弱勢教育的研究倫理：批判俗民誌方法論的觀點

Ethics in Educational Research for the Disadvantaged: From the Perspective of Critical Ethnography Methodology

陳意榕(Yi-Jung Chen)

批判俗民誌 ； 弱勢教育研究倫理視野 ； 雙贏倫理決定 ； Critical Ethnography ； the Ethical Horizon in Educational Research for the Disadvantaged ； Win-win Ethical Decisions

臺中教育大學學報：教育類

28卷2期（2014 / 12 / 01）

1 - 22

繁體中文

本文主要在透過批判俗民誌方法論的觀點，闡明其對弱勢教育研究的倫理議題之意義與啟示。在研究架構上，研究者將教育研究倫理考量置於巨觀與微觀弱勢教育研究的脈絡中，而提出「弱勢教育研究倫理視野圖」，最後再以McLaren（1999）的著作為例，藉由檢視批判俗民誌中對倫理議題的處理，提出對弱勢教育研究倫理之省思。最終，弱勢教育研究的意義及科學精神透過雙贏倫理決定之達成，得以彰顯。

The main purpose of this study is to illustrate the significance and implications of the ethics in educational research for the disadvantaged by applying critical ethnography methodology. The research attempts to place the modes of ethical considerations in the context of educational research for the disadvantaged through macro and micro examination. As a result, the researcher came up with an adapted figure, titled ＂The Ethical Horizon in Educational Research for the Disadvantaged＂. Analyzing McLaren's masterpiece ＂Schooling as a Ritual Performance: towards a Political Economy of Educational Symbols and Gestures＂ by examining the application of critical ethnography methodology, several reflections gradually emerges in the study. Finally, the meaning of educational research for the disadvantaged is enriched and the spirit of science fully enshrined by the accomplishment of win-win ethical decisions.

1. 何粵東(2005)。敘說研究方法論初探。應用心理研究，25，55-72。
   連結：
2. 常善媚、徐畢卿(2004)。生手進田野：一位田野研究者的體驗與反思。醫學教育，8(3)，293-300。
   連結：
3. 賴明亮(2004)。臨床研究倫理及教學：由第四屆亞澳倫理委員會論壇談起。醫學教育，8(4)，444-446。
   連結：
4. 魏曼伊(2008)。教育研究另一途徑：網路調查研究。中正教育研究，7(2)，97-128。
   連結：
5. Russell, B. (1932). Education and the social order. New York: Routledge.
6. Weber, M. (1946). From Max Weber (H. Gerth & C. W. Mills.Eds.). New York: Oxford University Press.
7. Kant, I. (1947). The fundamental principles of the metaphysics of ethics (T.S. Kingsmill, Trans.). London: Longmans, Green.
8. Bond, T. (2005). Researching education: A quest of trust? Keynote lecture given on the M.Ed. course, University of Cambridge, Faculty of Education, March..
9. Allmark, J.,Boote, J.,Chambers, E.,Clarke, A.,Mcdonnell, A.,Thompson, A.,Tod, A.(2009).Ethical issues in the use of in-depth interviews: literature reviews and discussion.Research Ethics Review,5(2),48-54.
10. Anderson, G.,Arsenault, N.(1998).Fundamentals of educational research.London:The Falmer Press.
11. Anderson, L.(1989).Critical ethnography in education: origins, current status, and new directions.Review of educational research,59(3),249-270.
12. Atkinson, J.(1989).A lost dimension in soft systems practice.Journal of Applied Systems Analysis,16,43-53.
13. Barab, A.,Thomas, K.,Dodge, T.,Squire, K.,Newell, M.(2004).Critical design ethnography: Designing for change.Anthropology and Education Quarterly,35(2),254-268.
14. Bridges, D.(2001).The ethics of outsider research.Journal of philosophy of Education,35(3),371-387.
15. Burgess, R.(Ed.)(2005).The ethics of educational research.London, UK:The Falmer Press.
16. Carspecken, P.(1996).Critical ethnography in educational research: A theoretical and practical guide.New York:Routledge.
17. Chang, Y-K.(2005).Through queers eyes: Critical educational ethnography in queer studies.The Review of Education, Pedagogy, and Cultural Studies,27,171-208.
18. Charlton, I.(1998).Nothing about us without us: Disability power and oppression.Berkeley:University of California Press.
19. Cohen, L.,Manion, L.,Morrison, K.(2000).Research methods in education.London:Routledge Falmer.
20. Coleman, M.(Ed.),Briggs, A.(Ed.)(2002).Research methods in educational leadership and management.London, UK:Paul Chapman.
21. Denscombe, M.(2003).The good research guide.Maidenhead:Open University Press.
22. Flewitt, R.(2005).Conducting research with young children: Some ethical considerations.Early Child Development and Care,175(6),553-565.
23. Halai, A.(2006).Ethics in qualitative research: issues and challenges.Pakistan:The Aga Khan University.
24. Hatfield, Gary(tr.),Allison, Henry(ed.),Heath, Peter(ed.)(2002).Theoretical Philosophy after 1781.Cambridge University Press.
25. Hobbes, T.(1996).Leviathan.Oxford, UK:Oxford University Press.
26. Howe, K.,Moses, M.(1999).Ethics in educational research.Review of Research in Education,24,21-60.
27. Hume, D.(1985).Essays: Moral, political, and literary.Indianapolis, IN:Liberty Press.
28. Janna, H.(2006).Here I am now: Critical ethnography and community service-learning with immigrant and refugee undergraduate students and youth.Ethnography and Education,1(1),67-86.
29. Jordan, S.,Yeomans, D.(1995).Critical ethnography: Problem in contemporary theory and practice.British Journal of Sociology of Education,16(3),389-408.
30. Locke, J.(1988).Two treatises of government.New York:Cambridge University Press.
31. Locke, J.(1997).Political essays.New York:Cambridge University Press.
32. Locke, John,Laslett, Peter(ed.)(1988).Two Treatises of Government.Cambridge:
33. Losco, J.(Ed.),Williams, L.(Ed.)(1992).Political theory classical writings contemporary views.New York:St. Martin's Press.
34. Madison, S.(2005).Critical ethnography: Method, ethics, and performance.Thousand Oaks:Sage.
35. Marx, K.,Fowkes, B.(Trans.)(1976).Capital: A critique of political economy.New York:Penguin.
36. McLaren, P.(1999).Schooling as a ritual performance: Towards a political economy of educational symbols and gestures.Lanham, MD:Rowman & Littlefield.
37. Mills, A.(2007).Access to multiliteracies: A critical ethnography.Ethnography and Education,2(3),305-325.
38. Morrow, V.(2009).The ethics of social research with children and families in young lives: Practical experiences.U.K.:Young Lives, Department or International Development, University of Oxford.
39. Ogbu, J.(1983).Minority status and schooling in plural societies.Comparative Education Review,27(2),168-190.
40. Oliver, P.(2003).A students' guide to research ethics.Maidenhead:Open University Press.
41. Orb, A.,Eisenhauer, L.,Wynaden, D.(2001).Ethics in qualitative research.Journal of Nursing Scholarship,33,93-96.
42. Pendlebury, S.,Enslin, P.(2001).Representation, identification and trust: Towards an ethics of educational research.Journal of Philosophy of Education,35(3),361-370.
43. Simon, R.,Dippo, D.(1986).On critical ethnographic work.Anthropology & Education Quarterly,17(4),195-202.
44. Simons, H.(Ed.),Usher, R.(Ed.)(2000).Situated ethics in educational research.London:Routledge Falmer.
45. Small, R.(2001).Codes are not enough: What philosophy can contribute to the ethics of educational research.Journal of Philosophy of Education,35(3),387-405.
46. Stutchbury, K.,Fox, A.(2009).Ethics in educational research: Introducing a methodological tool for effective ethical analysis.Cambridge Journal of Education,39(4),489-504.
47. Thomas, J.(1993).Doing critical ethnography.Newbury Park:Sage.
48. Thomas, J.,O' Maolchatha, A.(1989).Reassessing the critical metaphor: An optimistic revisionist view.Justice Quarterly,6(2),143-172.
49. Todorov, T.(1969).Structural analysis of narrative.Novel: A Forum on Fiction,3(1),70-76.
50. Weber, Max(1951).Gesammelte Aufsätze zur Wissenschaftslehre.Tübingen:
51. 方永泉(2002)。當代思潮與比較教育研究。臺北市:師大書苑。
52. 王鳳雄(2010)。攜手計畫課後扶助方案的探討：批判俗民誌的觀點。研習資訊，27(6)，29-36。
53. 江吉田(2004)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。南投縣，國立暨南國際大學。
54. 何明晃(2009)。經常逃學而不逃家少年其學校與家庭經驗之研究。青少年犯罪防治研究期刊，1(1)，29-82。
55. 余一鳴(2002)。科學哲學的發展對方法論研究的啟示。復興崗學報，76，259-285。
56. 吳英黛(2002)。物理治療專業中的醫學倫理。物理治療，27(2)，100-109。
57. 李御嘉(2011)。2010年人體試驗：研究倫理審查會國際研討會紀實。醫療品質雜誌，5(1)，102-105。
58. 李淑菁(2006)。教育政策研究的傳統與批判：一個東方的性別觀點。教育政策科學與實務，臺北市:
59. 李嘉齡(2002)。批判俗民誌與比較教育研究。國立台北師範學院學報，15，211-232。
60. 林志翰(2009)。人體試驗：研究倫理委員會儲備訪查委員制度元年。醫療品質雜誌，3(5)，97-99。
61. 洪雯柔(2009)。批判俗民誌：比較教育方法論。臺北市:五南。
62. 胡幼慧編(1996)。質性研究：理論、方法及本土女性研究實例。臺北市:巨流。
63. 徐偉民(2004)。博士論文(博士論文)。高雄市，國立高雄師範大學。
64. 浦忠勇、闕河嘉(2008)。原住民研究倫理：從狩獵計畫談起。農業推廣學報，24，73-90。
65. 國立中正大學編(2000)。質的研究方法。高雄市:麗文。
66. 張瑋琦(2010)。以原住民知識為基礎之社區總體營造：應用人類學在佳平部落的實踐與挑戰。臺灣原住民研究論叢，7，155-180。
67. 陳再晉(2012)。基因研究倫理與法規之政策觀點。醫療品質雜誌，6(1)，32-37。
68. 曾淑惠(2009)。評鑑委託單位倫理守則之建構。教育政策論壇，12(4)，93-125。
69. 黃于虔(2010)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。高雄市，國立中山大學。
70. 黃健泰(2002)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。嘉義縣，國立中正大學。
71. 劉源祥(2008)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。花蓮縣，國立東華大學。
72. 蔡甫昌(2010)。研究倫理委員會之實務與反思。臺灣醫學，14(3)，324-333。
73. 蔡甫昌(2003)。醫療照護中的利益衝突。健康世界，216，87-91。
74. 蔡甫昌、林芝宇、張志寧(2008)。研究倫理的歷史、原則與準則。臺灣醫學，12(1)，107-122。
75. 盧美秀、林秋芬(2006)。護理研究倫理的考量。源遠護理，1(1)，30-36。
76. 戴華、甘偵蓉、鄭育萍(2010)。人文社會科學與研究倫理審查：執行研究倫理治理架構計畫的考察與反思。人文與社會科學簡訊，12(1)，10-18。
77. 嚴春財(2006)。原住民教育研究方法新論：批判俗民誌的觀點。研習資訊，23(6)，119-124。
78. 嚴振農(2010)。博士論文(博士論文)。南投縣，國立暨南國際大學。

1. (2016)。從教育領域的質性研究談研究倫理議題。教育研究月刊，272，30-43。