题名

網路論壇口碑強度、雙面訊息與口碑順序對說服效果之影響－產品涉入之干擾效應

并列篇名

Persuasive Effects of Argument Strength, Message Sidedness and Order of Word-of-Mouth in On-line Forums: The Moderating Role of Involvement

DOI

10.6188/JEB.2010.12(4).03

作者

徐淑如(Shu-Lu Hsu)；董和昇(Her-Sen Doong)；柳雅婷(Ya-Ting Liou)

关键词

網路口碑 ； 論點強度 ； 訊息順序效果 ； 說服效果 ； 知覺可信度 ； 產品涉入 ； Electronic WOM ； Argument Strength ； Message Order Effect ； Persuasive Effect ； Perceived Credibility ； Product Involvement

期刊名称

電子商務學報

卷期/出版年月

13卷1期（2011 / 03 / 01）

页次

135 - 167

内容语文

繁體中文
中文摘要

網路的普及帶動消費者言論的自由傳播，網路論壇中個人的評論與使用經驗已成為消費者重要的參考資訊。不同於人際口碑著重傳播者特性的探討，網路口碑在可匿名發表的情況下，難以明確判斷傳播者的身分，使得訊息在說服過程的角色更形重要。在訊息特性中，過去研究常就論點的強弱或是正、負面探討消費者認知的差異，然而在網路論壇中，消費者可能同時接觸正面與負面意見，根據雙面訊息與順序效果的觀點，消費者對於只提供正面觀點的訊息並不一定較同時包含正、負雙面論點的訊息有更高的說服效果，此外，消費者的認知亦可能受正、負面訊息出現的順序所影響，而訊息順序的效應，尚可能因消費者產品涉入程度不同而有差異。 本文旨就論點強度、單面／雙面訊息與訊息順序等特性，探討網路論壇口碑的說服效果，其中，說服效果是以口碑知覺可信度、品牌態度與口碑傳播意圖為探討範圍，並考量消費者產品涉入程度是否影響口碑特性的說服效果。本研究採取實驗法，搜集網路論壇一真實品牌口碑，依據口碑論點強度（高與低）、單面／雙面訊息與正、負面口碑出現順序（正正、正負、負正）共分為六個實驗組。實驗結果顯示，口碑知覺可信度對消費者品牌態度的轉變與口碑傳播意圖具有正向的影響，強化口碑的論點將有助於提升消費者之知覺可信度，對於高產品涉入者的影響尤為顯著。相較於單面訊息，提供雙面訊息並未顯著增加口碑知覺可信度。最後，在正、負面口碑順序方面，採取先負後正的口碑順序，對低產品涉入者品牌態度的提昇具有較佳的效果。
英文摘要

Through on-line forums, the Internet enables customers to engage in electronic word-of-mouth (eWOM) communications. Different from traditional WOM of which research focuses on the effects of sources of WOM, eWOM needs more studies on the persuasive effects of characteristics of messages on consumers' attitudes and communication intentions. This study investigates whether the argument strength, message sideness and order of eWOM can affect consumers' perceived credibility, brand attitude and eWOM communication intention and how these effects are changed by consumer involvement. Several hypotheses are proposed, and an experiment is conducted that addresses these questions in the context of online consumer forums. The resulting analysis suggests that the argument strength may lead to perceived credibility of eWOM, especially for consumers with high product involvement. Further, the message sideness and the order of eWOMs only influence the low-involvement consumers' perceived credibility and the brand attitude, respectively. Finally, the brand attitude and the communication intention of eWOM are enhanced as the perceived credibility increases.
主题分类 人文學 > 人文學綜合
基礎與應用科學 > 資訊科學
基礎與應用科學 > 統計
社會科學 > 社會科學綜合
参考文献
  1. 黃麗霞、張重昭(2003)。訊息來源、正負面訊息與市場行家特質對網路訊息傳播之影響。電子商務研究，1(1)，25-40。
    連結：
  2. Lazarsfeld, P.(1940), Radio and the Printed Page, New York: Duell, Sloan and Pearce.
  3. Allport, G. W. and Postman, L. (1947), "An analysis of rumor," Public Opinion Quarterly, 10(4), 501-517.
  4. Asch, S. E. (1946), "Forming impressions of personality," Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology, 41(3), 258-290
  5. Anderson, N. H.,Hubert, S.(1963).Effects of concomitant verbal recall on order effects in personality impression formation.Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior,2(5-6),379-391.
  6. Andrews, L. C.,Durvasula, S.,Akhter, S. H.(1990).A framework for conceptualizing and measuring the involvement construct in advertising research.Journal of Advertising,19(1),27-41.
  7. Arndt, J.(1967).Word of Mouth Advertising: A Review of the Literature.New York:Advertising Research Federation.
  8. Ashton, A.,Ashton, R.(1988).Sequential belief revision in auditing.The Accounting Review,63(4),623-641.
  9. Babin, J. B.,Lee, Y. K.,Kim, E. J.,Griffin, M.(2005).Modeling consumer satisfaction and word-of-mouth: Restaurant patronage in Korea.The Journal of Services Marketing,19(3),133-139.
  10. Bansal, H. S.,Voyer, P. A.(2000).Word-of-mouth process within a service purchase decision context.Journal of Service Research,3(2),166-177.
  11. Bickart, B.,Schindler, R. M.(2001).Internet forums as influential sources of consumer information.Journal of Interactive Marketing,15(3),31-40.
  12. Blackwell, R .D.,Miniard, P. W.,Engle, J. F.(2001).Consumer Behavior.New Jersey:Harcourt College Publishers.
  13. Bone, P. F.(1995).Word-of-mouth effects on short-term and long-term product judgments.Journal of Business Research,32(3),213-223.
  14. Bordia, P.,Rosnow, R. L.(1998).Rumor rest stops on the information highway.Human Communication Research,25(2),163-179.
  15. Bradburn, N. M.,Mason W. M.(1964).The effect of question order on responses.Journal Marketing Research,1(1),57-64.
  16. Chebat, J. C.,Picard, J.(1985).The effects of price and message-sidedness on confidence in product and advertisement with personal involvement as a mediator variable.International Journal of Research in Marketing,2(2),129-141.
  17. Cheung, M. Y.,Luo, C.,SIA, C. L.,Chen, H.(2007).How do people evaluate electronic word-of-mouth? Informational and normative based determinants of perceived credibility of online consumer recommendations in China.Proceedings of Pacific Asia Conference on Information Systems,Auckland:
  18. Coulter, K. S.,Punj, G. N.(2007).Understanding the role of idiosyncratic thinking in brand attitude formation.Journal of Advertising,36(1),7-20.
  19. Craig, C. S.,McCann, J. M.(1978).Assessing communication effects of energy conversation.Journal of Consumer Research,5(2),82-88.
  20. Crowley, A. E.,Hoyer, W. D.(1994).An integrative framework for understanding two-sided persuasion.Journal of Consumer Research,20(4),561-574.
  21. Difonzo, N.,Bordia, P.(2000).How top pr professionals handle hearsay: Corporate rumors, their effects, and strategies to manage them.Public Relations Review,26(2),173-190.
  22. Eagly, A. H.,Wood, W.,Chaiken, S.(1978).Causal inferences about communicators and their effects for opinion changes.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,36(April),424-435.
  23. Earl, R. L.,Pride, W. M.(1980).The effect of advertising structure, message sidedness, and performance test results on print advertisement informativeness.Journal of Advertising,9(3),36-45.
  24. East, R.,Hammond, K.(2005).The impact of positive and negative word of mouth on brand choice.Proceedings of Australian and New Zealand Marketing Academy (ANZMAC) Conference
  25. Etgar, M.,Goodwin, S. A.(1982).One-sided versus two-sided comparative message appeals for new brand introductions.Journal of Consumer Research,8(March),460-465.
  26. Evans, M.,Wedande, G.,Ralston, L.,Hul, S.(2001).Consumer interaction in the virtual era: Some qualitative insights.Qualitative Market Research,4(3),150-159.
  27. Flanagin, A. J.,Metzger, M. J.(2000).Perceptions of internet information credibility.Journalism & Mass Communication Quarterly,77(3),515-540.
  28. Fornell, C.,Larker, D.(1981).Evaluating structural equation models with unobserved variables and Measurement errors.Journal of Research Marketing,27(3),445-466.
  29. Garbarino, E.,Johnson, M. S.(1999).The different roles of satisfaction, trust, and commitment in customer relationships.Journal of Marketing,63(2),70-87.
  30. Garreston, J. A.,Burton, S.(1998).Alcoholic beverage sales promotion: An initial investigation of the role of warning messages and brand characters among consumers over and under the legal drinking age.Journal of Public Policy and Marketing,17(1),35-47.
  31. Golden, L. L.,Alpert, M. I.(1987).Comparative analysis of the relative effectiveness of one and two sided communication for contrasting products.Journal of Advertising,16(1),18-25.
  32. Hair, J.,Black, W.,Babin, B.,Anderson, R.(2005).Multivariate Data Analysis.Prentice Hall.
  33. Hanson, W. A.(2000).Principles of Internet Marketing.Ohio:South-Western College Publishing.
  34. Haugtvedt, C. P.,Wegener, D. T.(1994).Message order effects in persuasion: An attitude strength perspective.Journal of Consumer Research,21(1),205-218.
  35. Hennig-Thurau, T.,Gwinner, K. P.,Walsh, G.,Gremler, D. D.(2004).Electronic word-of-mouth via consumer-opinion platforms: What motivates consumers to articulate themselves on the internet?.Journal of Interactive Marketing,18(1),38-52.
  36. Herr, P.,Kardes, F.,Kim, J.(1991).Effect of word-of-mouth and product-attribute information on persuasion: An accessibility-diagnostic perspective.Journal of Consumer Research,17(4),454-462.
  37. Highhouse, S.,Gallo, A.(1977).Order effects in personnel decision making.Human Performance,10(1),31-46.
  38. Hogarth, R. M.,Einhorn, H. J.(1992).Order effects in belief updating: The belief-adjustment model.Cognitive Psychology,24(1),1-55.
  39. Hoviand, C. I.,Janis, I. L.,Kelley, H. H.(1953).Communication and Persuasion, New Haven, Communication.Yale University Press.
  40. Johnson, E. N.(1995).Effects of information order, group assistance, and experience on auditor's sequential belief revision.Journal of Economic Psychology,16(1),137-160.
  41. Johnson, T. J.,Kaye, B. K.(2004).Webelievability: A path model examining how convenience and reliance predict online credibility.Journalism and Mass Communication Quality,79(3),619-642.
  42. Jones, E. E.(ed.)(1972).Attribution: Perceiving the Causes of Behavior.Morristown, NJ:General Laming Press.
  43. Kamins, M. A.,Assael, H.(1987).Moderating disconfirmation of expectations through the use of two-sided appeals: A longitudinal approach.Journal of Economic Psychology,8(2),237-253.
  44. Kanungo, R. N.,Johar, J. S.(1975).Effects of slogan and human model characteristics in product advertisements.Canadian Journal of Behavioural Science,7(2),127-138.
  45. Kardes, F. R.,Herr, P. M.(1990).Order effects in consumer judgment, choice, and memory: The role of initial processing goals.Advances in Consumer Research,17(1),541-546.
  46. Katz, E.(1957).The two-step flow of communication: An up-to-date report on an hypothesis.The Public Opinion Quarterly,21(1),61-78.
  47. Kempf, D. S.,Palan, K. M.(2006).The effects of gender and argument strength on the processing of word-of-mouth communication.Academy of Marketing Studies Journal,10(1),1-18.
  48. Kerlinger, F. N.(1986).Foundations of Behavior Research.Fort Worth:Holt, Rinehart and Winston.
  49. Kiecker, P.,Cowles, D.(2001).Interpersonal communication and personal influence on the internet: A framework for examining online word-of-mouth.Journal of European Marketing,11(2),71-88.
  50. Kim, T.,Biocca, F.(1997).Telepresence via television: Two dimensions of telepresence may have different connections to memory and persuasion.Journal of Computer-Mediated Communication,3(2)
  51. Kinnear, T. C.(ed.),Michigan, A. A.(ed.)(1984).Advances in Consumer Research.Association for Consumer Research.
  52. Kiousis, S.(2001).Public trust or mistrust? Perceptions of media credibility in the information age.Mass Communication & Society,4(4),381-403.
  53. Kisielius, J.,Sternthal, B.(1986).Examining the vividness controversy: An availability-valence perspective.Journal of Consumer Research,12(4),418-431.
  54. Krosnick, J. A.,Aiwin, D. F.(1987).An evaluation of a cognitive theory of response-order effects in survey measurement.Public Opinion Quarterly,51(2),201-219.
  55. Lana, R. E.(1961).Familiarity and the order of presentation of persuasive communications.Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology,62(3),573-577.
  56. Lau, G.,Ng, S.(2001).Individual and situational factors influencing negative work of mouth behaviour.Revue Canadienne des Sciences de l' Administration,18(3),163-178.
  57. Machleit, K.(ed.),Yalch, R.(ed.)(2002).Online Consumer Psychology: Understanding and Influencing Consumer Behavior in the Virtual World.Hillsdale, NJ:Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
  58. Maloney, J. L.(ed.),Selverman, B.(ed.)(1979).Attitude Research Plays for High Stakes.Chicago:American Marketing Association.
  59. Midgley, D. F.(1976).A simple mathematical theory of innovative behavior.Journal of Consumer Research,3(6),31-41.
  60. Nguyen, H.,Masthoff, I.,Edwards, P.(2007).Persuasive effects of embodied conversational agent teams.Proceedings of the 12th International Conference on Human-Computer Interaction,Beijing, China:
  61. Nunnally, J.(1978).Psychometric Theory.New York:McGraw-Hill.
  62. Ohanian, R.(1991).The impact of celebrity spokespersons' perceived image on consumers' intention to purchase.Journal of Advertising Research,31(1),46-54.
  63. Park, D. H.,Lee, J.,Han, I.(2007).The effect of on-line consumer reviews on consumer purchasing intention: The moderating role of involvement.International Journal of Electronic Commerce,11(4),125-148.
  64. Peterson, C. R.,DuCharme, W. M.(1967).A primacy effect in subjective probability revision.Journal of Experimental Psychology,73(1),61-65.
  65. Petty, R. E.,Cacioppo, J. T.(1986).The elaboration likelihood model of persuasion.Advances in Experimental Social Psychology,19,123-205.
  66. Petty, R. E.,Cacioppo, J. T.(1984).The effects of involvement on response to argument quantity and quality: Central and peripheral routes to persuasion.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,46(1),69-81.
  67. Petty, R. E.,Cacioppo, J. T.,Schumann, D.(1983).Central and peripheral route to advertising effectiveness: The moderating role of involvement.Journal of Consumer Research,9(5),135-146.
  68. Roloff, M. E.(ed.),Miller, G. R.(ed.)(1980).Persuasion: New Directions in Theory and Research.Beverly Hills, CA:Sage.
  69. Rosnow, R. L.(1988).Rumor as communication: A contextualist approach.Journal of Communication,38(1),12-28.
  70. Silverman, G.(2001).The Secrets of Word-of-Mouth Marketing.Amacom Books.
  71. Smith, D.,Menon, S.,Sivakumar, K.(2005).Online peer and editorial recommendations, trust, and choice in virtual markets.Journal of Interactive Marketing,19(3),15-37.
  72. Smith, R. E.,Vogt, C. A.(1995).The effects of integrating advertising and negative word-of-mouth communications on message processing and response.Journal of Consumer Psychology,4(2),133-151.
  73. Solomon, M. R.(2002).Consumer Behavior-Buying.Having and Being, NJ:Prentice-Hall.
  74. Stiff, J. B.(1994).Persuasive Communication.New York:The Guildford Press.
  75. Subramani, M. R.,Rajagopalan, B.(2003).Knowledge-sharing and influence in online social networks via viral marketing.Communication of the ACM,46(12),300-307.
  76. Sussman, S. W.,Siegal, W. S.(2003).Informational influence in organizations: An integrated approach to knowledge adoption.Information Systems Research,14(1),47-65.
  77. Swinyard, W. R.(1981).The interaction between comparative advertising and copy claim variation.Journal of Marketing Research,18(May),175-186.
  78. Trotman, K. T.,Wright, A.(2000).Order effect and recency: Where do we go from here?.Accounting and Financial,40,169-182.
  79. Tseng, S.,Fogg, B. J.(1999).Credibility and computing technology.Communications of the ACM,42(5),39-44.
  80. Unnava, H. R.,Burnkrant, R. E.,Erevelles, S.(1994).Effects of presentation order and communication modality on recall and attitude.Journal of Consumer Research,21(December),481-490.
  81. Wathen, C. N.,Burkell, J.(2002).Believe it or not: Factors influencing credibility on the web.Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology,53(2),134-144.
  82. West, D.(1994).Validating a scale for the measurement of credibility: A covariance structure modeling approach.Journalism Quarterly,71(1),159-168.
  83. Whittier, T. E.,DiMeo, J.(1991).The effects of actor's race in commercial advertising: Review and extension.Journal of Advertising,20(1),54-60.
  84. Wilkie, W.(1986).Consumer Behavior.New York:John Wiley and Sons, Inc.
  85. Wright, P. L.(1973).The cognitive progresses mediating acceptance of advertising.Journal of Marketing Research,10(1),53-62.
  86. Ying, H. L.,Chung, C. M. Y.(2007).The effects of single-message single-source mixed word-of-mouth on product attitude and purchase intention.Asia Pacific Journal of Marketing and Logistics,19(1),75-86.
被引用次数
  1. 蔡璧如、莊苑仙、吳穎帆(2016)。網路互動性對網路口碑之影響─Facebook 與YouTube 的比較。商管科技季刊，17(1)，81-111。
  2. 陳欽雨、姚成彥、余念真(2017)。行動商務網站品質、心流體驗及網路口碑對消費動機影響之研究。顧客滿意學刊，13(1)，103-131。
  3. 董瑞人(2013)。大陸旅客來台旅遊行程效率層面服務補救與口碑宣傳之研究。島嶼觀光研究，6(4)，23-45。
  4. 楊于慧、施翠倚(2013)。顧客價值對購物網站品牌信任之影響－從眾屬性比較分析。行銷評論，10(2)，165-190。
  5. 游蓓怡,莊世杰,王晨宇(2018)。傳統、網路口碑行銷與不同團購產品對購買意願影響。修平學報，36，127-144。
print cancel