College Student Journal,43(1),74-85.
26. Paik, C.,Broedel-Zaugg, K.(2006).Pharmacy students' opinions on civility and preferences regarding professors.American Journal of Pharmaceutical Education,70(4),1-9.
27. Patron, H.,Bisping, T. O.(2008).Why students misbehave in class: An empirical analysis of classroom incivilities.Mountain Plains Journal of Business and Economics,9,61-74.
28. Rogus, J. F.(1985).Promoting self-discipline: A comprehensive approach.Theory Into Practice,24(4),271-276.
29. Rose, C. M.,Sharon, W. W.(2001).Classroom idea-sparkers.Childhood Education,77,222-227.
30. Ryan, K.,Bohlin, K. E.(1999).Building character in schools: Practical ways to bring moral instruction to life.San Francisco, CA:Jossey-Bass.
31. Vehmas, S.(2011).Disability and moral responsibility.TRAMES: A Journal of the Humanities & Social Sciences,15(2),156-167.
32. 陳慧琪(2011)。臺南市=Tainan, Taiwan，國立臺南大學教育學系課程與教學碩士班=Department of Education, National University of Tainan。

1. 黃寶園(2020)。品德教育實施成效及其調節變項之統合分析。教育研究與發展期刊，16(4)，33-70。
2. 廖珮妏(2020)。體驗教育培養大專生帶得走的品格信念指標之建構。當代教育研究季刊，28(3)，29-33+35。
3. 盧俊宏,陳斌,方彬彬(2022)。體育課情境中「個人與社會責任」內涵之探索：更新與擴展。體育學報，55(2)，175-191。
4. (2019)。大學生知覺課堂不適切行為之研究。高等教育，14(2)，63-98。