學校行銷研究的回顧分析：以1989~2014年臺灣期刊論文為範疇

Reviews of School Marketing Researches in Taiwan Journal Articles Database from 1989-2014

黃義良(Yi-Lian Huang)；王怡又(I-Yu Wang)

內容分析 ； 策略性行銷 ； 期刊論文 ； 學校行銷 ； content analysis ； strategic marketing ； journal article ； school marketing

彰化師大教育學報

26期（2014 / 12 / 01）

17 - 44

繁體中文

近年，學校行銷相關研究勃興，形成哪些發展與研究走向，殊值探討。本研究主要目的在分析臺灣地區歷年（1989~2014）來學校行銷期刊論文的研究成果與缺口。採用內容分析法分析臺灣期刊論文索引系統可查詢的126篇期刊論文。研究中採描述性與評鑑性兩種層面的分析架構，前者包含研究典範、研究方法、學校層級、學校性質、研究對象、行銷向度與相關變項等項目，研究發現各項目的發展並不均衡，整體上偏向質性典範、論述性方法、國小層級、無分公私性質、無特定對象與外部行銷。後者則評析研究論文中應用策略性行銷架構的程度，採Kotler與Andreasen（2008）的觀點為基準，包含分析、策略研擬與行銷執行等內涵，研究發現多數研究者並未能對學校進行完整的策略性行銷架構的檢視。搭配不同時期的分析，梳理出學校行銷研究的走向，藉以提升探討的深度。最終，研究提具建議，提供未來學校行銷研究時參考。

In recent years, researches related to school marketing are growing prosperously. What research trend and direction are formed is worth being explored further. The purpose of this study is to analyze the research results and gaps of journal articles on school marketing, which were published in Taiwan during the period of 1989~2014. Content analysis was used to analyze 126 articles collected from PerioPath Index to Taiwan Periodical Literature System. A two-dimension analysis framework, description and assessment, was adopted. The former included items, such as research paradigm, method, school level, school nature, subject of interest, and marketing direction. It is found that the development among each item is not balanced, tending to qualitative paradigm, descriptive method, elementary school level, non-public or non-private schools in nature, unspecified subject and external marketing. Based on the viewpoints of Kotler and Andreason (2008), the latter evaluated and analyzed how strategic marketing theory was applied to schools discussed in those journal articles, including analysis, marketing strategy planning, and the implementation of marketing strategy. It is found that most of the schools do not have a complete strategic marketing plan. Combined with different time period, the research direction on school marketing is identified to broaden the depth of discussion. Finally, this study provides suggestions for future research on school marketing.

1. 黃俊英(2011)。行銷管理─策略性觀點。臺北市:華泰。
   連結：
2. 黃義良(2009)。幼教機構服務行銷指標建構之研究。測驗學刊，56(4)，571-602。
   連結：
3. 黃義良(2002)。淺談學校運用網路發展形象行銷的具體策略。學校行政，20，17-22。
   連結：
4. 黃義良、丁學勤(2013)。學校行銷的研究之發展分析：EBSCO期刊資料庫論文的探索。臺中教育大學學報：教育類，27(2)，105-124。
   連結：
5. 羅明忠(2008)。國民小學學校行銷的研究評析及其對學校行銷策略的啟示。學校行政，58，133-149。
   連結：
6. 蘇容梅(2012)。大學關係行銷對學生行為意向之影響－學校品牌知名度的調節效果。臺北市立教育大學學報教育類，43(1)，1-26。
   連結：
7. 中美大學教育聯盟（2014）。少子化衝擊，教部擬大學退場規劃。2015 年 1 月1 日，取自https://www.facebook.com/CAUCTW/posts/666744806674104
8. Aaker, D. A.(2009).Strategic market management.New York, NY:John Wiley & Sons.
9. Albrecht, K.,Zemke, R.(2002).Service America in the new economy.New York, NY:McGraw-Hill.
10. Armstrong, G.,Kolter, P.(2009).Marketing: An Introduction.Upper Saddle River, NJ:Prentice Hall.
11. Bogdan, R. C.,Biklen, S. K.(1982).Qualitative research for education: An introduction to theory and practice.Boston, MA:Allyn and Bacon.
12. Brazington, A.(2012).Letting go.Campus Technology,25(8),16-20.
13. Bush, T.(Ed.),Bell, L.(Ed.)(2002).The principles and practice of educational management.London:Paul Chapman.
14. Capper, C. A.(1998).Critically oriented and postmodern perspectives: Sorting out the differences and applications for practice.Educational Administration Quarterly,34(3),354-379.
15. Davis, B.,Ellison, L.(1997).Strategic marketing for schools.London:Pitman Publishing.
16. Gronroos, C.(1984).A service quality model and its marketing implications.European Journal of Marketing,18(4),36-44.
17. Hanson, E. M.(1996).Educational Administration and organizational behavior.Boston, MA:Allyn and Bacon, Inc..
18. Iuliana, P.,Mihai, I. D.(2011).Knowing our "clients" for a better management in higher education services.Journal of Academic Research in Economics,3(3),355-362.
19. Kotler, P.(1999).Marketing management: Analysis, planning, implementation and control.Upper Saddle River, NJ:Prentice Hall.
20. Kotler, P.,Andreasen, A. R.(2008).Strategic marketing for nonprofit organization.Upper Saddle River, NJ:Prentice-Hall.
21. Lesli, A. M.(2006).Detroit schools struggle to stem student loss.Educational Week,25(42),1-2.
22. Litten, L. H.(1980).Marketing higher education's benefits and risk for the American academic system.Journal of Higher Education,51(1),40-56.
23. Loeb, S.,Valant, J.,Kasman, M.(2011).Increasing choice in the market for schools: Recent reforms and their effects on student achievement.National Tax Journal,64(1),141-164.
24. Moore, D.,Bowden-Everson, J.(2012).An appealing connection-The role of relationship marketing in the attraction and retention of students in an Australian tertiary context.Asian Social Science,8(14),65-80.
25. Nesset, E.,Helgesen, O.(2009).Modeling and managing student loyalty: A study of a Norwegian university college.Scandinavian Journal of Educational Research,53(4),327-345.
26. Ng, I. C. L.,Forbes, J.(2009).Education as service: The understanding of university experience through the service logic.Journal of Marketing for Higher Education,19(1),38-64.
27. Oplatla, I.,Hemsley-Brown, J.(2004).The research on school marketing: Current issues and future directions.Journal of Educational Administration,42(3),375-400.
28. Parasuraman, A.(1996).Understanding and leveraging the role of customer service in external, interactive and internal marketing.Frontiers in Service Conference,Nashville, TN.:
29. Saugstade, T.(2002).Educational theory and practice in an Aristotelian perspective.Scandinavian Journal of Educational Research,46(4),373-390.
30. Schneider, R. L.(2005).Marketing medical education: An examination of recruitment web sites for traditional and combined-degree MD programs.Journal of Marketing for Higher Education,14(2),19-36.
31. Stiber, G.(2001).Characterizing the decision process leading to enrollment in master's programs: Further application of the enrollment process model.Journal of Marketing for Higher Education,11(2),91-107.
32. Szekeres, J.(2010).Sustaining student numbers in the competitive marketplace.Journal of Higher Education Policy and Management,32(5),429-439.
33. 王文科(2014)。教育研究法。臺北市:五南。
34. 吳浚碩(2007)。學校網路行銷初探－以高雄縣山頂國小為例。國教之友，59(1)，55-62。
35. 吳清山、林天祐(2007)。教育名詞─品牌管理。教育資料與研究，75，163-164。
36. 周文欽(2004)。研究方法─實徵性研究取向。台北市:心理。
37. 林偉人(2007)。英美名校網路行銷分析。輔仁學誌─人文藝術之部，35，109-142。
38. 邱皓政(2011)。量化研究與統計分析。臺北市:雙葉。
39. 曾光華(2004)。行銷管理：理論解析與實務應用。臺北市:前程。
40. 黃文宏譯、莊勝雄譯、伍家德譯、Perreault, W. D.、McCarthy, E. J.(2004)。行銷管理。臺北市:麥格羅希爾。
41. 黃再德(1985)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。國立中山大學企業管理研究所。
42. 黃義良(2006)。教育行銷研究的趨勢與展望－以學位論文與期刊論文為例。學校行政，45，154-175。
43. 趙碧華譯、朱美珍譯、Rubin, A.(2004)。研究方法：社會工作暨人文科學領域的運用。臺北市:學富文化。
44. 潘世尊(2011)。教育研究的一種分析框架－兼論幼教研究可強化之方向。國民教育學報，8，199-223。
45. 潘淑滿(2003)。質性研究理論與應用。臺北市:心理。
46. 鄧勝梁、許紹李、張庚淼(2003)。行銷管理理論與策略。臺北市:五南。
47. 鍾娟兒(1989)。教育行銷與學校形象。商業職業教育，35，26-30。
48. 魏惠娟(2006)。臺灣地區學校行銷研究評析及其對學校行銷策略規劃的啟示：1984-2004的探索。教育政策論壇，9(2)，131-154。

1. 陳信助,張文權,林明地(2023)。「教師兼任行政工作倦怠」相關議題研究之回顧分析：以《學校行政》期刊論文為範疇。學校行政，146，60-87。
2. (2019)。臺灣學校績效責任議題研究之回顧分析：以1984~2018年期刊論文為範疇。教育研究月刊，302，133-155。