题名

以「無善無惡」為體用-論李贄的龍谿學詮釋

并列篇名

Taking "There Is No Good or Evil" as the Substance and the Application: On Li Zhi's Interpretation of Long-Xi's Studies

作者

袁光儀(Yuan Guang-Yi)

关键词

李贄(卓吾) ; 王畿(龍谿) ; 無善無惡 ; 陽明後學 ; Li Zhi (Zhuo-Wu) ; Wang Ji (Long-Xi) ; there is no good or evil ; later scholar of Yang-Ming's school

期刊名称

漢學研究集刊

卷期/出版年月

34期(2022 / 06 / 01)

页次

1 - 3+5-42

内容语文

繁體中文

中文摘要

本文針對《卓吾先生批評龍谿王先生語錄鈔八卷》一書,考察李贄對於龍溪文章之圈點與批語,則可見李贄乃以王龍溪「無善無惡」之「即本體即工夫」的先天之學為唯一成聖要道。在掌握本體上,李贄乃強調本體之悟乃「為己之學」,須真知為仁由己;而在工夫實踐上,李贄則特重破除成心,自見已過。而在著重為仁由己、自省改過的「為己之學」中,李贄一方面對於俗學、聖學之别,擺出必辨其異、毫不妥協的態度;另一方面對於三教與諸子,卻又反對儒者之嚴辨異學,而強調無須分別,當見其大同的精神。在此辨與不辨之間,一方面是對於聖學不得混於功利俗學的堅持,另一方面則是展現仁者當以萬物為一體的胸襟,其智慧與洞見使人深思警醒。

英文摘要

Focusing on the book A Quotation Selection of Mr. Zhuo-Wu's Criticisms on Mr. Wang Long-Xi, the article examines Li's marks and comments on Long-Xi's articles and thus discovers that Li sees Long-Xi's learning of nature as "practice based on the substance" featuring "there is no good or evil" as the only way to become a saint. In the aspect of grasping the substance, Li stresses that the substance's enlightenment is a "learning for oneself": one must truly know that practicing benevolence depends on themselves; in the aspect of the practice, he especially values dispelling prejudices and emphasizes on seeing one's own faults. As for the "learning for oneself" with stress on self-dependent benevolence, self-reflection, and self-correction, Li on one hand has an uncompromising attitude towards distinguishing the differences between mundane learning and saintly learning while on the other hand, about the three teachings and the various thinkers, opposes to Confucians' strict distinction from others and emphasizes that there is no need to separate but a necessity of exhibiting the spirit of great harmony. Between differentiating and not differentiating, one aspect is his insistence that saintly learning should never be confused with profit-minded mundane learning, while the other aspect is his presentation of benevolent people's broad-mindedness that regards all things as one. The wisdom and insights help people think deeply and stay alert.

主题分类 人文學 > 語言學
人文學 > 中國文學
参考文献
  1. 袁光儀(2010)。蒙以養正-李贄《九正易因》之〈蒙卦〉解與「童心說」。成大中文學報,29
    連結:
  2. (2002).續修四庫全書.上海:上海古籍出版社.
  3. (1986).景印文淵閣四庫全書.臺北:商務印書館.
  4. (宋)陸九淵(1992).陸象山全集.北京:中國書店.
  5. (明)王畿,吳震(編校整理)(2007).王畿集.南京:鳳凰出版社.
  6. (明)李贄,張建業(編)(2000).李贄文集.北京:社會科學文獻出版社.
  7. (明)李贄,張建業(編)(2000).李贄文集.北京:社會科學文獻出版社.
  8. (明)李贄,張建業(編)(2000).李贄文集.北京:社會科學文獻出版社.
  9. (明)李贄,張建業(編)(2000).李贄文集.北京:社會科學文獻出版社.
  10. (明)李贄,張建業(編)(2000).李贄文集.北京:社會科學文獻出版社.
  11. (明)李贄,張建業(編)(2000).李贄文集.北京:社會科學文獻出版社.
  12. (明)沈德符(1976).萬曆野獲編.臺北:偉文圖書公司.
  13. (明)耿定向.耿天臺先生文集.臺北:文海出版社.
  14. (明)黃宗羲(1987).黃宗羲全集.臺北:里仁書局.
  15. (明)黃宗羲(1987).黃宗羲全集.臺北:里仁書局.
  16. 王寶峰(2012).李贄儒學思想研究.北京:人民出版社.
  17. 牟宗三(1983).中國哲學十九講.臺北:學生書局.
  18. 牟宗三(1980).從陸象山到劉蕺山.臺北:學生書局.
  19. 吳震(2009).泰州學派研究.北京:中國人民大學出版社.
  20. 周群(2004)。「二溪」卓吾關係論。東南學術,2004(1)
  21. 岡田武彥,吳光(譯),錢明(譯),屠承先(譯)(2016).王陽明與明末儒學.重慶:重慶出版社.
  22. 林其賢(1992).李卓吾的佛學與世學.臺北:文津出版社.
  23. 唐君毅(1984).中國哲學原論.原教篇.臺北:學生書局.
  24. 袁光儀(2019)。李贄的龍谿學詮釋初探-讀《卓吾先生批評龍谿王先生語錄》。李贄與海絲文化-南安市紀念李贄誕辰490周年學術研討會論文集,福州:
  25. 高瑋謙(2009).王龍溪哲學系統之建構:以「見在良知」說為中心.臺北:學生書局.
  26. 張建業(編)(2013).李贄研究資料匯編.北京:社會科學文獻出版社.
  27. 陳清輝(1993).李卓吾生平及其思想研究.臺北:文津出版社.
  28. 彭國翔(2015).良知學的展開王龍溪與中晚明的陽明學增訂版.北京:生活.讀書.新知三聯書店.
  29. 溝口雄三(2014).李卓吾.兩種陽明學.北京:生活.讀書.新知三聯書店.
  30. 溝口雄三,林右崇(譯)(1994).中國前近代思想的演變.臺北:國立編譯館.