题名

憲政本土化與憲政民主發展－加拿大憲法變遷的啟發

并列篇名

The Patriation of Constitution and Constitutional Democracy: Experience in Canadian Constitution Change

作者

林岱緯(Tai-Wei Lin)

关键词

憲政本土化 ； 憲政民主 ； 憲法變遷 ； patriation of constitution ； constitutional democracy ； constitution change

期刊名称

台灣國際研究季刊

卷期/出版年月

15卷3期（2019 / 09 / 01）

页次

83 - 100

内容语文

繁體中文
中文摘要

憲法象徵一個國家的最高規範，倘若國家的最高規範必須經由其他國家的認可與批准程序，實不符合民主的基本邏輯，1982年以前的加拿大即是此例。本文從憲政民主應立基於憲政本土化的觀點出發，並以加拿大的憲法變遷作個案分析，探討憲法本土化的變遷過程，以及憲法變遷如何深化憲政民主。
英文摘要

As the supreme regulation, it does not conform to the value of democracy that constitution must be approved by other countries, such as Canada before 1982. This article considers that constitutional democracy should be base on the patriation of constitution and looks into the experience of constitution change in Canada.
主题分类 人文學 > 人文學綜合
社會科學 > 社會科學綜合
参考文献
  1. Abu-Laban, Yasmeen,Nieguth, Tim(2000).Reconsidering the Constitution, Minorities and Politics in Canada.Canadian Journal of Political Science,33(3),465-497.
  2. Ackerman, Bruce A.,Charney, Robert E.(1984).Canada at the Constitutional Crossroads.University of Toronto Law Journal,34(2),117-135.
  3. Albert, Richard(2017).The Conventions of Constitutional Amendment in Canada.Osgoode Law Journal,53(2),399-441.
  4. Albert, Richard(2016).Four Unconstitutional Constitutions and their Democratic Foundations.Cornell International Law Journal,50,169-98.
  5. Albert, Richard(2015).The Difficulty of Constitutional Amendment in Canada.Alberta Law Review,39,85-113.
  6. Albert, Richard(2014).Constitutional Amendment by Constitutional Desuetude.American Journal of Comparative Law,62(3),641-686.
  7. Alcantara, Christopher(2013).Ideas, Executive Federalism and Institutional Change: Explaining Territorial Inclusion in Canadian First Ministers’ Conferences.Canadian Journal of Political Science,46(1),27-48.
  8. Banting, Keith G.(ed.)(1985).The Politics of Constitutional Change in Industrial Nations.London:MacMillan Press.
  9. Behnke, Nathalie,Benz, Arthur(2009).The Politics of Constitutional Change between Reform and Evolution.Publius,39(2),213-240.
  10. Bellamy, Richard S.,Castiglione, Dario(1997).Constitutionalism and Democracy: Political Theory and the American Constitution.British Journal of Political Science,27(4),595-618.
  11. Bernal, Carlos(2014).Foreword - Informal Constitutional Change: A Critical Introduction and Appraisal.American Journal of Comparative Law,62(3),493-513.
  12. Bird, Brian(2017).The Unbroken Supremacy of the Canadian Constitution.Alberta Law Review,10,755-775.
  13. Breton, Albert(1984).An Analysis of Constitutional Change, Canada, 1980-82.Public Choice,44(1),251-272.
  14. Cairns, Alan C.(1988).Citizens (Outsiders) and Governments (Insiders) in Constitution-Making: The Case of Meech Lake.Canadian Public Policy,14,121-145.
  15. Cameron, David R.,Jacqueline, D. Krikorian(2008).Recognizing Quebec in the Constitution of Canada: Using the Bilateral Constitutional Amendment Process.University of Toronto Law Journal,58(4),389-420.
  16. Cameron, Jamie(2017).Legality, Legitimacy and Constitutional Amendment in Canada.Osgoode Legal Studies Research Paper,13,1-33.
  17. Careless, Anthony G.,Stevenson, Donald W.(1982).Canada: Constitutional Reform as a Policy-Making Instrument.Publius,12(3),85-98.
  18. Choate, Joseph H. 1916. “Constitutional Change without Amendment.” North American Review, Vol. 203, No. 722, pp. 75-80.
  19. Clokie, H. McD. 1942. “Basic Problems of the Canadian Constitution.” Canadian Journal of Economics and Political Science, Vol. 8, No. 1, pp. 1-32.
  20. Close, David(1985).Politics and Constitutional Reform in Canada: A Study in Political Opposition.Publius,15(1),161-176.
  21. Dawson, Mary(2012).From the Backroom to the Front Line: Making Constitutional History or Encounters with the Constitution: Patriation, Meech Lake, and Charlottetown.McGill Law Journal,57(4),955-1000.
  22. Feldstein, Raphael. 2018. “The Repatriation of the Constitution and Alternative Dispute Resolution.” (https://www.cfcj-fcjc.org/sites/default/files/docs/hosted/17429-repatriation.pdf) (2019/2/1)
  23. Greene, Ian(1990).Conflict of Interest and the Canadian Constitution: An Analysis of Conflict of Interest Rules for Canadian Cabinet Ministers.Canadian Journal of Political Science,23(2),233-256.
  24. Hogg, Peter W.(1984).The New Canadian Constitution: Introduction.American Journal of Comparative Law,32(2),221-224.
  25. Hogg, Peter W.(1992).Formal Amendment of the Constitution of Canada.Law and Contemporary Problems,55(1),253-260.
  26. Kay, Richard S.(2011).Constituent Authority.American Journal of Comparative Law,59(3),715-761.
  27. Kilgour, D. Marc(1985).Reply: Distributing the Power to Amend Canada’s Constitution.Canadian Journal of Political Science,18(2),389-96.
  28. Knickerbocker, Madeline R.,Nickel, Sarah(2016).Negotiating Sovereignty: Aboriginal Perspectives on a Settler-Colonial Constitution, 1975-1983.BC Studies,190,67-87.
  29. Lederman, William R.(1984).Canadian Constitutional Amending Procedures: 1867-1982.American Journal of Comparative Law,32(2),339-359.
  30. Lesson, Howard(2017).Four Lenses of Patriation.Constitutional Forum,26(2),43-56.
  31. Lutz, Donald(2000).Thinking about Constitutionalism at the Start of the Twenty-First Century.Publius,30(4),115-135.
  32. Mayo, H. B.(1957).Majority Rule and the Constitution in Canada and the United States.Western Political Quarterly,10(1),49-62.
  33. McRoberts, Kenneth(2001).Canada and the Multinational State.Canadian Journal of Political Science,34(4),683-713.
  34. Meekison, J. Peter(1999).Constitutional Patriation: The Lougheed- Lévesque Correspondence.Kingston, Ont.:Queen’s University.
  35. Mendelsohn, Matthew(2000).Public Brokerage: Constitutional Reform and the Accommodation of Mass Publics.Canadian Journal of Political Science,33(2),245-272.
  36. Olson, Kevin(2007).Paradoxes of Constitutional Democracy.American Journal of Political Science,51(2),330-343.
  37. Ranney, Austin,Kendall, Willmoore(1951).Democracy: Confusion and Agreement.Western Political Quarterly,4(3),430-439.
  38. Remillard, Gil(1984).The Constitution Act, 1982: An Unfinished Compromise.American Journal of Comparative Law,32(2),269-281.
  39. Riddell, William R. 1919. “Constitutional Amendments in Canada.” Yale Law Journal, Vol. 28, No. 4, pp. 314-23.
  40. Russell, Peter H.(1991).Can the Canadians Be a Sovereign People?.Canadian Journal of Political Science,24(4),691-709.
  41. Sabetti, Filippo(1982).The Historical Context of Constitutional Change in Canada.Law and Contemporary Problems,45(4),11-32.
  42. Savard, Jean-François(ed.),Brassard, Alexandre(ed.),Côté, Louis(ed.)(2013).Quebec-Ontario Relations: A Shared Destiny?.Quebec City:Presses de l'Université du Québec.
  43. Schwartz, Alex(2011).Patriotism or Integrity? Constitutional Community in Divided Societies.Oxford Journal of Legal Studies,31(3),503-526.
  44. Scott, Stephen(1982).The Canadian Constitutional Amendment Process.Law and Contemporary Problems,45(4),249-281.
  45. Stein, Michael B.(1997).Improving the Process of Constitutional Reform in Canada: Lessons from the Meech Lakeand Charlottetown Constitutional Rounds.Canadian Journal of Political Science,30(2),307-338.
  46. Studlar, Donley T.,Christensen, Kyle(2006).Is Canada a Westminster or Consensus Democracy? A Brief Analysis.Political Science and Politics,39(4),837-841.
  47. Swinton, Katherine(1992).Amending the Canadian Constitution: Lessons from Meech Lake.University of Toronto Law Journal,42(2),139-169.
  48. Tushnet, Mark(2003).Forms of Judicial Review as Expressions of Constitutional Patriotism.Law and Philosophy,22(3),353-379.
  49. Walters, Mark D.(2012).Dicey on Writing the “Law of the Constitution”.Oxford Journal of Legal Studies,32(1),21-49.
  50. Watts, Ronald L.(1996).Canada: Three Decades of Periodic Federal Crises.International Political Science Review,17(4),353-371.
  51. 殷海光基金會(2007).自由主義與新世紀台灣.台北:允晨文化.
print cancel