職棒裁判判決與球迷知覺公平的關係：團體偏私的效果

Relationship of professional baseball referees' judgement and perceived fairness of fans: The effect of group favoritism

10.6497/BSEPT.202007_20(2).0001

許建民(Chien-Ming Hsu)；黃賢哲(Hsien-Che Huang)；黃煜(Yu Huang)；葉靜秀(Ching-Hsiu Yeh)

內團體 ； 外團體 ； 球隊認同 ； 觀眾行為 ； in-group ； out-group ； team identification ； spectator behavior

臺灣運動心理學報

20卷2期（2020 / 07 / 31）

1 - 17

繁體中文

目的：瞭解職棒球迷對裁判判決公平性的知覺是否會因所屬團體和狀況條件的不同而有所差異。方法：以二因子受試者間設計將120名中信兄弟球迷依團體類型（內團體、外團體）和狀況條件（有利條件、不利條件）的不同進行四組分派，俟其觀賞完指定影片後立即針對裁判判決的公平性知覺進行評斷。結果：二因子變異數分析結果顯示，團體類型和狀況條件單獨存在時並不會對公平性知覺帶來太大的影響，但將兩個因素同時納入考量時，則會有交互作用效果出現。在主審的判決對內團體有利和對外團體不利的二種情況下，公平性評斷就會較高；然若是對內團體不利和對外團體有利的另二個情況，公平性評斷就會較低。結論：本研究結果支持高認同球迷對裁判判決公平性的評斷會受團體偏私所影響，也就是球迷會因為團體立場的不同，對事件的解讀就不一致，而這個解讀通常會以對自己有利的角度去看待事情。根據上述研究發現，也在實務和未來研究層面提供一些建議。

Purpose: This study examined the effects of the status of belong group and favorable condition on the professional baseball fans' perception of the fairness of referees' judgement. Method: A two-factor factorial design was applied to estimate the effective of group favoritism in this study and 120 fans of Brothers Baseball Club were divided into four sections by group type (in-group and out-group) and favorable condition (favorable and unfavorable). These participants were asked to review the specific plays of game videos and responded immediately to the perception of fairness of the referee's judgement. Results: The results indicated an interaction of group type and favorable condition on the perception of fairness of the referee's judgement, instead of the main effects of group type and favorable condition. To elaborate, the perception of fairness of the referee's judgement would be higher when the judgements were favorable to the in-group and unfavorable to the out-group. In contrast, the perception of fairness of the referee's judgement would be lower when the judgements were unfavorable to the in-group and favorable to the out-group. Conclusion: The findings support that, for those fans who have a high level of team identification, their perception of fairness of referee's judgements is likely to be influenced by group favoritism. Therefore, it always depends on the group position and favorable condition for fans to interpret the fairness of the referee's judgements. This study also provides suggestions for practitioners and researchers based on our findings.

1. 姜定宇,葛玉璇(2018)。因人而異的知識分享：對自己人偏私的調節效果。人力資源管理學報，18(2)，1-30。
   連結：
2. 姜定宇,鄭伯壎(2014)。華人差序式領導的本質與影響歷程。本土心理學研究，42，285-357。
   連結：
3. 高三福,龐雲漢,謝承甫,陳忠強(2014)。籃球裁判吹判失誤、補救方式與顧客滿意度之關係。體育學報，47(1)，103-114。
   連結：
4. 張滿玲,鍾昆原(2011)。正義與情理：偏袒與重才的人事決定對主管的公正及人情評價之影響。中華心理學刊，53(3)，349-370。
   連結：
5. 許建民,高俊雄(2006)。職棒球迷支持球隊因素與球隊認同關係之比較研究：以兄弟象與興農牛為例。國立體育學院論叢，17(3)，17-30。
   連結：
6. 顏志龍(2014)。實驗法的原理及其在運動和體育研究上的運用。體育學報，47(4)，475-488。
   連結：
7. Aberson, C. L.,Healy, M.,Romero, V.(2000).Ingroup bias and self-esteem: A meta-analysis.Personality and Social Psychology Review,4,157-173.
8. Branscombe, N. R.,Wann, D. L.(1994).Collective self-esteem consequences of outgroup derogation when a valued social identity is on trial.European Journal of Social Psychology,24,641-657.
9. Branscombe, N. R.,Wann, D. L.,Noel, J. G.,Coleman, J.(1993).Ingroup or out-group extremity: Importance of the threatened social identity.Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin,19,381-388.
10. Crocker, J.,Luhtanen, R.(1990).Collective self-esteem and ingroup bias.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,58,60-67.
11. Dietz-Uhler, B.,Murrell, A.(1999).Examining fan reaction to game outcomes: A longitudinal study of social identity.Journal of Sport Behavior,22,15-27.
12. Goldie, S. R.,Wolfson, S.(2014).Soccer fans’ self and group perceptions of superiority over rival fans.Journal of Sport Behavior,37,24-36.
13. Grieve, F. G.,Wann, D. L.,Zapalac, R. K.,Cyr, C. Y.,Lanter, J. R.(2018).Factors associated with college students’ identification with high school football teams.Journal of Sport Behavior,41,148-167.
14. Hastorf, A. H.,Cantril, H.(1954).They saw a game: A case study.The Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology,49,129-134.
15. Hewstone, M.,Rubin, M.,Willis, H.(2002).Intergroup bias.Annual Review of Psychology,53,575-604.
16. Noel, J. G.,Wann, D.,Branscombe, N. R.(1995).Peripheral ingroup membership status and public negativity toward outgroup.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,68,127-137.
17. Simmons, J. M.,Greenwell, T. C.(2014).Differences in fan-family conflict based on an individual’s level of identification with a team.Journal of Sport Behavior,37,94-114.
18. Snibbe, A. C.,Kitayama, S.,Markus, H. R.,Suzuki, T.(2003).They saw a game: A Japanese and American (football) field study.Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology,34,581-595.
19. Spinda, J. S. W.(2012).Perceptual biases and behavioral effects among NFL fans: An investigation of first-person, second-person, and third-person effects.International Journal of Sport Communication,5,327-347.
20. Tarrant, M.,North, A. C.(2004).Explanations for positive and negative behavior: The intergroup attribution bias in achieved groups.Current Psychology,23,161-172.
21. Taylor, D. M.,Doria, J. R.(1981).Self-serving and group-serving bias in attribution.The Journal of Social Psychology,113,201-211.
22. Unkelbach, C.,Memmert, D.(2008).Game management, context effects, and calibration: The case of yellow cards in soccer.Journal of Sport & Exercise Psychology,30,95-109.
23. Wann, D. L.,Branscombe, N. R.(1995).Influence of identification with a sports team on objective knowledge and subjective beliefs.International Journal of Sport Psychology,26,551-567.
24. Wann, D. L.,Dolan, T. J.(1994).Spectators' evaluations of rival and fellow fans.The Psychological Record,44,351-358.
25. Wann, D. L.,Grieve, F. G.(2005).Biased evaluations of in-group and out-group spectator behavior at sporting events: The importance of team identification and threats to social identity.The Journal of Social Psychology,145,531-545.
26. Wann, D. L.,Koch, K.,Knoth, T.,Fox, D.,Aljubaily, H.,Lantz, C. D.(2006).The impact of team identification on biased predictions of player performance.The Psychological Record,56,55-66.
27. Wann, D. L.,Melnick, M. J.,Russell, G. W.,Pease, D. G.(2001).Sport fans: The psychology and social impact of spectators.New York:Routledge Press.
28. Wenger, J. L.,Brown, R. O.(2014).Sport fans: Evaluating the consistency between implicit and explicit attitudes toward favorite and rival team.Psychological Reports: Mental & Physical Health,114,572-584.
29. 吳曉雯(2002)。桃園市，國立體育學院體育研究所。
30. 李美枝(1993)。從有關公平判斷的研究結果看中國人之人己關係的界線。本土心理學研究，1，267-300。
31. 李美枝,許正聖(1995)。從台灣大學生內團體偏私基礎之解析看社群意識發展的可能性。本土心理學研究，4，150-182。

1. 黃煜,許建民(2021)。球迷理性嗎－自利歸因偏誤的觀點。中華體育季刊，35(2)，69-76。
2. 鄭雯蔚,許建民(2021)。你們我們不一樣！論球迷的內團體偏私。大專體育，156，10-17。