题名

父母恥感教養、幼兒恥感與其社會行為之關聯：以臺灣三歲幼兒為研究對象

并列篇名

THE RELATIONSHIPS AMONG PARENTAL SHAMING, CHILDREN'S SHAME AND SOCIAL BEHAVIORS OF THREE-YEAR-OLD TAIWANESE CHILDREN

DOI

10.6151/CERQ.202306_31(2).0003

作者

涂妙如(Miao-Ju Tu)；謝淑惠(Shu-Hui Hsieh)；江明珊(Ming-Shan Chiang)；程景琳(Ching-Ling Cheng)

关键词

父母恥感教養 ； 幼兒恥感 ； 幼兒社會行為 ； 臺灣幼兒發展調查資料庫 ； parental shaming ； children's shame ； children's social behavior ； Kids in Taiwan

期刊名称

當代教育研究季刊

卷期/出版年月

31卷2期（2023 / 06 / 30）

页次

91 - 93+95-97+99-133

内容语文

繁體中文;英文
中文摘要

研究目的：華人父母的教養深受儒家思想影響，特別是強調與道德倫理及行為規範相關的「恥感教養（shaming）」，乃華人父母以「使子女感到羞恥」做為引導子女為其行為負責、培養子女自省能力，協助子女社會化的重要技巧之一。「恥感（shame）」屬於自我意識情緒（self-conscious emotions）之一，指個體關注於他人對自己的負面評價，意識到自我的失敗和侷限，並對此感到不滿及自我譴責的情緒感受。隨著認知能力發展，三歲幼兒開始能夠理解外在規範、標準與他人的觀點，並具備依據外界規則來評價自己行為的能力，發展出恥感等具有自我評價意涵的自我意識情緒。本研究聚焦於三歲幼兒的恥感進行探討，研究目的為了解臺灣三歲幼兒父母之恥感教養、幼兒恥感與其社會行為間的關聯，並探討幼兒性別在父母恥感教養與幼兒恥感間的調節作用，以及幼兒恥感在父母恥感教養與幼兒社會行為間的中介作用。研究設計／方法／取徑：本研究使用「臺灣幼兒發展資料庫」36月齡組第一波資料進行分析，篩選受訪者為幼兒親生父母且為本國國籍者，並排除重大傷病或身心障礙之幼兒後，得研究樣本計1,873筆資料（父親計312人、母親計1,561人；男童947人、女童926人）。本研究使用R軟體進行資料分析，以Spearman等級相關計算兩兩變項間之相關係數，以Wilcoxon檢定探討相依樣本的差異性，最後以lavaan套件分析線性結構方程模型，並以Bollen-Stine bootstrap重複5,000次來呈現穩健的研究結果，及以95%信賴區間（confidence interval，CI）作為效果是否顯著的判斷基準。研究發現或結論：分析結果顯示：本研究假設模型具有可接受的整體適配度。主要結果有四：（一）父母恥感教養與三歲幼兒恥感達顯著正相關。（二）父母恥感教養與三歲幼兒恥感的關聯受到幼兒性別的調節作用。（三）幼兒恥感與其合群、順從與退縮之社會行為達顯著關聯。（四）父母恥感教養會透過幼兒恥感影響其合群、順從與退縮等社會行為，但此中介效果僅發生在女童。研究原創性／價值：本研究透過結構方程模型分析臺灣父母恥感教養、三歲幼兒恥感以及幼兒社會行為間的關聯，呈現華人恥感教養的影響效應。教育政策建議或實務意涵：本研究建議親職教育工作者，可引導育幼父母了解幼兒社會化的發展歷程，給予年幼子女學習人際互動時合適的教養策略，幫助幼兒內化社會規範的能力，建立合宜之行為界線。
英文摘要

Purpose: With the belief of shame in Confucianism, most ethnically Chinese parents teach their children by shaming practices, which guides their children's behavior, and helps them to build the ability of self-disciplining with a feeling of shame. Shame is one of the self-conscious emotions. A feeling of shame helps individuals pay close attention to others' negative comments, and to realize one's failures and limitations, thus enabling them to express the emotions of indignation and self-criticism. Three-year-old children gradually become able to perceive social norms, common standards, and others' perspectives, and to possess the ability to evaluate their behaviors. This study focuses on shame among three-year-old children. The objectives of this study were to identify the relationships among parental shaming, three-year-old children's shame, and the children's social behaviors; and the mediating effect of children's shame in the relationship between parental shaming and children's social behaviors. Design/methodology/approach: This study used data on 36-month-old children collected from Kids in Taiwan (KIT): National Longitudinal Study of Child Development and Care, and recruited biological parents of children included in the data as the study sample; only those who held Taiwanese nationality were enrolled in the sample. This study finalized the sample at 1,873 participants (including 312 fathers, 1,561 mothers, 947 boys, and 926 girls). To conduct the data analysis, we used the R software for Windows, calculated the correlation between each pair of variables by using Spearman's rank correlation, and used the Wilcoxon test to explore the differences between dependent samples. Finally, the lavvan package was implemented to analyze the linear structural equation model, with the Bollen-Stine bootstrap repeated 5000 times to obtain robust results. Moreover, a 95% confidence interval (CI) was used to serve as the criterion for judging whether the effect was significant. Findings/results: The results of the hypothetical model had an acceptable fit. The study's main findings are as follows: Parental shaming was found to be significantly and positively correlated with three-year-old children's shame. Parental shaming was able to predict the three-year-old children's shame and was moderated by children's gender. In particular, the influence of parental shaming shows more effects among girls. The study result proves that when parents use shaming more, girls have a higher probability of feeling shame. Additionally, regarding the association between children's shame and their social behaviors, children's shame was significantly and positively correlated with the behaviors of cooperation, compliance, and withdrawal. Finally, the mediating effect test showed that stronger parental shaming was associated with a higher level of children's shame, which in turn resulted in more social behaviors (i.e., cooperation, compliance, and withdrawal), but this phenomenon only happened among girls. Originality/value: This study analyzed the sample with a structural equation model, delving into the relationships among parental shaming, children's shame, and children's social behaviors, demonstrating the influence of ethnically Chinese parental shaming. Implications for policy/practice: Based on the results of the analysis, this study recommends that parenting educators could guide the parents of young children to understand the developmental process of socialization, equipping them with proper parenting strategies for children to learn how to build interpersonal relationships with others. This will help young children internalize the capacity of adapting to society, and establish fitting boundaries for young children's behavior.
主题分类 社會科學 > 教育學
参考文献
  1. 江文慈, W. T.(2018)。情緒表達的性別差異：跨情境的分析。教育心理學報，49(3)，345-366。
    連結：
  2. 吳欣璇, H. H.,金瑞芝, J. C.(2011)。華人家庭文化脈絡下新住民母親的親子關係－以一越南出生與柬埔寨長大的新住民母親為例。應用心理研究，51，111-148。
    連結：
  3. 林俊瑩, C. Y.,邱欣怡, H. Y.,葉芝君, C. C.(2012)。社經背景、幼年受管教經驗與教養價值觀對學前教育階段家長管教子女方式的影響。中華輔導與諮商學報，32，123-149。
    連結：
  4. 林鉦棽, T. C. C.,彭台光, T. K.(2012)。組織研究的中介檢測：緣起、爭議、研究設計和分析。管理學報，29(4)，333-354。
    連結：
  5. 韓貴香, K. H.(2014)。社會比較情境中表現劣者的沒面子感受與情緒：臉面共享成員在場與情境公開性的影響。中華輔導與諮商學報，41，1-24。
    連結：
  6. Acar, B. A. V.,Cakmak, Z.,Saritas, A. D.(2019).Parenting and children’s prosocial and problem behaviors in middle childhood: The role of Turkish mothers’ emotion socialization practices.Social Development,28(2),333-346.
  7. Adrichem, D. S.,Huijbregts, S. C. J.,Heijden, K. B.,Goozen, S. H. M.,Swaab, H.(2020).Aggression in toddlerhood: The roles of parental beliefs, parenting behavior and precursors of theory of mind.Social Development,29(2),427-442.
  8. Aghaie Meybodi, F.,Mohammadkhani, P.,Pourshahbaz, A.,Dolatshahi, B.,Havighurst, S. S.(2019).Improving parent emotion socialization practices: Piloting tuning in to kids in Iran for children with disruptive behavior problems.Family Relations,68(5),596-607.
  9. Alessandri, S. M.,Lewis, M.(1996).Differences in pride and shame in maltreated and nonmaltreated preschoolers.Child Development,67(4),1857-1869.
  10. Alwaely, S. A.,Yousif, N. B. A.,Mikhaylov, A.(2021).Emotional development in preschoolers and socialization.Early Child Development & Care,191(16),2484-2493.
  11. Bafunno, D.,Camodeca, M.(2013).Shame and guilt development in preschoolers: The role of context, audience and individual characteristics.European Journal of Developmental Psychology,1(2),128-143.
  12. Baron, R. M.,Kenny, D. A.(1986).Moderator-mediator variables distinction in social psychological research: Conceptual, strategic, and statistical considerations.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,51(6),1173-1182.
  13. Baumeister, R. F.,Bushman, B. J.(2007).Angry emotions and aggressive behaviors.Emotions and aggressive behavior
  14. Belsky, J.,Domitrovich, C.(1997).Temperament and parenting antecedents of individual differences in three-year-old boy’s pride and shame reactions.Child Development,68(3),456-466.
  15. Broekhof, E.,Bos, M. G. N.,Rieffe, C.(2021).The roles of shame and guilt in the development of aggression in adolescents with and without hearing loss.Research on Child & Adolescent Psychopathology,49(7),891-904.
  16. Castilho, P.,Carvalho, S.,Marques, S.,Pinto-Gouveia, J.(2017).Self-compassion and emotional intelligence in adolescence: A multigroup mediational study of the impact of shame memories on depressive symptoms.Journal of Child & Family Studies,26(3),759-768.
  17. Chao, R. K.(1994).Beyond parental control and authoritarian parenting style: Understanding Chinese parenting through the cultural notion of training.Child Development,65(4),1111-1119.
  18. Chaplin, T. M.,Casey, J.,Sinha, R.,Mayes, L. C.(2010).Gender differences in caregiver emotion socialization of low-income toddlers.New Directions for Child & Adolescent Development,2010(128),11-27.
  19. Chen, J. J.,Sun, P.,Yu, Z.(2017).A comparative study on parenting of preschool children between the Chinese in China and Chinese immigrants in the United States.Journal of Family Issues,38(9),1262-1287.
  20. Chen, J. J.-L.,Chen, T.,Zheng, X. X.(2012).Parenting styles and practices among Chinese immigrant mothers with young children.Early Child Development & Care,182(1),1-21.
  21. Chen, X.,Wu, H.,Chen, H.,Wang, L.,Cen, G.(2001).Parenting practices and aggressive behavior in Chinese children.Parenting: Science & Practice,1(3),159.
  22. Cibich, M.,Woodyatt, L.,Wenzel, M.(2016).Moving beyond "shame is bad": How a functional emotion can become problematic.Social & Personality Psychology Compass,10(9),471-483.
  23. Cole, P. M.,Tamang, B. L.,Shrestha, S.(2006).Cultural variations in the socialization of young children´s anger and shame.Child Development,77(5),1237-1251.
  24. Cui, M.,Graber, J. A.,Metz, A.,Darling, C. A.(2019).Parental indulgence, sel-fregulation, and young adults’ behavioral and emotional problems.Journal of Family Studies,25(3),233-249.
  25. da Luz Bernardo Antunes, M.,do Céu Teixeira Salvador, M.(2016).Social anxiety disorder and depressive symptoms in adolescence: The mediator role of the impact of traumatic shame experiences.Journal of Child & Adolescent Psychology / Revista de Psicologia Da Criança e Do Adolescente,7(1/2),397-415.
  26. de Hooge, I. E.,Breugelmans, S. M.,Wagemans, F. M. A.,Zeelenberg, M.(2018).the social side of shame: Approach versus withdrawal.Cognition and Emotion,32(8),1671-1677.
  27. de Hooge, I. E.,Breugelmans, S. M.,Zeelenberg, M.(2008).Not so ugly after all: When shame acts as a commitment device.Journal of Personality & Social Psychology,95(4),933-943.
  28. de Hooge, I. E.,Zeelenberg, M.,Breugelmans, S. M.(2011).A functionalist account of shame-induced behaviour.Cognition and Emotion,25(5),939-946.
  29. Declerck, C. H.,Boone, C.,Kiyonari, T.(2014).No place to hide: When shame causes proselfs to cooperate.The Journal of Social Psychology,154(1),74-88.
  30. dos Santos, M. A.,de Freitas e Castro, J. M.,de Freitas Lino Pinto Cardoso, C. S.(2020).The moral emotions of guilt and shame in children: Relationship with parenting and temperament.Journal of Child & Family Studies,29(10),2759-2769.
  31. Edwards, J. R.,Lambert, L. S.(2007).Methods for integrating moderation and mediation: A general analytical framework using moderated path analysis.Psychological Methods,12,1-22.
  32. Else-Quest, N. M.,Allison, C.,Higgins, A.,Morton, L. C.(2012).Gender differences in self-conscious emotional experience: A meta-analysis.Psychological Bulletin,138(5),947-981.
  33. Fine, S. E.,Izard, C. E.,Trentacosta, C. J.(2006).Emotion situation knowledge in elementary school: Models of longitudinal growth and preschool correlates.Social Development,15(4),730-751.
  34. Fliek, L.,Daemen, E.,Roelofs, J.,Muris, P.(2015).Rough-and-tumble play and other parental factors as correlates of anxiety symptoms in preschool children.Journal of Child and Family Studies,24(9),2795-2804.
  35. Fu, G.,Brunet, M. K.,Lv, Y.,Ding, X.,Heyman, G. D.,Cameron, C. A.,Lee, K.(2010).Chinese children's moral evaluation of lies and truths-roles of context and parental individualism-collectivism tendencies.Infant and Child Development,19(5),498-515.
  36. Fung, H.(1999).Becoming a moral child: The socialization of shame among young Chinese children.Ethos,27(2),180-209.
  37. Fung, H.(2006).Affect and early moral socialization: Indigenous research from Taiwan.Indigenous and cultural psychology: Understanding people in context
  38. Fung, H.,Chen, E. C.(2001).Across time and beyond skin: Self and transgression in the everyday socialization of shame among Taiwanese preschool children.Social Development,10(3),419-437.
  39. Ghasemi, A.,Zahediasl, S.(2012).Normality tests for statistical analysis: A guide for non-statisticians.Int. J. Endocrinol. Metab,10,486-489.
  40. Hart, D.,Matsuba, M. K.(2007).The development of pride and moral life.The self-conscious emotions: Theory and research
  41. Hayduk, L. A.,Littvay, L.(2012).Should researchers use single indicators, best indicators, or multiple indicators in structural equation models?.BMC Medical Research Methodology,12(159),1-17.
  42. Helwig, C. C.,To, S.,Wang, Q.,Liu, C. Q.,Yang, S. G.(2014).Judgments and reasoning about parental discipline involving induction and psychological control in China and Canada.Child Development,85,1150-1167.
  43. Hill, N.,Tyson, D.(2008).Excavating culture: Ethnicity and context as predictors of parenting behavior.Applied Developmental Science,12(4),188-197.
  44. Huang, C. Y.,Shen, A. C. T.,Hsieh, Y. P.,Feng, J. Y.,Wei, H. S.,Hwa, H. L.,Feng, J. Y.(2017).Cultural perspective on parenting, trait emotional intelligence and mental health in Taiwanese children.International Journal of Emotional Education,9(2),4-16.
  45. Julian, T. W.,McKenry, P. C.,Mckelvey, M. W.(1994).Cultural variations in parenting: Perceptions of Caucasian, African-American, Hispanic, and Asian-American parents.Family Relations,43(1),30-37.
  46. Kelley, S. A.,Brownell, C. A.,Campbell, S. B.(2000).Mastery motivation and self evaluative affect in toddlers: Longitudinal relations with maternal behavior.Child Development,71(4),1061-1071.
  47. Kim, L.,Knudson, M. C.,Tuttle, A.(2014).Toward relationship-directed parenting: An example of North American born second-generation Korean-American mothers and their partners.Family Process,53(1),55-66.
  48. Kirby, J. N.,Sampson, H.,Day, J.,Hayes, A.,Gilbert, P.(2019).Human evolution and culture in relationship to shame in the parenting role: Implications for psychology and psychotherapy.Psychol Psychother,92(2),238-260.
  49. Kline, R. B.(2005).Principles and practice of structural equation modeling.the Guilford Press.
  50. Lagattuta, K. H.,Thompson, R. A.(2007).The development of self-conscious emotions: Cognitive processes and social influences.The self-conscious emotions: Theory and research
  51. Leary, M. R.(Ed.),Tangney, J. P.(Ed.)(2012).Handbook of self and identity.The Guilford Press.
  52. Lee, J.,Kim, M.,Park, M.(2014).The impact of internalized shame on social anxiety in adolescence: The mediating role of experiential avoidance.Journal of Asia Pacific Counseling,4(1),65-81.
  53. Lewis, M.(2003).The role of the self in shame.Social Research,70(4),1181-1204.
  54. Lewis, M.(2007).Self-conscious emotional development.The self-conscious emotions: Theory and research
  55. Lewis, M.,Alessandri, S. M.,Sullivan, M. W.(1992).Differences in shame and pride as a function of childrens gender and task difficulty.Child Development,63(3),630-638.
  56. Lewis-Morrarty, E.,Degnan, K. A.,Chronis-Tuscano, A.,Rubin, K. H.,Cheah, C. S.,Pine, D. S.,Fox, N. A.(2012).Maternal over-control moderates the association between early childhood behavioral inhibition and adolescent social anxiety symptoms.Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology,40(8),1363-1373.
  57. Lieber, E.,Fung, H.,Leung, P. W. L.(2006).Chinese child rearing beliefs: Key dimensions and contributions to the development of culture appropriate assessment.Asian Journal of Social Psychology,9(2),140-147.
  58. Loader, P.(1998).Such a shame – A consideration of shame and shaming mechanisms in families.Child Abuse Review,7(1),44-57.
  59. Louie, J. Y.,Oh, B. J.,Lau, A. S.(2013).Cultural differences in the links between parental control and children’s emotional expressivity.Cultur. Divers. Ethnic Minor. Psychol,19,424-434.
  60. Luby, J.,Belden, A.,Sullivan, J.,Hayen, R.,McCadney, A.,Spitznagel, E.(2009).Shame and guilt in preschool depression: Evidence for elevations in self-conscious emotions in depression as early as age 3.Journal of Child Psychology & Psychiatry,50(9),1156-1166.
  61. Lui, P. P.,Rollock, D.(2013).Tiger mother: Popular and psychological scientific perspectives on Asian culture and parenting.American Journal of Orthopsychiatry,83,450-456.
  62. Luo, R.,Tamis-LeMonda, C. S.,Song, L.(2013).Chinese parents’ goals and practices in early childhood.Early Childhood Research Quarterly,28(4),843-857.
  63. Ma, J.(2020).Parenting in Chinese immigrant families: A critical review of consistent and inconsistent findings.Journal of Child & Family Studies,29(3),831-844.
  64. McKee, L.,Roland, E.,Coffelt, N.,Olson, A.,Forehand, R.,Massari, C.,Jones, D.,Gaffney, C.,Zens, M.(2007).Harsh discipline and child problem behaviors: the roles of positive parenting and gender.Journal of Family Violence,22(4),187-196.
  65. Messinger, D. S.(2002).Positive and negative: Infant facial expressions and emotions.Current Directions in Psychological Science,11(1),1.
  66. Miceli, M.,Castelfranchi, C.(2018).Reconsidering the differences between shame and guilt.Europe̕s Journal of Psychology,14(3),710-733.
  67. Miguel, H. O.,McCormick, S. A.,Westerlund, A.,Nelson, C. A.(2019).Rapid face processing for positive and negative emotions in 5-, 7-, and 12-month-old infants: An exploratory study.British Journal of Developmental Psychology,37(4),486-504.
  68. Mills, R. S. L.(2003).Possible antecedents and developmental implications of shame in young girls.Infant & Child Development,12(4),329-349.
  69. Mills, R. S. L.,Arbeau, K. A.,Lall, D. I. K.,De Jaeger, A. E.(2010).Parenting and child characteristics in the prediction of Shame in early and middle childhood.Merrill-Palmer Quarterly: Journal of Developmental Psychology,56(4),500-528.
  70. Mills, R.,Freeman, W.,Clara, I.,Elgar, F.,Walling, B.,Mak, L.(2007).Parent proneness to shame and the use of psychological control.Journal of Child & Family Studies,16(3),359-374.
  71. Mills, R.,Hastings, P.,Serbin, L.,Stack, D.,Abela, J.,Arbeau, K.,Lall, D.(2015).Depressogenic thinking and shame proneness in the development of internalizing problems.Child Psychiatry & Human Development,46(2),194-208.
  72. Mintz, G.,Etengoff, C.,Grysman, A.(2017).The relation between childhood parenting and emerging adults’ experiences of shame and guilt.Journal of Child and Family Studies,26(10),2908-2920.
  73. Monteiro, L.,Fernandes, M.,Torres, N.,Santos, C.(2017).Father’s involvement and parenting styles in Portuguese families: The role of education and working hours.Análise Psicológica,35(4),513-528.
  74. Mousavi, S.,Low, W.,Hashim, A.(2016).Perceived parenting styles and cultural influences in adolescent’s anxiety: A cross-cultural comparison.Journal of Child & Family Studies,25(7),2102-2110.
  75. Muñoz, S. M. D,Navarro, M. J.,Díaz, R. A.,Coronilla, G. M.,Porcel, G. A. M.,Gil, G. E.(2020).Parenting practices among parents of children with attention deficit/hyperactivity disorder: Gender related differences.Journal of Clinical Psychology,76(1),239-245.
  76. Muris, P.,Meesters, C.(2014).Small or big in the eyes of the other: On the developmental psychopathology of self-conscious emotions as shame, guilt, and pride.Clinical Child & Family Psychology Review,17(1),19-40.
  77. Muris, P.,Meesters, C.,Bouwman, L.,Notermans, S.(2015).Relations among behavioral inhibition, shame- and guilt-proneness, and anxiety disorders symptoms in non-clinical children.Child Psychiatry & Human Development,46(2),209-216.
  78. Muris, P.,Meesters, C.,Heijmans, J.,Hulten, S.,Kaanen, L.,Oerlemans, B.,Stikkelbroeck, T.,Tielemans, T.(2016).Lack of guilt, guilt, and shame: A multi-informant study on the relations between self-conscious emotions and psychopathology in clinically referred children and adolescents.European Child & Adolescent Psychiatry,25(4),383-396.
  79. Muris, P.,Meesters, C.,van Asseldonk, M.(2018).Shame on me! Self-conscious emotions and Big Five personality traits and their relations to anxiety disorders symptoms in young, non-clinical adolescents.Child Psychiatry & Human Development,49(2),268-278.
  80. Negrini, L. S.(2020).Coparenting supports in mitigating the effects of family conflict on infant and young child development.Social Work,65(3),278-287.
  81. Ng, G.(2019).Exploring how shame affects Asian Americans in the classroom.Christian Higher Education,18(5),370-381.
  82. Nguyen, T.,Chang, P. P. W.,Loh, J. M. I.(2014).The psychology of Vietnamese tiger mothers: Qualitative insights into the parenting beliefs and practices of Vietnamese-Australian mothers.Journal of Family Studies,20(1),48-65.
  83. Olthof, T.(2012).Anticipated feelings of guilt and shame as predictors of early adolescents´ antisocial and prosocial interpersonal behaviour.European Journal of Developmental Psychology,9(3),371-388.
  84. Öztürk Samur, A.(2015).A study on the relationship between externalising behaviours and emotional skills of 60-72-month-old children.Early Child Development & Care,185(1),75-83.
  85. Petrescu, M.(2013).Marketing research using single-item indicators in structural equation models.Journal of Marketing Analytics,1(2),99-117.
  86. Rademacher, A.,Koglin, U.(2019).The concept of self-regulation and preschoolers’ social-emotional development: A systematic review.Early Child Development & Care,189(14),2299-2317.
  87. Ramírez-Uclés, I.,González-Calderón, M. J.,del Barrio-Gándara, V.,Carrasco, M. Á.(2018).Perceived parental acceptance-rejection and children’s psychological adjustment: The moderating effects of sex and age.Journal of Child & Family Studies,27(4),1336-1348.
  88. Ridinger, G.(2020).Shame and theory-of-mind predicts rule-following behavior.Games,11(3),36.
  89. Roos, S.,Hodges, E. V. E.,Salmivalli, C.(2014).Do guilt- and shame-proneness differentially predict prosocial, aggressive, and withdrawn behaviors during early adolescence?.Developmental Psychology,50(3),941-946.
  90. Root, A. K.,Denham, S. A.(2010).The role of gender in the socialization of emotion: Key concepts and critical issues.New Directions for Child & Adolescent Development,2010(128),1-9.
  91. Rosseel, Y.(2012).lavaan: An R package for structural equation modeling.Journal of Statistical Software,48(2),1-36.
  92. Röttger-Rössler, B.,Scheidecker, G.,Jung, S.,Holodynski, M.(2013).Socializing emotions in childhood: A cross-cultural comparison between the Bara in Madagascar and the Minangkabau in Indonesia.Mind, Culture & Activity,20(3),260-287.
  93. Scarnier, M.,Schmader, T.,Lickel, B.(2009).Parental shame and guilt: Distinguishing emotional responses to a child's wrong doings.Personal Relationships,16(2),205-220.
  94. Shaver, P. R.,Wu, S.,Schwartz, J. C.(1992).Cross-cultural similarities and differences in emotion and its representation.Emotion
  95. Sloane, S.,Baillargeon, R.,Premack, D.(2012).Do infants have a sense of fairness?.Psychological Science,23,196-204.
  96. Stapleton, C. M.,Zhang, H.,Kitzmann, K. M.,Cohen, R.(2019).Children’s social status and anticipated shame and guilt experiences.Journal of Social & Personal Relationships,36(6),1807-1830.
  97. Stuewig, J.,Tangney, J. P.,Heigel, C.,Harty, L.,McCloskey, L.(2010).Shaming, blaming, and maiming: Functional links among the moral emotions, externalization of blame, and aggression.Journal of Research in Personality,44(1),91-102.
  98. Stuewig, J.,Tangney, J.,Kendall, S.,Folk, J.,Meyer, C.,Dearing, R.(2015).Children’s proneness to shame and guilt predict risky and illegal behaviors in young adulthood.Child Psychiatry & Human Development,46(2),217-227.
  99. Tangney, J. P., Dearing, R. L., Wagner, P. E., & Gramzow, R. (2000). The test of self-conscious affect-3 (TOSCA-3). George Mason University. https://doi/10.1037/t06464-000
  100. Tangney, J. P.,Stuewig, J.,Mashek, D. J.(2007).Moral emotions and moral behavior.Annual Review of Psychology,58,345-372.
  101. Tangney, J. P.,Wagner, P. E.,Fletcher, C.,Gramzow, R.(1992).Shamed into anger? The relation of shame and guilt to anger and self-reported aggression.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,62,669-675.
  102. Thomaes, S.,Bushman, B. J.,Stegge, H.,Olthof, T.(2008).Trumping shame by blasts of noise: Narcissism, self esteem, shame, and aggression in young adolescents.Child Development,79(6),1792-1801.
  103. Thomaes, S.,Stegge, H.,Olthof, T.,Bushman, B. J.,Nezlek, J. B.(2011).Turning shame inside-out: "Humiliated Fury" in young adolescents.Emotion,11(4),786-793.
  104. Thompson-Walsh, C.,Scott, K. L.,Lishak, V.,Dyson, A.(2021).How domestically violent fathers impact children’s social-emotional development: Fathers’ psychological functioning, parenting, and coparenting.Child Abuse & Neglect,112
  105. Velotti, P.,Elison, J.,Garofalo, C.(2014).Shame and aggression: Different trajectories and implications.Aggression and Violent Behavior,19(4),454-461.
  106. Wang, L.,Pan, H.,Zhang, H.(2020).The effect of emotional intensity of shame on children’s prosocial behaviour.European Journal of Developmental Psychology,17(2),263-274.
  107. Wang, S.,Tamis-LeMonda, C. S.(2003).Do child-rearing values in Taiwan and the United States reflect cultural values of collectivism and individualism?.Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology,34(6),629-642.
  108. Wong, Y. J.,Kim, B. S.,Nguyen, C. P.,Cheng, J. K. Y.,Saw, A.(2014).The interpersonal shame inventory for Asian Americans: Scale development and psychometric properties.Journal of Counseling Psychology,61(1),119.
  109. Wu, P.,Robinson, C. C.,Yang, C.,Hart, C. H.,Olsen, S. F.,Porter, C. L.,Wu, X.(2002).Similarities and differences in mothers’ parenting of preschoolers in China and the United States.International Journal of Behavioral Development,26,481-491.
  110. Yakeley, J.(2018).Shame, culture and mental health.Nordic Journal of Psychiatry,72,S20-S22.
  111. Yaman, A.,Mesman, J.,IJzendoorn, M.,Bakermans-Kranenburg, M.,Linting, M.(2010).Parenting in an individualistic culture with a collectivistic cultural background: The case of Turkish immigrant families with toddlers in the Netherlands.Journal of Child & Family Studies,19(5),617-628.
  112. Zhang, S. X.(1995).Measuring shaming in an ethnic context.The British Journal of Criminology,35(2),248-262.
  113. 林文瑛, W. Y.,王震武, J. W.(1995)。中國父母的教養觀：嚴教觀或打罵觀？。本土心理學研究，3，2-92。
  114. 林惠雅, H. Y.(2000)。母親與幼兒互動中之教養行為分析。應用心理研究，6，75-96。
  115. 林惠雅, H. Y.(1999)。母親信念、教養目標與教養行為（一）：內涵意義之探討。應用心理研究，2，143-180。
  116. 林慧芬, H. F.(2011)。「換個顏色吧？」－母親教養行為中的指示、應答與幼兒順從、不順從之個案研究。民生論叢，5，121-156。
  117. 張鑑如, C. J.(2019)。,未出版
  118. 莊耀嘉, Y. C.,楊國樞, Yang, K. S.(1997)。角色規範的認知結構。本土心理學研究，7，282-338。
  119. 許桂華, G. H.,何英奇, Y. C.(1998)。父母獲取順從策略及其影響因素之質性研究。教育心理學報，30(1)，195-220。
  120. 陳丹丹, D. D.(2017)。君子恥之：清初遺民學人的道德思辨與文化重建－以顧炎武、李顒、張履祥為例。中國文學學報，8，285-304。
  121. 馮涵棣, H. D.,梁綺涵, C. H.(2008)。越南媽媽．臺灣囡仔：臺越跨國婚姻家庭幼兒社會化之初探。臺灣人類學刊，6(2)，47-88。
  122. 馮涵棣, H. D.,陳倩慧, C. H.(2002)。情緒、文化與道德社教化：以羞恥感為例的探討。情感、情緒與文化：臺灣社會的文化心理研究
  123. 謝育伶, Y. L.,陳若琳, J. L.(2008)。母親教養行為、幼兒行為調節和幼兒社會能力之相關。幼兒教育，290，6-21。
  124. 韓美群, M. C.(2006)。社會主義榮辱觀教育視域下的儒家倫理價值。湖北社會科學，2006(12)，129-131。
print cancel