题名

Green Supplier Selection and Assessment in GSCM Using Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) for Information and Electronic Industry

并列篇名

用層級分析法評選綠色供應鏈管理之綠色供應商－以資訊電子產業為例

DOI

10.6188/JEB.2007.9(1).03

作者

邱城英(Cherng-Ying Chiou)；王博引(Po-Yin Wang)；陳慧秋(Hui-Chiu Chen)；葉春淵(Chun-Yuan Yeh)

关键词

資訊電子産業 ； 綠色供應商評選 ； 綠色供應鏈管理 ； 專家意見 ； 層級分析法 ； Information and Electronic Industry ； Green Supplier Selection and Assessment ； Green Supply Chain Management GSCM ； Experts' Opinions ； Analytic Hierarchy Process AHP

期刊名称

電子商務學報

卷期/出版年月

9卷1期（2007 / 03 / 01）

页次

147 - 176

内容语文

英文
中文摘要

台灣的資訊電子產業在全球工業供應鏈體系中，扮演產品代工生產階段(OEM/ODM)的重要角色。近幾年來，歐盟實施的廢電子電機設備(WEEE)及電子電機設備中危害物質限制(RoHS)兩大環保指令，對國內的資訊電子產業影響最大。因此，很多的資訊電子代工廠商積極輔導其供應商實行綠色供應鏈管理，以成就更好的環境績效。有鑑於此，本研究根據相關文獻及透過學者及此產業專家問卷，藉由二個不同層面的考量，而獲得較客觀的篩選方法。最後，共彙總出六個構面及二十四個綠色供應鏈中綠色供應商之評估準則。再經由層級分析法，決定各評估準則之權重，並建立綠色供應商之評選模式，以幫助此產業選擇其最適合之綠色供應夥伴。
英文摘要

Taiwan plays a very important role in the production and outsourcing for the OEMs and ODMs in the global supply chain system of the information and electronic industry. In the recent few years, two of the most important environmental protection directives of WEEE, and RoHS in the European Union have greatly influenced the information and electronic industry. Therefore, many OEMs/ODMs want to help their suppliers to achieve a better environmental performance in supply chains. This study focuses on green supplier selection and assessment in green supply chain management (GSCM) through various criteria and sub-criteria from literature reviews and Delphi experts' opinions, and then uses the AHP method to set up a green supplier rating system that can be applied to the information and electronic industry of Taiwan. Furthermore, this study can provide the evaluation model with the industry in implementing the best GSCM practices. The research results indicate that the supply chain base such as cost, quality, delivery schedule, and service performance is the most critical assessment criteria in the green supplier selection. Green material selection, ISO-14001 certification, and suppliers' credit problems are also main evaluation sub-criteria. The internal management system also plays an important factor because the authorization by top management affects the willingness to get involved in the GSCM.
主题分类 人文學 > 人文學綜合
基礎與應用科學 > 資訊科學
基礎與應用科學 > 統計
社會科學 > 社會科學綜合
参考文献
  1. Abegglen, J. C.,G. Stalk(1985).Kaisha: The Japanese Corporation.New York:Basic Books.
  2. Albino, V.,A. C. Garavelli(1998).A Neutral Network Application to Subcontractor Rating in Construction Firms.International Journal of Project Management,16(1),9-14.
  3. Allenby, B. R.,A. Fullerton(1991).Design for Environment-A New Strategy for Environmental Management.Pollution Prevention Review,2(1),51-61.
  4. Apsan, H. N.(2000).Running in Nonconcentric Circles: Why Environmental Management Isn't Being Integrated into Business Management.Environmental Quality Management,9(4),69-75.
  5. Azzone, G.,M. Brophy,G. Noci,R. Welford,W. Young(1997).A Stakeholders' View of Environmental Reporting.Long Range Planning,30(5),699-709.
  6. Babic, Z.,N. Plazibat(1998).Ranking of Enterprises Based on Multicriterial Analysis.International Journal of Production Economics,56-57,29-35.
  7. Barbarosoglu. G.,T. Yazgac(1997).An Application of the Analytic Hierarchy Process to the Supplier Selection Problem.Production and Inventory Management Journal,38(1),14-21.
  8. Beamon. M. B.(1999).Designing the Green Supply Chain.Logistics Information Management,12(4),332-342.
  9. Bevilacqua. M.,A. Petroni(2002).From Traditional Purchasing to Supplier Management: A Fuzzy Logic-Based Approach to Supplier Selection.International Journal of Logistics,5(3),235-255.
  10. Bowen, F. E.,P. D. Cousins,R. C. Lamming,A. C. Faruk(2001).The Role of Supply Management Capabilities in Green Supply.Production and Operations Management,10(2),174-189.
  11. Carroll, A. B.(1979).The Pyramid of Corporate Social Responsibility: Toward the Moral Management of Organizational Stakeholders.Business Horizons,4(4),497-505.
  12. Carroll. A. B.(1999).Corporate Social Responsibility: Evolution of a Definitional Construct.Business and Society,38(3),268-295.
  13. Carroll. A. B.(1991).A Three-Dimensional Conceptual Model of Corporate Social Performance.Academy of Management Review,34(4),39-48.
  14. Carter, C. R.,L. M. Ellram(1998).Reverse Logistics: A Review of the Literature and Framework for Future Investigation.Journal of Business Logistics,19(1),85-102.
  15. Carter, C. R.,M. M. Jennings(2004).The Role of Purchasing in Coiporate Social Responsibility: A Structural Equation Analysis.Journal of Business Logistics,25(1),145-186.
  16. Cebi, F.,D. Bayraktar(2003).An Integrated Approach for Supplier Selection.Logistics Information Management,16(6),395-400.
  17. Chan, A. H. S.,W. Y. Kwok,V. G. Duffy(2004).Using AHP for Determining Priority in a Safety Management System.Industrial Management + Data Systems,104(5/6),430-445.
  18. Chan, F T S.(2003).Interactive Selection Model for Supplier Selection Process: An Analytical Hierarchy Process Approach.International Journal of Production Research,41(15),3549-3579.
  19. Chan, F T S.,H. K. Chan(2004).Development of the Supplier Selection Model-A Case Study in the Advanced Technology Industry.IMechE,218(12),1807-1824.
  20. Chan, F.T.S.,N. Kumar(2005).Global Supplier Development Considering Risk Factors Using Fuzzy Extended AHP-Based Approach.Omega,33(1),1-15.
  21. Chao. C. N.,E. E. Scheuing,K. M. Dubas,V. Mummalaneni(1993).The Assessment of Supplier Selection: Chinese Purchasing Managers' Criteria and Their Implications for Western Marketers.International Journal of Physical Distribution & Logistics Management,23(8),31-37.
  22. Chen. C. T.,C. T. Lin,S. F. Huang(2006).A Fuzzy Approach for Supplier Evaluation and Selection in Supply Chain Management.International Journal of Production Economics,102(2),289-301.
  23. Cheng, E. W. L.,H. Li(2001).Information Priority-Setting for Better Resource Allocation Using Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP).Information Management & Computer Security,9(2/3),61-70.
  24. Cheng, E. W. L.,H. Li,D. C. K. Ho(2002).Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP): A Defective Tool When Used Improperly.Measuring Business Excellence,6(4),33-37.
  25. Chiang, J. H.,M. L. Tseng(2005).The Impact of Environmental Characteristics on Manufacturing Strategy under Cleaner Production Principles Guidance.Journal of American Academy of Business,7(1),163-168.
  26. Chiou. C. Y.,H. C. Chen,C.Y. Yeh(2006).Critical Factors of Green Supplier Selection in Green Supply Chain Management in Responding to International Environmental Pressures: A Case Study of Taiwan's Information and Electronic Industry.Proceedings of 2006 International Conference on Knowledge-Based Economy Global Management,Taiwan:
  27. Choy, K. L.,W. B. Lee(2002).On the Development of a Case Based Supplier Management Tool for Multinational Manufacturers.Measuring Business Excellence,6(1),15-22.
  28. Copacino, W. C.(1996).Seven Supply Chain Principles.Traffic Management,35(1),60.
  29. Current, J.,C. Weber(1994).Application of Facility Location Modeling Constructs to Vendor Selection Problem.European Journal of Operational Research,76(3),387-392.
  30. Darnall, N.,Sarkis, J. (edited)(2001).Green Manufacturing and Operations: From Design to Delivery and Back.Sheffield, UK:Greenleaf.
  31. De Boer, L.,E. Labro,P. Molrlacchi(2001).A Review of Methods Supporting Supplier Selection.European Journal of Purchasing and Supply Management,7(2),75-89.
  32. Degraeve, G. W.(1966).An Analysis of Vendor Selection: System and Decisions.European Journal of Operational Research,125(1),34-59.
  33. Dempsey. W. A.(1978).Vendor Selection and the Buying Process.Industrial Marketing Management,7(4),257-267.
  34. Dickson. G. W.(1966).An Analysis of Vendor Selection System and Decisions.Journal of Purchasing,2(1),5-17.
  35. Ding. H.,L. Benyoucef,X. Xie(2005).A Simulation Optimization Methodology for Supplier Selection Problem.International Journal of Computer Integrated Manufacturing,2/3(18),210-224.
  36. Dulmin, R.,V. Mininno(2003).Supplier Selection Using a Multi-Criteria Decision and Method.Journal of Purchasing & Supply Management,9(4),177-187.
  37. Ellram, L. M.(1993).Total Cost of Ownership-Elements & Implementation.International Journal of Purchasing and Materials Management,29(4),3-11.
  38. Ellram, L. M.(1995).Total Cost of Ownership: An Analysis Approach for Purchasing.International Journal of Physical Distribution and Logistics Management,25(8),4-23.
  39. Ellram. L. M.,A. Carr(1994).Strategic Purchasing: A History and Review of the Literature.International Journal of Purchasing and Materials Management,30(1),2.
  40. Fatkin, H.,Sarkis. J. (edited)(2001).Green Manufacturing and Operations: From Design to Delivery and Back.Sheffield, UK:Greenleaf.
  41. Florida, R.,D. Davison(2001).Gaining from Green Management: Environmental Management Systems Inside and Outside the Factory.California Management Review,43(3),64-84.
  42. Ghodsypour, S. H.,C. O''Brien(1998).A Decision Support System for Supplier Selection Using an Integrated Analytic Hierarchy Process and Linear Programming.International Journal of Production Economics,56/57,199-212.
  43. Gregory, R. E.(1986).A Matrix Approach.Journal of Purchasing and Materials Management,22(2),24-29.
  44. Hakansson. H.,B. Wootz(1975).Supplier Selection in an International Environmental-An Experimental Study.Journal of Marketing Research,12(1),46-51.
  45. Handfield, R. B.,S. A. Melnyk(1996).GreenSpeak.Purchasing Today.
  46. Handfield, R. B.,S. V. Walton,R. Sroufe,S. A. Melnyk(2002).Applying Environmental Criteria to Supplier Assessment: A Study in the Application of the Analytical Hierarchy Process.European Journal of Operational Research,141(1),70-87.
  47. Hart, S. L.(1995).A natural-resource-based view of the firm.The Academy of Management Review,20(4),986-1014.
  48. Hart. S. L.(2005).Innovation. Creative Destruction and Sustainability.Research Technology Management,48(5),21-27.
  49. Hart. S. L.(1997).Beyond Greening: Strategies for a Sustainable World.Harvard Business Review,75(1),66-76.
  50. Hervani, A. A.,M. M. Helms,J. Sarkis(2005).Performance Measurement for Green Supply Chain Management.Benchmarking: An International Journal,12(4),330-353.
  51. Holt, G. D.(1998).Which Contractor Selection Methodology.International Journal of Project Management,16,153-164.
  52. Hong, H. H.,S. C. Park,D. S. Jang,H. M. Rho(2005).An Effective Supplier Selection Method for Constructing a Competitive Supply-Relationship.Expert Systems with Applications,28(4),629-639.
  53. Humphreys, P.,R. Mclvor,F. Chan(2003).Using Case-Based Reasoning to Evaluate Supplier Environmental Management Performance.Expert Systems with Applications,25(2),141-153.
  54. Hunt. C. B.,E. R. Auster(1990).Proactive Environmental Management: Avoiding the Toxic Trap.Sloan Management Review,31(2),7-16.
  55. ISO 9000 and ISO 14000
  56. Kahraman, C.,U. Cebeci,D. Ruan(2004).Multi-Attribute Comparison of Catering Service Companies Using Fuzzy AHP: The Case of Turkey.International Journal of Production Economics,87(2),171-184.
  57. Kannan, V. R.,K. C. Tan(2002).Supplier Selection and Assessment: Their Impact on Business Performance.Journal of Supply Chain Management,38(4),11-21.
  58. Karpak, B.,R. R. Kasuganti,E. Kumcu(1999).Multi-Objective Decision-Making in Supplier Selection: An Application of Visual interactive Goal Programming.The Journal of Applied Business Research,15(2),57-71.
  59. Keoleian, G.,D. Menerey(1994).Sustainable Development by Design: Review of Life Cycle Design and Related Approaches.Air & Waste,44(5),645.
  60. Kovar, J. F.(2005).Waste Management: Solution Providers Are Helping Customers Make Sure.CRN,1149,18-22.
  61. Lai, I. F.(2004).National Cheng Kuang University.
  62. Lambert, A. J. D.,Sarkis. J. (edited)(2001).Green Manufacturing and Operations: From Design to Delivery and Back.Sheffield. UK:Greenleaf.
  63. Lee. E. K.,S. Ha,S. K. Kim(2001).Supplier Selection and Management System Considering Relationships in Supply Chain Management.IEEE Transactions on Engineering Management,48(3),307-318.
  64. Lehmann. D. R.,J. O Shaughnessy(1982).Decision Criteria Used in Buying Different Categories of Products.International Journal of Purchasing and Materials Management,18(1),9-14.
  65. Linstone, H. A.,M. Turoff(1975).The Delphi Method: Techniques and Applications.London:Addison Wesley Longman Publishing Co.
  66. Liu, J.,F. Y. Ding,V. Lall(2000).Using Data Envelopment Analysis to Compare Suppliers for Supplier Selection and Performance Improvement.Supply Chain Management,5(3),143-150.
  67. Llewellyn. J. T.(1998).Evaluating Corporate Claims of Social Responsibility: Developing a Citizenship Checklist.Research in Corporate Social Performance and Policy,15,89-106.
  68. Mandal. A.,S. G. Deshmukh(1994).Vendor Selection Using Interpretative Structural Modeling (ISM).International Journal of Operations and Production Management,14(6),52-59.
  69. A Report of Current Taiwan's ICT Industry
  70. Martin, M.,Sarkis, J. (edited)(2001).Green Manufacturing and Operations: From Design to Delivery and Back.Sheffield, UK:Greenleaf.
  71. Masella. C.,and A. Rangone(2000).A Contingent Approach to the Design of Vendor Selection Systems for Different Types of Cooperative Customer/Supplier Relationships.International Journal of Operation and Production Management,20(1),70-84.
  72. Mason, T.(1996).Getting Your Suppliers on the Team.Logistics Focus,4(1),10-12.
  73. Min, H.(1992).Selection of Software: The Analytic Hierarchy Process.International Journal of Physical Distribution & Logistics Management,22(1),42-52.
  74. Min, H.(1994).International Supplier Selection: A Multi-Attribute Utility Approach.International Journal of Physical Distribution & Logistics Management,24(5),24-33.
  75. Min, H.,W. P. Galle(1997).Green Purchasing Strategies: Trends and Implications.International Journal of Purchasing and Materials Management,33(3),10-17.
  76. Mitchell, V. W.(1992).Using Delphi to Forecast New Technology Industries.Marketing Intelligence and Planning,10(2),4-9.
  77. Mollenkopf, D. A.,D. Closs(2005).The Hidden Value in Reverse Logistics.Supply Chain Management Review,9(5),34-43.
  78. Muralidharan, C.,N. Anantharaman,S. G. Deshmukh(2002).A Multi-Criteria Group Decision Making Model for Supplier Rating.Journal of Supply Chain Management,38(4),22-33.
  79. Nagel, M. H.(2003).Managing the Environmental Performance of Production Facilities in the Electronics Industry: More Than Application of the Concept of Cleaner Production.Journal of Cleaner Production,11(1),11-26.
  80. Narasimhan, R.(1983).An Analytical Approach to Supplier Selection.Journal of Purchasing and Materials Management,19(4),27-32.
  81. Noci, G.(1997).Designing 'Green' Vendor Rating Systems for the Assessment of a Supplier's Environmental Performance.European Journal of Purchasing & Supply Management,3(2),103-114.
  82. Nydick. R. L.,R. P. Hill(1992).Using the Analytic Hierarchy Process to Structure the Supplier Procedure.International Journal of Purchasing and Materials Management,28(2),31-36.
  83. Olhager, J.,E. Selldin(2004).Supply Chain Management Survey of Swedish Manufacturing Firms.International Journal of Production Economics,89(3),353-361.
  84. Pearson, J. N.,L. M. Ellram(1995).Supplier Selection and Evaluation in Small Versus Large Electronics Firms.Journal of Small Business Management,33(41),53-65.
  85. Petroni, A.,M. Braglia(2000).Vendor Selection Using Principal Component Analysis.Journal of Supply Chain Management,36(2),63-69.
  86. Preuss. L.(2005).Rhetoric and Reality of Corporate Greening: A View from the Supply Chain Management Function.Business Strategy and the Environment,14(2),123-139.
  87. Ragatz, G. L.,R. B. Handfiled,T. V. Scannell(1997).Success Factors for Integrating Suppliers into New Product Development.Journal of Product Innovation Management,14(3),190-202.
  88. Rao, P.(2002).Greening the Supply Chain: A New initiative in South East Asia.International Journal of Operations & Production Management,22(6),632-655.
  89. Rebstock, S. E.,R. Kaula(1996).The Effectiveness of an Analytic Hierarchy Process in Group Decision Making: A Case Study.International Journal of Computer Applications in Technology,9(2/3),95-105.
  90. Rice. S.(2003).Commitment to Excellence: Practical Approaches to Environmental Leadership.Environmental Quality Management,12(4),9-22.
  91. Rogers. D. S.,R. Tibben-Lembke(2001).An Examination of Reverse Logistics Practices.Journal of Business Logistics,22(2),129-148.
  92. Saaty, T. L.(2000).Fundamentals of Decision Making and Priority Ttheory with the Analytic Hierarchy Process.Pittsburgh, PA:RWS.
  93. Saaty, T. L.(1990).Decision Making for Leader.Pittsburgh, PA:RWS.
  94. Saaty, T. L.(1994).How to Make a Decision the Analytic Hierarchy Process.Interfaces,24(6),19-43.
  95. Saaty, T. L.(1980).The A analytic Hierarchy Process: Planning, Priority Setting, Resource Allocatio.New York:McGraw-Hill.
  96. Sarkis, J.,G. Nehaman,J. Preist(1996).A Systemic Evaluations Model for Environmentally Friendly Conscious Business Practices and Strategy.Proceeding of the 1996 IEEE International Symposium on Electronics and the Environment
  97. Sarkis, J.,L. M. Meade,S. Talluri(2004).E-Logistics and the Natural Environment.Supply Chain Management,9(3/4),303-312.
  98. Sarkis, J.,S. Talluri(2002).A Model for Strategic Supplier Selection.Journal of Supply Chain Management,38(1),18-28.
  99. Sarkis. J.(2003).A Strategic Decision Framework for Green Supply Chain Management.Journal of Cleaner Production,11(4),397-409.
  100. Sarkis. J.(1998).Theoiy and Methodology: Evaluating Environmentally Conscious Business Practices.European Journal of Operational Research,107(1),159-174.
  101. Sarkis. J.,A. Rasheed(1995).Greening the Manufacturing Function.Business Horizons,38(5),17-27.
  102. Schvaneveldt. S. J.,H. Yanagida,A. Isobe,Sarkis, J. (edited)(2001).Green Manufacturing and Operations: From Design to Delivery and Back.Sheffield, UK:Greenleaf.
  103. Sethi, S. P.(1995).Introduction to AMR's Special Topic Forum on Shifting Paradigms: Societal Expectations and Corporate Performance.Academy of Management Review,20(1),18-21.
  104. Sethi, S. P.(1975).Dimensions of Corporate Social Responsibilities.California Management Review,17(3),58-64.
  105. Proceedings of NZSSES 2004 International Conference on Sustainability Engineering and Services
  106. Siying, W.,Z. Jinlong,L. Zhicheng(1997).A Supplier-Selecting System Using a Neutral Network.IEEE International Conference on Intelligent Processing Systems,New York:
  107. Spencer, G. W.(1998).Canada,The University of New Brunswick.
  108. Sroufe, R. P.(2000).Michigan University.
  109. Stock, J. R.(1998).Development and Implementation of Reverse Logistics Program.Oak Brook, IL:Council of Logistics Management.
  110. Related to Industrial Standard in Green Products
  111. Tam, M. C. Y.,V. M. R. Tummala(2001).An Application of the AHP in Vendor Selection for a Telecommunications Systems.Omega,29(2),171-182.
  112. Thompson, K. N.(1990).Supplier Profile Analysis.Journal of Purchasing and Materials Management,26(1),11-18.
  113. Timmerman, E.(1986).An Approach to Supplier Performance Evaluation.Journal of Purchasing and Materials Management,26(1),11-18.
  114. An ESTO project report, The institute for Prospective Technological Studies, Spain
  115. Udo, G. G.(2000).Using Analytic Hierarchy Process to Analyze the Information Technology Outsourcing Decision.Industrial Management & Data Systems,100(9),421-429.
  116. Verma, R.,M. E. Pullman(1998).An Analysis of the Supplier Selection Process.Omega,26(6),739-750.
  117. Vokurka, R. J.,J. Choobineh,L. Vadi(1996).A Prototype Expert System for the Evaluation and Selection of Potential Suppliers.International Journal of Operations and Production Management,16(12),106-127.
  118. Walton, S. V.,R. B. Handfield,S. A. Melnyk(1998).The Green Supply Chain: Integrating Suppliers into Environmental Management Processes.International Journal of Purchasing and Materials Management,34(2),2-11.
  119. Wang, B.,Y. Z. Bai,M. Li(2004).Science and Technology Management Research.China:Management School of Tianjin University.
  120. Weber, C. A.,J. R. Current,A. Desai(1998).Non-Cooperative Negotiation Strategies for Vendor Selection.European Journal of Operational Research,108(1),208-223.
  121. Weber, C. A.,J. R. Current,W. C. Benton(1991).Vendor Selection Criteria and Methods.European Journal of Operational Research,50(1),2-18.
  122. Weber, C. A.,L. M. Ellram(1992).Supplier Selection Using Multi-Objective Programming: A Decision Support System Approach.International Journal of Physical Distribution & Logistics Management,23(2),3-14.
  123. Wu. J. H.(2005).Taichung Healthcare and Management University.
  124. Yang. J.,H. Lee(2002).Identifying Key Factors for Successful Joint Venture in China.Industrial Management & Data Systems,102(2),98-109.
  125. Zhu, Q. H.(2004).Green Supply Chain Management.Beijing, China:Chemical Industrial Publishing Company.
  126. Zhu, Q. H.,J. Sarkis(2004).The Link between Quality Management and Environmental Management in Firms of Differing Size: An Analysis of Organizations in China.Environmental Quality Management,13(3),53-64.
  127. Zhu, Q. H.,Y. Geng(2001).Integrating Environmental Issues into Supplier Selection and Management: A Study of Large and Medium-Sized State-Owned Enterprises in China.Greener Management International,35,27-40.
  128. Zsidisin, G. A.,S. P. Siferd(2001).Environmental Purchasing: A Framework for Theory Development.European Journal of Purchasing and Supply Management,7(1),61-73.
被引用次数
  1. 蔡政緯、張基成(2012)。以網路模糊德懷術與模糊層級分析法發展數位化學習歷程檔案之知識管理行為量表。教育資料與圖書館學，50(1)，103-133。
  2. 吳玫瑩、江家麟(2011)。電機電子產業之綠色供應商評選量表的建構。數據分析，6(2)，19-48。
  3. (2011)。國立大學相關基金會監督管理機制與會計資訊揭露之探討。教育政策論壇，14(2)，91-116。
print cancel