從多樣性元素與空間整合模式探討歷史性都市古蹟旅遊發展策略

The Spatial Patterns and Quality of the Core and Periphery Factors in Urban Heritage Tourism

10.7110/HKGJ.200806.0136

游舜德(Tony Shun-Te You)

市中心生氣與活力 ； 聚集經濟 ； 古蹟保存 ； 都市行銷 ； City viability and vitality ； Agglomeration economies ； Heritage conservation ； Urban marketing

華岡地理學報

21期（2008 / 06 / 01）

136 - 158

繁體中文

全球的歷史性都市在當前發展上，均面臨了同樣的課題，即如何在全球化激烈競爭的環境下，定義出都市本身永續發展的目標與策略。此類城市的空間規劃者，亟思透過經營管理與行銷策略等方法，使歷史文化都市再活化，讓歷史文化遺產不僅不成爲發展上的包袱，反而爲該都市形成獨特性與相對優勢的資源。歷史文化都市由於具有悠久的古蹟遺產，這些有形與無形的資產所具備的內涵與氣質，往往是其他都市在發展上亟欲尋求卻不可得的。但歷史性城市並非僅一味的透過多樣化與功能提升便可極大化其聚集經濟，毫無規範的歧異度可稱爲混亂，而與空間配置效率原則相牴觸的多樣性，反而會減損聚集經濟的效果。 本文希望透過多樣性與聚集經濟相關理論，分析歷史都市中所構成的多樣性元素的品質面向，及這些元素在空間規劃與營運管理上的相關性，並針對五大策略方向進行探討：其一爲核心、周邊與支援性元素的有效整合，包含類別、權重與空間分派的連貫性；其二爲多樣性元素在空間規劃上的合理效率分配與連貫，包括要素空間模式的運用與元素的連貫性；以及正向交互作用的極大化軸線發展兩個理論；其三討論歷史性都市發展上各相關部門相互支援的效率與協調能力；第四個策略重點在於都市行銷策略的擬定：相對優勢的建立與發揮；以及第五個策略建議探討各元素的經營管理，也就是從市鎮中心管理模式中尋求聚集經濟極大化的方法。

Historical cities in the world now face the same concern: how to establish sustainable strategies, thus to increase competitions both in tourism and economy. Nevertheless, conflicts always occurred between protecting heritages and increasing the strength in urban tourism industry. Previous research showed that only a city with enough economic power has the ability to sustain its viability and vitality in urban tourism, so as to maintain its wish in preserving the historical and cultural heritages. This paper aims to reveal the spatial arrangement for the core and periphery factors, namely the quality of variety, in historical cities. Through gravity model, the connection and accessibility between core factors should be intensified. At the same time, the periphery factors enhance the variety in tourism and the supportive services increase the amenity of staying. The strength of attractiveness for these core factors enables the city the possibility solution in considering its development strategy. Only the customer-oriented based city that can draw in the desired quantity of customers. This research compared a southern historical city. To show that both the quantity of its core and periphery attractions should be increased and also the consideration in creating a more user friendly connection is crucial.

1. Borg, Jan van der,Costa, P.,Gotti, G.(1996).Tourism in European heritage cities.Annals of Tourism Research,23(2),306-321.
2. Brown, S.(1991).Shopper Circulation in a Planned Shopping Centre.International Retail and Distribution Management,19(1),17-24.
3. Caserta, S.,Russo, A. P.(2002).More means worse asymmetric information spatial displacement and sustainable heritage tourism.Journal of Cultural Economics,26,245-260.
4. Chang, T. C.,Milne, S.,Fallon, D.,Pohlmann, C.(1996).Urban heritage tourism: the : global local Nexus.Annals of Tourism Research,23(2),284-305.
5. Christaller, W.,C. W. Baskin (trans.)(1933).Die Zentralen Orte in Suddeutschland, Verlag. Traduit par Baskin.Englewood Cliffs, N.J.:Prentice-Hall, Central Places in Southern Germany.
6. Du Cros, H.(2001).A new model to assist in planning for sustainable cultural heritage tourism.International journal of tourism research,3,165-170.
7. Fujita, M.(1989).Urban Economic Theory: Land Use and City Size.Cambridge University Press.
8. Fujita, M.,J. Thisse(2002).Economics of Agglomeration Cities, industrial Location, and Regional Growth.Cambridge University Press.
9. Goldstein, G. S.,T. J. Gronberg(1984).Economies of Scope and Economies of Agglomeration.Journal of Urban Economics,16,91-104.
10. Gössling, S.(2003).Market integration and ecosystem degradation: is sustainable tourism development in rural communities a contradiction term? Environment.Development and Sustainability,5(4),383-400.
11. Gössling, S.(2003).Market integration and ecosystem degradation: is sustainable tourism development in rural communities a contradiction term? Environment.Development and Sustainability,5(3),383-400.
12. Hotelling, H.(1929).Stability in Competition.Economic Journal,39,41-57.
13. Hovinen, G. R.(1995).Heritage issues in urban tourism: an assessment of new trends in Lancaster county.Tourism management,16(5),381-388.
14. Krugman, P.(1991).Increasing Returns and Economic Geography.The Journal of Political Economy,99(3),483-499.
15. Li, Y.(2003).Heritage tourism the contradictions between conservation and change.Tourism and Hospitality Research,4(3),247-261.
16. Marshall, A.(1920).Principles of Economics.London:Macmillan and Co. Limited.
17. Nasser, N.(2003).Planning for urban heritage places: reconciling conservation, tourism, and sustainable development.Journal of Planning Literature,17(4),467-479.
18. Panzar, J. C.,R. D. Willig(1981).Economies of Scope.The American Economic Review,71(2),268-272.
19. Prideaux, B.(2002).Building visitor attractions in peripheral areas- can uniqueness isolation to produce viability?.International Journal of Tourism Research,4,379-389.
20. Russo, A. P.,Boniface, P.,Shoval, N.(2001).Tourism management in heritage cities.Annals of Tourism Research,28(3),824-826.
21. Schiller, R.(1994).Vitality and viability: challenge to the town centre.International Journal of Retail and Distribution Management,22(6),46-50.
22. Yuo, T. S.(2004).UK,University of Reading (UK), The Department of Real Estate and Planning.
23. 李自浩、游舜德(2005)。從休閒觀光元素連續性概念探討花蓮區域行銷之策略。2005年全國學生休閒、觀光、遊憩學術論文研討會
24. 唐富藏、于宗先編(1986)。空間經濟學。聯經出版社。
25. 陳睿、呂斌(2004)。區域旅遊地空間自組織網絡模型及其應用。地理與地理信息科學，20(6)，81-96,98。
26. 游舜德、許慧琪編(2001)。二十一世紀台灣20大購物中心全覽。流通快訊與中華民國購物中心協會。
27. 蘇平、黨寧、吳必虎(2004)。北京環城遊憩帶旅遊地類型與空間結構特徵。地理研究，23(3)，403-410。

1. 殷寶寧(2014)。以博物館為方法之古蹟活化策略探討—淡水古蹟博物館觀眾經驗研究個案。博物館學季刊，28(4)，23-53。