合約商評選及委外策略分析：以飛機維修為例

Analysis of Contractor Selection and Outsourcing Strategies: The Case of Aircraft Maintenance

10.6736/JPSR.201509_12(2).0001

陳欽雨(Chin-Yeu Chen)；呂博裕(Bor-Yuh Leu)；鄭鈞元(Chun-Yuan Cheng)

合約商評選 ； 關鍵因素 ； 委外策略 ； Contractor Selection ； Critical Factors ； Outsourcing Strategy

績效與策略研究

12卷2期（2015 / 09 / 01）

1 - 29

繁體中文

本研究採用專家問卷調查法，以航空公司中、高階主管和從業人員為調查對象，結合運用模糊平均數、灰關聯度值及集群分析，將45 項考量因素依重要性衡量值進行排序及集群分析，分成基本因素、重要因素及關鍵因素等三個集群，從中篩選出28 項重要考量因素，進一步萃取出品質、交期、授權認證、執照等10 項評選因素。同時，選擇停機線全代理、停機線一般代理及機體修護等三種國內航空公司常用之飛機維修委外策略，分析其對28 項評選重要考量因素之差異性影響及實務意涵。研究結果發現，生產設備、庫存量、應變能力等九項評選因素，在不同之委外策略下，其重要性是有所差異的。研究結果可提供航空公司進行評選飛機維修廠商及績效考核，同時亦可作為採行不同維修委外策略評選考量因素之參考。

The study investigated the domestic aviation industry, selecting medium or top managers and professionals as samples, and adopted the approaches of fuzzy numbers, grey relation, and clustering techniques for analysis. For selecting qualified outsourcing contractors, forty-five criteria are chosen as the concerned factors ranking in the order of their ratings. Subsequently, a two-step cluster analysis was performed based on the ratings to identify the inherent groups. A two-step cluster analysis was performed using the twenty-eight criteria which were categorized into three groups named as based factors, significant factors, and critical factors. The critical factors including ten criteria are quality, delivering date, authorization and certification, license, and so on. The study further analyzed how the twenty-eight criteria were affected by three types of outsourcing strategies, aircraft line maintenance full handling, aircraft line maintenance general ground servicing, and aircraft heavy maintenance. The results indicated that there were nine criteria with discrepancy of significance when applied to different outsourcing models. The findings can offer the airlines to select contractors and outsourcing strategies, as well as evaluate their performance.

1. 何煖軒(2013)。高鐵桃園站站區開發及聯外運輸系統之研究。績效與策略研究，10(2)，1-32。
   連結：
2. 袁瑞霞(2006)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。國立中央大學土木工程學研究所。
   連結：
3. 盧文民、王東寶(2011)。科技專案研發效率與技術擴散能力之研究。績效與策略研究，8(1)，1-22。
   連結：
4. (2002).The Economics of Outsourcing.
5. Alkaabi, H.,Potter, A.,Naim, M.(2007).An outsourcing decision models for airlines' MRO activities.Journal of Quality in Maintenance Engineering,13(3),217-227.
6. Arnold, U.(2000).New dimensions of outsourcing: A combination of transaction cost economics and the core competencies concept.European Journal of Purchasing & Supply Management,6(1),23-29.
7. Bhagat, P.,Byramjee, F.,Taiani, V.(2010).A framework of total value orientation for strategic outsourcing decisions.Competitiveness Review: An International Business Journal,20(4),305-321.
8. Brewer, B.,Ashenbaum, B.,Ogden, J. A.(2013).Connecting strategy-linked outsourcing approaches and expected performance.International Journal of Physical Distribution & Logistics Management,43(3),176-204.
9. Cao, Q.,Wang, Q.(2007).Optimizing vendor selection in a two-stage outsourcing process.Computers & Operations Research,34(12),3757-3768.
10. Chaudhry, S. S.,Forst, F. G.,Zydiak, J. L.(1993).Vender selection with price break.European Journal of Operational Research,70(1),52-56.
11. Collins, J. S.,Millen, R. A.(1995).Information systems outsourcing by large American industrial firms: Choices and impacts.Information Resources Management Journal,8(1),5-13.
12. Delmotte, J.,Sels, L.(2008).HR outsourcing: Threat or opportunity?.Personnel Review,37(5),543-563.
13. Deng, J. L.(1989).Introduction to grey system theory.The Journal of Grey System,1(1),1-24.
14. Deng, J. L.(1982).Control problems of grey system.Systems and Control Letters,1,288-294.
15. Dickson, G. W.(1966).An analysis of supplier selection systems and decision.Journal of Purchasing,2(1),5-17.
16. Ellram, L. M.,Tate, W.L.,Billington, C.(2008).Offshore outsourcing of professional services: A transaction cost economics perspective.Journal of Operations Management,26,148-163.
17. Guielford, J. P.(1965).Fundamental statistics in psychology and education.New York:McGraw-Hill.
18. Heywood, J. B.(2001).Outsouring dilemma: The search for competitiveness.New York:McGraw-Hill.
19. Houshyar, A.,David, L.(1992).A systematic supplier-selection procedure.Computer and Industrial Engineering,23(1-4),173-176.
20. Jain, R. K.,Natarajan, R.(2011).Factors influencing the outsourcing decisions: a study of the banking sector in India.Strategic Outsourcing: An International Journal,4(3),294-322.
21. Jiang, B.,Frazier, G. V.,Prater, E. L.(2006).Outsourcing effects on firms' operation performance: An empirical study.International Journal of Operations & Production Management,26(12),1280-1300.
22. Kar, A. K.,Pani, A. K.(2014).Exploring the importance of different supplier selection criteria.Management Research Review,37(1),89-105.
23. Lambert, D. M.,Stock, J. M.,Ellram, L. M.(1998).Fundamentals of logistics management.Boston, MA:Irwin/McGraw-Hill.
24. Lomas, P. N.(1997).The implications of outsourcing.Frozen Food Age,46(5),33-36.
25. Millinton, A.,Eberhardt, M.,Wilkinson, B.(2006).Supplier performance and selection in China.International Journal of Operations & Production Management,26(2),185-201.
26. Minoli, D.(1995).Analyzing outsourcing: Reengineering information and communication system.New York:McGraw-Hill.
27. Nam, K.,Rajagopalan, S.,Rao, H. R.,Chaudhury, A.(1996).A two-level investigation of information systems outsourcing.Communication of the ACM,39(7),36-44.
28. Nydick, R. L.,Hill, R. P.(1992).Using the analytic hierarchy process to structure the supplier selection procedure.International Journal of Purchasing and Materials Management,28(2),31-36.
29. Ordanini, A.,Silvestri, G.(2008).Recruitment and selection services: Efficiency and competitive reasons in the outsourcing of HR practices.International Journal of Human Resource Management,19(2),372-391.
30. Ordoobadi, S. M.(2009).Development of a supplier selection model using fuzzy logic.Supply Chain Management: An International Journal,14(4),314-327.
31. Ordoobadi, S. M.,Wang, S.(2011).A multiple perspectives approach to supplier selection.Industrial Management & Data Systems,111(4),629-648.
32. Punniyamoorty, M.,Mathiyalagan, P.,Lakshmi, G.(2012).A combined application of structural equation modeling (SEM) and analytic hierarchy process (AHP) in supplier selection.Benchmarking: An International Journal,19(1),70-92.
33. Quinn, J. B.,Hilmer, F. G.(1994).Strategic outsourcing.Sloan Management Review,36(4),43-56.
34. Samaranayake, P.,Kiridena, S.(2012).Aircraft maintenance planning and scheduling: an integrated framework.Journal of Quality in Maintenance Engineering,18(4),432-453.
35. Sevkli, M.,Koh, S. C. L.,Zaim, S.,Demirbag, M.,Tatoglu, E.(2008).Hybrid analytical hierarchical process model for supplier selection.Industrial Management & Data Systems,108(1),122-142.
36. Sharpe, M.(1997).Outsourcing, organizational competitiveness and work.Journal of Labor Research,18(4),535-549.
37. Soukup, W. R.(1987).Supplier selection strategies.Journal of Purchasing and Materials Management,23(2),7-13.
38. Suff, R.(2007).Outsourcing the recruitment process: Quality gains over quantity.IRS Employment Review,863,26-32.
39. Taaffe, K. M.,William, R.,Grigg, A. L.(2014).Performance metrics analysis for aircraft maintenance process control.Journal of Quality in Maintenance Engineering,20(2),122-134.
40. Tate, W. L.,Ellram, L. M.(2009).Offshore outsourcing: A managerial framework.Journal of Business & Industrial Marketing,24(3/4),256-268.
41. Thompson, K. N.(1990).Vendor profile analysis.Journal of Purchasing and Materials Management,Winter,11-18.
42. Timmerman, E.(1986).An approach to vendor performance evaluation.Journal of Purchasing and Materials Management,22(4),2-9.
43. Weber, C. A.,Current, J. R.(1993).A multi-objective approach to vendor selection.European Journal of Operational Research,68(2),173-176.
44. Yang, C. C.,Chen, B. S.(2006).Supplier selection using combined analytical hierarchy process and grey relational analysis.Journal of Manufacturing Technology Management,17(7),926-941.
45. Zadeh, I. A.(1965).Fuzzy sets.Information and Control,8,338-353.
46. 王晴(2005)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。中國文化大學企業管理研究所。
47. 許志諭(2005)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。國立成功大學高階管理碩士在職專班。
48. 黃子賢(1998)。國科會大學生參與專題研究計劃成果報告國科會大學生參與專題研究計劃成果報告,國立雲林科技大學工業工程與管理技術系。