臺灣路跑賽事參與者與當地居民對效益、衝擊、支持及永續發展認知之比較研究

The Comparison of the Benefits, Impact, Support, and Sustainability between Participants and Residents for Road Race Events in Taiwan

10.6169/NCYUJPEHR.14.3.01

劉照金(Chao-Chin Liu)；許玫琇(Mei-Hsiu Hsu)；陳志明(Zhi-Ming Chen)；莊哲仁(Che-Jen Chuang)

路跑賽事 ； 賽事效益 ； 賽事衝擊 ； 賽事支持 ； 永續發展 ； road race ； events benefit ； event impact ； event support ； sustainability

嘉大體育健康休閒期刊

14卷3期（2015 / 12 / 31）

1 - 15

繁體中文

本研究目的旨在比較臺灣路跑賽事參與者與當地居民對路跑賽事效益、衝擊、支持及永續發展之認知差異。研究方法以臺灣地區路跑賽事參與者與當地居民為研究對象，採便利取樣方法，獲得有效問卷1,825份，以獨立樣本t檢定路跑參與者與當地居民在路跑效益、衝擊、賽事支持及永續發展之認知差異，以配對樣本t檢定受試者對路跑賽事正面效益與負面衝擊認知差異。結果如下：(一)臺灣路跑賽事參與者在社會效益、環境效益、經濟效益、賽事支持及永續發展認知顯著高於當地居民，而在社會衝擊、環境衝擊及經濟衝擊之認知沒有顯著差異；(二)路跑賽事參與者或當地居民對路跑正面效益認知均顯著高於負面衝擊認知。綜合結論，本研究發現臺灣路跑賽事參與者在社會效益、環境效益、經濟效益、賽事支持及永續發展認知顯著高於當地居民，而且路跑賽事參與者或當地居民對路跑賽事正面效益認知明顯高於負面衝擊認知，主要原因可能與路跑參與者獲得社會正向認同，而當地居民卻須承擔環境、經濟及社會層面之衝擊結果，導致參與者或當地居民對路跑效益、賽事支持及永續發展認知落差，不過參與者與當地居民均認為路跑賽事正面效益高於負面衝擊。

This study compares the benefits, impact, support, and sustainability between participants and residents for road race events in Taiwan. The subjects were road race event participants and local residents. A questionnaire was self-developed called ＂road race events benefit, impact, support and sustainable cognitive scale.＂ A total of 1825 valid questionnaires were collected. The results revealed the following: 1) road race event participant cognition of social benefits, environmental benefits, economic benefits, event support, and sustainability were significantly higher than local residents; however, no significant differences were found in cognition of social impact, environmental impact, and economic impact; and 2) road race event participants and local residents cognition of the positive benefits were significantly higher than their cognition of the negative impacts. In conclusion, this study found that road race event participant cognition regarding the social benefits, environmental benefits, economic benefits, event support, and sustainability were significantly higher than for local residents. Also, road race event participant cognition regarding the positive benefits was significantly higher than the negative impacts. This was mainly caused by road race participants obtaining a positive social identity and local residents have to bear the impact of the results of the environmental, economic, and social dimensions, and resulting cognitive gap for event benefits, event support, and sustainability of participants and local residents. However, participants and local residents all believe that the positive benefits were higher than the negative impact of the road race events in Taiwan.

1. 張孝銘、邱姿菁(2011)。影響運動賽會觀光客運動觀光參與行為因素之研究─以金門國家公園馬拉松路跑賽為實證。休閒產業管理學刊，4(2)，57-76。
   連結：
2. 劉照金、董燊、郭芳坤、黃仲凌、陳志明(2015)。臺灣路跑賽事效益、衝擊、支持及永續發展量表編製之研究。美和學報，34(2)，1-30。
   連結：
3. Prat, A. G. (2000, 5, 12) . New trends in leisure and tourism. Retrieved Jan. 21th, 2015, from http://www.travelturisme.com/estudios/pdf/I-ocio-turismo.pdf
4. The U.S. Travel Association (2012, 8, 10) . Marathons, Tourism Works for America (2007 edition) , 2014, 02, 24. Retrieved from www.ustravel.org
5. 郭豐州 (2015，3 月7 日 ) 。《郭老師的跑步教室》：2014 台灣路跑回顧。2015年7 月12 日取自http://talk.ltn.com.tw/article/breakingnews/1250474
6. Hillcrest High School (2009, 12, 14) . Case study: The impact of The Comrades Marathon on sport tourism in South Africa. Retrieved May 12th, 2015 from http://www.gttp.org/content/listings/68/files/12/SouthAfrica.pdf
7. UNWTO (2004, 9, 12) . Sustainable development of tourism conceptual definition. 14 May, 2014, Retrieved from http://www.unwto.org/sustainable/concepts.htm
8. 曾文祺 (2013，9 月10 日 ) 。全年路跑211 場參賽127 萬人。2013 年12 月10日取自http://life.chinatimes.com/LifeContent/1409/20130910000399.html
9. Moore, B. (2007, 10, 13) . The environmental impact of running. Retrieved May 22th, 2015 from Welcome to Run to Win! http://news.runtowin.com/2007/10/15/the-environmental-impact-of-running.html
10. Dickinson, J. & Shipway, R. (2007, 5, 12) . Resource guide to the impact of events. Hospitality, Leisure, Sport and Tourism Network. Retrieved May 2, 2015 from https://www.heacademy.ac.uk/sites/default/files/the_impact_of_events.pdf
11. Stevenson, J. (2008, 8, 26) . Running's impact on the earth. Retrieved May 23, 2015 from R unner's World. http://www.runnersworld.com/other-gear/runnings-impact-earth
12. Agrusa, J.,Kim, S. S.,Lema, J. D.(2011).Comparison of Japanese and North American runners of the ideal marathon competition destination.Asia Pacific Journal of Tourism Research,16(2),183-207.
13. Akis, S.,Peristianis, N.,Warner, J.(1996).Residents' attitudes to tourism development: The case of Cyprus.Tourism Management,17(7),481-494.
14. Andereck, K.,Vogt, C.(2000).The relationship between residents' attitudes toward tourism and tourism development options.Journal of Travel Research,39(1),27-36.
15. Bob, U.,Swart, K.,Moodley, V.(2005).Evaluating socio-economic impacts of sport tourism events: Case studies from Durban, South Africa.Proceeding of The Impacts of Events Conference 2005,Sydney:
16. Brunt, P.,Courtney, P.(1999).Host perceptions of sociocultural impacts.Annals of Tourism Research,26(3),493-545.
17. Burgan, B.,Mules, T.(1992).Economic impact of sporting events.Annals of Tourism Research,19(2),700-710.
18. Chalip, L.,McGuirty, J.(2004).Bundling sport events with the host destination.Journal of Sport Tourism,9(3),267-282.
19. Chen, J. S.(2001).Assessing and visualizing tourism impacts from urban residents' perspectives.Journal of Hospitality & Tourism Research,25(3),235-250.
20. Cropanzano, R.,Mitchell, M.(2005).Social exchange theory: An interdisciplinary review.Journal of Management,31(6),874-900.
21. Daniels, M. J.,Norman, W. C.,Henry, M. S.(2004).Estimating income effects of sport tourism events.Annals of Tourism Research,31(1),180-199.
22. Dwyer, L.,Forsyth, P.,Spurr, R.(2005).Estimating the impacts of special events on an economy.Journal of Travel Research,43(4),351-359.
23. Fredline, E.(2005).Host and guest relations and sport tourism.Sport, Culture and Society,8(2),263-279.
24. Fredline, E.,Faulkner, B.(1998).Resident reactions to a major tourist event: The Gold Coast Car Race.Festival Management and Event Tourism,5(4),185-201.
25. Getz, D.(2005).Festivals, special events and tourism.New York:Van Nostrand.
26. Grundey, D.,Sarvutyte, M.,Skirmantaite, J.(2008).Prospects for sustainable tourism in Lithuania: A national survey: Guest editorial.Transformations in Business and Economics,7(1),21-51.
27. Gursoy, D. J.,Jurowski, C.,Uysal, M.(2002).Resident attitudes: A structural modeling approach.Annals of Tourism Research,29(1),79-105.
28. Hagham, J.(ed.)(2005).Sport tourism destinations.Amsterdam:Elsevier.
29. Hardiman, N.,Burgin, S.(2010).Visit impacts and canyon management in the Blue Mountains, Australia: Canyoners' perspectives and wilderness management.Managing Leisure,15(4),264-278.
30. Harrill, R.(2004).Residents' attitudes toward tourism development: A literature review, with implications for planning.Journal of Planning Literature,18(3),251-266.
31. Higham, J.(1999).Sport as an avenue of tourism development: An analysis of the positive and negative impacts of sport tourism.Current Issues in Tourism,2(1),82-90.
32. Horne, J. D.,Manzenreiter, W.(2004).Accounting for mega events: Forecast and actual impacts of the 2002 Football World Cup Finals on the host countries Japan/Korea.International Review for the Sociology of Sport,39(2),187-203.
33. Hritz, N.,Ross, C.(2010).The perceived impacts of sport tourism: An urban host community perspective.Journal of Sport Management,24(2),119-138.
34. Jackson, E.(ed.),Burton, T.(ed.)(1999).Leisure studies: Prospects for the Twenty-First Century.State College PA:Venture Publishing.
35. Jönsson, C.,Lewis, C. C.(2014).Impacts of hosting a sport event in tourism high season.Recreation and Society in Africa, Asia and Latin America,5(1),1.
36. Ko, D. W.,Stewart, W. P.(2002).A structural model of residents' attitude for tourism development.Tourism Management,23(5),521-530.
37. Kotze, N.(2006).Cape Town and the Two Oceans Marathon: The impact of sport tourism.Urban Forum,17(3),282-193.
38. MacDonald, M.(1998).Agendas for sustainability: Environment and development into the twenty-first century.London:Routledge.
39. Monterrubio, J. C.,Ramírez, O.,Ortiz, J. C.(2011).Host community attitudes towards sport tourism events: Social impacts of the 2011 Pan American Games.e-Review of Tourism Research (eRTR),9(2),33-46.
40. Mules, T.,Dwyer, L.(2005).Public sector support for sport tourism events: the role of cost-benefit analysis.Sport, Culture and Society,8(2),338-355.
41. O'Brien, D.,Chalip, L.(2007).Sustainability and sport events: exploring synergies between economic and social leverage.abstract book of 15th Congress of the European Association for Sport Management- Sport Events and Sustainable development,Turim: Italia:
42. Ohmann, S.,Jones, I.,Wilkes, K.(2006).The perceived social impacts of the 2006 Football World Cup on Munich residents.Journal of Sport & Tourism,11(2),129-152.
43. Ritchie, B.(Ed.),Adair, D.(Ed.)(2004).Sport tourism: interrelationships, impacts and issues.Clevedon:Channel View Publications.
44. Sharpley, R.(1999).Tourism, tourists and society.Huntingdon:Elm Publications.
45. Sheldon, P.,Var, T.(1984).Resident attitudes to tourism in North Wales.Tourism Management,5(1),40-48.
46. Turco, D. M.,Riley, R.,Swart, K.(2002).Sport tourism.Warrentown, WV:Fitness Information Technology, Inc..
47. Twynam, G. D.,Johnston, M.(2004).Changes in host community reactions to a special sporting event.Current Issues in Tourism,7(3),242-261.
48. University of Algarve(2003).Algarve Golf Study.Faro:University of Algarve.
49. Videira, N.,Correia, A.,Alves, I.,Ramires, C.,Subtil, R.,VIartins, V.(2006).Environmental and economic tools to support sustainable golf tourism: The Aigarve experience, Portugal.Tourism and Hospitality Research,6(3),204-217.
50. Weaver, D.(2006).Sustainable tourism.Oxford:Elsevier.
51. 陳春安(2011)。路跑運動之休閒效益研究。南台人文社會學報，5，73-98。
52. 陳家倫、楊涵鈞、簡欣穎(2012)。Nike Running Club 跑者參與動機與滿意度之研究。屏東教大體育，15，379-393。
53. 陳祺緼(2013)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。彰化巿，國立彰化師範大學地理學系。
54. 陳麗君、吳政崎、牟鍾福(2008)。運動觀光永續發展之研究。大專體育學術專刊，2008，305-311。
55. 劉照金(2015)。科技部專題研究計畫成果報告科技部專題研究計畫成果報告,台北市:中華民國科技部。

1. 劉照金,董燊,張俊一(2022)。台灣路跑賽事參與者市場區隔分析。運動休閒管理學報，19(1)，95-118。
2. 劉照金、劉一慧、董燊、李晉豪(2017)。臺灣路跑賽事滿意度、參與意圖及再參與行為之整合模式。大專體育學刊，19(4)，301-315。