题名

同工不同酬：職業運動薪資歧視之文獻回顧

并列篇名

An unmended gap: A literature review of wage discrimination among professional sports

DOI

10.6497/BSEPT.202007_20(2).0002

作者

方佩欣(Pei-Hsin Fang)；梁卓朗(Cheuk-Long Leung)；王傑賢(Jye-Shyan Wang)

关键词

雇主歧視 ； 受雇者歧視 ； 消費者歧視 ； 運動經濟 ； employer discrimination ； employee discrimination ； customer discrimination ； sports economics

期刊名称

臺灣運動心理學報

卷期/出版年月

20卷2期（2020 / 07 / 31）

页次

19 - 44

内容语文

繁體中文
中文摘要

職業運動中的薪資歧視一直是勞動經濟、運動經濟研究者及實務工作者所關注的議題。由於薪資與組織績效、員工生產力節節相關，若薪資歧視存於職業球隊之中，選手的努力動機及團隊凝聚力甚或將大幅下降。本研究透過範域文獻回顧，分析職業運動的薪資歧視文獻，發現近年的相關研究以種族與國籍的薪資歧視議題為主。本研究從文獻中探討消費者歧視的原因，發現多數研究以經濟學家的市場歧視理論、贏家詛咒以及制度限制來解釋職業運動薪資歧視。最後，本研究提出學術及實務管理意涵，供未來研究者及職業運動工作者參考。
英文摘要

Wage discrimination among professional sports has long stood as a concern not only to labor/sports economists but also to practitioners, since payment stays influential to both organizational performance and employee productivity. If wage discrimination permeates through professional sports teams, working incentives and teamsmanship will even be negatively affected. This study turns back to previous studies with scoping review method to analyze the issue of wage discrimination among professional sports. We find that academia recently takes ethnicity and nationality as the critical element of wage discrimination, as well we further discuss the causes of wage discrimination. Becker's market discrimination theory, winner's curse, and regulations are applied to understand wage discrimination. Finally, our academic and practical arguments are also given as references to future researchers and professional sports team managers.
主题分类 社會科學 > 心理學
社會科學 > 體育學
参考文献
  1. 林錫波,高俊雄,林國棟(2011)。中華職棒勞資公平關係之機制。大專體育學刊，13(4)，337-348。
    連結：
  2. 徐茂洲(2012)。以潛在成長模式驗證中華職棒大聯盟19-21年薪資成長變化之研究。運動休閒管理學報，9(1)，21-38。
    連結：
  3. 莊林貴,陳淑滿,柯天路,林敏政(2004)。臺灣職棒從業者教育程度與薪資之關聯研究。教練科學，4，309-320。
    連結：
  4. 廖清海,楊世達(2010)。運動表現與薪資之關聯性探討─以中華職棒大聯盟十九年為例。運動與遊憩研究，4(3)，57-67。
    連結：
  5. 蔡孟娟,雷文谷,謝春宣(2012)。戰力或負擔？中華職棒外籍與本國籍野手績效之比較。運動休閒管理學報，9(2)，202-216。
    連結：
  6. Ajilore, O.(2014).Do white NBA players suffer from reverse discrimination?.Economics Bulletin,34,558-566.
  7. Annala, C. N.,Winfree, J.(2011).Salary distribution and team performance in Major League Baseball.Sport Management Review,14,167-175.
  8. Balkin, D. B.,Gomez-Mejia, L. R.(1990).Matching compensation and organizational strategies.Strategic Management Journal,11,153-169.
  9. Becker, G.(1971).The economics of discrimination.Chicago:The University of Chicago Press.
  10. Berkowitz, I.(Ed.)(1965).Advances in experimental social psychology.New York:Academic Press.
  11. Berri, D. J.,Leeds, M. A.,von Allmen, P.(2015).Salary determination in the presence of fixed revenues.International Journal of Sport Finance,10,5-25.
  12. Berri, D. J.,Simmons, R.(2009).Race and the evaluation of signal callers in the National Football League.Journal of Sports Economics,10,23-43.
  13. Bodvarsson, Ö. B.,Banaian, K.(1998).Wage premiums and league tables.Quarterly Journal of Business and Economics,37,65-80.
  14. Bodvarsson, Ö. B.,Brastow, R. T.(1999).A test of employer discrimination in the NBA.Contemporary Economic Policy,17,243-255.
  15. Bodvarsson, Ö. B.,Brastow, R. T.(1998).Do employers pay for consistent performance: Evidence from the NBA.Economic Inquiry,36,145-160.
  16. Bodvarsson, Ö. B.,Papps, K. L.,Sessions, J. G.(2014).Cross-assignment discrimination in pay: A test case of major league baseball.Labour Economics,28,84-95.
  17. Bodvarsson, Ö. B.,Partridge, M. D.(2001).A supply and demand model of co-worker, employer and customer discrimination.Labour Economics,8,389-416.
  18. Bodvarsson, Ö. B.,Pettman, S. P.(2002).Racial wage discrimination in Major League Baseball: Do free agency and league size matter?.Applied Economics Letters,9,791-796.
  19. Brown, E.,Spiro, R.,Keenan, D.(1991).Wage and nonwage discrimination in professional basketball: Do fans affect it?.American Journal of Economics and Sociology,50,333-345.
  20. Bruggink, T. H.,Williams, D.(2009).Discrimination against Europeans in the National Hockey League: Are players getting their fair pay?.The American Economist,54,82-90.
  21. Bryson, A.,Rossi, G.,Simmons, R.(2014).The migrant wage premium in professional football: A superstar effect?.Kyklos,67,12-28.
  22. Burnett, N. J.,Van Scyoc, L. J.(2015).Compensation discrimination in the National Football League.Journal of Economics and Economic Education Research,16,60-71.
  23. Burnett, N. J.,Van Scyoc, L. J.(2013).Compensation discrimination for defensive players.Journal of Sports Economics,16,375-389.
  24. Bykova, A.,Coates, D.(2020).Does experience matter? Salary dispersion, coaching, and team performance.Contemporary Economic Policy,38,188-205.
  25. Capen, E. C.,Clapp, R. V.,Campbell, W. M.(1971).Competitive bidding in high-risk situations.Journal of Petroleum Technology,23,641-653.
  26. Celik, O. B.,Ince-Yenilmez, M.(2017).Salary differences under the salary cap in Major League Soccer.International Journal of Sports Science & Coaching,12,623-634.
  27. Chris, J.,Todd, P.(2019).NFL salary cap allocation: Matching theory with observed behavior.Economics Bulletin,39,270-279.
  28. Dey, M. S.(1997).Racial differences in National Basketball Association players salaries: A new look.The American Economist,41,84-90.
  29. Dietl, H. M.,Lang, M.,Rathke, A.(2009).The combined effect of salary restrictions and revenue sharing in sports leagues.Economic Inquiry,49,447-463.
  30. Ducking, J.,Groothuis, P. A.,Hill, J. R.(2014).Compensation discrimination in the NFL: An analysis of career earnings.Applied Economics Letters,21,679-682.
  31. Ducking, J.,Groothuis, P. A.,Hill, J. R.(2017).Compensation discrimination: An analysis of linebackers, defensive linemen, and defensive backs in the National Football League.The Review of Black Political Economy,44(3-4),251-260.
  32. Eschker, E.,Perez, S. J.,Siegler, M. V.(2004).The NBA and the influx of international basketball players.Applied Economics,36,1009-1020.
  33. Gius, M.,Johnson, D.(1998).An empirical investigation of wage discrimination in professional basketball.Applied Economics Letters,5,703-705.
  34. Gius, M.,Johnson, D.(2000).Race and compensation in professional football.Applied Economics Letters,7,73-75.
  35. Groothuis, P. A.,Hill, J. R.(2013).Pay discrimination, exit discrimination or both? Another look at an old issue using NBA data.Journal of Sports Economics,14,171-185.
  36. Gwartney, J.,Haworth, C.(1974).Employer costs and discrimination: The case of baseball.Journal of Political Economy,82,873-881.
  37. Hamilton, B. H.(1997).Racial discrimination and professional basketball salaries in the 1990s.Applied Economics,29,287-296.
  38. Hill, J. R.(2004).Pay discrimination in the NBA revisited.Quarterly Journal of Business and Economics,43(1/2),81-92.
  39. Hill, J. R.,Groothuis, P. A.(2017).Is there a wage premium or wage discrimination for foreign-born players in the NBA?.International Journal of Sport Finance,12,204-221.
  40. Hill, J. R.,Jolly, N. A.(2012).Salary distribution and collective bargaining agreements: A case study of the NBA.Industrial Relations: A Journal of Economy and Society,51,342-363.
  41. Hill, J. R.,Spellman, W.(1984).Pay discrimination in baseball: Data from the seventies.Industrial Relations,23,103-112.
  42. Hoang, H.,Rascher, D.(1999).The NBA, exit discrimination, and career earnings.Industrial Relations: A Journal of Economy and Society,38,69-91.
  43. Hoffer, A. J.,Friedel, R.(2014).Does salary discrimination persist for foreign athletes in the NBA?.Applied Economics Letters,21,1-5.
  44. Holmes, P.(2011).New evidence of salary discrimination in Major League Baseball.Labour Economics,18,320-331.
  45. Idson, T.,Kahane, L.(2000).Team effects on compensation: An application to salary determination in the National Hockey League.Economic Inquiry,38,345-357.
  46. Jane, W. J.(2012).Minority's salsry discrimination in the chinese professional baseball league.International Journal of Sport Finance,7,73-93.
  47. Jane, W. J.,Chen, S. T.,Kuo, M. H.(2013).Does salary discrimination by nationality exist? The case of Nippon Professional Baseball league.Modern Economy,4,93-101.
  48. Jang, H.(2019).Salary distribution and team outcome: The comparison of MLB and KBO.Journal of Global Sport Management,4,149-163.
  49. Jenkins, J. A.(1996).A reexamination of salary discrimination in professional basketball.Social Science Quarterly,77,594-608.
  50. Jennings, K.,Mclaughlin, F.(1989).Wage and performance discrimination: The situation facing Hispanics and blacks in Major League Baseball.Journal of Behavioral Economics,18,237-250.
  51. Jones, J. C. H.,Nadeau, S.,Walsh, W. D.(1999).Ethnicity, productivity and salary: Player compensation and discrimination in the National Hockey League.Applied Economics,31,593-608.
  52. Jones, J. C. H.,Walsh, W. D.(1988).Salary determination in the national hockey league: The effects of skills, franchise characteristics, and discrimination.Industrial and Labor Relations Review,41,592-604.
  53. Kahn, L. M.(1992).The effects of race on professional football players compensation.Industrial and Labor Relations Review,45,295-310.
  54. Kahn, L. M.(2000).The sports business as a labor market laboratory.Journal of Economic Perspectives,14,75-94.
  55. Kahn, L. M.,Shah, M.(2005).Race, compensation and contract length in the NBA: 2001-2002.Industrial Relations,44,444-462.
  56. Kahn, L. M.,Sherer, P. D.(1988).Racial differences in professional basketball players’ compensation.Journal of Labor Economics,6,40-61.
  57. Katayama, H.,Nuch, H.(2011).A game-level analysis of salary dispersion and team performance in the national basketball association.Applied Economics,43,1193-1207.
  58. Keefer, Q. A.(2013).Compensation discrimination for defensive players: Applying quantile regression to the National Football League market for linebackers.Journal of Sports Economics,14,23-44.
  59. Lavoie, M.(2000).The location of pay discrimination in the National Hockey League.Journal of Sports Economics,1,401-411.
  60. Lazear, E. P.,Rosen, S.(1981).Rank-order tournaments as optimum labor contracts.Journal of Political Economy,89,841-864.
  61. Leeds, M. A.,Sakata, S.,von Allmen, P.(2012).Labor markets and national culture: Salary determination in Japanese baseball.Eastern Economic Journal,38,479-494.
  62. Lenten, L. J.,Geerling, W.,Kónya, L.(2012).A hedonic model of player wage determination from the Indian Premier League auction: Further evidence.Sport Management Review,15,60-71.
  63. Longley, N.(2003).The effects of inter-league competition on labor market discrimination: Assessing the impacts of the world hockey association.The Social Science Journal,40,651-656.
  64. Longley, N.(1995).Salary discrimination in the National Hockey League: The effects of team location.Canadian Public Policy,4,413-422.
  65. McLean, R.,Veall, M.(1992).Performance and salary differentials in the National Hockey League.Canadian Public Policy/Analyse de Politiques,18,470-475.
  66. Mulholland, J.,Jensen, S. T.(2019).Optimizing the allocation of funds of an NFL team under the salary cap.International Journal of Forecasting,35,767-775.
  67. Naito, H.,Takagi, Y.(2017).Is racial salary discrimination disappearing in the NBA? evidence from data during 1985-2015.International Review of Applied Economics,31,651-669.
  68. Ouchi, W. G.(1980).Market, bureaucracies, and clans.Administrative Science Quarterly,25,129-141.
  69. Pager, D.,Bonikowski, B.,Western, B.(2009).Discrimination in low-wage labor market: A field experiment.American Sociological Review,74,777-799.
  70. Palmer, M. C.,King, R. H.(2006).Has salary discrimination really disappeared from Major League Baseball?.Eastern Economic Journal,32,285-297.
  71. Peach, J. T.,Fullerton, S. L.,Fullerton, T. M.(2015).An empirical analysis of the 2014 Major League Baseball season.Applied Economics Letters,23,138-141.
  72. Scott, F. A., Jr,Long, J. E.,Somppi, K.(1985).Salary vs. marginal revenue product under monopsony and competition: The case of professional basketball.Atlantic Economic Journal,13,50-59.
  73. Scully, G. W.(1973).Economic discrimination in professional sports.Law and Contemporary Problems,38,67-84.
  74. Singh, P.,Sack, A.,Dick, R.(2003).Free agency and pay discrimination in Major League Baseball.Sociology of Sport Journal,20,275-286.
  75. Slottje, D. J.,Hirschberg, J. G.,Hayes, K. J.,Scully, G. W.(1994).A new method for detecting individual and group labor market discrimination.Journal of Econometrics,61,43-64.
  76. Smith, E.,Seff, M. A.(1989).Race, position segregation and salary equity in professional baseball.Journal of Sport and Social Issues,13,92-110.
  77. von Allmen, P.,Leeds, M.,Malakorn, J.(2015).Victims or beneficiaries: Wage premia and national origin in the National Hockey League.Journal of Sport Management,29,633-641.
  78. Wang, J. S.,Fang, P. H.,Wu, T. M.(2017).An inquiry into wage discrimination based on nationality: The case of the Korean Baseball Organization.International Journal of Sport Finance,12,359-385.
  79. Yang, C.,Lin, H.(2012).Is there salary discrimination by nationality in the NBA?.Journal of Sports Economics,13,53-75.
  80. 林灼榮,黃琛瑞,謝俊魁,李明倫(2012)。職棒野手之攻守表現能否反映於其薪資？三階段System DEA之應用。經濟與管理論叢，8(1)，101-120。
被引用次数
  1. (2024)。「範域文獻回顧」在運動社會科學的應用。大專體育學刊，26(1)，i-viii。
print cancel