鈍劍選手之技能水準對攻擊分位預期能力之比較

The expertise effect in anticipating the foil fencing attack positions

10.6497/BSEPT.202307_23(2).0001

楊謹蔓(Chin-Man Yang)；黃揚名(Yang-Ming Huang)；陳尹華(Yin-Hua Chen)；謝宗諭(Tsung-Yu Hsieh)

預期 ； 時間遮蔽 ； 運動學訊息 ； 擊劍 ； Anticipation ； Temporal occlusion ； Kinematics ； fencing

臺灣運動心理學報

23卷2期（2023 / 07 / 31）

1 - 17

繁體中文;英文

目的：本研究以時間遮蔽典範之概念出發，探討不同技能水準鈍劍選手，在預測對手進攻不同分位的表現。方法：招募優秀與一般選手各14位，呈現對手兩種攻擊分位於攻擊完成前不同時間點之畫面，要求其觀察並預測對手的攻擊分位。兩組選手的預測正確率和反應時間，均以三因子混合設計變異數分析進行統計考驗。結果：優秀組預測正確率較高、反應時間較短。兩組均在預測四分位與八分位、於不同觸擊前時間點的正確率呈相反趨勢，特別是優秀組在預測八分位之正確率隨觸擊前時間越短而提高；一般組正確率雖也有此趨勢，但在觸擊前120毫秒下降，可能與畫面中選手劍條與劍道重疊干擾導致，突顯優秀組能除了知覺劍條的位置，亦能偵測畫面中對手關鍵之運動學前線索。兩組在預測四分位之正確率，優秀組仍能比一般組更快做出預判。結論：高技能水準選手更能有效地在短時間內，知覺對手進攻不同部位時之持劍姿勢以及武器移動之重要訊息，進而增進預判表現，可供一般選手參考。

Purpose: : This study used temporal occlusion paradigm to investigate the action anticipation of expert and non-expert foil fencers while observing various attack movements of an opponent player. Method: Attack movements of different time points were visually presented to 14 experts and 14 non-expert fencers. Participants were instructed to observe and predict the position of the attack as soon as possible. Reaction times and accuracy data were analyzed using three-way (2 groups x 4 time occlusion points x 2 attack positions) mixed-design ANOVAs. Results: Expert fencers outperformed non-expert fencers in all stimulus conditions by showing higher accuracy and shorter reaction times. Interestingly, the two groups showed opposite patterns in their accuracy as the occlusion time decreased for the Quarte and Octave positions. Specifically, expert fencers showed higher accuracy for an attack on the Octave position in later temporal occlusion conditions. However, non-expert fencers were less accurate for the 120ms condition, which may be due to the disruption by the opponent's foil overlapped fencing piste. Nevertheless, expert fencers had shorter reaction time when both groups anticipated the Quarte position. Conclusion: These results indicated that experts not only detected accurate positions of the foil, but also perceived the precues of movement kinematics of the opponent. These empirical findings demonstrate the importance of anticipation cues, which can be beneficial for the design of training interventions to enhance athletes' perceptual skills.

1. 王三財,陳世昌,陳奕良(2019)。複合式訓練對擊劍選手下肢爆發力及動作反應之探討。運動研究，28(2)，67-88。
   連結：
2. 謝宗諭,劉有德(2007)。生物動作與運動。中華體育季刊，21(2)，68-74。
   連結：
3. FIE Technical Rules (2020). Rules for competitions of the FIE, Losananne, Switzerland: FIE, 2020. https://fie.org/fie/documents/rules
4. Abernethy, B.(1990).Anticipation in squash: Differences in advance cue utilization. between expert and novice players.Journal of Sports Sciences,8(1),17-34.
5. Abernethy, B.(1990).Expertise, visual search, and information pick-up in squash.Perception,19(1),63-77.
6. Abernethy, B.,Gill, D. P.,Parks, S. L.,Packer, S. T.(2001).Expertise and The perception of kinematic and situational probability information.Perception,30(2),233-252.
7. Abernethy, B.,Russell, D. G.(1987).The relationship between expertise and visual. search strategy in a racquet sport.Human Movement Science,6(4),283-319.
8. Albert, B.,Tullis, T.(2013).Measuring the user experience: collecting, analyzing, and presenting usability metrics.Elsevier.
9. Alder, D.,Ford, P. R.,Causer, J.,Williams, A. M.(2014).The coupling between gaze behavior and opponent kinematics during anticipation of badminton shots.Human Movement Science,37,167-179.
10. Cañal-Bruland, R.,Mann, D. L.(2015).Time to broaden the scope of research on. anticipatory behavior: a case for the role of probabilistic information.Frontiers In Psychology,6,1518.
11. Cañal-Bruland, R.,Mooren, M.,Savelsbergh, G. J.(2011).Differentiating experts' anticipatory skills in beach volleyball.Research Quarterly for Exercise and Sport,82(4),667-674.
12. Causer, J.,Smeeton, N. J.,Williams, A. M.(2017).Expertise differences In anticipatory judgements during a temporally and spatially occluded task.PloS One,12(2),e0171330.
13. Chen, Y. H.,Chang, C. Y.,Huang, S. K.,Yen, N. S.(2020).Nonlinear engagement of action observation network underlying action anticipation in players with different levels of expertise.Human Brain Mapping,41(18),5199-5214.
14. Chen, Y. H.,Lee, P. H.,Lu, Y. W.,Huang, S. K.,Yen, N. S.(2017).Contributions of perceptual and motor experience of an observed action to anticipating its result.Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Perception and Performance,43(2),307-316.
15. Gibson, J. J.(2014).The ecological approach to visual perception: classic edition.Psychology press.
16. Gray, R.(2021).How we learn to move: A revolution in the way we coach & practice sports skills.Perception Action Consulting & Education LLC.
17. Gredin, N. V.,Bishop, D. T.,Broadbent, D. P.,Tucker, A.,Williams, A. M.(2018).Experts integrate contextual priors and environmental information to improve anticipation. Efficiency.Journal of Experimental Psychology: Applied,24(4),509-520.
18. Hagemann, N.,Schorer, J.,Canal-Bruland, R.,Lotz, S.,Strauss, B.(2010).Visual perception in fencing: do the eye movements of fencers represent their information pickup?.Attention, Perception & Psychophysics,72(8),2204-2214.
19. Johansson, G.(1973).Visual perception of biological motion and a model for its analysis.Perception & Psychophysics,14(2),201-211.
20. Loffing, F.,Cañal-Bruland, R.(2017).Anticipation in sport.Current Opinions In Psychology,16,6-11.
21. Loffing, F.,Hagemann, N.(2014).On-court position influences skilled tennis players' anticipation of shot outcome.Journal of Sport and Exercise Psychology,36(1),14-26.
22. Mann, D. L.,Schaefers, T.,Cañal-Bruland, R.(2014).Action preferences and The anticipation of action outcomes.Acta Psychologica,152,1-9.
23. Murphy, C. P.,Jackson, R. C.,Cooke, K.,Roca, A.,Benguigui, N.,Williams, A. M.(2016).Contextual information and perceptual-cognitive expertise in a dynamic, temporally-constrained task.Journal of Experimental Psychology Applied,22(4),455-470.
24. Newell, K. M.(1986).Constraints on the Development of Coordination.Motor Development in Children: Aspects of Coordination and Control,Dordrecht:
25. Roi, G. S.,Bianchedi, D.(2008).The science of fencing.Sports Medicine,38(6),465-481.
26. Runswick, O. R.,Green, R.,North, J. S.(2020).The effects of skill-level and playing-position on the anticipation of ball-bounce in rugby union.Human Movement Science,69,102544.
27. Savelsbergh, G.,Gastel, P.,Van Kampen, P.(2010).Anticipation of penalty kicking direction can be improved by directing attention through perceptual learning.International Journal of Sport Psychology,41(1),24-41.
28. Williams, A. M.(2009).Perceiving the intentions of others: how do skilled performers make anticipation judgments?.Progress in Brain Research,174,73-83.
29. Williams, A. M.,Jackson, R. C.(2019).Anticipation in sport: Fifty years on, what have we learned and what research still needs to be undertaken?.Psychology of Sport and Exercise,42,16-24.
30. 李冠毅(2018)。台中市，國立台灣體育運動大學體育研究所。
31. 林紀光(2020)。桃園市，國立體育大學運動保健學系。
32. 陳尹華(2008)。台北市，國立台灣師範大運動科學研究所。
33. 劉奕呈(2011)。台東市，國立台東大學進修部。

1. (2024)。以視覺辨識桌球擊球與揮空拍動作協調型態差異。臺灣運動心理學報，24(2)，47-61。