题名

從國際法分析菲律賓群島制度主張

并列篇名

An Analysis of the Archipelagic Regime of the Philippines: From an International Law Perspective

作者

姜皇池(Huang-chih CHIANG)

关键词

菲律賓 ； 群島國制度 ； 群島基線 ； 海洋法公約 ； 無害通過權 ； 群島海道通行權 ； the Philippines ； regime of archipelagic States ； archipelagic baselines ； Law of the Sea Convention ； right of innocent passage ； right of archipelagic sea-lane passage

期刊名称

台灣國際研究季刊

卷期/出版年月

12卷4期（2016 / 12 / 01）

页次

1 - 53

内容语文

繁體中文
中文摘要

本文分成五大部分，用以檢視菲律賓的群島基線在國際法下之合法性。除對菲律賓在爭取群島制度的奮鬥過程予以陳述外，並檢視菲國在2009 年所通過之『群島基線法』之相關規定，雖然該法律在有關基線長度、群島水域比規定符合海洋法公約之相關規範，但因菲國有其歷史與政治因素，仍無法賦予外國船舶在菲律賓所主張群島水域內之無害通過權，亦否認外國船舶的群島海道通行權利，因此本文認為菲律賓的『群島基線法』仍未能完成符合『海洋法公約』之規定。
英文摘要

The present article is composed of five parts with the purpose of examining the legality of the Philippines' archipelagic baselines claim in the eyes of international law. In addition to an elaboration of the efforts of the Philippines to legalize the regime of archipelagic States in the international community, this article further examines the relevant provisions of the recently promulgated 2009 Law of Archipelagic Baselines of the Philippines. Although the provisions relating to the length of baselines and water-land ratio as provided in the 2009 Law are in conformity with the relevant provisions of the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea, the Philippines’s legislation denies the innocent passage and archipelagic sea-lanes passage rights for foreign vessels in the archipelagic waters of the Philippines. Accordingly, this article concludes that the Archipelagic Baselines Law of the Philippines is not in full conformity with the UNCLOS.
主题分类 人文學 > 人文學綜合
社會科學 > 社會科學綜合
参考文献
  1. 蒲國慶(2012)。菲律賓領域主張之演進。台灣國際法季刊，9(2)，123-48。
    連結：
  2. 胡念祖， 2009。〈對菲律賓海域主張演變之評析〉（ http://www.mofa.gov.tw/official/Home/Detail/f90399b3-3356-4052-95dc-aa4b6fae4895?arfid=8f8092a6-b477-4f92-bf94-031da11665cd&opno=0ab69338-b476-449c-8554-2c7d26534828 ）（2014/3/26）
  3. (1984).The Southeast Asian Archipelagic States: Concept, Evolution, and Current Practice.Honolulu:East-West Environment and Policy Institute, East-West Center.
  4. Evensen, Jens. 1958, “Certain Legal Aspects Concerning the Delimitation of theTerritorial Waters of Archipelagos.” A/CONF.13/18 (http://legal.un.org/diplomaticconferences/lawofthesea-1958/docs/english/vol_I/17_A-CONF-13-18_PrepDocs_vol_I_e.pdf) (2016/10/14)
  5. Magallona, et. al. v. Executive Secretary, et al., G.R. No. 187167, 2011 (http://sc.udiciary.gov.ph/jurisprudence/2011/august2011/187167.html) (2016/10/14)
  6. 王冠雄，n.d.〈菲律賓群島基線劃分群島海域問題之探討〉（http://www.mofa.gov.tw/official/Home/Detail/ac10dc3c-9d92-4449-831d-7b15350b5684?arfid=8f8092a6-b477-4f92-bf94-031da11665cd&opno=0ab69338-b476-449c-8554-2c7d26534828）（2014/3/26）。
  7. Garcia, Michael. 2009. “The Philippines Baselines Law.”(http://www.un.org/depts/los/nippon/unnff_programme_home/alumni/tokyo_alumni_presents_files/alum_tokyo_garcia.pdf) (2016/10/14)
  8. Trillanes, Antonio F. IV. n.d. “The Baseline Issue: A Positon Paper.”(http://www.google.com.tw/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd=17&ved=0ahUKEwifitHTpOrLAhUFnZQKHYmBAls4ChAWCD8wBg&url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.trillanes.com.ph%2Fsite%2Fassets%2Ffiles%2F1109%2Fbaseline_issue.doc&usg=AFQjCNFwFtfGzGENaoT7GCCHbr8OylYm-g) (2016/10/14)
  9. Oceans and Law of the Sea, United Nation. 2013. "Declarations and Statements." (http://www.un.org/Depts/los/convention_agreements/convention_declarations.htm #Philippines) (2016/10/14)
  10. Abad, Florencio(1977).Lessons from the RP-Taiwan Agreement on Sea Lane Passage.Ocean Law and Policy Series,1(1),70-73.
  11. Batongbacal, Jay L.(1997).The Philippines' Right to Designate Sea Lanes in Its Archipelagic Waters under International Law.Ocean Law and Policy Series,1(1),81-116.
  12. Batongbacal, Jay L.(2001).The Maritime Territories and Jurisdiction of the Philippines and the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea.Philippine Law Journal,76,123-68.
  13. Baumert, Kevin,Melchior, Brian(2015).The Practice of Archipelagic States: A Study of Studies.Ocean Development and International Law,46,60-80.
  14. Bautista, Lowell(2013).The Philippine Claim to Bajo de Masinloc in the Context of the South China Sea Dispute.Journal of East Asia and International Law,6(2),497-529.
  15. Bautista, Lowell B.(2011).Philippine Territorial Boundaries: Internal Tensions, Colonial Baggage, Ambivalent Conformity.Journal of Southeast Asian Studies,16,35-53.
  16. Bautista, Lowell B.(2010).The Legal Status of the Philippine Treaty Limits in International Law.Aegean Review of the Law of the Sea and Maritime Law,1(1),111-39.
  17. Bautista, Lowell B.(2008).The Historical Context and Legal Basis of the Philippine Treaty Limits.Asian-Pacific Law and Policy Journal,10,1-31.
  18. Bautista, Lowell B.(2009).International Legal Implications of the Philippine Treaty Limits on Navigational Rights in Philippine Waters.Australian Journal of Maritime and Ocean Affairs,1(3),88-96.
  19. Beckman, Robert(2013).The UN Convention on the Law of the Sea and the Maritime Disputes in the South China Sea.American Journal of International Law,107(1),142-63.
  20. Beckman, Robert C.,Schofield, Clive H.(2014).Defining EEZ Claims from Islands: A Potential South China Sea Change.International Journal of Marine and Coastal Law,29(1),193-243.
  21. Bernhardt, J. Peter, A.(1994).The Right of Archipelagic Sea Lanes Passage: A Primer.Virginia Journal of International Law,35,719-75.
  22. Bernhardt, Rudolf(ed.)(1992).Encyclopedia of Public International Law.Amsterdam:Elsevier.
  23. Blay, S. K. N.,Piotrowicz, R. W.,Tsamenyi, B. M.(1984).Problems with the Implementation of the Third United Nations Law of the Sea Convention: The Question of Reservations and Declarations.Australian Year Book of International Law,11,67-107.
  24. Bowett, D. W.(1960).The Second United Nations Conference on the Law of the Sea.International and Comparative Law Quarterly,9,415-35.
  25. Brown, E. D.(1994).The International Law of the Sea.Aldershot:Dartmouth.
  26. Churchill, R. R.,Lowe, A. V.(1999).The Law of the Sea.Yonkers, N.Y.:Juris Publishing.
  27. Coquia, Jorge R.(1983).Development of the Archipelagic Doctrine as a Recognized Principle of International Law.Philippine Law Journal,58,13-41.
  28. Coquia, Jorge R.(1990).Maritime Boundary Problems in the South China Sea.British Columbia. Law Review,24(1),117-25.
  29. Coquia, Jorge R.(1997).Some Legal and Constitutional Issues on Archipelagic Sea Lanes.Ocean Law and Policy Series,1,52-55.
  30. Coquia, Jorge R.(1962).Territorial Sea of Archipelagos.Philippines International Law Journal,1(1),139-56.
  31. Dean, Arthur H.(1960).The Second Conference on the Law of the Sea: The Fight for the Freedom of the Seas.American Journal of International Law,54(4),751-89.
  32. del Castillo, Lilian(ed.)(2015).Law of the Sea, From Grotius to the International Tribunal for the Law of the Sea: Liber Amicorum Judge Hugo Caminos.Leiden:Brill.
  33. Dellapenna, Joseph W.(1970).The Philippines Territorial Water Claim in International Law.Journal of Law and Economic Development,5(1),45-61.
  34. Demirali, Agim(1975).The Third United Nations Conference on the Law of the Sea and An Archipelagic Regime.San Diego Law Review,13(3),742-64.
  35. Drigot, Diane C.(1982).Oil Interests and the Law of the Sea: The Case of the Philippines.Ocean Development and International Law,12(1-2),23-70.
  36. Dubner, Barry Hart(1976).The Law of Territorial Waters of Mid-Oceanic Archipelagos and Archipelagic States.The Hague:Martinus Nijhoff.
  37. Encomienda, Alberto A.(2009).Archipelagic Sea Lanes Passage and the Philippines Situation.Freedom of Seas, Passage Rights and the 1982 law of the Sea Convention,Leiden:
  38. Feliciano, Florentino P.(1962).Comments on Territorial Waters of Archipelagos.Philippine International Law Journal,1(1),157-77.
  39. Forbes, Vivian Louis(2009).Indonesia's Delimited Maritime Boundaries.Heidelberg:Springer.
  40. Hamzah, B. A.(1984).Indonesia's Archipelagic Regime: Implications for Malaysia.Marine Policy,8(1),30-43.
  41. Jayakumar, S.(ed.),Koh, Tommy(ed.),Beckman, Robert(ed.)(2014).The South China Sea Disputes and the Law of the Sea.Cheltenham:Edward Elgar.
  42. Jayewardene, Hiran W.(1990).The Regime of Islands in International Law.Dordrecht:Martinus Nijhoff.
  43. Koh, Tommy T. B.(1987).The Territorial Sea, Contiguous Zone, Straits and Archipelagoes under the 1982 Convention on the Law of the Sea.Malaya Law Review,29(2),163-99.
  44. Ku, Charlotte(1991).The Archipelagic States Concept and Regional Stability in Southeast Asia.Case Western Reserve Journal of International Law,23(3),463-78.
  45. Kusumaatmadja, Mohtar(1973).The Legal Regimes of Archipelagoes.The Law of the Sea: Needs and Interests of Developing Countries,Kingston:
  46. Kwiatkowska, Barbara(1991).The Archipelagic Regime in Practice in the Philippines and Indonesia: Making or Breaking international Law?.International Journal of Estuarine and Coastal Law,6(1),1-32.
  47. Larson, David(1987).Innocent Transit and Archipelagic Sea Lanes Passage.Ocean Development and International Law,18(4),411-44.
  48. Lewis, Alexander(1983).Baseline Delimitations and Maritime Boundaries.Virginia Journal of International Law,23(4),503-36.
  49. Lumba, Solomon F.(2009).The Philippine Archipelagic Baselines Law.Journal of East Asia and International Law,2,296-98.
  50. Manansala, Mario C.(1974).The Philippines and the Third Law of the Sea Conference: Scientific and Technical Impact.Philippine Yearbook of International Law,3,135-43.
  51. Manansla, Mario(1997).Designation of Archipelagic Sea Lanes in the Philippines.Ocean Law and Policy Series,1(1),6-11.
  52. Molenaar, Eric(1995).Coastal State Jurisdiction over Vessel-Source Pollution.The Hague:Kluwer Law International.
  53. Munavvar, Mohamed(1995).Ocean States: Archipelagic Regimes in the Law of the Sea.Dordrecht:Martinus Nijhoff.
  54. Nandan, Satya N.(ed.),Rosenne, Shabtai(ed.)(1993).United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea 1982: A Commentary.Dordrecht:Martinus Nijhoff.
  55. Nelson, L. D. M.(2001).Declarations, Statements and 'Disguised Reservations' with Respect to the Convention on the Law of the Sea.International and Comparative Law Quarterly,50(4),767-86.
  56. Nordquist, Myron H.(ed.),Moore, John N.(ed.)(2012).Maritime Border Diplomacy.Leiden:Brill.
  57. O'Connell, D. P.(1971).Mid-Ocean Archipelagos in International Law.British Yearbook of International Law,45,1-77.
  58. Prescott, J. R. V.(1982).Maritime Jurisdiction in Southeast Asia: A Commentary and Map.Honolulu:East-West Center.
  59. Prescott, Victor,Schofield, Clive(2015).The Maritime Boundaries of the World.Leiden:Brill.
  60. Roach, J. Ashley,Smith, Robert W.(1996).United States Responses to Excessive Maritime Claims.The Hague:Martinus Nijhoff.
  61. Roach, J. Ashley,Smith, Robert W.(2000).Straight Baselines: The Need for a Universally Applied Norm.Ocean Development and International Law,31(1),47-80.
  62. Rothwell, Donald(2014).Baselines under the International Law of the Sea.Report of the 76th Conference of the International Law Association
  63. Rothwell, Donald R.(ed.),Elferink, Alex G. Oude(ed.),Scott, Karen N.(ed.),Stephens, Tim(ed.)(2015).Oxford Handbook of the Law of the Sea.New York:Oxford University Press.
  64. Rothwell, Donald(ed.),Elferink, Alex Oude(ed.),Scott, Karen(ed.),Stephens, Tim(ed.)(2015).Oxford Handbook of the Law of the Sea.Oxford:Oxford University Press.
  65. Severino, Rodolfo C.(2011).Where in the World Is the Philippines? Debating Its National Territory.Singapore:Institute of Southeast Asian Studies.
  66. Severino, Rodolfo C.(2012).The Philippines' National Territory.Southeast Asian Affairs,12,257-62.
  67. Soriano, Samuel(1997).Negotiating History of the Archipelagic Sea Lanes' Passage.Ocean Law and Policy Series,1(1),67-69.
  68. Symmons, Clive R.(1979).The Maritime Zones of Islands in International Law.Leiden:Brill.
  69. Tanaka, Yoshifumi(2015).The International Law of the Sea.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
  70. Tangsubkkul, Phiphat,Dzurek, Daniel J.(1982).The Emerging Concept of Midocean Archipelagos.Ocean Yearbook,3,386-404.
  71. Tangsubkul, Phiphat(1984).The Southeast Asian Archipelagic States: Concept, Evolution, and Current Practice.Honolulu:East-West Environment and Policy Institute, East-West Center.
  72. The Geographer, Department of State(1973).Strait Baselines: The Philippines.Limits in the Seas,33
  73. Tsamenyi, Martin,Schofield, Clive,Milligan, Ben(2009).Navigation through Archipelagos: Current State Practice.Freedom of Seas, Passage Rights and the 1982 law of the Sea Convention,Leiden:
  74. U.S. Department of State, Office of Ocean and Polar Affairs, Bureau of Oceans and International Environmental and Scientific Affairs(2014).Philippines:Archipelagic and other Maritime Claims and Boundaries.Limits in the Seas,142
  75. United Nations、 Office for Ocean Affairs and the Law of the Sea(1992).The Law of the Sea: Practice of Archipelagic States.
  76. United Nations、 Office for Ocean Affairs and the Law of the Sea(1990).The Law of the Sea: Archipelagic States: Legislative History of Part IV of theUnited Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea.New York:United Nations.
  77. Whiteman, Marjorie(1965).Digest of International Law.Washington, D.C.:U.S. Department of State.
  78. Wiley, Mason(2014).Baselines under the International Law of the Sea.Report of the 76th Conference of the International Law Association
  79. Wolfrum, Rüdiger(ed.)(2012).Max Planck Encyclopedia of Public International Law.Oxford:Oxford University Press.
  80. Wolfrum, Rüdiger(ed.)(2012).Max Planck Encyclopedia of Public International Law.Oxford:Oxford University Press.
  81. 姜皇池(2004)。國際海洋法。台北:新學林。
  82. 姜皇池(2013)。從廣大興看台菲專屬經濟海域重疊問題。台灣法學雜誌，227，21-33。
  83. 陳德恭(2009)。現代國際法海洋法。中國北京:海洋出版社。
  84. 陳德恭(1988)。現代國際海洋法。中國北京:中國社會科學出版社。
  85. 陳鴻瑜編(1997)。東南亞各國海域法律及條約彙編。埔里:國立暨南大學東南亞研究中心。
被引用次数
  1. 陳偉華(2021)。美國挑戰中國南海「洋中群島」制度的國際法分析。國際關係學報，51，1-37。
  2. 呂嘉穎(2020)。全球化的沒落？由陸權式的經濟思考談起－以一帶一路下的中國大陸思維為例。明新學報，44(1)，103-123。
print cancel